Everything posted by RJA
-
Is Joe Ryan Who We Thought He Was?
Good article. I love Ryan but I don't think he will ever be a front end starter unless his secondary stuff improves, both in quality and location. Given the fact that they were desperate to have quality starters on the team, fans rushed to annoint him a star last year based on a few games. Now that the bloom is off the rose a bit, some fans are disappointed in him. Even if he doesn't improve his secondary offerings, he will still be a quality part of the rotation. Let's hope he develops into more, but appreciate his talents even if he ends up as a 3 or 4.
-
Short Starts Are Not a Minnesota Twins Thing
Owning baseball teams is a rich person's hobby, not a business. But, I have a question for you Major League Ready, if Pohlad bought the Twins for let's say 25 million, and it is now worth approximately 1.4 billion, has his net worth increased? It astounds me that people continue to ignore capital appreciation when looking at team payrolls. Yearly income is not the reason rich people buy sports franchises, and if they run them to maximize yearly profits they are insulting the fans given how much they make on yearly appreciation.
-
Short Starts Are Not a Minnesota Twins Thing
Bean5302 is spot on. The Twins are much different than other teams and refuse to get off this third time through the order bugaboo. I also believe that by routinely limiting pitch counts in the minors in the interest of avoiding injuries (how has that worked out??), you are essentially preparing these pitchers to pitch a maximum of 5 innings in the majors. It is a self fulfilling prophecy. If you are used to throwing only 60-70 pitches, you are going to create a psychological barrier and you will tire out after 60-70 pitches. I actually think by babying pitchers, we are doing them and the team a disservice.
-
Analyzing Minnesota’s Trend of Acquiring Potentially Injured Pitchers
Dyson clearly didn't have any red flags. He just turned out to have been dishonest with himself and/or his teams. Maeda had some issues, but he seemed to have a pretty good history, so I am not sure anyone could have predicted his surgery. On the other hand, everybody and their unce knew Paddack wasn't right, so that was not a wise move, especially since he had already had one TJ surgery. I suspect if he recovers, it will likely be 2024 before he is "whole" again. Why make this trade when you want a pitcher to help you this year? It makes no sense. Mahle did not have as big of a red flag, but when a pitcher has arm shoulder issues in early July, the chance of it acting up again is significant. If you are making a deadline deal, why take a risk that the player you desperately need is going to be on the IL? And, he did cost significant prospect capital IMHO. Do I want the FO to sit on its thumbs at the deadline? No, I want the FO to sign a good free agent pitcher to avoid being in the position to have to give up prospects for someone at the deadline. Or, if you are going to add someone, don't focus on players with a history of injuries or one who has had arm or shoulder issues early in current season, even if the acquistion cost is higher. Penny wise and pound foolish methinks.
-
Twins Minor League Report (9/6): Ober and Company Shut Out Opposition
The best news last night was Ober pitching and pitching well. It would help for this year and next year if he could get back in the rotation yet this fall. For whatever reason, one time Smeltzer looks unhittable and the next time he can't get anyone out. With his stuff, it is all about command. Williams is quietly having quite a year--27 homers and 84 RBI (I know, old time stats) in 98 games. It will be interesting to see if he builds on his success next year.
-
Louie Varland Will Make His MLB Debut for Twins on Wednesday
A player making his major league debut is one of the coolest parts of baseball. I can only imagine the butterflies he must feel especially debuting in the Bronx. It will be a blast to watch. Development is a highly individual thing. If you had asked me in spring training who would most likely come up as a starter, I would have thought Balazovic would be the guy, but Varland passed he and SWR up this summer. Let's hope the local kid does well.
-
Dump the Arizona Fall League
Interesting idea. The AFL is a blast to visit--kind of like spring training as you are close to the action and can access players and listen in on conversations by scouts in the stands. Teams usually send a mix of prospects, from their elite guys to guys that are earlier in their development stage. I am not sure if expanding the concept would enhance development or whether it would be better for most players to work on things individually like Varland did in the offseason. I am not close enough to the details of offseason training to give this a yea or nay.
