Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

markos

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by markos

  1. I think the most difficult challenge for 2018 will be threading the needle between development and contending. As some examples: - Kepler can't hit lefties right now. At some point (let's say June) he still has a sub-.600 OPS against lefties, do the Twins start platooning him? - Polanco spent a good chunk of the season as one of the worst hitters in baseball. If he starts off like that again, how much leash does he get? - Mejia was a serviceable back-of-the-rotation arm, and I'm reasonably optimistic that he could potentially be more. But if he struggles in April, how many starts does he get before getting demoted to the bullpen or AAA? If the Twins were not contenders, the easy answer is to give each of them as many PAs or starts as possible. But this team is a contender (and a weak one who will need every win possible), which makes the decision more difficult. Similarly, the second most difficult challenge will be how long to stick with older players who struggle to start the season: - Mauer just has his best season since 2013. How much should he play if he reverts to his 2015 form and has a .720 OPS in June? - How long is Gibson's leash this season? Last year he was given a second chance after a disastrous start, and for the most part he made that decision look good. With a (potentially) deeper rotation this year, does he get another chance like that? - Castro just has his best hitting season since 2013 at age 30. When do they switch it from Castro-Garver to Garver-Castro if he isn't hitting. Obviously not all of these situations will occur. But the several of them might, and every day the coaching staff and front office will need to make decisions regarding who gives the team the best chance to win.
  2. There have been similar situations where MLB has still suspended players: https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/mlb-bans-derek-norris-from-playing-for-rest-of-2017-under-domestic-violence-policy/ https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/mlb-suspends-mets-jeurys-familia-15-games-under-domestic-violence-policy/ It will be telling if Addison Russell gets any suspension for his incident: https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/mlb/2017/06/21/addison-russell-wife-mlb-domestic-violence-investigation/416595001/
  3. That makes so much more sense. Thanks for clarifying.
  4. His wRC+ (which purportedly adjusts for league and ballpark factors) increased from 112 to 117. As to whether or not that 5-point increase in wRC+ is meaningful, well, that is certainly debatable.
  5. While I certainly don't think it is likely, it is certainly possible for two reasons. First, this is baseball, and just about anyone can seemingly wake up as one of the best hitters in baseball. Second, beyond the randomness, Rooker does have a solid track record and an existing toolkit to thrive in the current juiced-ball, no ground balls environment. It certainly isn't crazy to see him tighten up his strike zone judgement in a way that Sano has failed to do so far.
  6. I'm not certain that you are looking at the correct data. Gordon's OPS: 2016: .721 2017: .749 OBP: 2016: .335 2017: .341 I would not characterize a 28-point difference in OPS as microscopic. Over a full season, that is roughly 10 runs (approximately 1 WAR). I do think that it is fair to say that across the board (other than K%, which directly affects BA), Gordon was better in 2017. BB%, BB/K, ISO, OBP, SLG, GB% (way lower), LD%, FB% (both way up), SB%. All that said, I agree that the end of last season was disappointing, and I also agree that he still needs to show a lot next year. But I think that it is very encouraging that for the first time he actually showed some power. Admittedly, it is a small sample, but for years now scouts that liked him have been betting that he would start tapping more power than he had shown in HS and the lower minors. Well, it finally flashed for a while. It might not stick (it didn't really in the second half), but it is undoubtedly better to show a skill, even over a small sample, than to have never shown the skill at all. I still have him as my #2 in the Twins system.
  7. markos commented on Physics Guy's blog entry in Blog Physics Guy
    This is a good twist on the usual prospect list. Interesting to think through the prospects from this angle. Mostly agree with your list. It is hard to know where to put Gordon. He could easily put pushed into a starters role depending on injuries, but otherwise I think he is kind of a long shot to spend any meaningful time in the majors this year. If I was to make one change, I would probably move Littell up a few spots.
  8. For me, the only actionable info from this kind of analysis is in determining whether or not Rosario is a viable option to be a back-up CF in case Buxton is out of the lineup for a few days (a DL stint probably means Granite is brought up). When he initially came up, I thought that Rosario could easily cover that roll. While no one is going to match Buxton's defensive ability, I think the gap between Buxton and Rosario is now much larger than I initially thought. So I'm now leaning toward having the 4th OF position go to someone who is a legitimate CF option rather than purely a corner guy.
  9. I really don't like this trade for the Pirates, but it is clear that the Twins couldn't provide what they were looking for. They wanted big league ready players, and right now the Twins don't have a surplus of players like that. Granite is probably the only one. On a related note, has the "trade in a dollar for 4 quarters to try to extend a window of contention" plan worked for any small-market team yet? The Rays tried really hard (trading Shields, Zobrist, Price, et al), but they haven't had a winning season since 2013. It certainly looks like the Pirates are trying hard to win 75-80 games a year.
