Everything posted by markos
-
FA's Arrieta or Lynn the only two choices
I agree. Obviously price matters, but I think Lynn is the best option. Digging into his numbers, it is interesting that though his ERA was worse in the first half, his BB and K peripherals were much better in the first half - basically at his career average. It certainly isn't surprising that he would wear down after a year rehabbing TJS. Regarding Cobb, it is probably worth pointing out that Baseball-Reference calculated that TB had the second easiest pitching environment in all of baseball (including national league teams). Their method looks at strength of opponents, defense and ballpark factors. While I have some specific issues with their methodology, it can't be completely discounted. When thinking about Cobb (or Archer for that matter), it is probably worth factoring in that the AL East was actually pretty mediocre offensively last season.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2018 Top Prospects: #5 Alex Kirilloff
Fangraphs actually had Kiriloff in their top-100 (at #99).
- Article: Twins Daily 2018 Top Prospects: #6 Wander Javier
-
Other SP trade candidates: Aaron Nola, any others that you like?
At this point, it might be more worthwhile to try to guess who is going to be selling at the trade deadline. Stroman has already been mentioned. Do the Mariners make Paxton available? What about the Orioles with Gausman or Bundy? I have a hard time seeing the Giants putting Bumgarner on the block, but maybe Samardzija? Does the new FO in Arizona try to get out from under the Greinke contract if they falter this year? At what point to the Mets need to start rebuilding? Does that make deGrom available?
-
Article: Twins Daily 2018 Top Prospects: #8 Blayne Enlow
Sorry for the delayed response on this, but it has occupied my thoughts for a while now. I certainly share the intuition that you articulated - namely, the player development process and prospect evaluation has revolutionized over the past decade-plus. But at the moment I just haven't seen data to back it up that these prospect rankings are significantly better than they were before. Even a chart compiled this offseason doesn't show any major improvement in the overall performance of, at least, BA's prospect lists over the past twenty years: It certainly feels like the rankings should be better in this day and age, with so much more information and more people/organizations taking prospect ranking seriously. But at the same time, a lot of the public prospect analysts (and presumably the best) have been hired away by specific clubs. So maybe while teams are getting better and better, there are countervailing forces that are keeping the public content more or less the same. Also, the game itself is changing extremely quickly - the flyball revolution, juiced balls, increased velocity, different balls between majors and minors. It's possible that at some level, the skills (or lack there of) that mattered even five years ago just don't matter in the same way right now. Finally, maybe is just a lag in the data - HS players from the draft class of 2013 are just starting to reach the majors, so we won't really "know" how good the 2014 ranking will be until 2023(?) or so. Maybe part of our disagreement is that we are just talking about different things. When I'm talking about a "contributor", I'm talking about a player that is at least a consistent 4th-outfielder, backup catcher, utility infielder, platoon bat, 4th starter or middle reliever. Someone who can provide consistent above-replacement-level performance over a decent time frame. Ben Revere was a contributor. Joe Benson was not. You get the idea. If you are talking about the odds that they will at least get a cup of coffee, then obviously our odds are going to be very different. Anyway, thanks for your comment. It has certainly given me a lot to ponder about over the last couple days.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2018 Top Prospects: #8 Blayne Enlow
Yep. I completely agree. Additionally, my own pet theory is that they had hoped that at least one other top player would have dropped to their 4th round pick at #106. They had enough money to offer another $2M bonus if someone was available. I think that partially explains the needlessly complicated maneuver to take Leach way underslot at #37 (unless, of course, they just really, really liked Leach!). I have yet to read a good explanation on what benefit they would have lost by taking Enlow (or whomever else they liked) at #37, especially a benefit greater than the risk that none of the high-end prospects would be available at #76.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2018 Top Prospects: #7 Brent Rooker
