Everything posted by Taildragger8791
-
Steven Gonsalves & Keith Law: Good but No Good
The scouting report I found said his slider was a 60 with potential to be a 70. That's plus and potential for plus-plus. It states it had good tilt and late diving action and was a definite out pitch at the next level. That doesn't sound at all like the pitch we hear about now, which is now described as single-plane and weak contact-inducing instead of being strikeout caliber.
-
Article: How The Twins Could Lose Another 100 Games
I keep hearing this line repeated but I don't see how it matters when the replacements are far from sure things to do any better. It's tantamount to swapping deck chairs on the Titanic. Santiago, Berrios, Duffey (obvious injury fill-in candidate), May, Hughes, Mejia, and Gonsalves could all easily get rotation time this year and replicate those 59 starts. God forbid if Ervin goes down or yo-yos back to Bad Santa(na), now you're really talking trouble. There are so many more paths to being terrible again than there are paths to notable improvement. And currently there are no paths to getting above average in the next couple of years, barring major trades or free agent acquisitions.
-
Article: How The Twins Could Lose Another 100 Games
The scary thing is that this could be a 100-loss team even if we kept everyone healthy all year. Considering our lack of depth, it gets a lot more likely if we lose any key players (Dozier, Sano, Buxton, Polanco, Ervin, maybe Santiago, and whoever the hell we have in the bullpen) for a significant length of time this year. Most of those guys stayed pretty healthy all year.The drop off is going to be steep behind most of them. And Sano & Buxton already have a propensity to get dinged up.
-
Article: How The Twins Could Lose Another 100 Games
Has there been any word this offseason on what Sano has been up to this offseason? Did he play in any winter leagues? I'd be curious to see how he looks when he shows up to spring training here, physically and focus-wise. I think it'll say a lot about the season he's going to have. Hopefully he learned he won't get by on talent alone at this level and was motivated to work a little harder at his craft. Another year of nagging injuries, looking sloppy, and appearing mentally unfocused is going to be disappointing. A focused and tenacious Sano should be scary good. I hope that's what we get starting in 2017.
-
Steven Gonsalves & Keith Law: Good but No Good
I've heard of guys developing variations on fastballs or changeups like that. I'm struggling to think of a time that a guy successfully overhauled a slider, curve, or some other significant breaking ball though. Improving feel or command is one thing, but changing the action of the pitch and learning to command it seems like a major development.
-
Steven Gonsalves & Keith Law: Good but No Good
How often do pitchers find a strikeout-quality primary breaking ball in or after their 5th season in the minors as a high school draftee (or whatever the comparable experience would be for a college draftee)? I honestly don't know, maybe it happens more than I think, but it seems extremely unusual. My understanding is that a pitcher's repertoire is basically established by this point, with maybe some of the fringy pitches being swapped out over time. I also think going into his age 22 season, after 3.5 years of full-time minor league development, we can drop the excuse that he played football in high school. Hell, Mauer was committed to Florida State as a QB and didn't need 3+ years to get caught up.
-
Steven Gonsalves & Keith Law: Good but No Good
Sorry, maybe I wasn't clear. I realize good breaking pitches need vertical movement. What I meant was why did it grade so well and why did the Twins not develop the pitch earlier if it was so flat? That seems like a big oversight. I assume they don't grade pitches based on results against HS hitters, but instead on rely on visual scouting. Otherwise every good draft prospect would be sitting on 60+ grades across the board and the reports would be meaningless.
