Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

markos

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by markos

  1. Why shouldn't Rosario play CF if Buxton is out for a prolonged period? I just don't see any evidence that the 32-year-old Stubbs will be any better than Rosario defensively. For me, Rosario is the backup CF, and the question is who will move into LF.
  2. It will be interesting to watch and see what the White Sox are able to do over the next few years. In some ways they are the inverse of the Twins. They have a ton of unproven and in some ways disappointing young pitching (Rodon, Fulmer, Giolito, Lopez); the Twins have a ton of unproven and in some ways disappointing young hitters (Buxton, Sano, Kepler, Rosario, Polanco). As far as young position players go, the White Sox have Moancada, Tim Anderson (he with the 9:1 strikeout-to-walk ratio) and, um... that's about it? They have a couple other guys that are interesting, but not much else in the pipeline. The White Sox certainly have a few more guys they could flip for position players (most notably Quintana and Abreu), but right now the Twins at least have arms in their pipeline that are fairly close. The White Sox could very well have the worst everyday lineup in the AL for the next two seasons. Maybe the plan is to sign a bunch of free agents.
  3. Maybe I'm mis-understanding PseudoSABR's argument, but the way I read it matched my own thoughts, which is that post-2010 the Twins were extremely unlucky when it came to opportunities to trade veterans for prospects. Basically the only player the Twins were able to trade for full value was Ben Revere. Morneau had chronic injury issues and was a shell of his former self. Baker was out with TJ surgery. Liriano was ineffective. Even Span had lingering injury questions before he was traded. Cuddyer wasn't traded (and yes, the compensation pick turned into Berrios, though I think in general teams would prefer to be able to trade for a prospect that has shown success in the minors rather than a mid-30s draft pick, but obviously a gray area there). If you looked at those 5 players (Span, Liriano, Baker, Morneau and Cuddyer) in 2010 and asked yourself how much trade value the Twins should expect if they were forced to rebuild, I think the answer would be a lot more than just a single top-100 prospect, a #32 pick and a utility infielder. Add in Dozier's current situation (where basically every contender was set at 2B), and it just adds insult to injury. Now I'm not arguing that the Twins did anything wrong; mostly I think they were just unlucky. But regardless, I share PseudoSABR's opinion that it contributed to the lackluster rebuild.
  4. I'm pretty scared of Kendall as well, but one thing has kept me marginally intrigued: he has shown A LOT more power than advertised (or at least more than I expected). He has a .316 ISO right now, and is on pace for 17 HRs this year, which would be ~35 HRs in 600 PAs. I'm obviously extrapolating from a fairly small sample size right now. But if it holds up for the entire season, that power-speed combination is pretty attractive even with some contact issues. He certainly isn't my #1 right now, but I haven't written him off yet, either.
  5. You have been advocating for a full rebuild on several different threads. How do you see the timeline working out in your scenario? The way I see, going the route of the Astros circa 2011 will guarrantee that the Twins will be among the worst teams in baseball for at least two more years, probably three. So when are you expecting them to return to contention? 2020? And if that is true, how do you fit Buxton and Sano into this plan? Their service clock is ticking, and both will potentially be free agents after the 2021 season.
  6. I wouldn't be surprised either if the Twins end up with 5-6 top-100 prospects next year. But as I've mentioned earlier in this thread, the fact that the Twins have 5 or 6 talented guys doesn't differentiate them from the majority of teams in baseball. Most teams have 5-6 players that could be top-100 guys if things break right. So what is going to be the differentiater for the Twins over the next 3-5 years? What is their path to 95+ wins and winning the AL pennant with the current state of the big league team and their current farm system? While I don't think the current squad is as bad as their record from last season may indicate, this is still a below-average big league roster right now. They have a long ways to go to get to the point where they are legitimate playoff contenders, and even further to go to be considered one of the top five teams in baseball. So my biggest question is how exactly is this organization, with this farm system, going to bridge that gap. Especially when you factor in that this organization is not going to be signing elite free agents. So the farm system will need to 1) produce above-average players to transform the current roster to a 95 win team. 2) back fill the talent lost as Dozier, Mauer, Santana get worse and/or leave the organization. 3) pick up the slack if any of the current young MLB players stagnate or get injured. 4) provide the high-upside prospects necessary to trade for good-to-great veterans to fill in gaps. I don't think the farm system has anywhere close to the depth necessary to do all four of those things without just hoping that the vast majority of the prospects will hit their ceilings. That is why I fret.