-
Mahle for Steer/Hajjar/Encarnacion-Strand - How did the Twins blow this one so badly??
Two points. The FO knew they needed a top level starter last offseason and sat on the sidelines while the best crop of free agent starters ever went elsewhere. Where were they last offseason? Second, Mahle had issues with his shoulder in early July, and when a pitcher has a shoulder strain, especially in early July, the chance of it reoccuring after he throws a bunch more pitches during the summer is pretty high, and that is what happened. They were left to choose between 2 or 3 starters at the deadline because they did nothing during free agency.
-
Mahle for Steer/Hajjar/Encarnacion-Strand - How did the Twins blow this one so badly??
I think the problem is more complex than simply questioning what the Twins did at the deadline. The question also includes an analysis of why they had to do what they did at the deadline. Had the FO participated in the best free agent period in history for quality starting pitching and secured a quality number 1 starter, there may have been no need to trade for Mahle at all. For example, one of the reasons the FO didn't pursue Rodon was injury concerns--even when getting him on a deal like the Giants would only have required a one or two year investment--but they were very happy to trade for Paddack who had nowhere near Rodon's stuff AND who had even bigger red flags concerning injuries. Paddack was immediately injured, had TJ surgery and now is out until sometime next year. It will likely be 2024 before he is fully recovered. And, of course, the Paddack trade also brought us Pagan who has been a lifesaver in the bullpen ;). Had they added Rodon, it would be Rodon, Gray, and Ryan at the top of the rotation which would be better than Mahle, Gray and Ryan even if Mahle were healthy, and the Twins could have kept the prospects or used them in the off season to acquire more pitching. The same is true of the bullpen where they added Pagan and Smith when there were a lot of better arms available. Hence, the need to add Lopez (who has had a half year of success total in the majors) for more prospects. The point I am making is that this FO reacts to things too late and end up making bad deals, or overpaying as a result.
-
Twins Minor League Report (9/4): Brooks Blasts While Winder Wheels
I think Varland has a chance to be a good starter, but Dobnak and Smeltzer will end up in the bullpen at best next year IMHO. Balazovic has been horrible this year, so I suspect he will need most or all of next year to reestablish himself as prospect. Maybe injuries bothered him, but the times I have seen him he simply has no command of the strike zone. He is not pitching the way you would like a top prospect to pitch. Winder I simply don't know about. I think he has good potential, but he is up and down, and injured. As TwinsDr2021 notes, none of these guys are getting any younger. Frankly, I think Prielapp may be the best of the bunch. I can't wait to see him pitch. I presume Varland or Winder will be called up to replace Mahle and maybe Gray.
-
Mahle for Steer/Hajjar/Encarnacion-Strand - How did the Twins blow this one so badly??
Good comment about judging trades too early. I think the point many are making about Mahle is why trade for him when he had an injury issue earlier this season if one of the main reasons you acquired him is to help you make the playoffs. He might be great next year and the long term results of the trade may look better, but it does nothing for this year. And, all of this is the result of the FO's unwillingness to sign free agent pitchers of quality. They think that is too risky yet they happily trade for Paddack and Mahle, both of whom had some level of questions about their health. And, free agent pitchers don't cost prospects, only money. And that is the answer right there, money. Plus, who have they brought up through the system as successful starters--Ober, and we don't yet know how good he will be, but he has promise. Winder? Injured. Balazovic? Can't get people out at AAA. Canterino? Injured. Hajjar? Povich? Traded. Varland and SWR? Still in minors, but have promise. Ryan? Gray? Obtained in trades. Not a sparkling record methinks.
-
Mahle for Steer/Hajjar/Encarnacion-Strand - How did the Twins blow this one so badly??
