Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

markos

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by markos

  1. I get what you are saying. Frankly, I haven't read anything yet that has done a convincing job of articulating exactly why Greene is so special. To be sure, I think he is a very good prospect and understand why he is in consideration for the top pick. But some people (like KLaw) are talking about him as a elite talent without explaining exactly why. Basically, I want someone to come out and explain exactly what differentiates Greene from prior top HS picks like Pint, Kolek, Stewart, Bundy, Taillon, Aiken, etc. My suspicious is that his "generational talent" projection is based on two things: First, he is really young - not turning 18 until August. Pint, for example, has a November birthday and was 9 months older than Greene at draft time. Second, he is apparently super athletic, and a good enough SS to be considered a first-round pick as a position player. I suspect that draft analysts project a lot based on athleticism. And there are some good examples of how that works out. Madison Bumgarner was basically just arm strength and athleticism when he was drafted. He didn't have a breaking ball or a decent changeup, and he has trouble repeating his delivery. But he threw 95 and was very athletic. And he was young - still 17 on draft day. On the other hand, Kohl Stewart is super athletic, and that hasn't helped him develop so far. But like I said, I really want someone (KLaw, Callis, Sickels, etc) to come out with a convincing explanation for why he is such an amazing talent.
  2. History The Twins selected Nick Gordon with the 5th overall pick in the 2014 draft out of Olympia HS in Florida. He is the son of former major league pitcher Tom Gordon, and brother of current major leaguer Dee Gordon. Immediately after signing, Gordon was assigned to the Twins Rookie-ball affiliate in Elizabethton. This was a reasonably aggressive move for the organization, as they often start their HS draftees in the Gulf Coast League at Fort Myers. In 255 plate appearances, he hit .294/.333/.366, good for a 101 wRC+. Gordon spent the entire 2015 season at Cedar Rapids where he hit a solid-but-not-spectacular .277/.336/.360, which was good for a 104 wRC+. In 2016, Gordon moved up to Fort Myers. In 493 PAs, he hit .291/.335/.386, good for a 112 wRC+. To cap off his season, he was selected by the Twins to play in the Arizona Fall League, where he hit a robust .346/.404/.444. Gordon is starting the 2017 season at Chattanooga, the Twins AA affiliate. Pre-2017 Prospect Rankings Fangraphs (Eric Longenhagen): #66 “Gordon’s actions at shortstop were not as polished in the Fall League as I’d hoped to see, but he clearly has the physical ability to play a solid shortstop while being competent, but not impactful, with the bat.” ESPN (Keith Law): #53 “The tools say he’ll be an average big leaguer, but I believe his instincts and understanding of the game will allow him to be more.” Baseball America: #60 “Gordon’s game is predicated more on fundamentals than flash, and he’ll need to continue to refine those fundamentals for him to stick at shortstop. Gordon’s instincts and feel for the game are ahead of many players his age—thanks in part to his big league genetics—and that aptitude helps him play above his raw tools.” Baseball Prospectus: #48 "You’ve had ham and cheese sandwiches on white bread that were more exciting than Gordon, but hey, ham and cheese sandwiches get the job done when you’re hungry." Minor League Ball (John Sickels): #43 (B+) “Projects as a regular shortstop with an above-average glove who will hit for average, show some pop to the gaps, and steal 15-20 bases a year.” MLB Pipeline: #48 “Gordon continues to be more high floor than high ceiling, a prospect who doesn't have one "wow" tool, but who can do everything relatively well. He'll continue his path toward being a solid everyday big leaguer with a move to the upper levels.” As you can see, there is a strong consensus with Gordon right now. He is a good prospect, but a high-floor/low-ceiling one. He is very clearly a second-tier shortstop prospect now behind guys like Gleyber Torres, Amed Rosario, JP Crawford and Brendan Rodgers. His future value is strongly dependent on being average-ish at basically everything, as there aren't a lot of signs right now that he will end up above-average or plus in many areas. Keys for 2017: There are three areas that I will be keeping a close eye with regard to Gordon: Power: Gordon has yet to have an ISO above .100 in any full season, though he was close last year in the pitcher-friendly Florida State League. While he doesn’t need to have a lot of power to be a productive big leaguer, even a small jump in power would definitely improve his outlook. There is an expectation that he will show more power as he fills into his frame, but that hasn't really happened yet. Plate Discipline: As mentioned in several of his prospect writeups, Gordon has pretty good bat-on-ball skills, but has a tendency to chase and expand the zone. His career K% is reasonable (~17%) but his walk rate is a little on the low side (<6%). If he isn’t able to improve his power, then it is imperative that he is able to add more value with the plate by walking at a higher frequency. Defense: This is probably the most difficult skill to judge, but it is the linchpin of his entire profile. If Gordon isn’t an average or better shortstop, it is unlikely that he will hit enough to make up for his defensive liabilities, or to switch to an easier position on the defensive spectrum.
