Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Tomj14

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Tomj14

  1. I don't think either are really blocked, there are plenty available innings and at bats for a 4th OF, that can can also play DH and 1B. If he is hot you can start him at DH once a week, 1B once a week. and couple of times in the outfield, and if he is still better than anybody, well that player moves into 4th outfielder role. Same can be said for Lewis at 3B, 2B, SS and possibly CF, which could be harder to move Donaldson because of salary but Polanco and Arraez can and should be moved in and out if Lewis is better than either. The only way I see a prospect blocked is if Kirlloff, Lewis and Larnach are all mashing in the minors at the same time, but you than how great is that
  2. "Do the Twins Really Need to Add Another Starter?" As of 1/16/2020 they don't NEED to add another starter, they have a bunch. I mean one is out at least half the year, another is injury prone and suspended for a 1/4 of the season, one has had pretty bad second half, one before his "contract" year was just above average, and 4 are basically rookies and one of them is injury prone. So do I fell confident in the above to win the central and go deep into the playoffs. ummm, not really, but super hopeful that two of those rookies pitch well enough to pencil in the rotation next year. So with that said, No they don't need to add another starter, but it would help this year and the future to bring in a pitcher you could pencil in the rotation for a least a few years, so they aren't going into every off season looking for 2,3,4 starting pitchers to fill out the rotation.
  3. Well the crow I ate for breakfast tasted pretty darn good. If I would have actually thought they would sign Donaldson, I wouldn't have been as critical of them not signing the pitchers.
  4. Last year was absolutely a success based on 101 wins, winning the division, homer record and some might say because they kept the core and prospects in tact, but mostly because it was fun to watch and see. But it also felt a little hollow because when this HUGE surprise was happening some of the fans seen this team was missing a few pieces and hoped like heck the Front Office seen how special this team was and would fill those needs and give the players and fans a chance at some super special. That didn't happen and then they got swept. So the fans were hoping for a little bit of excitement and talent being brought in to help this team this off season and nothing, sure they brought in a few arms that might help (hopefully will) but not one of my friends that are Twins fans, tweeted, texted or emailed saying sweet we got the player X. And for a team coming off of what they Twins did last season to basically do nothing to excite the fan base between that sweep and opening day is a complete failure (Only the biggest fans give two rats arse about spring training). The moves they made might be good baseball moves but most twins fans aren't on here breaking down these pitchers.
  5. He has no shot, how would they justify putting him in and leaving the other steroid users out?
  6. "Is Garver the best catcher in baseball? Is he one of the best offensive backstops in MLB history?" I love me some Garver, but lets not get crazy about Garver, He isn't the best catcher in baseball (yet) and is no where near one of the best offensive backstops ever at this point in his career (218 games and 5.7 oWar) and he will be 29 years old in a week.
  7. So in Two years when the Twins have Buxton, Kepler, Rosario, the guys will be in the minors and not playing on the big club at whatever position is needed? If that is the case they need to start trading some of the depth that is going to rot in the minors.
  8. I don't think it is unfair at all Cruz makes 12 million any young guy will make basically league minimum, and Castellanos will make more than Cruz with possibly less production, if the Twins minor league system is as good as everybody says, Rooker, Kirilloff, Larnach, Wallner and others could be putting up those numbers by 2021 or 2022 when Castellanos be given a full time job. By then Jeffers could be up and Garver be the DH, it makes zero sense to sign a DH for more than one or two years, plus everybody loves this so called "payroll flexibility" why give up any of that on a bat only player? I mean if Cruz wasn't here I could get behind giving Castellanos a 2/24 contract but that is it.
  9. So you are going to pay more (Nick) for less than what Cruz gives you offensively? That is some sort of logic.
  10. If you aren't going to sign an all star (non-pitcher) you don't give any player a contract longer than two years. You have so many guys getting close (in the next few years) that in no way should a costly non-all star be blocking them.
  11. I am guessing that it is his career high WAR is 2.9 in 2018 (he does have a pretty decent oWAR the last two years at 3.6 and 4.7). He doesn't wow people, plays no defense, costs a bunch of money and if the Twins aren't going to spend on pitching don't be stupid and spend on guys that block the greatest collections of prospects possibly ever assembled.
  12. It is the Twins so that is why they won't splurge, they might offer something like 2 years 24 million. Why would they pay more or go longer when you have possibly the greatest minor league system ever? On top of next year they will possibly be looking at starting pitchers again, plus Cruz could be gone, and they year after that possibly replacing Sano and Rosario.