I think the FO has messed up on a lot of things, but the deadline acquisitions this year are really questionable. Mahle is an example. He is a nice pitcher with good stuff, but the whole world knew he had some issues earlier this season. How many times have we seen it play out that a pitcher has a shoulder or arm issue that is reported to be minor, only to turn out a few months later to require surgery? If the main reason you acquire pitching at the deadline is to help the team make the playoffs, why risk trading for a player that has had an issue earlier in the season. Even if it does not end up requiring surgery, the chance that the injury reoccurs is pretty high. And, to give up what they did was unbelievable. But, how about Lopez. We gave up a lot for a reliever that has had a good partial season after years of failure. Doesn't it sound a little bit like a Pagan situation, one good brief run early in his career followed by 4 years of failure? What made them believe Lopez was a good long term bet? Why trade for a reliever with multi years of control, giving up excellent prospects, when he has no long term history of success? I could go on and on about Paddack, Dyson, Happ, Shoemaker, Colome, etc., but I fear this FO has a level of arrogance that makes them believe they are smarter than everyone else--smartest guys in the room syndrome. Throw in Cavaco and Sabato as number one picks and their record is pretty grim. When they do make good choices, they trade them away. God help us all.
-
3 Disappointing Seasons from Twins' Top Prospects
I think Martin needs to relax and play the game. I am not sure if he is trying to adjust his approach due to coaching suggestions, or is just putting pressure on himself, but he has to follow Baldelli's advice to the Twins before the win streak started and just go out and play and forget everything (ok, I cleaned it up a bit). It may be a situation like Buxton experienced when everyone was trying to tell him what to do and he finally just said the heck with it, and did his own thing. If he is still struggling next year, then I will worry. Balazovic looks totally out of sync, whether it is injury related or in his head, he needs to start fresh next year and try to build momentum. He has great stuff. Canterino will be fine. Surgery actually overdue. But, there is no denying that they all have been disappointments in their own way.
-
Correa and the SS market
Thanks for the thoughtful response. Good post. I certainly don't think the cupboad is bare if he comes back, and Mahle, Gray and Ryan are three nice starters, BUT to be a devil's advocate, I worry about the injury factor/history with so many of our players. I love Buck to death, but he is fragile. Mahle has had issues twice this year, which may mean nothing, but also could be a precursor to bigger issues. Winder has a history of issues, Canterino has just had TJ, and Maeda is coming back for TJ and that is not a sure thing, especially in the first year back. Paddack is questionable to be back. Plus, Balazovic has had a horrible year, so he will need to figure some things out before we can look to him. SWR has been inconsistent. Varland is on a good run, so he might be the best bet for next year. On the offensive side, Kirilloff is still a question mark as to whether he will come back from the surgery ready to do damage. Lewis is recovering from another major surgery. Jeffers needs a partner as he has not really established himself as yet. If we want to make noise in the postseason next year, I still think we need another 1 or 2 starter, a good catcher to pair with Jeffers, someone to replace Kepler who I think is a huge weak link offensively (maybe he would be a little better if they limit shifts), and 2-3 good bullpen arms. IF Acala comes back strong, and Stashak returns, that will help. Don't get me wrong, I like the core, especially if Correa is back, but these days a team needs a lot of depth in the rotation and bullpen given the frequency with which injuries are hitting pitchers. If everyone comes back healthy, and stays healthy, it will be a good roster, but it will still have holes that need fixing IMHO. Great to exhange thoughts with you. BTW, I hope you are right :).
-
Correa and the SS market
Great post. I think there is a tendancy to overrate current players with respect to their HOF potential, especially when they are on one of the big name winning clubs and/or having good years. And, I think the media biggies tend to push this sort of narrative during free agency. Of the group of shortstops you mention, I think Correa is clearly the best, as even in a year like this when he is not at his best offensively, his defense and game awareness make him special. IF he continues to perform for another 5 years plus, he could be HOF material IMHO. I think shortstop is one of the three most important postions on the field, along with CF and catcher, but I think it is a little less important now in the era of shifts than it was in the old days, but that may change if shifts are banned or regulated going forward. I would love to have Correa back so long as the FO doesn't think they can stand pat if he does return. Like last year, this offseason could be interesting. As for the salaries, it is just hard for me to even relate to those kind of numbers :).
