Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

markos

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by markos

  1. Some of the people that are upset about not picking Carlson (myself included) are upset because the Twins passed (twice!) on a player that analysts universally had ranked as one of the top-20 players in this draft. It has nothing to do with where he was from, and everything to do with skipping over a very talented player.
  2. Your mileage may vary, but I take "most scouts believe he can stick at short" to be damning faint praise for a prospect. If a kid doesn't get a firm, no-doubt endorsement that he can play SS in the big leagues, I don't have a lot of confidence. The path the majors is littered with prospects who "might stick at short". Eric Longenhagen: "Scouts are split on where that's going to be with most predicting Lewis will move off of his current shortstop and into center field." Keith Law: "he's a shortstop who is almost universally assumed to be moving off the position, with most people -- myself included -- assuming he's headed for center field." Baseball America: "Lewis said all of his role models have played shortstop and hopes to stay there, but there are scouts who see center field as his best future position." "He has the quick feet and plus arm strength required to play shortstop, though scouts aren’t certain that he’ll make the necessary adjustments as he continues to fill out and the speed of the game advances." John Sickels: "Optimists believe he can remain at shortstop due to his instincts, while pessimists think his arm will work better at second base. Everyone agrees he should show the range to handle center, but opinions vary on if his arm would be sufficient for right field if he slows down too much to handle center when he gets older."
  3. Very few draft and prospect analysts have expressed confidence that Lewis will stay at shortstop.
  4. No player has ever signed for more than $6.8M. How much of the $7.7M does everyone think Lewis will sign for? I can't imagine more than $6.5M. Moniak signed for only $6.1M last year.
  5. The Indians managed to put together a good rotation without relying on their top picks to be pitchers.
  6. Yeah, there really is no such thing. Every pitcher has a non-zero chance that his elbow/shoulder will fall apart. Every single one. It comes with being a pitcher. I think teams are getting better at identifying and preventing injuries, but it certainly isn't perfect yet.
  7. Where do you think Gordon would get drafted today if he was a college junior and, let's say, the third best hitter in the SEC?
  8. More than you might think. I'm defining 'big fastball' as 'sits 95+, touches 98+', with a touch less for lefties. So I don't consider Wright as having a big fastball either. But over the past 10 years, it is a pretty easy way (at least with my fuzzy, potentially self-selecting memory of past scouting reports) to put Rodon, Hoffman, Appel, Gray, Gausman, Cole, Harvey, Strasburg and Price in one group, and Tate, Jay, Fulmer, Nola, Freeland, Zimmer, Heaney, Hultzen, Bauer, Pomeranz, Minor, Leake, and Matusz in another.
  9. If you look at the past 15 years or so, the college guys drafted in the top 15 picks that actually became legit front-of-the-rotation starters all come out of college with big fastballs: Cole, Harvey, Sale, Strasburg, Price, Lincecum, Scherzer, Verlander, Prior. The only exception to this is possibly Jered Weaver. There is also a pretty long list of polished lefties with good-but-not-elite stuff that didn't amount to much in the majors: Sowers, Romero, Detwiler, Matusz, Minor, Bradley, Hultzen, Heaney. If you want to find exceptions to this, you really need to go all the way back to the 1990s when the A's selected Zito and Mulder. Maybe there is something about McKay that makes him unique in this regard, but I think there is a lot of historical evidence that pitchers like McKay will struggle.
  10. If he keeps hitting like he has been so far this year, I tend to agree with you.
  11. I get what you're saying, but the way Gordon has been hitting this year, he might be a top-25 prospect right now. In fact, if Gordon was a college junior and had a 1.200 OPS in the SEC (which is roughly what his current 153 wRC+ in AA would translate to), I think he would be the no doubt 1-1 pick ahead of McKay.
  12. I remembered this very differently. From what I read about Stewart prior to his draft, I got the sense that he already had a very good slider. For example, from BA's profile: "Stewart has boosted his fastball from 88-93 mph last summer to 91-96 for much of the spring, though his velocity tails off at times in the later innings. His life and command with his heater make it even more dominating, but his best offering is a power mid-80s slider with tilt. He has improved his curveball and shows feel for his changeup, and he’ll display four above-average big league pitches at times." http://www.baseballamerica.com/draft/2013-mlb-draft-first-round-analysis/#mGrdQtTsISop5ugp.97 And Keith Law's scouting report: "He hit 96 mph and sat 92-94 consistently, showing a plus slider at 85-88, a hard curveball at 79-82, and even a few changeups at 83-84 with decent arm speed. He drives the fastball down in the zone, with hard-boring life in on right-handers The slider is the knockout pitch right now, breaking very hard and late down and away from right-handed batters." http://www.espn.com/blog/mlb-draft/insider/post?id=31 If Kohl Stewart is a cautionary example for selecting Greene, I would argue that Stewart is a good example of how excellent natural athleticism doesn't always translate into command/control.
  13. Seth, great summary! Thanks for putting this all together and adding all the links. Huge day for the franchise. I'm looking forward to all the discussion here.
