Everything posted by mazeville
-
Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
He's going to get these complaints everywhere else he goes if his team says he should get down to a certain weight and he doesn't. It's common, and it's perfectly acceptable these days for teams to push better conditioning on their players. Regardless, I wouldn't want the Twins to sign Sano for 10 years now, anyway, because he hasn't performed like a player worth a 10-year contract. So the point is moot.
- Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
- Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
-
Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
It's not about weight. It's about conditioning. (Aaron Judge is clearly in better physical shape than Miguel Sano) Sano showed up to camp with some extra weight, according to the team. The team wants Sano to get into better shape. That is a legitimate concern for a player who struggled to come off of what was supposed to be a short-term leg injury, and who has seen his performance diminish in the second half of each of the past two seasons.
-
Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
Got it. But according to the Twins his ideal playing weight should be around 260 and according to reports I've seen it's closer to 290 or 300. That's the concern. 230 at this point is probably unrealistic. Regardless, my personal issue is that the Twins and fans are right to be worried about his conditioning. And I'll admit that I'm worried about this for entirely selfish reasons: I want Miguel Sano to be a regular all-star and a fixture in the middle of the order for several years. His best chance at accomplishing that is by improving his conditioning, regardless of what his ultimate weight is. (Maybe he should hang out with Matt Birk, who went from 310 pounds to 235 pounds ...)
- Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
-
Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
I would argue that it is. In 2016, Sano had an .823 OPS in the first half, and a .738 OPS in the second half. Last year, .906 OPS in the first half, .742 in the second half. Maybe that's not conditioning. Maybe pitchers figure him out. But man he went from Jose Abreu to Ryon Healy last year. By the way, Sano's .844 OPS would have been 13th best among the league's first basemen. Right behind Yonder Alonso and ahead of Mark Reynolds. It would have been 9th among third basemen. His bat plays better at third.
- Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
-
Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
Yes. He can get in better shape, genetics or not. Sano struck out 36% of the time and has taken a long time to recover from that foul ball off of his leg (which was supposed to be healed well before the end of the season). Maybe that had nothing to do with conditioning. But man it's hard to ignore that. (And yes, weight does have an impact on injury recovery time, especially when you're talking about the legs.) Regardless, that conditioning makes it more likely he stays at third where he definitely has above-average potential and a cannon for an arm. His value at third is far higher than it is as a DH, which some people on here oddly seem OK with. What bugs me is that the moment you mention "Sano" and "conditioning" in the same sentence we get odd responses with phrases like "BMI police." He's a professional athlete! If he didn't want to have his bosses hound on his conditioning he should have been a sports writer or an accountant. Want a good comparison? Try Pablo Sandoval. He had an OPS of .847 or above in three of his first four seasons. He clearly didn't have Sano's power, but he hit over .300 in those three seasons. He was an all star twice and received MVP consideration once. He's not an all star any more. Now look at him.
- Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
-
Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
First, he is far less valuable as a 1B/DH than he is a 3B. There is no question about that. It may not be the "end of the world," but he's certainly not the player he could be. And why are we excusing a player's conditioning like this? Why are you OK with him showing up to camp at 300 pounds? I just don't get that sentiment. I'm not saying Sano should be some skinny dude. But he definitely has to improve his conditioning and get in better shape. He has a lot of potential as a third baseman. Everybody should want him to realize that potential, and conditioning will get him there.
-
Article: Sano Going To Let It Eat
Are you saying that weight and conditioning don't matter? And your proof is by comparing Sano's performance with that of one single major league catcher? Miguel Sano is a professional athlete with enormous potential. Conditioning may not matter as much in baseball as it does, say, basketball, but it's still very important. Improved conditioning reduces the chances of injury and it improves healing time and could lengthen his career. Improved conditioning will also make it more likely that Sano spends that career as a third baseman and not a DH. Miguel Sano the third baseman is a LOT more valuable than Miguel Sano the DH. Miguel Sano's conditioning is a very legitimate concern.
-
Article: Minnesota's Winter Of Discontent
I don't blame the Twins for Ohtani. Fact is, he didn't want to come here. I'm not sure the Twins could have changed his mind on that. BUT, I do blame them for Cole and for Darvish. The Twins definitely had the prospects to serve up for Cole. And they could have beaten the Cubs' offer for Darvish. They did neither. I was hopeful that this new front office would be more aggressive in a situation like this than their predecessors. Instead, we get the same old, overly conservative approach.
-
Twins Give Darvish a Formal Offer
Me, every day for the last month: * Wakes up * * Checks Twitter, mlbtraderumors and Twins Daily to see if the Twins signed Darvish * * Grumbles an obscenity before getting to work. *
-
Twins Give Darvish a Formal Offer
I like your thinking. I'd probably go for someone like Lance Lynn, rather than Darvish, if I got Archer and then tried to sign Martinez. Because Martinez AND Darvish is probably too much to ask. We are Twins fans, after all. But Martinez would provide some nice Sano insurance while, once the big fella gets off his suspension, giving the Twins a one-two punch that would be awesome even if it isn't on par with New York's Judge-Stanton duo.
-
What is the end game?