-
Safe or Sorry: The Twins Have Two Pitchers to Question
Your post is interesting. Thank you. I would tend to look at season long statistics, or those that are most current--last 3-4 weeks--as every player/pitcher has up and down periods with respect to their performance. The thing every manager would like to avoid is starting a pitcher who is struggling currently, hence the most recent data is relevant. This in no way detracts from your premise about Bundy--I have been a critic and I agree with you that he has done better than he is given credit for.
- What Can Billy Hamilton Provide the Twins?
-
Twins Minor League Report (8/26): Way to Go, Willie Joe!
Three thoughts. It was nice to see Henriquez pitch well. His stuff is better than his stat line, and we have to remember he is still only 22 years old and pitching in AAA, so he has time to develop. He is one of those players who could put it all together and have a breakout year. Second, I wish stolen bases were still an important part of baseball. I am old enough to remember Maury Wills and his chase for 100, and Ricky Henderson causing chaos on the bases, and of course, our own Rod Carew stealing home. Maybe if shifts are restricted, stolen bases will come back. I think the game would be richer for it. Finally, Stewart and Boyle are what minor league baseball is all about. Young guys working their tails off, experiencing injuries and disappointments, and have the character and strength of will to fight back. I am looking forward to interviews with these guys in the offseason. I am in their corners.
-
Rocco Baldelli's future
Three thoughts. First, I suspect the FO is more involved in the actual management of the team than they should be. So, as others have suggested, if you replace Rocco with another manager who toes the line, nothing is gained. Second, Rocco has had a lot of injuries in the last few weeks which makes his lineup less than sparkling. But, I think he also needs to be accountable for running Pagan out there time after time and mismanaging the pitching staff earlier in the year which, IMHO, cost them 3 or 4 games in the standings which sure hurts them right now. Third, I can't see this FO replacing him. I think they will give him one more year. It had better be an active off season!
-
Matt Wallner’s Ceiling Compares to This Big-League Slugger
Oh my, Cody, I was hoping for a better comparison than Gallo! But, the reality is you might be right. He has struggled while at St. Paul which is usual for him when he moves up a level, but he only has 3 homers in 30 some games and is not making consistent contact, Like Gallo, he walks a lot, has prodigious power, and has trouble making contact. He is not the defensive player Gallo is despite his great arm. And, as others noted, he is older than many prospects. I like the kid and am pulling for him, but I am not sure that he will be able to adjust to the great sliders and off speed stuff at the next level. Let's hope so.
- Minor League Report (8/25): Varland Continues Dominance
-
Astros 6, Twins 3: Like a Broken Record
I hate to be a cynic, but this year looks like it is game, set, match. I know Seth is thoughtful in his defense of Rocco, and while his game and pitching decisions are "curious", I don't think any manager could win with this lineup. Gleeman's summary of why the team is losing in the Athletic today is spot on. Correa is not having a good year but what is really frustrating is that he should be the guy that comes up with the big hits, and timely homeruns, and he has been next to inept in that role this year. Maybe he put too much pressure on himself trying to create a championship culture, and is struggling to make it happen. But, one thing is clear, the Twins need to make some changes in the offseason and address the catching situation, Kepler, the bullpen (Lopez has looked shaky since coming over), the starting rotation, etc. There is a good core with Miranda, Polanco, Buxton, and Arraez, but who knows if Kirilloff will ever be healthy, Lewis will make a full recovery and be the player he was, and Larnach will prove himself. Kepler needs to be replaced with a solid corner right handed hitting outfielder. On the pitching side, even if Paddack and Maeda are back, how will they perform? Going into next year, given the inevitability of injuries, they need to add one top starter and bullpen help. And, they need catching help. I hope the FO is up to the challenge.