Yeah, I like Rooker, but I'm really trying to temper my expectations. He is still striking out a lot. And even the most polished college hitters struggle adjusting to the majors. The list of hitters that have made to the majors during their first full season after being drafted is extremely small. And by comparison, Rooker's A+ performance isn't that great compared to other hitters that actually made the leap, especially when it comes to bat control: Kyle Schwarber hit every bit as good as Rooker at A+, and he managed a 20% K% instead of Rooker's 30%. Schwarber's career MLB K% 30%. Alex Bregman had a sub-10% K% in his first taste of A+ after being drafted, and he made it up to the MLB the next season... and he had a 24% K%. Michael Conforto had a sub-20% K% in the minors before being called up. Andrew Benintendi crushed the minors, finishing with more walks than strikeouts when getting called up. I'm sure there are others, but I just don't see enough bat control with Rooker to have any confidence that he will be a fast mover. I think the Twins can afford to be aggressive with Rooker - I'd like to see him start in AA. But I have zero expectations that he will be an impact hitter in the big-league lineup by the end of 2018 - as a bat-only player he will need to be very good (think 120 wRC+) right off the bat to merit a spot at DH/1B on a competitive team.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2018 Top Prospects: #8 Blayne Enlow
Five players (including 3 other high school pitchers) received as large or larger bonuses than Enlow's $2 million despite being drafted between the Twins pick of Leach at #37 and the Enlow pick at #76. It is certainly possible that Enlow really was dead-set on the Twins and scared away other teams with outrageous fake bonus demands, but I think he would have taken their $2.5 million at the #54 pick had the Yankees picked him there (and offered 25% more than what he signed for with the Twins). Instead, I think the Yankees just liked Matt Sauer better. The Rays probably just like Michael Mercado at #40 better, and the Mariners liked Sam Carlson at #55 better.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2018 Top Prospects: #8 Blayne Enlow
I think you are greatly overstating the odds of those three producing in the big leagues. There have been numerous studies (example: http://www.thepointofpittsburgh.com/mlb-prospect-surplus-values-2016-updated-edition/) that have shown that even prospects ranked as high as 25-50 nationally have only slightly better than 50-50 odds of above replacement level careers. I like Badoo a ton, but I still think he probably only has a 25% chance at being a big league contributor. Graterol and Enlow are both intriguing, but as super young pitchers their odds are still extremely daunting.
-
National Writers on Twins Prospects
They are more bullish than you think. Steamer is projecting 0.3 WAR in 146 PAs. For a full season, that is 1.2 WAR. Repeating that over the next six seasons is ~7.7 WAR. PECOTA is even more optimistic: 0.5 WAR in 141 PAs, or 2.5 WAR over a full season. Frankly, I'm skeptical that Granite will actually hit with enough strength to make his high-contact game work in the big leagues. But all of the projection systems are picking up on the same signals; namely, Granite should make a lot of contact, get on base, run the bases well, and play a plus defense in centerfield.
-
Royce Lewis vs. 2017 Draftees Update Club
Or draft pitchers later in the draft. If you look back over the last 10 or so years, there frankly isn't much difference between the pitchers (particularly HS pitchers) drafted 1-15 as those drafted 30-45.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2018 Top 20 Prospect Countdown: 16-20
And Butera is still providing value for this team, in a way: Butera -> Sulbaran -> Nunez -> Mejia
-
National Writers on Twins Prospects
Yeah, I think the bullpen improvements have been a little underrated so far. They were pretty bad last year, and if they can even have a middle-of-the-pack bullpen would probably add 3-5 WAR from last year.
-
National Writers on Twins Prospects
Wow. I can't get my mind around including Kirilloff. I feel like I could rank 22 TWINS prospects between Gordon and Kirilloff without being too out of line. (Okay, that was mostly hyperbole, but you get my point.) I wonder what they see that I'm missing...
- Article: Free Agent Starters By The Numbers Part II: WAR and Projections
-
Article: Twins Weekly for Jan. 26-Feb. 1: Asking Questions
Thanks for continuing to compile this post each Friday. I always amazed with all the good content I've missed during the week.
-
Free Agent Starters and Rotation Candidates: By The Numbers (Part I)
Thanks for sharing the post. It is nice to have someone compile all the data. Personally, I agree with your statement that Lynn and Cobb probably slot better behind Santana/Berrios rather than in front of them. Also, I'm pretty bullish on Mejia, so it is nice to see number that back that belief up.
