Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

markos

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by markos

  1. I see. I thought we were talking about "acceptable" as in "acceptable #3 starter for a playoff contending team." As an arm for the back of the rotation, I agree that he is perfectly fine. But I think he is more likely to be a below-average starter going forward (as he has been 2 of the last 3 seasons by ERA+) rather than the above-average starter he has though 9 starts. So I'd really like to see the Twins bring in someone better than Santiago, rather than just back-filling behind him.
  2. Santiago (and the Twins in general) has benefitted from fairly weak opponents so far. There was an article posted on Fangraphs yesterday that showed that the Twins have had the second-worst opponent offense so far. He has been acceptable so far, but I'm not sure how well that projects forward. Facing the Rays and Astros back-to-back will be a good test.
  3. I don't think Estrada or Cueto will be in a Twins uniform without at least one of Gordon/Gonsalves/Romero being involved in the trade. Estrada might even require two of them. That's not a move I'd support. Personally, I think this is a good year for the Twins to be involved in trades for longer-term pitching asset. Basically, it would be nice if someone became available like Cole Hamels a couples years back. That might end up being Chris Archer or Gerrit Cole. I don't know if the Twins have the prospect capital to get a pitcher like that, but that's the type of starter they should be targeting. I just don't think that a back-of-the-rotation arm moves the needle enough to justify the cost.
  4. Nick Gordon has continued his torrid start. After 154 plate appearances: AVG: .319 OBP: .383 SLG: .464 ISO: .145 BABIP: .396 wRC+: 145 K%: 20.1% BB%: 9.7% It is still the case that his overall slash line is bouyed by an un-sustainable BABIP, but his early season improvements in walk rate and power have held up. His K% is creeping up a little bit, which is worrisome, but for now the tradeoff for more walks and more power is one worth making. Overall one has to be happy with the improvements so far. It is also worth pointing out that he is still running a 50-50 platoon with Veilma between SS and 2B.
  5. Jeff Zimmerman in one of the HardBall Times annuals created a model to predict team-controled WAR based on overall draft pick number. I used that model to predict how much WAR the Twins should have accumulated from 2006-2011 from their picks in the first ten rounds. Based on his model, their draft picks during those years should have generated ~55 WAR, but instead have only generated ~30 WAR. That -25 WAR gap is one of the five worst both in absolute terms as well as relative to the expected value. The overall results may change a little bit over the next few years as guys like Dozier, Gibson, Hicks and Rosario finish out their team-control seasons, but I think they are pretty much assured of being well below-average at this point.
  6. I'm don't have a good feel for valuing Robertson. He isn't exactly in the same category as Chapman/Miller/Davis; maybe closer to the Melancon/Kimbrel level. Considering he is more than a rental, I'm guessing the White Sox are looking for a consensus top-100 prospect plus another prospect with upside. Given the cost of relievers over the past couple of trade deadlines, I don't have much interest in having the Twins dive into that market. I'd rather seen them roll the dice with the young guys instead.
  7. I'm struggling with his velocity as well. I do take a little bit of solace in the fact that, in general, lefties are able to get away with less velocity. Bumgarner, Lester, Quintana all average in the 91-92 range. It is possible that there isn't much difference, practically speaking, between Wright at 92-95 and McKay at 90-93 given their respective handedness.
  8. Shoulder injuries suck. I'm not sure there is any good way to predict who is or isn't going to succumb to one. Predicting pitching is so freaking hard. Looking back over the past 10 drafts, how many pitchers drafted in the top-10 actually turned into legitimate top-of-the-rotation pitchers? There have been ~50 pitchers selected, and the (super subjective) list of Aces is something like: Bumgarner Price Strasburg Harvey Cole Obviously some of the recent guys still have time, and you can quibble with these names. But there are a lot more failures than successes. And every kind of failure, too. High-upside vs high-floor, college vs HS, safe vs. risky. Each category has its successes and (more) failures. I have no clue what the right decision is. Without an elite college hitter on the board, any decision they make can be easily second-guessed.
  9. I've been hoping to see a writeup like this, as I've wanted someone to explain the case for Greene as a "generational talent." But frankly, this kind of leaves me underwhelmed.
  10. Yep. The biggest change in how I try to evaluate defense in the past, I don't know, 10 years is the realization that the ability to make spectacular plays at the edges of one's range is not sufficient, and often not even necessary, for a player to be a valuable defender.
  11. It will be interesting to see how long he is able to maintain his .450 BABIP.
  12. Yeah, they have been pretty good about that. I'd just like to know where the accounting has them overall.
  13. Has anyone seen an overall count of Spielman's draft pick plus/minus over the years? I know he has a reputation for being willing to trade up to get his guy. I'm just curious how many later round picks he has given up over the years to do that.