  10. I think Mejia has a fair amount of trade value. He just finished his rookie season with a league-average ERA, and did a good job of missing bats both inside and outside the strike zone. Obviously, he has to tighten up his control in order to become a mid-rotation starter, but every year teams have to hand out multi-million dollar deals to veteran pitchers who have less upside than Mejia. Having him on the roster for the next six seasons for cheap is valuable. Personally, I have him as one of my top-10 assets.
  11. At what cost? That has to be factored in here. Buxton has already made multi-millions via his signing bonus plus his league-minimum salaries the past few seasons. If you are going to buy out free agent seasons, you'll have to make it worth his while. $150M over those 7 years? Lindor has reportedly turned down a $100M+ offer already. I think the current crop of young stars (Correa, Lindor, Bryant, Seager, et al) are going to push the envelope when it comes to extensions (and at least wait until after Harper/Machado reset the market next year). Also, if Fangraphs has figured out that long-term deals are overwhelmingly good deals for the teams, agents and the players union have probably figured out that out as well. I think the era of extremely team-friendly extensions (like Longoria's first deal or McCutchen's) for superstar players is probably over.
  12. On a scale of 1 (zero reason for concern) to 10 (he's going to be a bust), how worried are you about Javier's strikeouts? He K-ed in 27% of his PA last year, which was actually more than Sano when he was in Elizabethton. I'm probably at a 7 right now.
  13. You might be surprised how quickly the Wimmers and Levis return once the Twins start drafting in the mid-to-late 20s for several years in a row. Such is the rhythm of baseball...
  14. The questions about his defense were more about arm strength rather than footwork. Though that also can improve through instruction.
  15. This is a good interview, even though it wasn't as Twins-centric as I had hoped. One thing that stuck in my mind... Adler mentioned that the Twins actually had solid technical infrastructure created prior to Falvey's arrival, with a system that was running in the cloud and provided a systematic method for storing and accessing player data, models, etc. This comment corroborates other info I've heard from people within the front office. While Jack Goin's tenure with the Twins left some things to be desired on the research and analytic side, I think it is pretty clear that he took the job of creating/designing the technical infrastructure to support the research and analytics seriously, and everything I've heard/read indicates that he did a good job in that area.
  16. I think this avenue should be explored. Don't sell for Sano for peanuts, but if a team is willing to trade a legitimate top-of-the-rotation arm, then they should consider pulling the trigger. Unfortunately, I just don't see a lot of obvious options. Most of the top pitchers are already on contending teams. I can see arguments for the Rays to move Chris Archer or the Mets to move Jacob deGrom in exchange for Sano.
  17. I'm not sure this exactly answers your question, but this is my current analysis of Rosario's defense: When Rosario was first called up, I also assumed that he was a legit centerfielder that would be a real asset in the corners. But I've changed my mind for a number of reasons. It is easy to dismiss defensive stats, especially in small samples (though the statcast data may actually turn the corner on this - too early to tell). But with Rosario we almost three full seasons of data that tell a pretty consistent story. Further, it is backed up by some of the statcast metrics. - Statcast has been tracking the sprint speed of players for the past three seasons. Rosario's sprint speed readings have deteriorated every single season. His speed is no longer close to the average centerfielder and is barely an average corner-outfielder. He is slower than the almost-34 Denard Span, and he matches up close to guys like Justin Upton, Michael Conforto, and Aaron Judge. - Every single defensive metric (UZR, DRS, Statcast Outs-Above-Average, FRAA from BP, Clay Davenport) agreed that Rosario was somewhere between average and below-average last year. - If you pull out his arm statistics from 2015, every single metric throughout his entire career has agreed that Rosario is average-at-best when it comes to making plays. - I don't watch a ton of games, but this matches my eye test. Looking at the facets of outfield efficiency (first step, raw speed, route effiency, judging the wall, glovework), I can't say that I think Rosario is definitely above-average in any area. Don't get me wrong, I don't think he isn't bad in any area either. Just kind of average. Given his average raw athleticism, I think it is hard to make an eye-test case that he is above-average. Projecting forward, I think there are signs of concern: there is evidence that defensive ability peaks in the early-twenties - Rosario is now 26 - and his sprint speed has already decreased three years in a row. If those trends continue, I wouldn't be shocked if he settles in as a below-average-but-not-dumpster-fire outfielder by the time he reaches free agency. Something like 5-15 runs below average per season - i.e. more Melky Cabrera than Brett Gardner.
