Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

markos

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by markos

  1. Oswaldo Arcia played 37 games in CF at Elizabethton. I don't think his time in center is meaningful at all.
  2. Another warning sign with Turner is that he had a crazy .ISO spike (.225!), and the statcast data showed that he was more productive on flyballs than his launch angles and exit velocity would predict. There is some speculation that teams expected him to be more of a slap-hitter and positioned their outfielders too shallow. Regardless, the Nats have definitely put all their eggs in the Turner-at-shortstop basket, at least for this season. They brought in Eaton and traded away Espinosa, and their backup SS is Stephen Drew.
  3. I agree with this take, and it backs up my own memories of that draft. Jay might have been a tiny bit of a reach at #6, but almost every single draft prosnosticator had him in their top-10. And almost everybody was at least cautiously optimistic that he would be able to transition to a starter. For example, Keith Law, who is extremely biased against pitchers he pegs as future relievers (ex. he had super low draft rankings for Chris Sale (#47) and Carson Fulmer (#43) based on that concern), had Jay ranked #9.
  4. Yeah, I definitely have him above Kirilloff.
  5. Definitely a worthy concern to bring up; however, my defense for this ranking is twofold: 1) it is easy to underestimate how valuable a broad set of average skills can be, and 2) a CF/SS prospect can still be very valuable despite not hitting much. My poster-child for this kind of player is Denard Span. He never hit many homers, but he made a lot of hard contact (consistent above-average BABIPs) which translated into a lot of doubles and triples. He didn't walk a ton, but his 8% walk rate was very good when combined to his very low strikeout rate. All said, his overall batting line is just slightly above-average (105 wRC+). He wasn't a great base-stealer and got picked off too often, but overall he was an above-average baserunner because he was good at taking extra bases and stretching singles into doubles and doubles into triples. He was never flashy in centerfield (not like Hunter or Gomez), but he was very consistent and made enough plays to be at least average, maybe even above-average. All told, he has averaged almost 3 WAR per season for 9 seasons. That is an extremely good and valuable player. It isn't that much of a stretch to see Gordon in a similar light. He doesn't hit a lot of homers, but he makes hard contact and is getting extra bases. He is having some issues stealing bases, but all reports indicate that he is a heady baserunner who will take extra bases when available. I agree that he doesn't walk enough (relative to his strikeouts), but the Delmon Young comparison isn't completely fair - even Young, with all of his batting deficiencies, would have been perfectly fine big league player if he played an adequate CF or SS. In my mind, the big question is where exactly Gordon's defense will end up. Will he be a legitimate shortstop? Parsing through the scouting reports from the various prospect analysts, there is enough doubt to make me pause.
  6. Non-issue. If Javier is truly blocked by Gordon when he reaches the cusp of the majors in, say, 2021, he could make a fantastic trade chip if the Twins need to get an Ace (kind of like what the Cubs did with Torres). And if the Twins aren't competitive for whatever reason, then Gordon would be a valuable trade chip to speed up a rebuild. There is very little, if any, downside.
  7. Gleeman wrote an article (might be behind the paywall) discussing the Twins PECOTA projection: http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=31187
  8. I'm pretty sure Polanco is under team control for 6 more seasons. His short call-ups in 2014 and 2015 didn't count as full seasons.
  9. My explanation for why he has struggled is that his stuff has backed up. One of the major reasons that he was a consensus top-10 pick is that he not only had very good stuff going into the draft, but he also had the build, mechanics and athleticism that allowed scouts to project that his stuff would improve in pro-ball. Take this quote from BP: "Stewart's raw stuff, combined with the room for growth in that stuff, might make him the highest upside arm in the entire draft. He checks all the boxes for a future potential #1, including a big body, four-pitch mix, two potential plus-plus offerings, good athleticism, and repeatable mechanic that should improve as he continues to refine." Instead, every indication is that over the past 3+ years there has been zero grown. His stuff has stagnated at best, and backed up at worst. Looking at his velocity, the spring before his draft he was said to have a fastball that worked 91-96, but was inconsistent inning-to-inning and game-to-game. Today, you can basically copy-paste the same scouting report, though depending on who you talk to he is more in the low-90s than mid-90s. I think the exact same argument could be made for his command-and-control. And I'm not aware of anyone suggesting that his slider has improved in the past 3 years. Now, obviously this is a hard assertion to prove, and impossible to quantify without access to consistent PitchFX data. But that is my suspicion. I don't think it is completely fair to blame the Twins development for this - some HS kids develop better stuff; a lot don't. Stewart wouldn't be the first kid to have his stuff take a step back. But at the same time, the previous regime does not have many (if any?) positive results when it comes to guiding young power pitchers to the majors. So I guess that is why I'm holding onto some optimism for Stewart. Last year I was basically ready to write off Stewart as a non-prospect, but lots of prospect analysts were and are still bullish on Stewart's tools. Keith Law still has him ranked as a top-100 guy. The 2080 guys said he is still an arm that they really like. There is still upside there. A new regime with a better development program could work wonders for him.
