Everything posted by mazeville
-
Is Buxton gonna be an MVP candidate next year?
I agree - am generally not a huge fan of the Trout comparisons, especially as they put some unreasonable expectations on the kid's shoulders. But, I do tend to use Trout as an example to counter others who try to point out flaws in Buxton's game ...
-
Article: Miguel Sano And Negativity Bias
It's a well established fact that conditioning and weight impact injury recovery. Could he have included more medical evidence to support this? Sure. But it's hardly a new idea. And as a reminder, since this column has come out, it's been reported that Sano will likely take longer to come off the DL and could be kept from playing third base as a result: http://www.twincities.com/2017/08/25/miguel-sano-not-much-closer-to-returning-to-twins-lineup/ Now, maybe the slow recovery has nothing to do with weight. But given that the team fed a local columnist concern about Sano's weight and now he's recovering slowly enough that he'll take longer to come off the disabled list, boy it sure looks like that might be an issue here. And again, it's potentially keeping the team's biggest weapon from the lineup during a playoff push. If that's not a reason for concern, and a potential column, I don't know what is. I'm not saying all this because I loved the column -- frankly, the comment about "bags of fast food" was annoying; come on, Jim, these are 20-something dudes here -- but athlete conditioning in the modern era is a legitimate topic of discussion. And on this site, Sano's weight is a FREQUENT topic. Just read comments about how Sano should be DH in a couple of years ...
- Article: Miguel Sano And Negativity Bias
- Article: Miguel Sano And Negativity Bias
- Article: Miguel Sano And Negativity Bias
- Article: Miguel Sano And Negativity Bias
-
Article: Miguel Sano And Negativity Bias
How do you know it was "casually put out there by the team?" I hardly think that feeding concern about a player's conditioning to a columnist with a track record such as Souhan's is "casual." And nowhere does the article say that the Twins are "getting to him." If the Twins were really "getting to him" then they almost certainly would not be feeding this sort of thing to Souhan.
-
Article: Miguel Sano And Negativity Bias
It absolutely will be negatively impacting a team if his weight prevents him from recovering from this injury faster than he would had his conditioning been better. This is a team in a playoff race. Sano is the team's most dangerous hitter. He is out after fouling a ball off of his shin. Poor conditioning CAN prevent him from recovering sooner. No question about it.
-
Article: Miguel Sano And Negativity Bias
Oh, GOD, please. "We used to have a press who supported the team, and would even avoid publishing harmful negative stories." Give me a break. You really want a press that just writes happy-go-lucky pieces on the local nine? REALLY? And yet here you are on a blog where a sizable portion of the pieces and comments are critical about team decisionmaking and player performance? Honestly ... You can disagree with the article or take Souhan to task for his views -- believe me, some of his stuff makes me want to burn my paper -- but the day we get a press who only "supports the team" will hopefully be the day I did.
-
Article: Miguel Sano And Negativity Bias
The Strib beat writer defended the column, saying that Souhan got the idea from inside the clubhouse. This wasn't some columnist simply bashing Sano with nothing backing him up. He had people inside the organization worried about his conditioning. That is very significant. And conditioning IS a legitimate concern when it comes to a professional ball player because poor conditioning absolutely can lead to more injuries and long-tern problems. If the Twins weren't paying attention to Sano's conditioning, then then the GM should be fired and replaced with someone who is.
- Article: Miguel Sano And Negativity Bias
-
Article: Miguel Sano And Negativity Bias
I'm not a big fan of Souhan's columns. I'm even less of a fan on health-related pieces like this one. Some of the things written in the piece made me cringe. That said, I feel at least some pressure to get people on here to put away their pitchforks. 1. That piece clearly came from inside the Twins organization. The Strib's beat writer has been among the column's biggest defenders. Reserve much of your anger for whomever fed Souhan the piece. Because someone almost certainly did feed Souhan that piece. 2. Whether anybody likes it or not, size matters. I'm old enough to remember Kent Hrbek. And that means I'm old enough to remember a player who let his weight stand between himself and being a truly great player. He played in a diminishing number of games in his 30s, and his last game was at the age of 34. No, size isn't what put Sano on the disabled list. But size will affect his recovery time, and it most definitely could make him more injury prone as he gets older. Want a long career in sports? Take care of yourself, for crying out loud. It's a perfectly legitimate concern for a major league baseball team to be concerned about the conditioning of one of its best young players. In fact, I'd be irritated as hell if they weren't. Prince Fielder didn't miss a game for a long string in his 20s. But he was out of baseball at the age of 32.
-
Is Buxton gonna be an MVP candidate next year?
Dude has been playing at an otherworldly level and is one of the better players in baseball even with a horrific start, having improved in all areas of his offensive game as the season has progressed, and we're nitpicking. Mike Trout strikes out 20 percent of the time. He gets a lot more walks, true -- he's definitely more selective and is just a better hitter -- but pitchers obviously hate pitching to him. Buxton is going to strike out a fair amount. Get used to it. He's improved in that area a great deal. Assuming he continues to progress next year, he'll cut down perhaps a bit further. But you have to expect him to strike out a lot. But as long as he produces -- and he's producing -- he'll be fine.
-
Is Buxton gonna be an MVP candidate next year?
He will if he plays all next year like he has since July 1 of this year. Not necessarily going to hold my breath about it. But he has as much influence on the game as anyone in baseball when he's on a roll like this. He won those two games in Toronto pretty much by himself, and he won the first game with his speed and defense and the second one with his power.
