Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Taildragger8791

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Taildragger8791

  1. ERA alone in the minors doesn't mean much. K's, BB's, efficiency, and in-person scouting tell a much better story. Lots of pitchers get by on fringy stuff that they know how to get minor leaguers out with, especially in A ball, but then it doesn't translate to the majors. To this point he's performed like a cross between Gibson and Blackburn and hasn't excelled at anything, but he hasn't failed or stagnated either. He's young, I just don't see how you can expect major growth at this point. And without major growth he doesn't elevate the rotation or becomes more than a fringe #5 guy. If I'm planning a rotation roadmap for the next two years I'm certainly not reserving a spot for him. If something changes then they can always work him in somewhere later.
  2. Whether or not it's "putrid", a pitcher who gets shelled every other outing is still tough to live with. He struggles to get through 5-6 innings almost every start, even in those 0-3 run games. He puts piles of guys on base and puts his team on their heels the whole time, requiring them to get to every ground ball in order to limit the damage. He rarely has a clean game where you can count on him to eat innings and take pressure off the defense and offense. I'd still offer him arbitration because he won't be expensive and this rotation is going to be warmed over dog doo doo next year anyways. But that doesn't mean I'm content with his performance, and I'd still be looking to replace him ASAP. I also sure as heck wouldn't let him block a prospect that forces their way into the rotation next year. The offense and bullpen are slowly getting better and it's time to raise the bar for expectations from all 5 starters before we squander too many more seasons.
  3. You don't see how I can draw the conclusion that the Thins have drafted terribly? I didn't think that was a secret. I understand once players are in the system they all go through the same development channels. All I said is the Twins have somehow done ok lately at identifying and signing international talent, which is in contrast to their performance in the draft. I don't know if they're bringing in different types of players that fare better in their system, or they just got lucky on one side and unlucky on the other. You really think it's an unfair standard to ask for an average of 1-2 quality major leaguers out of the draft every 2-3 years? Because right now it's more like every 4-5. The Twins can't outspend their poor drafting like the Yankees, so they have to be better than league average at it.
  4. Sano and Kepler were international signees, not draft picks. For some reason the Twins seem to do okay at signing international talent and are abysmal at selecting and developing from the draft. I don't know what to draw from that but a team like the Twins will never compete without doing well at both.
  5. A number of pitching prospects look promising for a change, but after the number of faceplants we've witnessed I can't put too much faith in even dominant MiLB results right now. Especially when the Twins have been so poor at drafting/developing starters for decades. Until it happens I won't assume anything more than #4/#5 production and I'd still be looking to add a frontline starter from outside the organization for next year, if possible. The offense and bullpen have an opportunity to be league average or better next year and I'd rather not squander another season with a trainwreck rotation that's waiting on talent or is forcing unproductive prospects into it. Make guys force their way into the rotation with excellence and let's go win some games. If they're as good as people say they'll make it and we'll have an embarrassment of riches for a change. I know that may be an unrealistic fan's perspective but I'm tired of failed expectations and can't be sold on promise anymore.
  6. Once again, the puzzling disconnect between MiLB and MLB performance is on display. Why can't we just have nice things?
  7. Is there someone that can elaborate on what aspect of his defense is so deficient? I guess I haven't seen enough of him out there to notice more than a couple bad plays. He's not the fastest but he doesn't look like he's pulling a sled either. Considerably better than Delmon Young looking like he's pinching a penny between his but cheeks as he waddles. Does he take bad routes or misjudge balls? He seems to catch what he gets to and the arm looks passable. It's confusing how he could be rated so poorly when he looks to have average athleticism and baseball smarts.
  8. Not at all, it's probably much better. Against lefties in the minors this year he was .500/.545/.850. He's clearly HOF against southpaws. Don't mind that it was only 20 AB. I kid. No I don't, but I don't think it's terribly far off other than the power may be inflated. He does have a history of hitting well against lefties, especially looking at his minor league splits over the years. Why not ride it out and see if he can keep it up? He isn't blocking anyone this year. It wouldn't work out logistically, but he'd platoon well with Palka if they find themselves on a roster together. Palka does quite a bit better against righties over his career, especially in the power department.
  9. If you have a player hitting .333/.422/.538 I don't think you give half a rip about their defense as long as it isn't a total horror show. We experienced many years of Willingham and Delmon for less than that.
  10. I'd still rather prioritize the guy that can be league average all around over the guy that's elite defensively and a black hole offensively.
  11. Turner's weakness is offense, not defense. If the goal is to develop everyone then it makes sense to prioritize Garver playing catcher while getting Turner as many at bats as you can. Neither one will make it if they don't progress on the weaker half of their games.
  12. I don't think I'd list Trevor May as a success story yet. He's already fallen from starter to reliever, and while he has good stretches he still gets blown up at times. I wouldn't call him established. I want to see a full season ERA below 4.00 first. Kepler could turn out to be a feather in the cap, but it's still too early to call him a finished product. There are some back and forth adjustments with pitchers yet to come. I'm reserving judgment on the college relievers until they get to the majors. The Twins have had plenty of guys dominate in the minors, it's the translation to the big leagues where the wheels tend to come off. The next year or two will be pretty telling.
