Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

markos

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by markos

  1. For anyone interested, I started a new thread to try to get feedback (on and off the record) from people regarding Dozier and the Dodgers. It has been interesting following these threads and seeing how varying the opinions are on all the players involved. I'm really curious if there is a consensus somewhere, and what that might be. http://twinsdaily.com/topic/24575-dozier-to-dodgers-feedback/ I'll post results after the New Year.
  2. My answers: 1) Who do you expect the Dodgers to consider untouchable? Urias, Bellinger, Alvarez 2) How do you rank the following pitching prospects (feel free to include other names): Yadier Alvarez, Walker Buehler, Jose De Leon, Jordan Sheffield, Brock Stewart, Ross Stripling? Alvarez, De Leon, <gap>, Buehler, Stewart, <gap> Sheffield, Stripling 3) How do you rank the following hitting prospects (feel free to include other names): Cody Bellinger, Willie Calhoun, Yusniel Diaz, Gavin Lux, Alex Verdugo? Bellinger, <gap>, Diaz, Verdugo, <gap>, Lux, <gap>, Calhoun 4) Which of these role players (if any) would you be okay with as a 3rd or 4th piece (add other names if you want): Austin Barnes, Chris Taylor, Trace Thompson, Andrew Toles, Scott Van Slyke? Taylor, Thompson, Toles 5) Who are some interesting sleepers in the Dodgers system that you like? Caleb Ferguson, Mitch White 6) Who are on your 'I don't want this player in a trade no matter what' list? Calhoun, Van Slyke, Barnes 7) What is your minimum acceptable trade? De Leon, Stewart, Thompson 8) What is your dream trade (that does not include anyone you considered untouchable)? De Leon, Buehler, Stewart 9) Would you consider it a failure if Dozier is in a Twins uniform on Opening Day? Yes 10) What do expect Dozier's WAR to be in 2017 & 2018? 4 & 3.5 11) If Dozier is traded to the Dodgers, what is your over/under for his home runs in 2017? 25
  3. I've found the conversations within the various Dozier-to-Dodgers threads to be facinating. Not only has the conversation been smart, but everyone has been very respectful of each others opinions - and wow, those opinions vary wildly! Since it sounds like the hot stove will be only slowly simmering over the holidays, I'd like to do a little project. In order to get a broader sense of the breath of opinions out there, I'd like people to share their thoughts about the Dodgers system and Dozier's value. Feel free to message me directly if you don't feel like commenting publicly. Once 2017 rolls in, I'll compile the results and share what the broader community thinks about the value of Dozier and the Dodger prospects. In order to provide some semblance of order, here are a list of questions: 1) Who do you expect the Dodgers to consider untouchable? 2) How do you rank the following pitching prospects (feel free to include other names): Yadier Alvarez, Walker Buehler, Jose De Leon, Jordan Sheffield, Brock Stewart, Ross Stripling? 3) How do you rank the following hitting prospects (feel free to include other names): Cody Bellinger, Willie Calhoun, Yusniel Diaz, Gavin Lux, Alex Verdugo? 4) Which of these role players (if any) would you be okay with as a 3rd or 4th piece (add other names if you want): Austin Barnes, Chris Taylor, Trace Thompson, Andrew Toles, Scott Van Slyke? 5) Who are some interesting sleepers in the Dodgers system that you like? 6) Who are on your 'I don't want this player in a trade no matter what' list? 7) What is your minimum acceptable trade? 8) What is your dream trade (that does not include anyone you considered untouchable)? 9) Would you consider it a failure if Dozier is in a Twins uniform on Opening Day? 10) What do expect Dozier's WAR to be in 2017 & 2018? 11) If Dozier is traded to the Dodgers, what is your over/under for his home runs in 2017?
  4. I have read the same thing over the years from multiple sources. However, I can't seems to find a systematic study. The closest I could find via google was this BP article: http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=19162 It just looked at top-10 prospects that were traded. Overall, top-10 prospects averaged 12 WAR during their first 6 seasons. Traded top-10 prospects only averaged 6.
  5. I asked Sickels about Beede vs De Leon after he posted his Giants prospect list: http://www.minorleagueball.com/2016/12/20/14025292/san-francisco-giants-top-50-prospects-for-2017#408705117 Interesting responses from various people. I can see a decent case made that Beede is the better prospect. Although it seems like he has been around forever, Beede is almost a year younger than De Leon. And he has shown way more durability. Also, it should be pointed out that the Giants have historically been pretty willing to trading prospects.
