Everything posted by markos
-
Article: Daily Twins Daily: August 4, 2017
For what it's worth, Baseball Prospectus derived a proxy method for measuring framing without using PitchFX data that correlates pretty closely with their full framing stats. Using that, they had Garver as above-average last year in AA and slightly below-average this year in AAA. Also, their PECOTA projections think he will have ~.740 OPS (roughly league average) in the big leagues right now.
-
Article: Twins Trade Kintzler To Nationals
In defense of the front office regarding the rotation, I think they were counting on receiving a big-league-ready starter as part of any Brian Dozier trade. That trade soap opera didn't really finalize until the end of January, and by that point there weren't many (any?) good options remaining for starters to trade/sign. I guess Hammels was still available, as well as guys like Scott Feldman and Jered Weaver. But hard to fault them for just rolling with what they had at that point.
- Article: Rule 5 Addition Discussion
-
Article: Official Twins Daily July Trade Deadline Day Thread
I would say: Rosario two years ago. Polanco two years ago. Alex Meyer two years ago.
-
Article: Official Twins Daily July Trade Deadline Day Thread
I would be extremely happy if the ended up with one player that ranked C+ or higher.
-
Article: Official Twins Daily July Trade Deadline Day Thread
What I expect to see: - Kintzler - One other trade today Over/under of 2 trades today. What I would like to see: - Kintzler - Santana - Grossman -> Granite stays up when Buxton is called back up - Gimenez -> Garver called up as C/DH
-
Article: Official Twins Daily July Trade Deadline Day Thread
Underwhelming or not, anything is better than losing him for nothing at the end of the year. I will be happy with a return of anyone under the age of 24 that arguably slots into the top-30 of the Twins system.
- Article: Twins Trade Garcia To Yankees For Two Pitching Prospects
-
Rumor: Yankees and Twins had conversations about Santana
I know this isn't exactly what you asked (and I don't know if Gray is the guy I'd target...) but I have had thoughts that Kepler is the guy to dangle to try to get high-end pitching. Even though Buxton isn't hitting, I don't think he is replaceable by anyone in the organization at center. I'm as big a fan of Granite as you can find, but I don't think his defense, good as it is, matches Buxton's (for example, I'm 100% certain that Buxton catches Utley's double the other night). And as you mentioned, finding corner outfielders can be easier.
-
Rumor: Yankees and Twins had conversations about Santana
Or use the acquired prospects to trade for big league pitching in the offseason.
-
Article: Twins July Trade Candidates
For me, I have identical trade likelihood for Garcia and Kintzler. If one gets traded, I can't see any reason to hang onto the other.
-
Article: State Of The Twins: Reacting Too Quickly (Stream of Consciousness)
I would make only one minor addendum to your statement: Sell assets that won't be here to help us win long term and assets that are replaceable (in both ability and cost) in free agency. Santana, Escobar and maybe Grossman fit the latter criteria.
-
Can selling now improve 2018?
I see. Sorry, my comment came across harsher than I wanted. Generally speaking, I assume every player will try to get to free agency when they are this close. I thought maybe you had heard recent news/reports/rumors that he was open to an extension.
-
Can selling now improve 2018?
The case for trading Santana is: 1) It is highly likely that his 2018 performance (4.50-5.00 ERA, 180 innings) is replaceable this offseason in free agency for similar cost. 2) There are playoff teams that need pitching depth, in particular teams that are riding on young arms that may need help getting to and through the playoffs. Brewers and Yankees seem like best fits to me, but maybe the Nationals depending on how Strasburg's injury situation shakes out. 3) While acquiring MLB-ready pitching would be nice, the Twins don't necessarily need to trade for prospects that will be ready in 2018. Instead, they could just trade for lower-level prospects that they could use as trade chips in the offseason.
-
Can selling now improve 2018?
Do you know if that is even an option right now? Seems like Kintzler would be better off trying to get to free agency since he is so close.
-
Kyle Gibson optioned
Since Memorial Day weekend (past 11 starts), Gibson has a (admittedly weak) case as the Twins 3rd best pitcher. He has technically out-pitched Santana (lower ERA (4.83 vs 4.98), FIP (5.02 vs 5.78), xFIP (4.59 vs 4.91)) in almost idential innings/start (5.75 vs 5.97). He almost has as many quality starts as Santana and Berrios in that timeframe as well (4 vs 5). Also, if you look at BrooksBaseball, around the end of May he changed his release point and increased his velocity, which did add more movement to his pitches. That has corresponded with a return to his elite GB ways (top-20 in MLB). Overall, the results aren't great, but they certainly aren't terrible: 4.54 - American League average ERA for starters 4.83 - Gibson So for me, there is a clear separation right now between Gibson and the 5th-starter mess on this team. The latter problem was fixed (hopefully) with the Garcia trade. For what it's worth, both Steamer and PECOTA project Gibson to out-perform Colon over the rest of the season (Steamer significantly so). In the end, I think this is less about performance and more about roster flexibility - as many others have pointed out, Gibson can be optioned; Colon and Santiago cannot.
-
AL Central 2018 -- Is the door open?
