Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

markos

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by markos

  1. 80-61 have been posted. Fernando Romero makes an appearance. Still no Gordon or Jay (I'm guessing Jay doesn't make the list). Also, he ranked De Leon at #73, and part of the reasoning is that he says that De Leon doesn't have an out pitch, "De Leon generated just nine swing-and-misses in 302 pitches in the majors, which tells you something about his raw stuff." However, Fangraphs and BR both have him with 32 swing-and-misses in the big leagues, good for 10.3%, which would put him in the top-30 overall for qualified starters. Does anyone know of any other sources for swing-and-miss data? I don't think of Law as the type to make something like that up, but I'm at a lost for what would cause such a large discrepancy.
  2. Or alternatively, JDL was the guy that every other team wanted due to his proximity to the majors and minor league success.
  3. I'm not sure that playing crappily through an injury for several months is a positive thing.
  4. Sure, you can't dismiss positional scarcity, but it is also a factor that can change drastically over the next 18 months. So I do think it is worth trying to determine the underlying, intrinsic value of the player. My (incredibly simplistic) framework is this: Right now, say Dozier's intrinsic value is $2.00. In July, it will be $1.50. Next offseason, it will be $1.00. In July, 2018, it will be $0.50. The Dodgers are basically offering $1.00 for Dozier right now, and because of the current market conditions, that is the best offer available. Now, I don't think the Twins need to hold out for $2.00, as there is definitely some risk that Dozier will turn into a pumpkin or get injured or something like that. But right now there is a pretty big gap between what the Dodgers have been offering and what players of Dozier's caliber are traditionally worth. Further, there isn't a huge gap between what they are offering and what teams have traditionally been willing to offer for rentals at the end of their contracts. I've come full circle on this. Initially, I thought it would be a huge failure if Dozier is in a Twins uniform on Opening Day. But now, given the non-Dave rumors, I don't think that would be the wrong move, and actually it is a reasonable risk to take.
  5. I think there is a ton of evidence from recent trades (Zobrist, Cespedes, Kendrick, Heyward, Upton, Gomez, Lucroy) that Dozier should be able to still fetch a very good and MLB-ready pitching prospect either at the upcoming deadline, next offseason, or even at the 2018 deadline. If De Leon is basically the only, say, top-200 prospect being offered by the Dodgers, then the Twins should just walk away. I think there will be a prospect equivalent to De Leon (or at least 90% of De Leon) available over the next two years. And there is a non-zero chance that the market will move in the Twins favor depending on injuries.
  6. The Lucroy trade included Jeremy Jeffress, who has been an above-average reliever and has 3 seasons of team control left.
  7. IIRC, the site was primarily founded by a cadre of BP guys (Joe Hamrahi, Nick Faleris, Tucker Blair and Mauricio Rubio).
  8. The biggest problem with Adopt-A-Prospect is that the daily Minor League reports are too good. I adopted Alex Meyer for two years, and after every start 90% of the info that I'd want to share in the Alex Meyer thread was already reported in the Minor League report thread. And if there was any discussion to be had, it was mostly done in the Minor League report thread as well. It is hard to stay motivated to continue to update a prospect thread when you know the lion's share of the discussion and info will be elsewhere.
  9. Chris Mitchell's KATOH projections on Fangraphs add a unique perspective on these prospect rankings that's been missing. BP occasionally will put out list with their best PECOTA projections for prospects, but it isn't quite the same. I like it a lot. But that seems very different from the work that McDaniel, Farnsworth and now Longenhagen have been doing. Their lists seems much more scouting based.
  10. Yeah, the Fangraphs guys (much like BP) have really struggled to keep guys there for more than a couple years.
  11. If you use bWAR instead of fWAR, that just lowers the baseline. Last year the Twins only had 2 bWAR, so they need to improve by 14 WAR to get to league average and ~18 WAR to be above-average. And Santana's contribution is larger as well (4 bWAR). So using those numbers, they need to find 17-21 WAR worth of improvement. The underlying percentages don't end up changing very much - an solid return for Dozier will only fix ~33% of the problem.