  6. This is exactly the kind of analysis that I've been trying to do in order to inform my expectations. Where did you come up with your numbers? I've been using a combination of two sources: 1) Prospect surplus values as determined by http://www.thepointofpittsburgh.com/mlb-prospect-surplus-values-2016-updated-edition/ 2) Manually calculating the values based on the Chris Mitchell's KATOH+ projections. http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/top-21-prospects-los-angeles-dodgers/ Both methods have De Leon worth $40M or so. Alvarez by ranking is probably $30M+; KATOH+ has him at $15M. I've played around with my own variation the surplus value model, and I agree that Dozier is worth something around $50M. A lot depends (obviously!) on what one projects for his 2017 and 2018 seasons. Pessimistic projections (like Steamer or Warcels) have him closer to $30M in surplus. Assuming he duplicates his best two seasons (6.5 and 5.2 bWAR), then he would be worth closer to $80M. Assuming 8 WAR over the next two seasons would be $50M in surplus value. I think that is pretty reasonable.
  7. He was a potential top-10 pick before dealing with a elbow injury his junior year. He had TJ, and just came back late last year. Scouts from his outings have reported that his stuff is all the way back; in fact, he appears to be throwing harder than he did in college (working 95+, hitting 99). That is way better than De Leon's 91-93. Also, there is some concern that De Leon's change-up-centric approach won't miss bats in the big leagues, but Buehler has legitimate swing-and-miss pitches in both his slider/cutter and curve. Can't argue with De Leon's results so far, and I have him ahead of Buehler. But I can see the argument the other way.
  8. No problem. I just didn't want other people to get TOO excited about Stewart.
  9. Just as a clarification, those are Fangraph's future grades, not present grades.
  10. I like Stewart a lot. I know he hasn't had the prospect hype of the other names, and has a preceived lower upside, but I think he has a good chance to be sneaky good - more than just a 5th starter. Now I fully admit that this is just scouting statlines (SSS statlines at that) , but I compared him to the following 4 pitchers who also had limited MLB looks: Lucas Giolito Jose Berrios Reynaldo Lopez Jose De Leon Here is how Stewart ranked in various categories: K% - 2nd BB% - 2nd Soft Contact% - 1st Fastball velocity - 4th but a virtual tie with Giolito and Berrios (93.4, 93.3, 93,2) Gap between fastball and changeup - 1st Chase % - 1st In zone Contact % - Most swing-and-misses on pitches in the strike zone Out zone Contact % - 2nd Most swing-and-misses on pitches outside the strike zone Overall Swinging Strike % - 1st His strikeout/walk numbers were very similar to Berrios in the high minors. He has demonstrated the ability to miss bats in the big leagues. He is currently giving up too much hard contact, maybe too many flyballs and way too many homers. But there is enough positive indicators that I think he has legitimate Tanner Roark/Scott Baker upside and is not just a run-of-the-mill AAAA arm.
  11. My inclination is also that Alvarez is off the table (sorry Dave! I wish I could believe!!). But that said, the Dodgers may have adjusted their opinion about him after having him in their system for a year. Maybe they think he is a huge injury risk? Or that there is no way that he can hold up as a starter? There are a few legitimate reasons why they would be willing to sell high on him. Basically, at this point I've convinced myself that if he is in a Dozier deal, then there must be something wrong with him.
  12. My fear is that the Dodgers will decide that their team is good enough to start the upcoming season, and will hold onto their prospects to potentially upgrade their team at the deadline. They don't need Dozier right now, in the sense that they are already the best team in their division on paper. They don't know exactly what injuries or performance dropoffs will occur between now and July. Maybe Kershaw will get hurt again, or Jensen will blow out his elbow, and all of a sudden they need to find pitching. Or maybe Grandal tears an ACL and they need to trade for a catcher. Or Pederson takes a major step back and they need an centerfielder. If anything happens, they will be in a much better position to acquire a difference maker at the deadline if they hold onto De Leon and Alvarez. Further, they can potentially still upgrade 2B without Dozier AND keep their prospects. It is possible that veterans will lower their FA prices as the off-season progresses - the Dodgers could put together a nice little platoon with Utley/Drew and Aaron Hill for pretty cheap. That isn't a terrible platoon, probably 50-75% of Dozier's production, and better than what they have. And they keep the flexibility and future value. The Twins have the advantage that they have the best player, but the Dodgers have the advantage that they don't NEED to make a deal, that they have secondary options that aren't terrible, and that they can always use the prospects they keep to improve their team in a different way later.