The Royals backloaded a bunch of their contracts, so even though they have a lot of players coming off the books, they are only freeing up $10M-$20M (depending on what they do with arbitration and options). And I've read that they are probably beyond their payroll limit at their current $140M level. I don't see them signing anyone significant, though I could see one of Hosmer, Cain, or Moustakas accepting a qualifying offer.
-
Article: Twins Close To Acquiring LHP Jaime Garcia?
Yeah, I agree with your assumption. I think Garcia is not that dis-similar from the Mike Leake trade a couple years back. Leake, also a league-average-ish rental, was traded from the Reds to the Giants for two prospects, Keury Mella and Adam Duvall. Neither were top-100 guys, but both were legitimate prospects. Without working too hard to come up with comps, I think it would be something like Lachan Wells and Zach Granite.
-
Article: Rooker Promoted: Aggressive, or No?
The stigma placed upon these guys isn't that they will be old by the time they get to the majors; instead, it is placed on these guys because it is incredibly difficult to make any judgement about their performance when they are amongst the oldest players in their league. Rooker is going to be 23 next year. Anything he does below AA at that point is essentially meaningless as their are dozens and dozens of 23+yo college players who crush it in High-A every single season. I want to see him in AA next year not so much because it fast-tracks him to the majors, but because it puts him in an environment that will actually shed light on the likelihood of him reaching the big league and potentially becoming an impact performer.
-
Quintana to the Cubs
I'm really curious where you got your numbers from - particularly what your definitions of "stud" and "bust" are. I'm working on a project that is looking at this very topic. I don't have my data in front of me, but IIRC my numbers (using bWAR and BA top-100 lists since 1990) indicate that top-10 hitters are pretty good bets. ~60% end up above-average (>2 WAR/season) ~25% end up as a below average contributor (<2, >0.5 WAR/season) ~15% end up as a "bust" (<0.5 WAR/season) Now that doesn't necessarily contradict your comment (different definitions of stud and bust and whatnot). I'm mostly curious of other data sources that may or may not corroborate my analysis.
-
Quintana to the Cubs
Sure, but there is still a ton of risk buried in those rankings. They have had 4 top-11 picks and made 3 blockbuster trades, and they have focused 75% of the return on the riskiest, most high-variance asset in baseball - young pitching. Most analysis of prospect rankings has concluded that a pitcher will produce 25% to 50% less value over their team control than an equivalently ranked hitter. It seems like every other year there is talk about an amazing future pitching rotation that is working up through some teams minor league system, and over and over that has either failed to produce or fizzled out early. And their two best position players have significant risks in their own right. Yes, Moncada is the #1 prospect in baseball, but he is no Kris Bryant or Corey Seager. He is striking out over 33% of the time in AAA and may or may not stay in the infield. Jimenez is also very good, but he is just in high-A and strickly a corner outfielder. If his bat fails to project for whatever reason - lack of contact, power, walks or whatever, then he is just a guy, not a GUY. So maybe this all is just my pro-Twins thinking, but I really do think that the White Sox are on the road towards having an 80-85 win team four years that is good at piching but with mediocre hitting. At this point I don't see a future juggernaut. That said, they do have a couple more players to trade, as well as draft and free agency.
-
Quintana to the Cubs
They almost have to, right? Their position player pipeline is still really thin. Moancada and Jimenez are nice pieces (I guess like Buxton and Sano back in the day), but they don't really have any Gordons, Polancos, Keplers or even Rosarios also in the pipeline. Basically, if you broaden it to all 24-and-under position players (majors or minors), the Twins are way, way, way ahead of where the White Sox are.
-
Quintana to the Cubs
Yep. More evidence to my contention that the Twins just can't compete for elite players on the trade market right now.
-
Article: Deadline Primer: Should Nick Gordon Be On The Table?
The idea is that Santana is replaceable in free agency during the offseason. I know that opinions vary on Santana's future performance, but I'm more on the pessimistic side. Santana is on the books for $13M next year with a $14M team option for 2019. For that amount of money, the Twins should be able to find a reasonable facsimile of 35-36yo Santana. Between Santiago, Perkins and Gibson, the Twins have an additional $18M coming off the books. Obviously the details matter, but I'm thinking something like this scenario: - trade Santana to the a team (ex. Brewers: logic being that the Brewers could use some pitching help this year, and Santana makes a ready Garza replacement after he leaves in free agency this year) for a pitching prospect that is close but not quite major league ready (ex. Luis Ortiz: top-100 prospect, good-but-not-great 21yo in AA) and another prospect who would be top-30ish in the Twins org. - this offseason, sign one of the second-tier FA pitchers (Pineda/Lynn/Cobb) to a Jeff Samardzija-esque deal (5yr/~$100M). - also sign one of the older FA pitchers to 1 or 2 year deal at <$10/yr (Feldman/Estrada/Chavez/Vargas) Going into next year, the rotation is: Berrios Pineda/Lynn/Cobb Feldman/Estrada/Chavez/Vargas Meija Gonsalves/Ortiz/Romero While that is no one's idea of an elite rotation, I think it is respectable - at the very least better than what they've rolled out for much of this season. And based of my back-of-the-envelope calculations, they should still have ~$10M-15M left to address the bullpen.
- Article: Deadline Primer: Should Nick Gordon Be On The Table?