  3. I can take Tyler Jay and Nick Gordon.
  4. Maybe the odds are so small that it doesn't matter, but Greene's odds of succeeding as a hitter are meaningful - they are certainly not zero unlike other top HS pitchers (think Tyler Kolek). And his odds of providing at least some value are significantly increased since he plays an up-the-middle position. Allie is a good example. If Allie was a plus SS (which supposedly is Greene's potential at SS) instead of a corner outfield/1B guy, his career .741 OPS in AA is probably enough to get him a look in the big leagues.
  5. I see your point, but I think the "commitment" to defense is primarily seen with the fact that Grossman hasn't played an inning in the outfield yet. It is obviously a small sample so far (and we will probably never know for sure) but I would argue that a "bat-first" lineup against lefties would have Grossman in left, Escobar at 3rd, and Sano DHing. A lineup decision like that would be defensible against lefties, and better offensively. Instead, both Kepler and Rosario have started all 3 games against lefties, which at some level is prioritizing defense over offense. I think that is meaningful (and the right decision).
  6. As a point of reference, Kohl Stewart only pitched 20 innings after being drafted, but if I recall correctly he was shut down for a little while for a foot injury. Gonsalves pitched 28. On the other side, Kirilloff ended up with 232 PAs after the draft. I would probably have him pitch, but I see the argument the other way.
  7. They have #1, #35 and #37. I'm not particularly concerned about the positional breakdown. What I want to see is that they go after high-upside players, so no college relievers in the first 5 rounds. Depending on how the first pick plays out, they should have bonus pool money to play with in later picks. If forced to pick, there seems to be pretty good luck with selecting HS pitchers with picks in the 30s and 40s. From 2008-2012 there were 18 picks between #30 and #45 used on HS pitchers. Here is a list of the successes (to varying degrees): Jake Odorizzi Tyler Skaggs Taijuan Walker Noah Syndergaard Aaron Sanchez Henry Owens Michael Fulmer Lance McCullers Jose Berrios That seems like pretty good luck - arguably better than the HS pitchers selected with picks #1-#16. So given the option, I'd say draft the best available HS pitchers at #35 and #37. At lot will depend on how the bonus demands of the first picks. It would be nice to try to buy a kid out of a college commitment who slips into those mid-rounds. And from the standpoint of acquiring future trade capital, it would be a good idea to come away with 3-4 high upside HS arms - few things are more valuable in trades. After that, I think the "flawed college infielder" is an under-valued target for the 3rd-5th rounds, as seemingly a lot of those guys end up exceeding their hit or field projections.