-
Steven Gonsalves & Keith Law: Good but No Good
I couldn't find squat for 2016, but it's harder to search for than I expected. Javier at least seems to have power potential as a hitter but has questions on his future defensive position The only notable 2014 signing was Huascar Ynoa. Has a live arm but is a total crapshoot due to control issues. I guess if you go back to 2013 they signed Lewin Diaz for a good chunk of change, that dude looks like a potential monster hitter but apparently can't take a walk yet. Strikeout rate isn't bad yet though. Next year should be a big opportunity for him in Cedar Rapids. Amaurys Minier was the big get in 2012, but has spent 4 years in rookie ball and already moved from 3B to OF to 1B to likely a DH, strikes out a ton, and has work ethic questions. Woof. So yeah, it sounds like we haven't competed much for the top international talent in a while. That's disappointing and no doubt playing a factor in the system falling so far, along with our top draft picks mostly projecting to sub-superstar ceilings. Some of the above guys could put themselves on the map this season as they progress out of rookie ball, at least. The new bonus pool rules next year don't give us an advantage for sucking anymore, so they'll have to learn to recruit internationally on a level playing field. Hopefully the new front office has a better strategy for that than TR did. That also means the pressure is on not to botch the #1 pick.
-
Steven Gonsalves & Keith Law: Good but No Good
It's understandable that we would have dropped off a little with so much talent graduating out of the prospect rankings. But it's more than a little disappointing that we've dropped from top-2 to middle of the pack when we've been a nearly last place team for 5 out of 6 years. Shouldn't we have some more impact potential in the low minors? Have we not signed any significant international free agents the last few years?
- Steven Gonsalves & Keith Law: Good but No Good
- This has been a disappointing offseason
-
This has been a disappointing offseason
I'm curious as to how accurate baseruns tends to be. Is it one of those estimator stats that squishes things to the middle, thus no great/terrible team is ever as great/terrible as their record indicates? I'm more inclined to believe that in 2015 we considerably overshot based on having a losing record in all but one scorching hot month of the season. I'm also inclined to believe we really weren't much better than the 103 loss team we were last year. I don't see how we pick up 12 wins based on luck/regression. This team wasn't that unlucky, they just didn't do much well except occasionally string a whole bunch of hitting together. Their one potential strength, hitting, still has a huge streakiness factor to it due to the high strikeout rates from nearly all the key spots in the lineup. Defense won't be much better this year, outfield should be better without Sano but the infield is going to be an adventure (including that shiny new catcher who doesn't grade out well beyond pitch framing). I guess I'm just not one to expect improvement out of nowhere. It's not like we had a bunch of well-established proven vets that had off years (where you'd expect some regression). The pitching outside of Santana was just flat-out bad and filled with never-has-beens. Berrios is the only one I'd expect much improvement out of, and even that isn't a sure thing until we know if it was just rookie nerves/adjustments or if he's fatally flawed right now. I guess Santiago offers some hope, assuming the Twins don't break him. I'd expect progression from a few of the young hitters, but that won't be enough when we're giving up 6 runs a game. I think this roster will be fortunate to reach 70 wins unless we catch lightning in a bottle on the mound and the young hitters take another step forward.
- Article: Don't Sleep On Phil Hughes
- Article: Jorge Polanco At SS Could Be Disastrous
-
Article: Forecasting Mauer's Remaining Years
I don't know if there's actually any truth to this, but I'd be interested in some stats to back it up. However, it is true that over recent years umpires are calling the low strike more and that's traditionally been Mauer's weaker part of the zone. That's led to more strikeouts and weak contact, but not because he's getting screwed on bad strike calls.
-
Article: Forecasting Mauer's Remaining Years
I hope so, I just see it being difficult when the guy had a relatively short run of greatness compared to most HOF careers and his game was built around contact & on-base skills and gap power. He had very good defensive skills too, I think that gets lost a lot. It might take him a lot of years on the ballot. It would really help if he had some postseason accolades to point to, but alas, the damn Yankees and Phil Cuzzi. 50 career WAR also looks to be on the low end for HoF hitters that played in the last 40 years, and if they're considering only his catching years then he compiled about 45 WAR during that time. I don't think piling up 1-2 WAR per year at 1B for 5+ seasons is a factor in his case.