  7. Right. Is it "cheating" to make an early withdraw from your 401K provided you pay the extra tax? It is one thing to try to avoid getting caught when breaking the rules. It is another thing to accept the penalties.
  8. Fangraphs (and other sources that read directly from the pitchFX are measuring velocity 10-15 in front of the pitcher. I think it is 55 feet from home plate. So the velocity will be less than that detected from radar guns (used to get college velocity). Brooksbaseball extrapolates the velocity back to the release point, which much more closely matches the velocity read from a radar gun. http://www.brooksbaseball.net/velo.php?player=594798&b_hand=-1&gFilt=&pFilt=FA|SI|FC|CU|SL|CS|KN|CH|FS|SB&time=year&minmax=ci&var=mph&s_type=2&startDate=03/30/2007&endDate=03/07/2017 Where have you read that college pitchers gain velocity in the pros? Everything I've read has indicated the opposite. Sure, some pitchers gain, but the general trend is that pitchers lose velocity starting at age 21-22. Further, the difference between pitching once a week and pitching every 5 days is significant. But I'd be interested in reading evidence that supports your assertion. Also, what evidence do you have that the deception, velocity and movement of Faedo's slider is very similar to deGrom's?
  9. deGrom has averaged 95mph on his fastball over the past three seasons, which put him in the top-20of all starters during that time. From everything I've read, Faedo isn't close to averaging that right now, and he is only throwing once a week instead of every five days. Maybe Faedo could get there, but it is more likely that his stuff takes a step back when transitioning to pro-ball.
  10. Can you elaborate your point a little bit? I'm not sure I follow...
  11. Yes, the Twins have a lot of interesting guys in the low minors, and it is certainly true that the Twins system might look a lot better in a year or two if these guys all develop like we hope. But the problem is that the Twins are not unique in this regard. There are probably 20 teams that have half-a-dozen or more interesting guys in rookie ball or instructional league, and each one can make the same arguement that there farm system will be so much better if these kids just develop like they hope.
  12. This pretty much sums it up. One small addition: Teams will pick a HS player with one of their 11+ round picks that they know won't sign as a small goodwill gesture. The HS player may have declared that he is going to college no matter what, but by select the player the team is basically signalling "hey, we know you're going to college, but we think you're a good player and would like you in our system someday." Usually it amounts to nothing more than some good publicity. A recent example is when the Twins drafted local HS pitcher Logan Shore in the 29th round.
  13. I worry for several reasons: The current rankings are a sharp criticism to the organizations ability to select and develop talent over the past half-decade. You mentioned that there is a lot of young talent on the roster, guys like Sano, Polanco, Kepler, Rosario, Buxton and Berrios. What you don't mention is the majority of the young talent on the roster was acquired prior to all the losing. Buxton and Berrios are the only two players that were acquired post-2010. So despite having all those 90 loss seasons - and the high draft picks and giant bonus pools for both the domestic draft and international signings that come with all the losing - the talent they acquired and developed has been frankly underwhelming, not hiding on the big league roster. Even if one is very optimistic about the future projections of the current team and the players in the upper minors, you have to squint pretty hard to envision a path to 95 wins by 2020. To get to 95 wins, a team basically has to be above-average at every single position. Or it needs some true superstars to make up the difference. And at this point, who in the organization - at any level - has a decent shot at producing multiple 6+ WAR seasons over the next few years? Probably just Buxton, right? Having only one or two elite players surrounded by a average-at-best supporting cast is a great way to get stuck around 80-85 wins a year. With zero potential superstars on the horizon, and frankly few average-regulars either, I'm extremely worried that this Twins core is going to peak at about 85 wins. Mid-market and small-market teams that want to push themselves up to the next level often have to acquire superstars in the trade market. They aren't signing superstars in free agency. And to acquire major stars, a team needs prospect capital. The Royals, to take one example, spent a ton of prospect capital to acquire Shields and Davis (which helped kickstart them up to the 90-win level) and then Cueto and Zobrist. With the current state of the farm system, the Twins can't really compete for any elite players.
