Everything posted by drjim
-
What does it take to get Archer?
Typical Twins move, going after a guy because he has such great success against them.
-
Treading Water while the MLB trend points toward disparity
In 2012, they were 16th in revenue, but also 13th in payroll! I agree they have incentive to try and win, and winning would lead to more revenue, but that is much more on the front office than ownership. It's not so simple to just spend and try to win (and it seems they were spending relative to their revenue anyways). But in the bigger picture, the Twins were clearly entering a rebuild after 2012 and I would argue they ended up spending too much money on multiple years for mediocrity instead of being more targeted on guys they could flip for prospects. Now that they are good again, they have less prospect inventory AND they are locked into bad contracts that were justified in trying to spend more. This is why I personally push back on the "Pohlad's are cheap" narrative so hard. First, it isn't really backed up by any evidence, and brings down the overall quality of conversation on the site (and elsewhere). But second, and much more importantly, it really lets the front office off the hook for their incompetence. I personally don't care either way if the Pohlads own the team, but it is really a big mistake to assume a different owner would come in and spend more. That type of ownership behavior is not seen in the vast majority of other markets - I think Detroit is the only exception, and that was relatively temporary and is about to go hard the other direction.
-
Treading Water while the MLB trend points toward disparity
Twins were 23rd in revenue in 2016. There is a very valid reason why they spend less than average. Everything you say might be correct about making money, but that is true for all teams, and by that reasoning all teams would then bump up their payroll too. Not saying this is a bad thing (if you are a player), but it wouldn't solve the issue of where they are in payroll.
-
Catch rule
It was absolutely called correctly, no argument about that. I think it is a baffling rule.
-
Catch rule
Good column here: http://www.espn.com/blog/nflnation/post/_/id/262186/the-nfl-catch-rule-has-issues-but-steelers-survive-the-ground-call-was-right I don't buy either reason for keeping as is, and actually think more fumbles is a reason to change it!
-
Catch rule
I'm amazed at how dumb that rule is and that they still haven't fixed it. Two feet, knee, elbow, break the plane and incomplete.
-
What will it take to get Gerrit Cole?
It is more or less right where it would be with a different owner in the same market/revenue base. Lots of evidence for that position. Saying the Pohlads, because they have massive wealth, should outspend their market is a different argument. To which I say good luck.
-
Treading Water while the MLB trend points toward disparity
Obviously still needs to shake out, but Indians have lost their third best reliever, a major bat, and key players (Kluber, Miller) ended the season with injury. Twins should probably push in a little bit.
- Article: Twins Sign Closer Rodney To One-Year Deal
-
Minor League Player Transactions 2017-18
I wouldn't say never, but it was quite rare, and a lame narrative. And generally if they did fall into the trap, such as it was, it was to push a young player quicker than they should, which isn't necessarily a bad thing.
- Article: Twins Sign Closer Rodney To One-Year Deal
-
T-Wolves Regular Season Thread
I feel for all of you who are still fans.
-
2017-18 non-Twins MLB Off-Season Transactions Thread
I'm pretty sure cash still counts against the Dodgers here. The reason this works for them is that Kemp is spread over two years, while most of the Braves guys are done after this year. The cash just (more or less) evens out thr actual burden, not the accounting burden.
- Article: Twins Sign Closer Rodney To One-Year Deal
- Article: Twins Sign Closer Rodney To One-Year Deal
- Article: Winter Meetings: Reliever Roulette
-
What will it take to get Gerrit Cole?
I would take a healthy Bird over Frazier. I think they are going to spend resources on pitching over corner bats.
-
What will it take to get Gerrit Cole?
Yanks have Judge, Stanton and Gardner. Frazier is excess even without Harper.
-
What will it take to get Gerrit Cole?
Kepler and one of those arms is a lot. I may be higher on Kepler than the industry, but I wouldn't even think of trading him for Frazier.
-
Gophers Football
All indications are that the Gophs secured a solid recruiting class. I can't stand listening to Fleck, I thought the university did Claeys and co wrong, and I thought the coaching/performance this year was garbage - but there is a fair chance he solidifies the progran in a couple years. I wonder about the upside. Is it Mason/Kill or can he actually go higher. Will always be tough with the limited (and likely shrinking) talent base in the state.
- Baseball Bat Post Winter Meetings Top Free Agents Available By Position & Top 50
-
2017-18 non-Twins MLB Off-Season Transactions Thread
Matt Moore traded to the Rangers. He is someone I thought worth targeting as a second starter to add this offseason. (After Darvish of course)
-
"The Worst Generation"
I think it is more selfishness than malice. I'm hoping the Gen Xers and Millenials can do better.
-
2017-18 non-Twins MLB Off-Season Transactions Thread
Correct, typo on my part. I don't think signing Santana would also make Cleveland weaker. Losing him does. I suspect they'll move Brantley to 1b/dh and sign a cheap corner of. But their lineup takes a hit. They are also likely to trade Kipnis.
-
2017-18 non-Twins MLB Off-Season Transactions Thread
Carlos Santana to Cleveland, Cosart to the Angels (to play 3b). Don't mind seeing the Indians get weaker, Angels really going for it. Even more clear that right now that the Twins are 6th in the AL.