  12. But at a certain level, the Twins need to rely on internal growth and luck for the majority of their pitching improvement regardless of any Dozier trade. This is my thought process (using back-of-the-envelope calculations and fWAR). Last year, the Twins pitching staff managed 8 fWAR, 3rd worst in the league. Average pitching WAR is 16; above-average is 20+. Somehow between today and 2019, the Twins need to lift the talent level of their pitching staff by 8-12 WAR. Actually, more than that, because we can be pretty confident that Santana won't be providing 3+ WAR in 2019. So let's say 10-14 WAR. Even an optimistic projection of a Dozier trade is only providing 5-6 WAR per season in 2019. More likely, it is probably closer to 3-4 WAR. So basically, a Dozier trade is only going to fix 25%-50% of the pitching problem. The majority of the lift to go from terrible to above-average needs to be done outside of the Dozier trade. This is why, in my opinion, the most important thing that the new front office can do is to fix the pitcher development program for the organization. Even if the Dozier-for-De Leon trade actually happens and De Leon becomes a bona-fide ace, it won't matter unless the Twins can find/develop 2-3 other above-average starters and 3-4 above-average bullpen arms. Trading Dozier for pitching is neither necessary nor sufficient for having an above-average pitching staff in 2019. It could certainly help on the margins, but there is no way that it alone bridges the current gap in talent.
  13. Do you have any idea what the Rays are doing? Seems like Smyly would fetch more than Smith and change. And don't they have enough outfielders already? Kiermaier, Souza, Dickerson, Rasmus, Mahtook... Almost feels like they are shedding money.
  14. I agree with most of this analysis. I would also add that if we assume that Dodgers best offer was De Leon and some 'junk', recent trade history indicates that a similar package should be available at this trade deadline or next season. For example, Jonathan Lucroy and Carlos Gomez both returned arguably better packages with 1.5 years of team control remaining. Howie Kendrick, Justin Upton, Ben Zobrist returned similar packages with just one year remaining. And while the Ben Zobrist and Yoenis Cespedes deadline deals don't quite match the quality of De Leon, their returns (Sean Manaea and Michael Fulmer respectively) were nothing to sneeze at. All in all, I think the Twins should have a fair amount of confidence that there will be equally good offers available during the next 18 months if they try to move Dozier again.
  15. Dave's reports notwithstanding, I really do think that the Dodgers were lowballing the Twins with regard to Dozier, and offering nothing much other than De Leon. From the Dodgers perspective: - Dozier is a luxury, not a need, for them. They are heavy favorites for the division without him. - Dozier is arguably more helpful for playoff success, but the Dodgers don't need to acquire him now for the playoffs. They can wait until July. - Dozier's value is unlikely to increase between now and July 31. Even if he demonstrates that his new performance level is for real, that is counterbalanced by having less service time remaining. So it is really unlikely that they would have to pay significantly more in July. - They have a pretty good idea that they are the only bidder right now, and given the distribution of 2B talent, they probably expect that to continue throughout the season. - The Dodgers are pretty stacked with prospects, so it is unlikely that they will be outbid in July if they don't want to be. For example, let's say that Daniel Murphy goes down with a season ending injury, and all of a sudden the Nationals want Dozier. It is highly unlikely at this point that the Nats would be able to outbid the Dodgers. The Dodgers have the prospect advantage over almost every other club right now, so they aren't in a position where they will miss out on Dozier if they don't act now. But if the Twins actually did turn down De Leon and Alvarez, well that's just crazy.
  16. But all three will be in the Twins organization in 2019 and beyond. Dozier won't be.
  17. This is a key point. The clock is already ticking on the Twins next contention window, whether it feels like it or not. 2021 is the last season that the Twins are guaranteed to have Sano and Buxton. If you think they are going to be the core of the next great Twins team, then you have to be planning around that window. That said, a guy like Alvarez can still contribute. First, if he reaches his ceiling, he is knocking down the doors of the majors in 2018, and potentially dominating in 2019. Second, even if he isn't quite ready, he could be an incredibly valuable trade chip circa 2018 if they decide they need to go get some pitching.
  18. But it is hard to gauge how those prospects were valued at the deadline. Arguably, both headliners had trended up quite a bit by the trade deadline. The following January, BA had Fulmer and Manaea ranked at #47 and #48 overall, which isn't too far off of where De Leon is going to be ranked.