  8. Assuming everyone adheres to a strict 5-man rotation over the course of the month, the Twins will end up missing Verlander, Carrasco and Hamels. They will face Quintana twice, and Darvish, Duffy, Salazar each once. Rodon is currently on the DL. Overall, probably an average slate considering the teams, but definitely could be worse. Royals (Twins rotation number on bottom) 1,2,3,2,3,4 // Duffy only once 1,2,3,3,4,5 White Sox 4,5,1,5,1,2 // Rodon on DL. Get Quintana twice 4,5,1,5,1,2, Tigers 3,4,5,2,3,4 // miss verlander 2,3,4,2,3,4 Rangers 5,1,2 // miss Hamels (currently #3) in rotation 5,1,2 Indians 3,4,5,1 // miss Carrasco 3,4,5,1
  9. I think it is likely that they have to settle for less than De Leon next offseason or at the deadline in 2018. But I have a hard time seeing a scenario where they would drastically reduce their asking price between now and July 31.
  10. The frustrating thing with McKay is that he is so much more valuable to an NL team than the Twins. For him to be a legitimate asset at 1B/DH, he essentially needs to be one of the top-50 hitters in baseball. While I think that he does have that kind of ceiling, I'm not super confident that he'll hit at that level even if he dedicates himself to hitting. In the NL, on the other hand, it is pretty clear that even a top-300 hitter would be one of the best hitting pitchers in the game. For example, Jake Arrieta was the best hitting pitcher last year, and his wRC+ (91) was essentially the same as Trevor Plouffe. It is pretty easy to see how an NL team would say, "We're going to develop you as a pitcher, but you'll hit for yourself in the minors and DH as often as possible. Once you're in the big leagues, we will use you as a PH and backup at 1B when you aren't pitching." If he can be an average hitter, or even slightly below-average, he is probably adding 10-20 runs per season with his bat, not taking into account the added roster flexibility. That scenario just doesn't work for the Twins.
  11. Both PECOTA and KATOH have found that using height improves the accuracy of their projections.
  12. Steamer .224 .303 .374 ZiPS .221 .299 .374 PECOTA .239 .313 .405 I'm a little worried overall about Castro. There are enough warning signs with his profile (particular the increasing amount of Ks) that it wouldn't be shocking to see his offensive output crater. Therefore, I'm tentatively going to take the under on a .675 OPS.
  13. I'm not sure his strategy of "give up a lot of flyballs in a ballpark that suppresses right-handed power" is going to play in Minnesota.
  14. I'm very skeptical. The only thing that Santiago has going for him is his ERA, and that is clearly helped out by pitching in Anaheim (one of the top-5 pitcher parks, particularly against RHHs) in front of one of the best defenses (3rd in UZR from 2014-2016). And despite ballpark advantage, he STILL had a home run problem - one of the 5-10 worst pichers at HR/9 from 2014-2016. I think home runs will be a real problem for him this year.
  15. You keep saying that this is all about not showing emotion, which I don't think is true. It is about different frameworks for defining when and how to show emotion. Different cultures create rules and taboos about various actions and situations. That is what cultures do. When there is an incompatibility between what two different cultures expect, who gets to police that? Is it okay to say, "hey, I'm sorry you took offense to my actions, but it fine in our culture so you'll just have to deal." Let's take the following situation: All-star slugger is up against a struggling Rule-5 pick trying to mop-up a 11-4 blowout in late-April. A pitch gets away and almost hits the batter. Two pitches later the batter hits a monster homer. Batter stares at the homer, flips his bat, and show-boats his home run trot. What are the moral dimensions here? 1) From one culture's perspective, the better player is flaunting his superiority over a weaker player in a completely meaningless situation. That's mean-spirited, and in this case completely unnecessary. It is okay for the pitcher to take issue with the player behavior, and for the pitcher's teammates and coaches to rally around him against the batter. 2) From another culture's perspective, there was heightened conflict between the pitcher and batter after the errant pitch (which might have been intential! who knows!) The post-home run behavior was vindicated because the batter was the victor in this conflict. In the man-to-man conflict between the batter and pitcher, the batter was the winner; therefore, the batter get to demonstrate his superiority. Both cultures can be valid, but there is going to be disagreement in cases like this. Who is right in this case? And in general, can a player make any actions or say anything to his opponent that he want, no matter how mean or degrading so long as his "culture" says its okay? If the opponent and the his teammates complain about this, should they just shutup and let it go?