-
Article: MIN 6, TOR 1: Buxton, Bartolo Get Twins Back to Winning Ways
Oh for goodness sakes. Bunting is a GREAT part of Byron Buxton's arsenal and they should be encouraging bunting as much as humanly possible. Check out this piece on the best bunters of all time. https://www.beyondtheboxscore.com/2012/12/10/3748738/best-bunter-all-time-career-bunt-hits-bases-empty-mlb Do you know who is on this list? Mickey Mantle. From the article: Since July 1, Buxton has been a totally different hitter. He has improved steadily as the year has progressed, and right now he is the team's single best player (Yes, Sano included). Bunting enables Buxton to weather difficult stretches. But it adds a piece to his game that frustrates the hell out of other teams because they always have to be prepared for the possibility that he will bunt. The fact that he can do that, and hit a few pitches over the fence, makes him a potential superstar.
- Article: Golden Opportunity
-
Article: Twins In Driver's Seat In Wild-Card Race
I don't think it's any coincidence that the Twins' hot streak has coincided with Buxton's return from the DL. He's hitting well. And his fielding changes the game. It'll be much tougher to win without Sano, but he wasn't playing all that well to begin with. As long as other players step up, they definitely have a chance. Especially with that schedule.
-
Article: Feeling The Draft: Analyzing Minnesota's Stellar Early Returns
Nope. Aaron Judge weighs 280-plus and he plays RIGHT FIELD. Sano is doing fine at third. He will continue to do fine at third and, I imagine, he'll get better at it. It's not as if he's running up and down a basketball court and leaping for rebounds. It's not as if he's manning center field and running into walls. Dude plays third base.
- Article: Feeling The Draft: Analyzing Minnesota's Stellar Early Returns
-
Article: Feeling The Draft: Analyzing Minnesota's Stellar Early Returns
No. No no no. The best strategy is to keep him at third and let him develop there. He is still young. He has had only one real season playing at third. His bat is much more valuable at third than it is at first. There is zero -- ZERO -- reasons to move him off of that position. Even with his alleged defensive liability he is still the most valuable single player on the Twins team, per WAR.
-
Article: Feeling The Draft: Analyzing Minnesota's Stellar Early Returns
Seriously? I get so tired of this sentiment. Sano may not be Brooks Robinson. But he made a spectacular play last night, and he's made significant improvements in his defense versus last year. He works hard at it, and wants to be a good player. As he showed last night, and on many other occasions, he can make seriously good plays over there. Give him time. He's only 24 years old. This is his first full season in the majors playing third base. He can definitely. And his best value is as a third baseman, period. That's also the best option for the Twins, who can get a number of people to play first base -- you know, like the aforementioned Rooker, or Alex Kiriloff. I doubt anybody in the minors in the Twins' system, not Nick Gordon, not Wander Javier, not Royce Lewis, has the hitting potential that Sano has and is showing. People shouldn't be so quick to put Sano at first base or designated hitter.
-
Half Measures
I think screaming at the new GMs for "half measures" after one - one! - trade deadline is ridiculous. The fact is, Brian Dozier isn't getting the trade offers we think he should receive. I'm personally glad they didn't settle on Dozier for Jose DeLeon, given what he's done in AAA this year. And they can always trade Ervin Santana this offseason. And remember, the Twins were until recently in contention for the AL Central and would have been stoned if they traded away players when they were close to first place. They then traded two free agents, one of whom was a flip after just one start, and involved the Twins taking on salary. That's the type of aggressive move the previous regime hated. Give these guys some time. If they continue taking "half measures" this offseason, then by all means they should be worth some complaints. I hate -- HATE -- half measures, too. But I don't think this counts.
-
What will the roster moves be today?
He was likely given a strong indication that he would get a shot with the major league club. As I said, I don't have a problem with it. This is hardly some sort of devastating move that is going to block some young guy for years to come. It's not as if Slegers or someone else won't get a shot. They're just not pounding the door down right now. Let's put this into context. It's not as if they signed some mediocre guy for two or three years here. He's a borderline major leaguer on a minor league contract who will not be here next year unless he lights the world on fire. He's a placeholder. And that's probably what the team needs for the next few weeks. Would I prefer to see a young guy? Sure. But I'm also not the one watching AAA and AA games on a routine basis. I don't have scouts telling me who is ready and who is not. And I'm hardly an expert on the inner workings of service time and pitcher development. I also recall distinctly how people screamed for Jose Berrios last year. He destroyed AAA pitching. And yet when he got to the major league club he was awful. Slegers doesn't come close to the numbers Berrios posted last year. So be careful what you wish for.
-
What will the roster moves be today?
Please go back to my previous post and find where I said that Aaron Slegers will "never" get a shot. Oh, it's not there? Right. Because I didn't say it. I specifically said that nobody is screaming for a shot, and that is absolutely, 100 percent true. Slegers is having a good year, and could well get a shot at some point this year. But there is no problem giving someone a promised start when there isn't anybody utterly demanding it, and I'm sorry, but Slegers' AAA numbers just aren't screaming GET ME UP NOW.
-
What will the roster moves be today?
So who in AAA is screaming for a promotion? Aaron Slegers? Sorry, but is 6 k/9 rate in AAA just doesn't wow me. Fernando Romero and Stephen Gonsalves are both AA pitchers who at least need a few starts at AA before they can legitimately be brought up. Probably I'm missing guys. But right no there is no Jose Berrios just waiting in AAA for his shot at the majors. Sorry, there just isn't. I am ALL FOR playing young guys. I think the Twins failed to do that with guys like Alex Meyer when they were clearly losing. I also believe that the Twins will have more openings on the pitching staff this year, and September is only a month off. So I'm not going to get bent out of shape that the Twins filled their 5th starter position with a guy they promised would get a shot when he was signed a month or so ago. It's probably just a few starts, anyway.