Everything posted by mazeville
-
What can Minnesota offer Shohei Otani?
Why wouldn't they? $23 million for a young, controllable pitcher who is also a potential middle of the order bat? Are you kidding? Don't think for a minute the Twins won't spend. That is SUCH a misnomer. They gave Joe Mauer $23 million a year. They quickly signed Jason Castro last year. They signed Phil Hughes, Ricky Nolasco and Ervin Santana when they felt they needed starting pitching. $20 million is hardly a deal breaker. If $20 million keeps the Twins from signing a potentially generational talent, then the front office should quit and the Pohlads should sell the team. Preferably very cheaply, to me. I'm not saying Otani is. But $20 million should not be a barrier to signing a player like that.
-
What can Minnesota offer Shohei Otani?
This link includes the teams that can pay Otani more than $1 million. https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2017/11/latest-on-shohei-otani-4.html Money is clearly not the motivating factor. I'd still say the Yankees would be the frontrunner, much as I hate to admit it. Because if you're sacrificing money to come play baseball in the best league in the world, you'd probably want to play on its biggest stage. But ... I still say the Twins should make a play for him and see what they can do.
-
What can Minnesota offer Shohei Otani?
At the risk of ruining this most excellent thread ... why not the Twins? Major league clubs are limited in what they can pay Otani. And only the Rangers and the Yankees can pay more than the Twins under current rules. Now, I would not put the Twins ahead of the Rangers and the Yankees necessarily. The Yankees in particular offer Otani sponsorship opportunities to make up whatever gap there is. But couldn't the Twins let him be a two-way player? And it's not as if this is a terrible place -- hey, we all live here. And Target Field is awesome. In any event, I've been reading a lot of things that suggest the Twins have no chance. But the Twins should at least give it a shot. And I think it's high time this area stop being so self defeating when it comes to free agents. But just in case, please, nobody send him any lutefisk.
-
What can Minnesota offer Shohei Otani?
He can have mine. Seriously, I still have one. Actually, it's a shersey. Still. Says Nishioka on the back. Wore it a lot during the 103-loss season.
-
Article: Molitor's Manager Of The Year Chances
I think Molitor should win. I worry that he won't, and that it'll be Francona. But given Molitor's pitching staff -- he had to use 36 pitchers! -- and the team's improvement in the second half, he should win. Much easier to win games when you have a pitching staff like the one Cleveland uses. And a lineup like Houston's.
-
Why the Twins should stick to the 4/48 bin in free agency
So you're saying that the Twins would have only received a "mediocre starter" for a package of Andrew Benintendi and Clint Frazier? Because the Twins could have had those players rather than Tyler Jay and Kohl Stewart.
-
Why the Twins should stick to the 4/48 bin in free agency
One of the Twins' top 10 prospects was a sub-first round pick (Gonsalves, an excellent pick). Two of the Twins' top 15 prospects was a sub-first rounder (Blankenhorn). There are some good prospects found in lower levels like Lamont Wade and John Curtiss who are ranked from 15 to 20, per MLB. So yeah, I do consider what is done below the first round. The point is that those higher choices need to hit. TR missed with too many of them, which made the rebuilding more problematic.
-
Why the Twins should stick to the 4/48 bin in free agency
Sure he signed free agent pitchers ... out of necessity. The Twins' pitching was awful and the team had almost no pitching prospects at the time they signed Santana, Hughes and Nolasco during those offseasons. But come on. These are the Twins. They have never in my lifetime built a team off of free agency. It's not wrong whatsoever.
-
Why the Twins should stick to the 4/48 bin in free agency
Marlins' average draft position over that period: 8 Twins' average draft position: 4 I get that the draft is a massive crapshoot. But it drives me nuts that people keep arguing that TR had good drafts. He didn't. He had one good draft during a year he had the No. 2 draft pick and then a bunch of bad-to-mediocre drafts. Worse, in each case he could have had players that would have contributed to the major league team this year. The Twins didn't sign free agents under TR. They didn't go aggressively after international players under TR. They made a few trades for prospects, but not enough. And they didn't trade what prospects they did have for players who could make a good team better that one year the team had a shot at the Wild Card. All of which made the draft that much more important. And TR didn't do a good enough job drafting.