  13. I don't think this is all true. I don't recall anyone ranking Jay as the #1 pitching prospect, much less the #1 overall prospect. He was unanimously in the top-15 and mostly in the top-10, so it wasn't a giant reach for the Twins to pick him at #6. But it was still higher than he was ranked by most analysts. Frankly, I was surprised that they offered him the full slot value. It would have made the pick more understandable if they offered him an underslot deal and saved a few hundred thousand to spend another player or two later in the draft. http://insider.espn.com/mlb/draft/mock/?season=2015&version=1&source=Keith-Law-Big-Board http://www.baseballamerica.com/draft-preview/?
  14. I'd rather have Bucholz over Santiago. Seems like there is a pretty decent chance that the Phillies will be able to flip him at the deadline for more than they gave up to acquire him.
  15. Frankly, I don't care who the 3rd piece is if those two are included.
  16. Reminds me of another pre-draft scouting report from a past season: "The knock on X is the lack of a true secondary pitch. He pitches off his best weapon, a 92-94 mph fastball that has been up to 97 this spring. It has late life and finish. He has tried multiple grips and shapes with his breaking ball, and at times has flashed a fringe-average pitch that has tilt and late snap at 81 mph. X throws from a low three-quarters release point, which he doesn't repeat well, and that makes achieving downward action on his breaking ball difficult. His changeup is a below-average pitch that should improve when and if he throws it more often. Because of his size, athleticism and velocity, Xis a surefire first-rounder. The club that believes he can come up with a true breaking ball down the line could pop him as early as 10th or 11th overall." Madison Bumgarner, 2007 BA draft ranking: http://www.baseballamerica.com/online/draft/rankings/?rank=draft&year=2007
  17. Here is the article from a couple years ago. http://www.espn.com/blog/sweetspot/post/_/id/61823/was-mike-zuninos-failure-inevitable
  18. Yep. I read somewhere that you can do really well predicting success of the top college players just by looking at BBs and SOs: BBs > SOs == major league success. BBs < SOs == failure. Kendall last year, 62 SO, only 25 BBs.
  19. 2005? Liriano (21) Baker (23) Bonser (23) Durbin (23) Blackburn (23) Perkins (22) Garza (21) just drafted
  20. If you are saying the jury is still out on Jay (and I completely agree), then I think the same should be said about Romero. If you throw out Romero's "high school" years (age 17 and 18), then he has made all of 19 starts, and averaged only 5.6 IP/GS. He, like Jay, has yet to throw more than 90 innings in a season. Both have a long way to go - probably two full seasons of innings build up - before they can be counted on as legitimate big-league rotation candidates. Gonsalves, Berrios and Stewart have at least demonstrated the durability necessary to actually hold up over a full season.
  21. I understand and share the concern about Calhoun, but I like Stewart a lot. He is way, way, way better than Duensing ever was. He averaged 9+ K/9 and 2 BB/9 in the minors, averages 93+ on his fastball. Right now, he has way more in common with Scott Baker than he does with Duensing, Swarzak or similar ilk.
  22. I'm confident that there will be someone available with ace upside with their second and third picks. Defined broadly enough (and I define it pretty broadly), lots of pitchers have the potential to become an ace if everything works right. Consider 2010. Jameson Taillon was the clear-cut top pitching prospect in the draft and ended up going #2. If Harper wasn't in the same draft, Taillon would have had buzz as potentially the first RHP HS 1-1 pick, just like Greene. Noah Syndergaard was in the same draft. He was interesting: a big kid who worked 90-95 at the time, had a decent breaking ball but no change up. But he wasn't an elite draft prospect. He was given a 3rd-4th round grade; Keith Law didn't have him in his top-100 draft prospects; he was only offered a baseball scholarship from one college (Dallas Baptist University); he was drafted #38 but signed for 3rd round money. Aaron Sanchez is probably Ace-lite at this point, and he was picked just 5 spots ahead of Thor, also by the Blue Jays.
  23. MLB PIpeline also posted their top-50 draft prospects: http://m.mlb.com/news/article/210974064/hunter-greene-2017-draft-top-50-prospects-list/?topicid=151437456
  24. The slot distribution changed so that it isn't weighted as heavily toward the top picks. But I don't know what the exact change is. I haven't seen anyone distribute last year's slot values using the new rules, for example. But I have read that the top pick will get $1M-$2M less than last year.
  25. Another thought: Colorado and Baltimore are both trying to win now, and they both have competitive balance picks (though in the B round). I think the Twins should target those picks if they trade with them.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.