  18. Awesome post. Thanks so much for sharing.
  19. Baseball Reference has one estimate of his value. Fangraphs and Baseball Prospectus have very different estimates: Fangraphs valued him as a 3-5 WAR pitcher the past three seasons; Baseball Prospectus valued him as 5-6 WAR pitcher. So there are definitely analytic systems that value him highly. There is some evidence with James Shields and David Price that BR systemically underrates their pitching. If you were to predict their post-trade bWAR performance based on their last four seasons in TB, they both exceeded that expectation by ~50% after their respective trades. That gap is much smaller using fWAR: almost perfectly predictive in Shield's case and only underestimating Price's performance by ~10%. Obviously, Shields and Price are a sample size of two, so take it with a grain of salt. But at the same time, it certainly wouldn't surprise me in the least that BR's pitching WAR model breaks down a little bit at the extremes, and it is certainly the case that the Rays, by putting very good defenses in an extreme pitcher's park, are definitely an outlier. In fact, BR calculated that Archer had the 2nd easiest run environment (combination of opponents/ballparks/defense) of any pitcher in the AL behind fellow Ray Odorizzi. But it also made those decisions based on some contentious assumption. BR calculated that Archer's stadiums depressed run scoring by 4.5%; BP calculated it less that 2%. BR used DRS for defense which has the Rays as the best defense in baseball, 50 runs above average. UZR only has them at 8th, almost 30 runs less. All that said, I lean more towards Fangraphs and BP in this case. I don't think it is unreasonable at all to value Archer in similar terms to Jose Quintana. By age, performance, and contract they are very close. And Quintana did end up fetching an elite prospect in Jimenez and a very solid pitching prospect in Cease. I think Lewis + Romero is the Twins equivalent.
  20. This is my interpretation of the front office's thinking with the Rule V draft: - Hard throwing right-handed relievers are not a rare comodity across baseball. Every team has multiple guys in their minor league system that can throw hard but lack the results/durability to be a difference maker in the majors. Some small subset of those guys will have the light turn on and be dominate. Predicting the breakouts is hard - maybe impossible - so it is best to maximize chances. - Burdi is damaged goods to a certain degree. Have Atlanta nix the trade due after seeing his medicals is a pretty big red flag. - Given the above, there was a good chance that Burdi or Bard would have been passed over in the draft. - Even though they were drafted, there is a decent chance (maybe 50%) that they will be returned. - There were probably some players that they really like and were hoping would drop to pick 20. I'm not convinced that Kinley was the #1 guy on their board from the beginning. So playing that all out, there was a chance that by opening day the Twins would have all 3 players in their system, with only the Rule V pick taking up a 40-man spot. Additionally, there was also a chance that one of the players that they really liked would have dropped to #20. That is the best outcome, and conveniently also the outcome with the most roster flexibility. The risk was that they lose Bard and Burdi for essentially nothing, which is what might happen (there is still a chance that one or both gets returned). But given the rates at which Rule V draftees get returned (and Burdi's medicals), I think it was a risk worth taking. To sum up, I'm not convinced that they like Kinley more than Burdi or Bard. I think they went with the roster decisions that maximized the potential upside and roster flexibility.
  21. I largely agree with dbminn's analysis. I also think Buxton is ~$80M, but I actually have Sano (at ~$50M) lower for two reasons: 1) I think his projection overrates this PAs for next season. They are projecting ~600 PAs and he hasn't cracked 500 PAs yet. 2) He is going to be paid a lot (relative to Buxton) in arbitration because he is a HR and RBI guy. Based on the historic perfomance of #1 picks (average ~17 WAR over their first 7 seasons) and his current age (at least two full seasons away from the majors), I think ~$70M is a reasonable guess for Royce Lewis. And as dbminn said, there are a lot of levers you can pull that will adjust these numbers. So take the specific values with a large grain of salt. But directionally, I think they are correct - Archer is probably 25%-50% more valuable than any of Sano/Buxton/Lewis, so it will take more than just one of them (but less than two of them) to pry Archer away from the Rays.
  22. markos replied to Brandon's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
    I might have the details wrong, but the general idea is that the Dodgers swapped ~$38M in salary in 2018 for ~$38M spread between 2018 and 2019. This allows the Dodgers to get under the luxury tax threshold this season (they have been over for years - resetting this will save them tens of millions over the next few years). Atlanta gets to save ~$19M in 2019 by moving that money forward to 2018, plus McCarthy and Culberson have some legitimate value. Atlanta probably has thoughts of being a buyer next offseason, so having Kemp's salary moved makes some sense there.
  23. Very solid move. Obviously doesn't solve anything for next year, but definitely a good move looking forward.
  24. First, I think Cole has a fairly reasonable floor - he was an innings eater last year but still manage ~3 WAR, and prior to that he has averaged at least 4 WAR/200 innings. So that is good, especially considering where the Twins rotation is. Second, I think there is still a lot of upside. He just completed his age-26 season, so he is younger than anyone on the free agent market. He throws HARD, averaging over 95+ on his fastball. He has all the ingredients to make a leap in the next two seasons. It obviously isn't a given that he will, but he certainly can. And it isn't unheard of for pitchers to take their game to another level in their late-20s: Scherzer, Arrieta, and Kluber all went from slightly-better-than-league-average to Cy Young contender at age 28. That is the bet I'm making when I'm advocating for Cole. So that is what I think we are getting. A reasonable floor over the next two seasons with legitimate top-of-the-rotation upside. I think that is a good bet for the Twins to take right now.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.