-
Why the Twins should stick to the 4/48 bin in free agency
I'll name two: 2014 and 2015. Sure, Nick Gordon is a decent prospect. But nobody else has worked out below that. The Tyler Jay draft was terrible.
-
Why the Twins should stick to the 4/48 bin in free agency
No. It's a moot point, anyway. The Twins drafted 2nd, 4th, 5th and 6th during that four-year run of futility. For that we had one potentially great player in Byron Buxton. One good prospect in Nick Gordon whose strength is more in his high floor than his high ceiling. And two misses -- Tyler Jay and Kohl Stewart. I thought the Buxton pick was a no brainer, and fully defensible no matter who was drafted afterwards. Let's give the Twins the benefit of the doubt on Nick Gordon. But boy, Aaron Nola would look good in the Twins' pitching rotation right now. Or, I don't know, Trea Turner. Tyler Jay was a horrible pick. He was a reliever. The Twins wanted to convert him into a starter. The Twins instead could have had Andrew Benintendi. Among others. Kohl Stewart was a flat-out miss. I get that the MLB draft is more of a crapshoot than other drafts. But when a team drafts that high, that often, it has to hit more than once.
-
Why the Twins should stick to the 4/48 bin in free agency
Come on. This drives me insane. TR missed on several drafts. Several. He's had high draft picks -- so of course that 2012 draft was a good one. (And he gets kudos for that) But his drafts since have not been nearly as good. Tyler Jay will be a reliever. Kohl Stewart's expectations have fallen so much it's not even funny. Nick Gordon is a good prospect but a lot of people don't think he'll stick at short, and his upside is limited. Thank God for Stephen Gonsalves.
-
Article: The 5 Best Pitching Gambles In Free Agency
After Phil Hughes and Glen Perkins I don't want to touch any pitcher with thoracic outlet syndrome. At best you could do a minor league deal. But what's happened to some of these guys has been scary.
-
Why the Twins should stick to the 4/48 bin in free agency
You don't go to "Ryan's plan." You build from within. Collect as many assets as possible during your down years. When you are ready to compete, you find a free agent or a trade to supplement what you have. Ryan's two biggest problems were poor drafting, failed trades and poor preparation due to his failure to keep up with the times. But he was right in that free agency isn't a way to build a pitching staff, it's only a way to supplement your pitching staff because the available pitchers are usually older and more expensive than they should be. Theoretically, Jose Berrios takes a step forward to lead the staff next year (his stuff is ridiculous). And then perhaps Gonsalves and Romero do well once they get called up. Perhaps the new regime will let a few of those assets go to get a guy who would be better than any of the free agent options.
-
Early 2018 Power Rankings
I don't like "too early power rankings" like the one linked below, given that a lot can happen this offseason. Also, baseball is weird. But, this one is particularly annoying. http://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/21139850/ranking-mlb-teams-ahead-offseason He has the Twins listed 19th. And then he called the season "a little bit of a fluke." One thing about the Twins' 2017 season was this: It was NOT a fluke. The Twins won 85 games. They had a +27 run differential. Based on that, they would have won ... maybe 83 games. Winning two more games than your run differential hardly qualifies as a fluke. Sure, the pitching was iffy. But the lineup was not iffy. And the defense was not iffy. The Twins were a legitimate, 85-win team in 2017. Were they world beaters? Absolutely not. Were they somewhat lucky to make the playoffs? Yes. But they were certainly not a fluke.