  14. How much does this matter for a 17-year-old? As a counterpoint, here is a writeup (paraphrased) from a Baseball America draft profile of another 17-year-old pitcher a few years back: "The knock on X is the lack of a true secondary pitch. He pitches off his best weapon, a 92-94 mph fastball that has been up to 97 this spring. It has late life and finish. He has tried multiple grips and shapes with his breaking ball, and at times it has flashed a fringe-average pitch that has tilt and late snap at 81 mph. He doesn't repeat his release point well. His changeup is a below-average pitch that should improve when and if he throws it more often. Because of his size, athleticism and velocity, X is a surefire first-rounder." That was the writeup for Madison Bumgarner. http://www.baseballamerica.com/online/draft/rankings/?rank=draft&year=2007 Bumgarner was in the big leagues two years after being drafted, and he has had an above-average slider and average curve. As another datapoint, Clayton Kershaw definitely had a curveball going into the draft, but it wasn't so good at draft time to compel Baseball America to include him when listing the top HS tools in the draft. He had Best Fastball, but wasn't even listed for Best Breaking Ball, Best Command, or Closest To Majors. http://www.baseballamerica.com/today/draft/best-tools/2006/261350.html So for me, I don't think it is necessary for a HS kid, particularly an uber-athletic 17-year-old, to have an above-average breaking ball already developed. You quoted Verducci as saying “[o]rganizations have learned that if someone does not show an aptitude to spin a baseball as an amateur, it’s foolish to expect him to acquire the skill.” My question: Does Greene show the aptitude and he is just missing consistency? My biggest concern about Greene isn't his breaking ball (or lack there of) but his lack of innings. While a player's stuff is probably the main component that will determine if a kid becomes an elite big league starter, durability should not be discounted. It is less so now than past eras, but you still need to make 30 starts and throw 180+ innings over 6 months. And we have next to zero information about how Greene's arm will hold up under that kind of work load. While still not a perfect demonstration, at least McKay and Wright have both shown the ability to manage a college schedule without much trouble.
  15. But McKay is also going to switch to pitching every 5 days instead of once a week, so there is a real chance that he ends up losing velocity from that. So even if he benefits from not hitting, he is going to be hurt by pitching more often. I think it will be a wash. Maybe it will end up working out, but I think it is crazy to draft a guy who throws 89-91 with the 1-1 pick.
  16. Certainly seems like it would be money related at this point.
  17. When scouts or analysts talk about the 'floor' or 'ceiling' for prospects, I think there is a built-in, unspoken acknowledgement that the ultimate floor of every single prospect is "didn't make the majors", and the ultimate ceiling of every single prospect is "among the best players in baseball". But the interesting part is the risk distribution. In my own mental framework, I assume that they are really talking about the 10th-percentile outcome as the 'floor' and the 90th-percentile outcome as the 'ceiling'. The tail outcomes end up being basically the same for all players, so they are left unsaid.
  18. A lot depends on what you think of Santana going forward. If they keep him and his results start to match his peripherals, then the Twins are in an even worse hole. His K% is almost a career low, his BB% and HR/FB rates are at near career highs, and he is going to be 35 next year. I don't have a lot of confidence that his BABIP magic will continue. It certainly seems possible, perhaps even probable, that the Twins can take the (up to) $41M he is owed over the next three years and use that money on an equivalently good free agent pitcher. I don't think it is at all crazy to think that FA pitcher + prospect(s) > Santana for 2018-2019 for the equivalent amount of money.
  19. There are prospects that are high upside and "major league ready" that still may not be much help to a team fighting for the playoffs. In the Twins system, think about a guy like Romero. He is obviously high-upside and pretty close to the majors. But at this point there are still real questions about his durabily and he is probably on an innings limit this year due to past injuries. Lots of teams have prospects in the upper minors that they are currently planning on shutting down at the end of the minor league season. Think about what the Twins did with Berrios in 2015. With the Astros as an example, I can see how they might be reluctant to count on either Paulino (just 100 innings last year) or Martes (just 125) to provide innings for them in September and October, and how they might entertain the idea of trading one of them for Santana.
  20. I was thinking the exact same thing. The math still works out in the Twins favor regardless of who they pick at 1-1. No matter who the Twins select at 1-1, they will save SOME money from the first bonus pool. No player has yet signed for the full slot amount - in fact, no player has signed for more that $7M yet. The Twins have $7.7M, so I have to think they will save at least $700K, if not $1M. Further, if they are willing to pay the tax on going over by 5%, they can add another $700K of wiggle room. Pick #35 has a slot of $1.9M. So without playing ANY underslot games at 1-1, they can offer $3.5M at #35. Pick #37 has a slot of $1.8M, so if they have a cheap sign lined up there (say for $1M), then they can offer $4M+ at #35. So I think they can promise to every player in your second tier (roughly ranked #5-#15) $4M at #35. If one slides to #35, great! If not, then they can just start selecting highest upside available at every single pick. I don't know how closely anyone looked at the Padres last draft, but they spread their money around a lot, as they ended up giving out 7-figure bonuses to six picks last year despite only have 4 picks allocated that amount, In addition, they gave out two above-slot bonuses to players outside the first 10 rounds.
  21. Worse than that. Technically 7 teams have 2 picks before the Twins pick again at #35. Reds: #2, #32 Rays: #4, #31 A's: #6, #33 Brewers: #9, #34 Blue Jays: #22, #28 Rangers: #26, #29 Cubs: #27, #30 Personally, I think the Rangers and Cubs should not be underrated in this scenario. They are both very aggressive, creative organizations. If a top HS pitcher (say Baz) is dropping, I could easily see one of them picking him despite the high bonus demands. And they can still put together $4M+ for a signing bonus if they are creative with later picks and are also willing to pay the tax.
  22. I think it is close to 50-50. Since 2007, the majority of top-5 selected college pitchers have debuted in the majors the following season. Rodon, Gausman, Bauer, Pomeranz, Strasburg, Matusz and Price all got at least a cup of coffee - some of them significantly more. Further, the Twins will probably be in contention again and in need of pitching, which makes it less likely that they will try to manipulate service time.
  23. That small of gap isn't completely unheard of for good changeups. Jon Lester has almost exactly the same split - FB at 90-92 and CH at 84-86. Hector Santiago and Zack Greinke are similar.
  24. Along those lines, two omitted names that I found interesting: Sam Carlson and Alex Lange.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.