  14. I'm okay with taking at hitter at 1-1, provided they invest in high-upside pitching with later picks. I can't remember if I already posted it on this thread or not, but HS pitchers drafted with picks 30-45 have done basically just as well as HS pitchers drafted 1-15.
  15. When comparing to Yelich or Piscotty, it's worth remembering that HRs and RBIs are way more valuable in arbitration, so it isn't crazy to think that Sano's arbitration baseline should be higher.
  16. Yet MLB revenue and payroll has been skyrocketing during that time. I bet if you ranked that $7M increase over the past five years against the rest of the league, the Twins are probably in the bottom-5. Here are some payroll increases between 2011 and 2016 for mid-to-small market teams that should be comparable to the Twins: STL +$40M COL +$20M KC +$100M Bal +$60M Sea +$55M Pit +$50M Cle +$40M SD +$50M Oak +$15M TB +$20M
  17. I think it is mostly true that the Twins are among the least creative. Sure, the Twins haven't signed every single draftee exactly at slot since 2012. But neither has any other team. So you need to judge the Twins based on the other teams. Yes, they signed Benninghoff to a big-ish deal, but half the teams in baseball have signed at least one post-10th-round pick for similar money since 2012. That isn't a difference maker. Looking just at last year, Benninghoff was the only guy they signed for more than the 100K limit after round 10. Many other teams selected and signed multiple such players. The Dodgers alone signed 4. Going back further, since the current bonus pool structure started in 2012, the Twins have only signed 3 players total for more than the $100K limit after the 10th round. The only teams with the same or fewer such signings are the Orioles, Mariners and Rockies. Every other team has more. The Cardinals, Mets and Pirates all have signed 10 or more. And the Orioles and Mariners at least have the excuse that they have been winning and signing FAs, so their overall bonus pools have been much, much lower. Twins need to be judged based on opportunity. Since 2012, they have benefited by having some of the largest bonus pools and multiple extra picks. Yet I can count on one hand the number of "creative" moves that they have done over the past five drafts. So I think it is completely fair to say they are among the least creative teams in baseball.
  18. I'm starting to think that Gibson is cooked. Last year I kind of gave him a pass due to the various injuries. But his velocity just hasn't come back to his 2014-2015 levels, and his pitch movement just isn't the same either.
  19. History The Twins drafted Tyler Jay with the 6th overall pick in the 2015 draft out of the University of Illinois. After signing, he was assigned to Fort Myers, the Twins A+ affiliate in the Florida State League. He was put in the bullpen and pitched 18 ⅓ innings in 19 appearances. He finished with an ugly 3.93 ERA, but his peripherals were much stronger, as he struck out 27% of the batters he faced while only walking 10%, and he didn’t give up a single home run. In 2016, he was reassigned to Fort Myers, this time as a starter. He started 13 games and threw 69 ⅔ solid innings with a 2.84 ERA and good peripherals. After being promoted to AA Chattanooga, he started two games, moved to the bullpen for 3 more appearances before being shut down for the season with neck and shoulder injuries. Overall, his peripherals suffered as a starter, as his K% dropped to 22%. Pre-2017 Prospect Rankings Baseball Prospectus: #98 “Jay is slightly-framed—the uniform literally hangs off of him—and he didn’t consistently have the same mid-90s velo as a starter that he showed in short bursts. “ Minor League Ball (John Sickels): #99 ( B-prospect ) “I like his stuff a lot but ability to manage workload is an issue and prevents a higher grade at this time.” ESPN (Keith Law): Just Missed “industry-wide concerns remain about whether his slight frame could handle starting.” Fangraphs (Eric Longenhagen): Other Prospects in Consideration “This is a potentially dominant fastball/slider combination but the modest list of concerns scouts had about Jay as an amateur has grown a bit in the last 18 months. “ Baseball America: Unranked “The Twins’ Top 10 might have more questions than answers. ... Can lefthander Tyler Jay, the No. 6 overall pick in 2015, make a successful transition from reliever to starter?“ MLB Pipeline: Unranked “Jay's future continues to be debated even within the Twins organization. As a starter, he could have the chance to be at least a mid-rotation starter. Now that he is shortened up again, he could have both a 70-grade fastball and slider and get big league hitters out right now, with the ceiling of a future closer.” The consensus here is pretty clear: Jay didn’t answer any questions about his ability to transition to a starter during 2016, and the cautious optimism pre-draft has been replaced with a fair amount of skepticism. Outlook Early in spring training, the Twins announced that Jay was moving back to the bullpen for the foreseeable future. He was slated to start the season in the bullpen for Chattanooga, but instead he put on the DL with bicep tendinitis. Keys for 2017 Health: Hands down, the biggest key for Jay in 2017 is to demonstrate some kind of durability. Starting the season on the DL seems like an ominous sign, but hopefully he will come back soon and be able to pitch through the season effectively. Dominance: Once he starts pitching, I’m looking for signs that Jay will be a dominate force out of the bullpen. I’m not exactly sure what parameters I’d like to see, but I don’t think it is unreasonable to look for Jay to end up with a K% > 30% and BB% < 10% while at AA, and that he is effective against right-handed hitters and death to lefties.
