Everything posted by Dman
-
Gilberto Celestino’s Long-Term Upside
Celestino got off to a hot start last year but also had an unsustainable BABIP. I didn't watch a ton of Twins games last year but when I did I saw him mainly hit singles. I did sour on his bat as the season went on he was kind of a black hole in the lineup. If he doesn't develop power then to me he is a 4th outfielder at best. Still he is a right handed outfield bat and I believe he will improve as time goes on. As most on here are saying he should start at AAA and earn his way back up.
-
Temp Check on Austin Martin
To use an extreme example look at Aaron Judge vs Luis Arraez. Judge can hit the ball out of the park. He walks a lot and he hits for a decent average. He also plays above average defense at his position. Which team would have more success a team full Arraez type players or Aaron Judge type players? I think you know the answer. Since Arraez doesn't have power it doesn't mean he isn't valuable it just means he isn't as valuable as players who have close to his skills at the plate plus power. If you are looking to make your team better you are looking for players that fill out the full spectrum of skill set and power is an important piece as with one swing you can change a game. In Summary encouraging players that make good contact to sell out for power can make them more valuable if they can do it. I would say developing power is very important in todays game and likely always will be.
-
Temp Check on Austin Martin
I think Martin profiles best in Center field if his defense is good there. He doesn't have a great arm and that is why I don't think he is a good candidate for short. The arm hurts him in center some too when there are deep balls hit to center. Still he has speed, a good eye at the plate and is someone who can make contact so I think his value position (if he can play it well) is center. Granted he has potential for super utility as well. If you read the article from the Athletic (subscription required) then it appears the Twins did ask him to tweak his approach to go with a power swing early in counts and then shorten up after two strikes. Here are some excerpts from that article. "Before the start of the season, the Twins attempted to implement changes to Martin’s approach at the plate. The idea was that Martin — who has played a lot at shortstop but more likely profiles at second base and in center field — has such good bat-to-ball skills that he could sell out for power early in the count in an attempt to do more damage. Even if he didn’t come through, Martin is so good at hitting with two strikes that he could shorten up and still get on base enough to warrant the change." "But Martin recently told MLB Pipeline he used his time off to recalibrate. He created a new plan with his hitting coaches and started to get going again. Martin returned to action on Aug. 17 and, reverting to more of his old approach, finished with a solid September." So it is possible the Twins messed with his head too much. Hard to say but he does seem to be back to his normal self but without a ton of power. I am still a believer in Martin in the "Nick Gordon" role. Will have to wait and see how things turn out but this is a big year for Martin.
-
In Fairytale Land: Twins sign Correa ... what do you do?
I agree I would like to stay away from 10 years as those last three years could easily be negative value. I still think you need to find a way for him to potentially reach that 300M number though so would add a team option at the end to get to 300M with a 10M buyout or something. I think the issue the Mets have is they need\want to go twelve years to spread out the AAV and given the leg issue that contract is very unlikely to age well. I think the closer the Twins can get to a 7 year length the better and I like your 8 year proposal. I would modify it slightly and go 8/270 with an option for for a 9th year at 35M and a 10M buyout. That gets him to a potential 305M total contract value and a notable 33M per year AAV. He has a good chance to be productive the next 5 to 6 years baring injury and with the Twins potentially off the hook in year 8 that's not a bad deal for both sides IMO. I would give him opt outs in years 5,6 and 7 and would not give a no trade clause but would give him a list of teams he could not be traded to. Correa has been a consistently good player and it is going to take 30M per year to sign him and as I said earlier likely 300M in total to get a deal done. Even with the leg issue he should be fine the next 5 years so if the Twins can stay way from a ten year commitment then I would be happy to have Correa on this team to solve shortstop for the next several years. His big bat would be welcome and it would allow the team time to work in the younger guys coming up from the farm.
-
Twins Claim RHP Oliver Ortega Off Waivers from Angels
TBH I was thinking that if they think they are getting Correa to sign that they might be packaging Kepler and Enlow for something. I think you are right that they could add Larnach in a package as well for the right return. It depends on how they feel about Wallner in left as a replacement for Larnach I would think. I would skip on Mancini and probably Pillar. Wouldn't mind Farmer back on a decent deal as again if they sign Correa they will be dollar conscious. I guess will know in the next 7 days how things play out.