  16. Some of seemingly low numbers are due to being conservative about playing time. This estimates every team will have 700 PAs at 2B, which isn't exactly true. Last year, the Twins ended up with 734. Some of it is lineup position and overall team OBP. Batting 3rd on a bad offense will have 5% fewer plate appearances than batting leadoff on a good offense. Also, some of it is a hedge for injuries - even a single short DL stint can cut a player's PAs by 10%.
  17. Yeah, you're probably right. I'm not sure why anyone would trust Preller now. He has already decided some ethically questionable decisions were worth the long-term mess (like withholding medical info prior to trades). But you bring up a good point that the league could definitely step in if they think he is out-of-bounds with the draft behavior.
  18. Does anyone know if the new CBA kept the same penalties for going over the draft pool. Basically, is it still just a 100% tax on the first 5% over the pool, and then losing draft picks for more than that?
  19. Levine worked with Preller in Texas. He probably has a good idea how he operates. Frankly, I wouldn't be shocked if Preller convinces Greene that the Padres will give him $8M at #3, Greene tells everyone he won't sign for less than $8M, Green drops to #3, the Padres draft him, and then Preller only offers him $6M and says take-it-or-leave-it. He seems like that kind of guy.
  20. Santiago will have positive regression if he is allowed pitch in Anaheim's ballpark and in front of their defense. I mean, he had home run issues in Anaheim. I think a sub-5.00 ERA from him is unlikely.
  21. I don't think it is appealing to "luck" to use to fWAR in this case. Santiago has benefitted in the last three seasons from pitching in one of the best pitching parks in all of baseball (definitely top-5) and in front of one of the best defenses in all of baseball (4th by UZR from 2014-2016). Gibson has not had those same benefits, particularly in the case of defense where the Twins have been terrible (2nd worst by UZR in the same timeframe). There is an ERA gap between Santiago and Gibson, but it isn't huge. KG HS 2014 4.47 3.75 2015 3.84 3.59 2016 5.07 4.70 It works out to only 5-10 runs a season. Personally, I think the defensive and stadium differences are more than enough to explain Santiago's ERA advantage. Even bWAR has Gibson ahead over the past 3 seasons, 5.8 bWAR to 3.2 bWAR, because it recognizes that Gibson has faced harder opponents, in worse ballparks, and with worse defenses behind him.
  22. I ran some numbers a few months ago, and even when normalizing for draft position, the Twins from 2006-2011 were 27th or 28th in the league as far as draft results. It has been pathetic.
  23. Doesn't it have to be a fair amount of both? If you want to argue that they weren't at the level of their playoff competition, that's fine. But exactly how big of underdogs do they need to be in order for an 0-9 record to be an expected outcome? Or even a 3-19 record? My back-of-the-envelope calculations might be off, but wouldn't they need to be something like a 10-1 underdog in every single game in order for those results to be expected? It seems crazy to me that two playoff baseball teams would have such wide discrepancy. I can't check at work, but are any Vegas lines close to that for a single playoff game?
  24. One thing that wasn't mentioned in the article is that Rosario also swings and misses on pitches in the zone a lot. Of the 300 players with at least 500 PAs the past two seasons, Rosario is the 39th worst in terms of making contact when swinging at pitches in the strike zone. That isn't the be-all-end-all; however, when combined with his extreme aggressiveness on pitches outside the strike zone, it becomes a major liablity.
  25. Or he is going to need to sacrifice contact for power. He makes enough contact (K% of just 7.4% last year) that he might be able to rework his swing a little to get more power. If he can get to a .100 or .125 ISO, then he could be a legitimate backup, or maybe even a starter.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.