  13. The odds are the Twins would offer one less year than Castellanos wants and he goes somewhere else. Just saying!
  14. Good luck trading for any good to great pitcher if you think Cost makes them a negative trade value. Sure it would be great if the Sox ate the 50 million deferred money. But if he would have hit the open market this year instead of signing the extension I would believe some team would have paid him the 5/145 he got. Plus there is a chance if he returns to form he opts out after 2022. So it really would be 3/90.
  15. The only two trades I see the other team taking are possibly the Tigers and the Mets. Sale is 30 years old and had 218 K's 147 innings and a WAR of 2.3 in basically his worst season since becoming a starting pitcher. If the Twins could get him and no cash for Brusdar Graterol, C Ryan Jeffers, OF Gilberto Celestino, yes please, he is exactly what they Twins have needed for a long time. But no chance Boston would take that offer, ZERO, if they really want to get rid of him, they could get twice that at the deadline even if he is only slightly better next year than this year or wait until he is a bit healthier and get more. He is what I see happening, Boston keeps him and he is pretty good, around the deadline the Astros trade for him and they are back to their 3 big starting pitchers, the Twins and their fans are still talking about how great their prospects and just wait until 2022 when they are kicking butt. Sure Sano, Berrios, Buxton, Cruz, Odo, will be gone by then but you just wait it is going to be awesome. Maybe by then other teams will be willing to trade the Twins their best guys for a bunch of middle tier prospects.
  16. Would you trade Berrios for Lewis and Kirilloff/Larnach? If your answer is no, then IMO you could assume the Rays answer would be no as well. If I was trading Berrios to the Twins for prospects, it would take 3 of the top 10 guys and another from 11-20. (Lewis/Kiriloff, Larnach, Graterol/Balacovic and somebody else) So that is the what I would expect the price for Snell or any pitcher of his caliber to be. Or something close possibly removing Larnach and adding Thorpe/Dobnack/Smelzter. And here is the deal with they way this off season is going, maybe the Twins should be looking at trading Berrios for a similar haul
  17. Didn't realize the rule change, which makes depending on 3 rookies even worse.
  18. I wish Gonzo and Romero would have realized it was just that easy to fix.
  19. Lets be honest the 5th spot will be a rotation of players going back and forth between AAA, unless one flat out is great. Thorpe starts and after the game he will be on a plan back to AAA Smelzter will be up ready to pitch in relief or the next start, then after the game he will be sent down and the next guy will be here. There really will be no reason to have 5 set starters, when then continue to keep guys fresh and innings count down by sending them down for 10 days. IMO
  20. It comes from this is the same story that was told when it was Sano, Buxton, Kepler, Rosario, Berrios, Gonzo, Romero, and bunch of other prospects that failed (not saying the ones above failed, just the ones that did). This group has had a great regular season and a good one and hopefully another great one this year. But the payroll gods are coming because this group is getting really expensive and nothing (very little) was done to help them get deep in the playoffs before that bill comes due, why would this next group be any different?
  21. At 7 million, it seems like a good bet they will him out there until he is hurt, even if he is a terrible as Perez became.
  22. He is the problem with these signings. #1 7 million is to much money to cut him if he is terrible or put him in the pen. Christ they couldn’t do that with Perez. #2 basically signing hill means not trade for a starting pitcher at the deadline, they will say can’t give up prospects for somebody that isn’t as good as hill or they will be so bad that the need for two starting pitchers is crazy to trade prospects for. IMO as much as I would have been pissed expecting rookies to pitch 3/5 of a rotation at least if they were good you could go get more, now not so much, and at this point no need to sign Donaldson he can only hurt the payroll flexibility when they are once again going to need a handful of starting pitchers
  23. based on your comment right above this, why would you ever extend anybody?
  24. So never try, also pretend the future is near but never really mean it and if you get a season like 2019, tell the fans that was great but we are building for the future, the future that will never actually come. Congrats this is the new way for the MN Twins, and I will never pay for a seat in the Stadium to support this, I will watch on TV or listen on the radio to the team I love, but never really allow my self to go all in, in my heart when I know the team really never as either.
  25. They burned payroll flexibility by signing two guys to contracts more than one year? Please share the kool aid, I would love to have some, honestly I would love to have some.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.