- Twins Claim RHP Oliver Ortega Off Waivers from Angels
-
Twins Claim RHP Oliver Ortega Off Waivers from Angels
I think if they had a trade lined up this would be a horrible order of operations to do it in. It would make more sense or be better to do the trade first as in this scenario they have no leverage after 7 days. Still to your point I would hope they could get something decent in return for Enlow or that there is some sort of plan here. I know he was just coming back from TJ last year but he looked pretty hittable and a lot of the hits I saw were hard contact. The FO might just be down on what they think he can do. Hard to say.
-
Twins Claim RHP Oliver Ortega Off Waivers from Angels
I guess I thought the odd man out was going to be Sands and his 5.47 ERA but they must feel Enlow has the best chance to make it through. If you look at MLB.com Enlow looks like he has more polished pitches but I guess if the Twins are looking for a young power bullpen arm this move makes some sense. I don't love it when relievers have such high WHIP's but maybe they can teach him a slider or help him find the zone more. I do love having another high octane arm to work with and hopefully this is a move that works out. For anyone interested Ortega was the Angels 16th best prospect in 2021 not that the Angels have a top farm but he has been good in the minors. This also shows how hard it is for teams to carry arms that are not quite ready yet. Enlow was more than likely dead weight this season for sure but I think he might end up being the better pitcher in the end. Will have to wait and see how this one turns out.
-
Rumor: Another Correa rumor....
Wow I can't believe it. Still just how bad is this leg issue if even the free spending Mets don't want to the deal without more protection. I mean if Borras and Correa are certain it is not going to be an issue then just include the language that if that leg becomes an issues the contract changes. I would love Correa for the next five its the five years after that that worry me.
-
Rumor: A new team is talking with Boras about Correa…
If the Twins ended up with Correa I would have a lot of crow to eat. I still think the Mets get it done. Borras likely leveraging the Mets using the Twins offer as the bottom. If the Mets don't match then onto the Twins I would guess. The Lowest they can go is the Minnesota offer if you ask me. If the Mets don't match the Twins offer then I have to believe the Twins will get another chance. This has to be one of the craziest things to happen in Free Agency ever.
-
Why can’t I quit the Minnesota Twins?
I think with boards like this and being able to follow the farm there is always hope for another Twins World Series team at some point. Pretty sure I will always follow the Twins maybe not as close as I do right now but I will be listening\Watching. With the money disparity it is getting harder to watch the top revenue teams scoop up all the talent while the lower level teams essentially have to sit out free agency. Still hope is hard to kill and I will hope this team can find a way to beat the odds.
-
The Top 20 Minnesota Twins Assets of 2023: Part 3 (6-10)
Yeah I agree he always had trouble as a starter making it through a season even in the minors. If they wreck his arm as a starter and he needs TJ he could be out for two years. He made it through a full season in the pen at the MLB level with minimal issues and is an elite arm in that role. Do you want to risk losing your elite shutdown arm for a chance for him to do something he never really proved he could do in the minors? If it were me and I admit to being risk averse but I would keep him where he is. The other issue is he never really did develop that solid third pitch he needed to be a starter so he might not have the same level of success he has had as a reliever. And finally how many guys are there in MLB that can throw 100MPH fairly consistently as a starter (maybe Greene)? I guess I am not aware of any so again I think reliever is the right role for Duran.
-
The Top 20 Minnesota Twins Assets of 2023: Part 3 (6-10)
I don't know if you have been following Aaron Judge much but he is a career .284 hitter who K's about 28% of the time and just signed a contract to be the highest paid position player in baseball. I think that should tell you what teams value and it isn't batting average, it is OPS. I like Arraez a lot. Love his plate approach, his enthusiasm, and his work ethic. However, I would take Judge over Arraez any day of the week because with his power he can impact the game in ways Arraez just can't. Rodriquez is only in A ball but if he essentially maintains that profile all the way up he has a more valuable skillset than Arreaz at least the way baseball is played today. Granted Arraez can help the MLB team right now. Rodriguez could be years away yet hard to say.
-
Ranking the Trade Value of Twins Corner Outfielders
While Kirilloff and and Larnach have more value they also haven't been much worse or better than Kepler at the plate and they have a lot more years of control left. The Twins thing to do would be to move the higher salaried player IMO. Also Keplers ceiling appears to be known while Kirilloff, Larnach and Wallner are somewhat unknowns at this point. Certainly they could trade anyone of those players for the right deal I just think Kepler makes the most sense.