-
Article: Forecasting Mauer's Remaining Years
If he gets in it'll be on the batting titles, MVP, elite years of AVG & OBP, and some future generation of sportswriters that give weight to advanced stats during his catching days. Nothing he's doing at 1B is really helping his candidacy since he doesn't have the counting numbers that impress. He never cracked 100 RBI, only cracked 90 RBI once, and even 70 RBI only five times. Only one season above 13 HRs and six seasons in the double digits. Walks and doubles don't help much unless they come from an elite runner and base stealer. The counting stat he does have is hits, as you mentioned. It's not a sure thing, but he should reach 2,000 hits if he's healthy and plays at least 3/4 time the next two years or has a big bounce back year. I'm just not sure that'll be enough without elite run production, game-changing power, base-running numbers, or something else to go along with it. Especially when the last 5 years of his career will have been padding that hit total with replacement-level play at 1B.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
I'd have more faith in his ability to produce into his mid-30's if he had a longer track record of great performance. Those players you mentioned were great all through their 20's, they didn't suddenly have a surge on the cusp of 30. If he's still hitting 30+ jacks the next to years then sure, an extension would be warranted at some later point. If he falls back to hitting 25 jacks at .240/.320/.445 then I'd be a lot less likely to bet on this age 32+ seasons.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
That is one extremely optimistic prediction on Buxton. .265 with 15 homers and 25 steals would be a good 2017 for him and represent significant progress. He's capable of more but I'm not going to set my expectations too high this season. I don't see Buxton ever stealing much over 30 bases unless he gets more aggressive without slipping his success rate. Or he suddenly becomes an on-base machine.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
I agree there are some changes occurring which opens the opportunity for improvement. However, that still depends on a bunch of circumstances having the best reasonable outcome, and even then the ceiling is limited the candidates we'll be cycling through this year. All it takes is something like Molitor giving a long leash and 100 innings to a hobbled Hughes to undo a good chunk of that opportunity. If we shave a full run off our ERA, a monumental improvement, we'd still only be back to middle-of-the-pack. It's a steep climb to make in one season.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
Not really an equal comparison. Buxton and Sano are super young and extendable, Dozier will be 31 going on 32 the season following this contract. Pretty much a guarantee he walks because the Twins won't pay him $15+ million at that point. And we have a good player ready to slot into his defensive position. And 2017 is a pipe dream to compete because we have essentially the same pitching staff that just finished dead last in baseball again. It would take several long-shot circumstances all going extremely right to correct that. And we don't exactly play in a powder puff division, either. Obligatory disclaimer to avoid a straw-man response: Of course I don't advocate trading Dozier at all costs just to get rid of him, but it's pretty undeniable that the rebuild is going to be delayed/weakened if we can't flip him for pitching. Whether that's due to uncontrollable circumstances or the Twins' own mistakes, it doesn't change that fact.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
The only connection I'd draw, and I'd agree it's tenuous, is: 1) Front office - The front office and scouting system haven't yet been overhauled, it's only been ~3 months since Falvey/Levine took over. So we're still operating largely on the same infrastructure and scouting information from the Terry Ryan era. It'll take time to reorganize this. Falvey/Levine also may be hesitant to immediately stick their necks out on a deal that has a non-guaranteed return. 2) Ownership - Dozier is the face of the team right now and the only marketing darling we have. Amid dwindling fan interest the ownership may not be willing to accept a dip in on-field performance and ticket sales without a failure-proof return. It's admittedly a stretch, but that's the only connection I see.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
Demand could certainly be lower if he has another 2 month slump and invalidates the opinion that he's "figured it out and hit his prime".
-
Twins Interested in Jose Bautista?
Have to agree with this. Bautista doesn't do anything for us unless he comes in with the understanding that we trade him at the deadline if he's mashing. At least that assures he might end up with a contender in the second half and we possibly get better value than a 2nd round pick would provide. Otherwise, I'm not interested.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
Or maybe there's something going on with how the front office has operated that resulted in them not finding and getting great value in trades. Lack of creativity, poor negotiation, or insufficient scouting of other systems, perhaps.