I'm not sure why we're debating this because I'm all in favor of signing Darvish. I find this debate odd, to be honest, and think you're nitpicking a point when we both seem to agree on my major issue. When a long contract is an impediment is a pointless exercise, because it's an impediment whether it's a problem now or in six years. But, in simple terms, a six-year contract is more problematic than a four-year contract because that six-year deal carries more risk than the four-year deal. The longer the contract, the more likely it is the team gets stuck with an inexpensive, ineffective player. And the Twins cannot really afford too many bad contracts. But, if they didn't have those two contracts on board the Twins could make a play for additional players or take on additional salary. The Mauer and Hughes' contracts are more limiting that way. And Hughes, because he makes so much money, takes on a roster spot that could be given to a younger or more effective player. There's no question that both Mauer's and Hughes' contracts are problems.
-
What is the end game?
I think it's the sixth year that gives people the heebie jeebies. These giant contracts to 30-something pitchers just rarely work out. If he doesn't work out, in five or six years that $25 million will look awfully ugly. Imagine what the Twins could do if they didn't have Joe Mauer's $23 million contract (though he was definitely a valuable player last year) or Phil Hughes' contract. But again, I just think the Twins should do it, and accept the consequences later on. Just give him the sixth year.
-
What is the end game?
I think getting rid of arbitration would be far worse for the players than a cap. FAR worse. Arbitration helps provide younger players with better contracts. No arbitration means players will have to wait until free agency until they can get paid. And free agency often comes after their more productive years. So teams will sign guys to longer-term deals to buy out those arbitration years (like Dozier did -- he agreed to such a deal without buying out any free agency). And what we're seeing now is teams are not eager to sign free agents to long-term deals. So getting rid of arbitration would wipe out some negotiating leverage they have as younger, less experienced players. There is already a soft cap due to the luxury tax and teams are seeing the costs of that as the Yankees and Dodgers both keep their spending low to stay under that threshold. That's part of the problem this year -- there's nobody at the top driving up the cost for free agents while teams at the bottom unload salary to build for the future. So if I'm players, I probably agree to a cap in exchange for that floor. Unless they can somehow prove collusion, which is highly doubtful.
-
What is the end game?
I agree that I'd personally rather the Twins spend their money wisely. I don't want this team in five years to be burdened with a horrible contract. I'm 100% sympathetic with that concern and have a tough time arguing against it. But I just think that sometimes you have to bite the bullet and this is one such time. It would be a GREAT sign of faith in the current team. And it would send a strong message to fans: "When we say things are different, we mean it." Darvish would instantly make the Twins a legitimate contender. He would offset early concerns about pitching and would be some insurance against a decline by either Berrios or Santana -- struggles by either could basically doom the Twins' season as it currently stands. He is better than anybody available on the free agent market. And we DESERVE it. We've tolerated mediocre teams for too long. And we've watched other teams, even teams like Milwaukee, go all-in, signing and trading for big-name players in a bid to be competitive, while the Twins year after year basically go with what they have. We've given this team a brand new stadium only to watch it go on a long string of 90-loss seasons. We've been told to be patient for years. Now this team is ready to contend. They just need to do it. They have no more excuses. Until they make a signing such as Darvish they will have the "cheap" label hanging around their necks like a great big hunk of concrete. Just do it.
-
What is the end game?
I think if I'm the players I push for a floor and agree to a cap. That would prevent these complete teardowns, forcing teams to at least have some higher priced players on their rosters so they are above the floor. I don't think that teams would agree to a floor without an agreement on a harder cap than the one they have now. And to be honest, you really don't want teams doing complete teardowns like that. I've advocated for it as a Twins fan, but it's not great for baseball to have teams just selling off all their veteran players so they'll lose and get a top draft pick. Doing so should be a LOT harder.
-
What is the end game?
I don't know that it's the per-year dollars holding anything back as it is the length. Some of these guys want longer deals than GMs are willing to give, and I think that's holding back the market. It's interesting. Teams are getting smarter about longer-term contracts and the players have a real problem with it. Personally think this year leads to a major change in the agreement between players and owners that ultimately results in a salary floor and perhaps a stronger cap. As for this year, ultimately I think some players get nervous and start signing. I wish they'd get on with it, though.
-
Ervin Santana had Surgery Today
Sign Yu Darvish. Did someone say that already? If so, I'll just say it again. Sign Yu. Give him six years. I don't care.
-
Article: MLB Shift Driving Market Realities
Really good take. The other factor has been the success of teams like the Astros, who tore everything down for multiple years to collect assets and build for the future. The team rapidly improved once its better draft picks reached the majors, and won the World Series. Teams are getting smart about that. So fewer teams are trying to win, which is limiting the overall market. And teams like the Yankees and Dodgers are trying to control their spending to stay under the salary cap or because they spent too much in past years.
-
The Twins should sign Yu Darvish, regardless of price
I agree. I just think the Twins should take the risk, even if six years (seven is too much IMO ... six years also too much but not enough of a too much for me to say no). The Twins should just do it. Offer him 6/$160 and see if that gets it done and if it doesn't, quietly reveal that information to a reporter so people know that some big offers are being made. If Yu Darvish turns down a six-year deal then he's the problem.
-
The Twins should sign Yu Darvish, regardless of price
I agree. I'd rather go 6/$160 than 5/$150. 7/$175 is actually too much. Seven years for Darvish or any pitcher is too much. Six years is questionable. But I'd definitely do six years and $160 if that would get him and the other choice is 5/$150. As I said in the post that started this thread, I think the Twins should sign him even if it the cost is too high because we as fans deserve it, and they sort of owe us after all of these years. Plus it would quiet down concerns that they won't go for top starters. I doubt they do it. I'm less confident every day. But they should.