-
What Is Max Kepler’s Trade Value?
I go back and forth on Max's trade value. I mean several teams could have had a Max type player in Gallo for just money and yet the Twins managed to snag Gallo for a one year 11M contract. Max only costs 2.5M less and you have to give up trade capital as well. To me that says his market value might be lower than I was hoping. Still Max shows strong underlying numbers in a lot of area's and if the Yankee's did grab him with the short right field porch it could be a difference maker for Max. Just a few extra HR's that make it over that wall adds to his OBP and Slugging and I bet those numbers start looking much better. If the Twins do trade Max to the Yankee's they better make it hurt because I have a feeling he could have a monster season in the Bronx. I do agree with Mike though the Twins need to find a decent return or they might as well just hang onto Max. His value could increase by the deadline anyway. We will see if some team pony's up but it might be a while as teams continue to fill out rosters with FA's and decide what to spend there tradable assets on. Unless the Twins get a deal they deem to good to pass up I would probably hang onto Max.
- Why Did the Twins Sign Joey Gallo?
-
Why Did the Twins Sign Joey Gallo?
I could be wrong but I don't see the Twins trading Kep for a bag of balls. A team is going to have to give them something decent to move him otherwise they can just try and build his value back and depending on where they are do a deadline deal. I agree they could still use him for depth if they want to. They do have a lot of outfielders on the 40 man though. Would hate to see the Yankee's get him as so many Twins seem to perform well once there. If they do trade him to the Yankee's they need to get something better back than John Ryan Murphy.
- Why Did the Twins Sign Joey Gallo?
-
Why Did the Twins Sign Joey Gallo?
In comparison to Max, Gallo seems to perform just a little bit better in OBP, SLG and ultimately OPS. Gallo's batting average is terrible and coupled with the K's he will be a rally killer more often than not IMO. The good defense does help a lot though as it makes him valuable beyond his bat. He might be a slight upgrade over Max but not much that I can see. Will be interesting to see how this all shakes out. If he can bounce back it would really help this team so I hope he does find his HR stroke again.
-
What Would a Twins Rebuild Look Like?
Other than Kepler I think the team pretty much remains the same and they might even hang onto Kepler if they can't find the right return. Will have to see how desperate Miami is to trade later on but if they want MLB players like Polanco or Arraez then those talks will be tough. The Twins did a bunch of trading to get Maeda, Mahle and Gray I guess I don't know why they would give up on that now by trading them before the season starts. Last years flawed and injury riddled team was in first place in the division for most of the first half. I think they role with what they have and see how things develop. Also if one or all of Maeda, Mahle and Gray have really good years they all could be QO candidates. So any return would need to keep that in mind. It could be that none of them are worthy of a QO as well but still it seems worth while to wait on rebuild scenario's until we see how this team as constructed works out.
-
Pitching and Pipelines
Some really great comments on this topic. I think part of the issue that Mike brought up is perception (i.e what should the expectation of the pipeline be). The other part is that Falvey from Cleveland was supposed to do in Minnesota what he had helped do in Cleveland and to this point the pitching pipeline seems underwhelming, at least IMO. While ERA is just one piece in 2022 as a team Cleveland ranked tied for 5th and the Twins were 19th in team ERA. Pretty much all the teams in the top 10 of that stat went to the playoffs. What is my point? Whatever the FO is doing whether trading for guys or developing them they appear to be doing it worse than league average at the MLB level. Yep lots of injuries last year and we never really did get to use Mahle much but the FO needs to do better than this on the pitching side. I also want to highlight a point KirbyDome89 made. While I get that being balanced in the draft can be a good thing at some point when you have a deficiency I think you should focus more on that area. The Twins have focused on bats early in the draft and generally taken pitching later. That is fine if that strategy works out but now the team has a glut of hitters and not the same level of pitching to go with it. I also want to point out that the one year the Twins broke this trend in 2021 they took Petty, Hajjar and Povich in rounds 1,2, and 3 and what did they use as trade currency. Yep the pitchers picked in the higher rounds. I think the Twins need to take more swings at pitching in the draft. In 2021 Cleveland picked 18 pitchers in a 20 round draft. When you have a deficiency you need to take more shots at what you need and you should do it on the premium talent early in the draft as well as late. With all the trades the pitching pipeline further down at high A is essentially broken so there will be a gap there now. While the Twins have a pitching pipeline it hasn't been enough to lift this team where it needs to go and that has been the difference between the Twins and Cleveland. I think that is why so many of us feel it is broken or not working well. Love the positive vibs Mike. There is some success and some good things coming, I hope, but right now today it is hard to feel good about it.