  13. I appreciate the internal perspective you give, Jack. From the outside we only see the field staffs and the big guys in the front office, so that's what we can base evaluations off of. It's tough to see the changes that have taken place at the middle and lower levels since they aren't that visible. As a result it feels more like shuffling deck chairs than actual change when the front office is rotating the same names around for a couple of decades. Hopefully the changes you mentioned start proving themselves out at the bigger picture level. And hopefully the upcoming change in leadership will push us in a positive direction.
  14. This is what I'm hoping for as well. We know JRM can work behind the dish so hopefully Garver can take a bigger share of the starts there (assuming health is not the issue), and JRM can find at bats elsewhere on those days. He has to show he can be the #1 guy because I don't have a warm fuzzy feeling about JRM bouncing back and holding down the spot next year. We may need him to play 60%-70% of games at some point next year unless Suzuki is extended. Until he does it I don't see how you can count on it.
  15. I was figuring it was a difference of more like 35 games, if you're talking about getting 40% vs 65% of the starts over 137 regular season games. Not the end of the world, but that doesn't seem insignificant for developing at a skill position.
  16. That's unfortunate but it makes sense. I saw he was still in the lineup most days and his bat is coming along. I just worry his ability to play the catcher position isn't advancing at the same pace and will ultimately hold him back. He doesn't hit enough right now for a DH/1B type so I'm just trying to figure out what a reasonable timeline is for him.
  17. Jack, the issue you skipped over is the disconnect between minor league success and major league results. I think many would agree the Twins have done better lately at identifying and bringing in young talent, thus the strong farm system. But at some point, to borrow from Mike Zimmer of the Vikings, we transition to a "don't tell me about the labor, show me the baby" attitude in which on-field results with the big club is what matters. We can talk about the prospects and projections until the cows come home but at some point there must be results, and at best there's only been fleeting glimpses of it. The repeated struggles of young talented players gives the impression that our lovable team is somehow holding back talent instead of maximizing it. We certainly haven't overachieved at any aspect. Sure the chat response was hyperbole. But I don't think it's unfair to criticize an organization that has developed and retained very few players with sustained MLB value in the last 10 years. This next year or two could change the conversation and build a lot of equity for the system, but I hope you understand that it's hard to give credit ahead of time when considering recent results.
  18. Garver has by far the closest thing to an adequate bat between AA/AAA catchers but only started 40% of games at catcher in AA. I don't see how that changes much in Rochester with JRM and Paulino there. Not sure how they'll do that this year and it may be tough again next year if JRM and/or Turner are both needing AAA time. If they really think he can be an MLB catcher I'd think they'd find a way to get him more starts at his future position. It gives the impression they don't really believe in him as a catcher. Do he not have the chops for the position defensively? Is this a Josmil Pinto type of situation?
  19. Pretty sure Jimmer was saying Escobar on his own is a non-factor when considering who is the future starting SS, and separately that Gordon is too far away to be counted on as well. He wasn't suggesting that Gordon is going to displace Escobar or anybody.
  20. Seconded. I don't know why some people are so bent on trading him. I think he's going to be a great "glue" piece that does a bit of everything to help win games.
  21. Found Molitor's TD account. Do you have to list Winston Smith as an alias on legal paperwork?
  22. People act like a little patience is all that was needed for Carlos Gomez, but he didn't click until his 7th year in the majors and his 3rd team. He also hasn't been very good since he left Milwaukee. I seriously hope the Twins can apply some lessons learned to avoid that slow of development again. Everyone remarked about how rushed Gomez was at the time and how it set him back. It follows that using AAA is appropriate considering Buxton has spent less than a season between AA and AAA. I don't understand how we went from worrying about rushing guys to wanting every talented player in the majors today, sink or swim. Patience is required since there is no other option and he's still really young. Maybe it'll click in a year or two. But how long can a club wait? Gomez was mentioned a lot so I ask this: If you had the knowledge right now that it will take another 5 years of poor hitting before you get to enjoy about 3-4 great years, is that a process you want to calmly wait through? I envision this board and the fans getting awfully restless well before then. Edit: Typo
  23. Fangraphs had a solid article on Max's pitch recognition, evaluating his swing mechanics on different types of pitches to evaluate why he's been so successful. Pretty promising for his future. http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/a-case-study-in-pitch-recognition-with-max-kepler/
  24. I was clearly referring to this season. 2015 was a good year for him, no doubt, but I'm not sure what you're trying to accomplish by arbitrarily averaging last year (coincidentally his best year) and this year together. This year, in 7 out of 14 games he's given up 4+ runs in 6.1 or fewer innings. In another 3 he was saved by the bullpen in the 6th or 7th to keep him just out of that range. Sure, if we're being pedantic that isn't "most" but it's close enough that I don't otherwise see what the point is you're trying to make. I'm not saying Gibson is terrible or should be outright dumped. I'm just saying that it's fair to put him on the hot seat because there is significant room for improvement if they can find a replacement.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.