-
Mark Appel leaving baseball
I think it is fair to say that the college players (outside of Bryant, Judge and Gray) have been extremely crappy. But it is a little too early to write off the HS set. There may not be many stars in the group, but Frazier, Meadows, Smith, McGuire and Crawford all still have potential to end up as solid contributors.
-
Mark Appel leaving baseball
I think Kris Bryant has turned out okay.
-
Article: Do The Twins Need To Add a Right-Handed Bat?
I don't think it is crazy to think that Kepler is young enough that with more development he could become competent against lefties over the next 4+ seasons. But yes, if the Twins want to give up on that possibility ever happening and completely focus on this season, Kepler is definitely a guy to platoon. But that doesn't mean the Mauer isn't also a good platoon candidate. Focusing on just his 2017 is a fairly misleading. He just had his 5th best season against lefties for his entire career, partially on the back of his second-highest BABIP against lefties (.367). If you look at his last 4 seasons combined (almost 700 PAs), he has a sub-.700 OPS against lefties, including at .610 OPS in 2016. Going into his age-35 season, I will definitely take the under on him repeating or exceeding a .754 OPS against lefties in 2018.
-
Article: Do The Twins Need To Add a Right-Handed Bat?
Also, while I can understand not wanted to turn Kepler into a platoon guy yet, one of the biggest candidates for a platoon is Mauer. If this team is serious about squeezing every last win this coming season, they should seriously consider finding someone to take 100-150 of Mauer's PAs against lefties. For example, Holliday's worst season against lefties in the past 4 seasons is better than Mauer's best season. Last year, the Twins were 8th highest in total L-on-L PAs (590 total PAs), but were only 18th in wRC+ in that situation. It shouldn't be hard to switch ~200 PAs to better right-handed hitters next season.
- Article: Here's How The Experts Are Viewing Twins Prospects
-
Do large dollar, free-agent pitching contracts actually work out?
If you could guarantee me that Darvish will provide 9 WAR over the next two seasons, I think I'd make that deal no matter how badly years three through five turn out. Wins are so valuable to this team right now (where they are on the win curve, where they are compared to their competition, where they are in their competitive window), and their financial situation is so good in the near future. I guess it is partially a philosophical question. Sanchez basically went 6 WAR, 3, 1, -1, -2 over the five years of his deal. Would he have been better if he had gone 2, 2, 2, 2, 2 over that same window and ended up with something like 150 starts, 100 ERA+, 950 innings, 10 WAR? I think there is a decent argument that the former is better, even though the overall value is worse. And as spycake pointed out, the Tigers certainly wouldn't have been better off with the latter version. Anyway, we can certainly agree to disagree on this. I just think that with Sanchez, the Tigers paid for and got some elite performance. Obviously not as much as they would have liked, but enough to make the deal "fine" in the end.
-
Do large dollar, free-agent pitching contracts actually work out?
Signing Sanchez probably would have precluded them from signing Nolasco and Hughes, not Santana and Castro. Also, it is a little misleading to say Sanchez never topped 200 innings, because 1) he topped 195 innings three years in a row prior to his contract, and 2) he did top 200 innings in 2012 if you include the 20 playoff innings. Overall, I think the Sanchez deal worked out fine. He produced between 7 - 12 WAR (depending on the flavor) over the 5 seasons of his deal - basically, one elite season, one elite but injured season, and three mediocre to crappy seasons. For $16M/yr, that is more or less market price. And honestly, given his age and injury history, that's kind of Darvish's, well, not best-case scenario, but a good-case scenario.
-
Lewis and Gordon make pipeline's top 10 short stop
They edited that last part. It now reads: "By the end of the year, it's possible that Javier will be getting more of the attention among Twins shortstops. Signed for $4 million in 2015, he had a strong United States debut in the Rookie-level Appalachian League in 2017 and could really break out with a move to the Midwest League this season."