  14. I'm concerned about his velocity. If he is 92-95 pitching once a week, he is probably going to be 90-93 as a pro.
  15. Yeah, I'd like to see him do the opposite - pick pitchers that will stay healthy.
  16. In the interest of speculating wildly about the future, what are people's thoughts about Hughes's velocity over the short and medium term? My thoughts: - Right now, zero concern that he is just in the upper 80s. It is early, and he is working back from injury. - In four weeks, I'll be pretty concerned if he is still just working 89-90-91. I think there is a decent case to be made at that point to just move him to the bullpen. However... - This is probably a lost season for the team, so I don't think it is critical to move him to the bullpen right away. I would leave him as a starter for the first few months and see if 1) he regains the lost velocity over time, or 2) he can figure out a way to be effective with lower velocity. Neither of those options are particularly likely, but it's not like there is a lot to lose right now with being patient. To sum up, there are a lot of unknowns about his particular injury, and not a huge sample-size to make guesses about his likely recovery path. I think the Twins should error on the side of being too patient with him, even if he is getting knocked around in March/April/May. I'm curious what others think.
  17. From everything I've read, Greene, as a shortstop, would be in 1st round consideration but not an top pick. He is not at the same level as Machado, Correa or other elite HS SS players.
  18. Regardless who they at a 1-1, they should be able to bank some money. I don't think anyone 1-1 pick has signed for full slot yet. Most of the top-5 picks have all be underslot to one degree or another. They won't be able to bank a ton (like recent years), but I'm guessing something like $500k. Having almost back-to-back picks at 35 & 37 should allow them to pounce if a top player does fall to them. They can grab the player at #35 and then pick someone significantly underslot at #37. Adding that to the savings at with the first pick, they could probably offer $3M+ at #35 if a player warranted it, which is basically what the major overslot players received last year from the Reds/Braves/Phillies. This won't require any shenanigans with the 1-1 pick. Just take the best player.
  19. We are still a month away from Opening Day. Don't tempt fate!
  20. Key point here. I know we've all gotten pretty numb to bad pitching during this decade, but last year's squad was 60 runs worse than any of the 2011-2014 seasons. They could shave off 100 runs this year and still be one of the 5 worst teams in baseball in terms of runs allowed.
  21. Agree on Kendall. How much upside does Wright have? He is sitting low-to-mid 90s, and occasionally cracking 95. Translating that to pro-ball workload, that isn't terribly impressive. Gerrit Cole he is not (as one recent example). Is he even at the Kevin Gausman level? It will be interesting to see how his velocity tracks during the next months, but right now I'm not impressed.
  22. The take-home message from the article you linked: If the Twins take Greene, the most important thing is to make sure he doesn't tear his rotator cuff while defending his brother in a bar fight. Personally, I don't think the competition quality for high schoolers is very important, particularly for pitchers. I'm very confident that professional scouts and decision makers are not judging Greene's abilities by his box score stats, but rather are judging this tools and projection. But even beyond that, Greene (and almost every other top high school prospect) spent a lot of his summer playing in showcase tournaments around the country. Outside of the top-tier of the SEC, not many college players have the opportunity to play against a dozen or more potential first round picks like the HS players get to in these tournaments. Also, I'm not sure how much weight to put on secondary pitches (or lack there of) right now. How good were Kershaw's secondaries coming out of HS? I know that was the big knock on Bumgarner going into his draft. At a certain level, the selection of a HS pitcher is a bet on the projection of their tools: arm strength, athleticism, build and work ethic. I'm not sure how much present-day stuff and results factor into that.
  23. Important to always translate college velocity. Because they only pitches once a week, college starters will generally lose 1-2 mph when they switch to throwing every 5 days. So, when Wright "worked in the low-to-mid 90s, touching 97 mph", in my mind that translates to "worked in the low 90s, touching 95 mph".
  24. Much of the (at least public) work that tries to project prospects has found that SBs are a statistically significant indicator for future success. For example, Chris Mitchell's KATOH projection system uses SB% (Stolen base attempts / times on first base) because it was a predictor of reaching the major leagues, even at the rookie ball level. In fact, it was more significant than walk rate at that low of level. In addition, there is a line of thought that stolen bases and triples form a decent proxy for overall athleticism, which in turn can be use to predict defensive ability. In the case of Kirilloff, the lack of stolen bases are a legitimate concern. Certainly not the be all end all, but combined with scouting reports that universally project him to a corner position (and some that say he looks pretty good at first base!), there is a fair amount of evidence that points to him being a liability in the outfield, and potentially on the base paths as well. Obviously there is a continuum here, but if he ends up closer to the Kubel/Arcia end of the spectrum rather than the Rosario/Kepler end, then that just adds even more pressure on his bat.
  25. How often is Gonsalves actually hitting 94+ with his fastball? This seems like a very generous description. If he was regularly hitting the mid-90s, I think there would be a lot less concern about how his stuff will play in the majors.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.