-
Rumor: Ace Available in Trevor Bauer?
Well I guess if you want a club house cancer Bauer is a good bet. His own team mates on the Dodgers wanted the FO to get rid of him even before the issue that got him suspended. If the Dodgers don't want him back I pity the team that grabs him. Maybe his ordeal was a wake up call, hard to say but old dogs are hard to change. I do believe in second chances but given the circumstances I don't think the Twins can take that kind of chance as they are about a little over a year after struggling with club house vibs of there own. Bauer would be a pass for me.
-
The Twins Know They Need Pitching, Right?
Not much FA action in the entire central this year. Seems like the White Sox are more interested in moving salary than anything else this year. If the Twins get a starter it needs to be a front of the rotation type of pitcher or they might as well stick with what they have. Once again they appear to have pitching depth with Gray, Maeda, Mahle, Ryan, Ober, Winder, Varland and SWR with Paddack back maybe mid year. So lot's of 5th starter material to work with. They can't be counted on but if Balazovic, Enlow and Hedrick improve dramatically they could be depth as well. If they can't find a deal they like I can see them standing pat. If the FO thinks Polanco is a guy that gets it done not sure why they would hesitate. They would still have Arraez they can plug in there and Jullien seems likely to be ready for 2nd at some point next year and they also have Martin who can play there and Lee might be an option at Short or second so they are going to have to move somebody off this team at some point. Switch hitters are hard to come by but if the return is front of the rotation pitcher that this team desperately needs then I think they need to do it. Honestly unless they get a deal they like I think the Twins will stand pat with what they have. It isn't sexy but might be enough to take the central if this team can find a way to hit lefties.
-
Twins Had a Chance to Get Back in the Carlos Correa Mix, and Passed
I agree with you. Boegarts got a 280M deal and he was supposed to be second fiddle to Correa. The minimum I mean minimum had to be a 300M deal. If they were never going to go there it seemed hard to believe this was ever going to get done. Sorry but I don't buy Seth's theories on this. They had Correa all year last year what due diligence was left? If there was any then that makes this FO look incompetent IMO. If the Twins really wanted Correa they likely could have had him by adding an Option year where he gets 30M if the keep him and 15M to buy him out. That gets them over the 300M guaranteed and potentially matches the Mets offer. Maybe the Mets would have moved the bar further out then hard to say but I would have a lot more respect for their efforts if they had done that. I will say Boras feeling the need to move off of San Fran so quickly is odd and doesn't play well. As noted by others he is notoriously patient in making deals. Certainly seems like he could have given them through Christmas to make a decision. Still I guess with the deal falling through and Correa being aced out late in market last year he might not have wanted to wait for what he might have felt was an inevitable "no deal" from the Giants. It would have been hard to renegotiate with the Giants if they no longer wanted to go 13 years as it could set a precedent for teams outbidding and then exclusively negotiating after "finding something" in the physical. He also might have just been pissed and wanted to hurt SF by moving Correa elsewhere. Hard to say what the motivation might have been but I will agree with others that is suspicious. At any rate I am not too upset the Twins didn't get Correa for 10 years. Those last 3 to 4 to 5 years of talking what a dead weight he is would have sucked. However, my point stands. If this FO really wanted Correa I think they could have had him but the bar was 300M. They should have known that from the beginning. If they were not going to go there they probably had no business even bidding.
-
The Twins Skimping on Correa Presents More Questions Than Answers
At this point In the end this whole thing seemed like a lose\lose for the FO. This board has already given them grief for signing guys that had potential injury concerns. Upping the offer after another team gave pause to how long Correa might last seems like a bad idea for a small market team. I mean even the generally free spending Giant didn't want to take on the risk why would the Twins? I don't really blame the FO not getting back into this mess if they even had much of a chance anyway. Cohen would have out bid them almost no matter what they put out there for a number. If Correa "really" wanted to be in Minnesota he could have taken a small discount to do it. He chose not to and that tells me all I need to know. Time to just move on.