-
Article: Trevor May Presents A Planning Paradox For Twins
1. Can't have too many pitchers. 2. I don't think Mejia is the lock you say he is. 3. If the Twins think he is a potential major league starter this year they can potentially trade Gibson this offseason. 4. Can't have too many pitchers. 5. Twins should still look to acquire another starter this offseason.
-
Article: The Brian Dozier Trade That Almost Was
I'm not sure the Twins were "stubborn," so much as they had a price in mind and they intended to get it and when they didn't get it they didn't make a trade. That's what good GMs do. There was no need to trade Dozier he is a good player. I was all on board for a Dozier trade, but I certainly didn't want the team to trade him only for a single pitcher. He was worth more than that. Hard to say the Dodgers made a mistake, given the season they had. But Dozier would look awfully good in that lineup. And it would be nice to have a couple of really good pitching prospects who could step in to the rotation next year (DeLeon is still a good prospect despite his 2017). But it was better that the Twins made the playoffs this year.
-
3B next year - crazy idea thread
Crazy idea: Get Sano's weight down this offseason and keep him at third where his value is far higher than it is at DH. He has considerable potential at third. Everybody should hope that he stays there.
-
Article: Twins Daily Awards 2017: Most Valuable Player
Can't fully argue with it. I'd personally say Buxton is the MVP, simply because his defense almost single handedly turned the team from a bad defensive team into a good defensive team. Also, his hitting really came on this year. Mauer was also a stud this year on both sides of the ball, and his defense saved an awful lot of errors over there at first.
-
Article: Injury Cloud Surrounds Buxton's Breakout Season
I think he's a major league ballplayer and that major league ballplayers get injured from time to time. He didn't miss that much time this year. Be far more concerned about Miguel Sano.
-
Surgery for Sano?
Man, what a bummer. Hope he gets healthy this offseason. Would have been nice having that bat in the middle of the lineup against the Yankees.
-
Who's Your MVP?
You're also forgetting Jorge Polanco, who took off after the all-star break and is the No. 3 hitter on one of the top offenses in the game while playing a steady shortstop. And Trevor Hildenberger, who helped stabilize the bullpen and is basically the Twins' Andrew Miller at this point. I'm going to say Buxton because of the improved hitting and the insane good defense, which has bolstered the pitching staff. I'd put him slightly -- slightly -- ahead of Mauer, who has been a steady force in the lineup and should be a gold glove winner at first. Dozier is also slightly behind because of his second half. But you can't forget Hildy and Polanco. Both have been phenomenal this year.
-
Monitor: Manager of the Year and Fired?
No, he didn't do a good job last year, and I would have been perfectly fine if he got fired. There are also other elements to the performance last year, notably the dumb Sano-in-right-field experiment; a complete lack of a shortstop; no pitching after Santana and a disaster of a bullpen. On top of that, you had a GM who was 10 years behind the times in terms of analytics and scouting. But, again, he did a bad job. But he got a second chance, and the team has a 20-plus game improvement. And now he's had two of three years in which the team has outperformed its expectations by a considerable amount. So yeah, he deserves to keep managing.
-
Monitor: Manager of the Year and Fired?
Molitor is not going to get fired. And he does not deserve to be fired. They are on the verge of being the only team to go from 100-plus losses to the playoffs. They've improved by more than 20 wins this year, more than even the most optimistic prognostications. I do not see the problem with his bullpen usage, given that his bullpen has been little more than a bunch of spare parts. His lineup construction is fine. I vehemently disagree with his bunting tactics, but it's hardly the fireable offense people on here say it is. Numerous players have responded to in-season coaching. The fielding is infinitely better this year. Players like Jorge Polanco and Byron Buxton have gone from busts to season saviors. The team has avoided losing streaks longer than 4 games. Molitor has done wonders without the benefit of much pitching or a bullpen or a lineup that for part of the year was little more than Sano and a collection of underperforming youngsters. Give the dude a break.
-
Should the Twins offer Mauer a Koivu-like extension?
I give Mauer another contract. Don't see any point in letting him sign somewhere else.