  20. I don't think you are looking at the right team, as every single point you made is untrue. http://www.baseball-reference.com/register/team.cgi?id=9811adcd The 2017 Chattanooga Lookouts have used 26 players so far. 7 players are 23-and-younger [Gordon (21), Stewart (22), Romero (22), Rosario (23), Jorge (23), Wade (23), Vielma (23)] 7 players are 27-and-older [Rodriguez (27), Turley (27), Fernandez (27), Rohlfing (28), Tracy (28), Clemens (29)] The median hitter and pitcher ages for the team are actually OLDER than the PA-weighted average. They have the second oldest hitters (by PA-weighted average) and third oldest pitchers. Even if you broaden it to all of AA, Chattanooga is definitely in the bottom-10 with both hitters and pitchers. Also, the Chattanooga ERA is definitely bolstered by the fact that the 4 27-and-older pitchers have thrown 33% of the innings and combined for a 1.60 ERA. Now, your points would all be more-or-less correct if you were talking about the Rays, Cubs or Braves affiliates. Combined, they have a single 27-year-old, a pitcher who has pitched all of 5 innings.
  21. Are their any scenarios that you would support not taking Greene? I've been trying to think through some options, and I think it will be hard, risky, but not impossible for the Twins to come away with two top-10 talents. For example, they pick, say, Beck at 1-1 and offer $5.5M (roughly #5 money). If my back-of-the-envelope calculations are correct, they should be be able to scrape together another $5.5M at #35 if needed (combination of underslot at #37 and paying some bonus pool tax). Then they could convince some (all?) of the top college guys (like Wright, Bukauskas, Smith, Faedo, and Kendall) to demand top-5 money and threaten to go back to school (not unlike Mark Appel). BA's mock has Faedo going #10 to the Angels, and that spot only has a slot value of $4.3M. Beck+Faedo would be a pretty good haul.
  22. 54 plate appearances into the season, Nick Gordon is off to a hot start. Now, it is only 54 plate appearances, so please don't adjust your priors too much. But the early results are encouraging. AVG: .333 OBP: .389 SLG: .458 ISO: .125 BABIP: .385 wRC+: 157 K%: 16.7% BB%: 9.3% Now his overall batting line is inflated by a high BABIP, but the key factor right now is that he is hitting for power and his walk-rate is up without an increase in is strikeout-rate. He has played the majority of games at SS (8), but has a few starts at 2B as well (4). It's still early, but so far so good.
  23. Frankly, I don't think there is enough evidence to say that he is any different from the guy from last year. Maybe he should be put into a higher-leverage role. But he is succeeding right now because he hasn't given up a home run yet and has a .208 BABIP against. Both of those things are going to change. He has only faced 33 batters. His K% and BB% are "better", but we are only talking about a difference of 1 SO and 1 BB from what his rates from last year would predict. He isn't getting significantly more swinging strikes than last year, and his swinging strike rate of 10% would barely put him in the top-100 relievers from last year. His velocity is only up a little bit, and he has never been a high velocity guy. Even in college he was 88-92 out of the bullpen. There aren't many elite relievers that average <93 MPH. I think it is just too early to conclude anything about Duffey right now. Let's see how he is doing around Memorial Day.
  24. I would contend that Grossman in the outfield is a problem.
  25. I think that is a mischaracterization of what is happening here. I don't think it is contradictory to hold these two thoughts at the same time: 1) Play the kids as much as possible 2) If there is a level of play that is so bad that you won't play the kids, then have a backup plan in place. Personally, I would prefer that Buxton keeps playing through his struggles. But if they are going to sit him, then I would like a legitimate outfielder to take his place. And in my opinion, Grossman and Santana are not legitimate outfielders. Further, given the age, lack of experience and prior track records of Rosario/Buxton/Kepler, it certainly seems likely that at least one of them would struggle significantly. It's not like this was unforeseeable.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.