  10. Two rebuttals to a couple of points that have been raised in Stewart's defense. - At this point we are almost four full seasons past his high school career. Whether or not he focused on baseball in high school should have such a minimal impact on his results right now. On top of that, at the time of the draft there was very little concern about how his HS football career was going to hold his development back on the mound. In fact, it was often brought up as a positive, in the sense that "look how good he is, and he hasn't even focused on pitching full time. Imagine how fast he will develop once he focuses on baseball full time!" Contrast the scouting reports of Stewart that year to those of Trey Ball, who EVERYONE agreed was a major, major project as a pitcher. Heck, even as late as October, 2013, Baseball America selected Stewart as the "Closest To The Majors" for that high school draft class. Personally, I think it is more of a post hoc excuse for his lackluster performance rather than a serious consideration at the time. - As mentioned above by Spycake, his results, particularly his ERAs and HR rates, have in part been surpressed by the leagues in which he has been playing. For example, a 3.20 ERA is superficially very good, but in the Florida State League in 2015, that was just league average. Similarly, he gave up 4 HRs in the FSL; the average pitcher in that league would have given up 6. A similar dynamic played out in the Southern League.
  11. Maybe? I obviously don't know the inner workings of the PECOTA system, but at a certain level all projection systems predict that young players will get better and older players will get worse. And the Twins, for the most part, are a young team. And they did make one major move. Adding up: 1) Going from Suzuki to Castro is a huge (3ish WAR) improvement for PECOTA because they incorporate their framing metrics into the projections. 2) Add a mild improvement for every starter under 27, subtract a mild downgrade for everyone over 30, and assume everyone in the middle maintains. This is a pretty young team, with 10-12 more young players than old. So even a mild age adjustment (say, 0.25 WAR) would add 3ish WAR. This is all very hand-wavey, but at a high-level that is the direction this team is moving. I think the 80 win projection is surprising - definitely higher than I would go - but I don't think that 75 or 77 is unreasonable, especially if one buys into the fact that the 2016 was better than its record indicated.
  12. An argument for the optimistic scenario runs something like this: - Their Pythag record last year was 65 wins. - Their BaseRuns record last year was 71 wins. So there were some signs that last year's team was really an unlucky 70-win team talent-wise. (Similar to how the 2015 team was a very lucky 75-win team talent-wise) If you use that as the baseline, then getting to 80 wins is possible. It's still a big lift, but not CRAZY.
  13. When did the fences change? I looked back several years, and frankly Diaz's results are middling at best compared to other Twins youngsters at Eizabethton. Josmil Pinto, 2009, 20yo, 166 wRC+ Oswaldo Arcia, 2010, 19yo, 197 wRC+ Eddie Rosario, 2011, 19yo, 175 wRC+ Miguel Sano, 2011, 18yo, 153 wRC+ Kennys Vargas, 2011, 20yo, 132 wRC+ Max Kepler, 2012, 19yo, 153 wRC+ Jorge Polanco, 2012, 18yo, 143 wRC+ Travis Harrison, 2012, 19yo, 138 wRC+ Jermaine Palacios, 2015, 18yo, 131 wRC+ Lewin Diaz, 2016, 19yo, 149 wRC+ Other than Sano, none of the others managed to hit enough (yet, anyways) to be an above-average 1B/DH option. But if the ballpark characterizations have changed, then maybe it is more meaningful.
  14. The projected standings have changed a lot in the last couple of days. The Twins are now up to 80-82. http://www.baseballprospectus.com/fantasy/dc/ <shrug/>
  15. He was better, but I don't think it was a massive step forward - he was very, very good as a sophomore. http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/profile.asp?P=stephe-strasburg
  16. On the flip side, there have been lots of college starters that projected to be top-of-the-rotation guys that failed to pan out. Appel, Miller, Matusz, et al. Jury is still out with Gray, Cole and Gausman. I'm not sure the data are stronger one direction or the other. Fortunately, the Twins still have several months to collect more information on these players. I'm definitely not a draft historian, but it certainly seems from what I've read that Greene is on a different level than most former top HS pitchers. He is way more athletic than Kolek, and it sounds like he has a lot more velocity than guys like Stewart, Aiken. In fact, I'm not sure even Giolito and Taillon regularly reached triple-digits. Anyway, I'd love to see a long-time draft guru (like Law or Callis, for example) write a post comparing/contrasting Greene to other top HS pitchers.
  17. Really? I thought he was the consensus top pick at this point in 2009. Who didn't have him ranked #1?
  18. I'm not sure how much interest he will have at the deadline even if he is pitching well. He doesn't strike anyone out, and he's not left-handed. Despite being quite successful last season (at least by ERA), the Nats didn't think he was worth having on their playoff roster.
  19. This list just reiterates how much of the near-term success of this franchise is dependent on Buxton and Sano (and Kepler/Berrios/Polanco to a lesser extent). It's awfully hard to put together a 90+ win team without having a core of 4-5 players contributing 20+ WAR. Is there anyone in the minors right now that can be penciled in for 4+ WAR in 2019 and beyond? The #1 pick might help, and maybe a future Dozier trade will also help.
  20. FWIW, Law had Jay listed in his "Just missed" article. He said that his stuff has backed up a little bit compared to where he was in college, but he should be given another year as a starter before switching him back to relief. http://www.espn.com/blog/keith-law/insider/post?id=6327
  21. I don't think the overall pool was cut at all, just the distribution was changed. So if the top 10 picks get less but picks 50-300 all get more, that's fine by me. Unless I fat-fingers something, the overall bonus pool is 2-3% higher this year than last year ($228M vs $233M).
  22. Gagne would have been the 9th best #5 pick of all time. Guzman would have been the 11th best.
  23. I have wondered throughout this entire process exactly how much they explored options without De Leon as the centerpiece. Maybe that route could have allowed for more high-upside-but-farther-away talent. For example, perhaps the Twins would have been able to get a package like Stewart, Buehler and Lux.
  24. The Rays are generally considered a pretty smart team, and they thought JDL was worth acquiring. They have made a living acquiring the right pitching prospects.
  25. He has often brought it up with regard to pitchers from Korea and Japan, who frequently have better results in the US than their raw stuff would indicate. And many of those pitchers (both starters and relievers) primarily get by with fastball-changeup or fastball-splitter combinations.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.