  19. I think he is ranked high because most scouts/analysts agree that: 1) He can stick at short. 2) He will have enough power. 3) He has demonstrated very good contact and plate discipline skills at a very young age. When talking about slap hitters who may or may not develop power, there is a big difference between a guy like Revere (~.050 ISO) and a guy like Span (~.100 ISO). I think most scouts think (hope?) Albies will fall in the latter category and hit enough doubles and triples to be an average or better hitter. If he is also an average or better shortstop, then that is a 3-4 WAR player, just like Span was for much of his career. That's my two cents. I would like Albies in a trade, coupled with one of Wisler/Blair and then one of their high-upside A-ball pitchers.
  20. If you use Baseball Prospectus (which includes framing), Grandal was a 6.8 WAR player last year.
  21. This is an after-the-fact analysis, but this article walks through the logic that the Eaton deal was reasonable. http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/comparing-the-dexter-fowler-and-adam-eaton-decisions/ Basically, it all depends on if you think of Giolito's future projection. If one still considers him a top-10 prospect, then it was an overpay. If one considers him more of a run-of-the-mill prospect, say somewhere in the 40-60 range (and there is fair amount of evidence that he is trending that way), then it wasn't.
  22. I agree. Looking at past trades for similarish players (Lucroy, Gomez, Eaton, Donaldson, Kendrick, Zobrist (twice), Frazier, Upton, Tulowitzki, Simmons) and adjusting for context (for example, the Gomez trade included Mike Fiers, Kendrick was for a single season, Eaton has a longer contract, etc), Dozier is worth a top-50 prospect, a top-75-150 prospect and another piece of marginal value. For me, De Leon fits the top-50 piece and Stewart is in the top-75-150. That's why I have said a deal centered around those two is fair. As you pointed out, we are kind of flying blind with so little up-to-date prospect reports and rankings, but right now I feel pretty strongly that Alvarez is also a top-50 guy (I'd argue that if he was at, say, UCLA right now with his results and stuff, he would be on the short list for potential 1-1 in next years draft). So getting 2 top-50 guys plus another top-75-150 guy is a better deal for Dozier than any of the other trades from the past few years. For everyone who is arguing that minimally acceptable deal involves 3 top pieces, what are you using to set that expectation?
  23. As a counter-argument: - Dozier hit 75% of his home runs against the AL Central, despite only playing 44% of his games against them: 11 v KC, 8 v CWS, 6 v CLE, 6 vs DET. He hit as many home runs against the Royals as he did against all non-AL Central teams combined. - from June 1, 2015 through May 31, 2016 over 680 PAs, Dozier had a .685 OPS, 85wRC+ with only a .295 OBP. - since 1996, roughly once a year there is an infielder (2B, 3B, SS) in his late twenties who has a single season with >=30 RAA_offense despite not having a single prior season of >20 (like Dozier). Of those, only two managed to meet the >=30 RAA_offense threshold again. - if you expect Dozier to continue his second-half performance, you are basically arguing that Dozier will 1) continue to lead MLB in ISO by .030 points. 2) continue to exceed his career BABIP by .025 points. 3) continue to be among the top-10 in all of baseball in HR/FB ratio. For me, there are just so many warning signs in Dozier's second half that expecting him to meet or exceed his performance from last year seems very unlikely. Not impossible, but unlikely. I'm not saying that he is going to fall off a cliff, but I think that an expected value of 7-9 WAR over the next two seasons is much more likely than 10+.
  24. Sorry. Yes, my point was not fully fleshed out in my previous post. Basically, I was trying to point out that not ALL extensions are bad at this point and some would even enhance his trade value. So there might (might!) be a window where an extension is a win-win for the twins and Dozier. Especially since it isn't crazy to think that a 32-year-old Dozier might have very few options if he has a bad 2018, kind of like Desmond in after 2015.
  25. I don't disagree, but here is a thought experiment for everyone... If instead of having 2yr-$15M, he instead had 3yr-$26M with a team option for $14, is he more valuable or less valuable than he is right now?

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.