-
Players like Baldelli as a person but....
Hey Seth, thanks for the extended comment. I always learn stuff when I read your articles or comments. I think you asked some sincere questions, so I am going to respond to them in the interest of an honest exhange of perspectives. You ask what made Tom Kelly a great tactician. The game as played 30-35 years ago was much different than the one being played today. There were different rules (no three batter minimum for relief pitchers for example), and different strategies (limited shifts, a desire to make contact rather than striking out 200 times, more hit and run, more bunting, more base stealing, etc.), all of which means that a manager's job was much different. But, what made Tom Kelly stand out was his ability, especially late in games, to get the matchups he wanted rather than what the opposing manager wanted. For example, Kelly would pinch hit in the 7th inning knowing that the opposing manager was likely to bring in a certain reliever--say a lefty specialist--to face the pinch hitter. Then in the 9th inning that pitcher would not be available to face players that Kelly did not want facing that pitcher--say Hrbek or Bush. He managed like it was a chess game, and was often several moves ahead of the opposition. And, he had a knack for making the "right" move more often than not. The game requried more strategy than it does today. It was different. Gladden, Hrbek, Bush, Blyleven and all the old players speak of this in interviews when talking about Tom Kelly. I trust their judgement. Why is nobody following suit these days if his style worked so well--because the game has changed, some for the better and some for the worse, and baseball like all sports is trendy. Once some team has success with a certain style or approach--be it a west coast offense in football, or smaller lineups in the NBA, other teams follow suit. The style in baseball now is to have starters pitch a limited number of innings, and hitters focus on launch angle (the three true outcomes approach). That is a style that exists from the lowest minor league levels to the majors. It is not a surprise that pitchers only last 5 or 6 innings when that is all that is expected of them in their minor league development. It may also have to do with the increased velocities and the pressure it puts on arms. Frankly, if the Twins today had two starters who could pitch 250 or more innings like Blyleven and Viola in 1987, I suspect the bullpen would be much better, if of course, they were allowed to stay in the game. It is impossible to compare players or managers from different eras. I am not sure Tom Kelly would be successful today. And, I agree with you that managers win when they have talent and lose when they don't. A great manager may get a few extra wins a year, but it is unlikely to make a huge difference over 162 games. I will say, however, that the the 1987 starting rotation was Viola and Blyleven and pray for rain. Straker? Smithson? Carlton? That year was probably Kelly's best job of managing. Thanks for your detailed comments. I love this site :).
-
Astros 5, Twins 3: Late Rally Falls Short Again, Twins Drop 5th Consecutive
I hope this is the last year we have to watch Kepler's ineptitude at the plate. His defense does not make up for his lack of offense. For the past few years, I keep expecting he will adjust his approach, but outside of brief stretches, he continues to hit ground balls for outs and double plays. Rocco is Rocco. He is not going to change his approach. Going forward, if Rocco stays which I assume he will, the Twins better have a deep and quality bullpen because he is going to use it a lot. I would like to think the Twins could bounce back and make a run, but with Buxton out and with the lineup they put out there, I just don't see that happening.
-
Twins Minor League Report (8/24): Edouard Julien is Him
Great questions. I think there need to be big changes this winter, which is a topic for another day. I think these three players (assuming Lewis recovers from a second surgery), together with Miranda, Larnach, hopefully Kirilloff, Arraez, Buxton, and Polanco should make a pretty good core, and should happen sometime next year. Julien is an exciting prospect. They should give him a hard look next spring, and even if he goes to St. Paul, he should arrive sometime next summer. He has the makings of a professional hitter--good power, great eye, and drives the ball consistently. Plus, he has great speed and steals bases. I know, I know we shouldn't look to next year, but.....