Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Taildragger8791

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Taildragger8791

  1. Gotcha. I misunderstood the presentation of the data there. But 100 pitches at 95+ still isn't a lot. If he just flat out doesn't have the bat speed or reaction time necessary then he's done. But if it's just a mechanical tweak or learning how to time those pitches then he could still be alright. I still don't think we know which it is, so I'm not ready to close the book on him without giving him to opportunity to try.
  2. I appreciate the analysis. There's definitely a pattern but it's hard to make a definitive judgement from these results with barely 1/2 a season of experience combined between AAA/MLB, especially when there was a questionable injury involved. He never got a chance to make an adjustment. And maybe the wrist injury played into his inability to adjust to heat (requiring more force on the affected area). We've watched plenty of rookies come up and pile up disappointing numbers, regularly taking 2-3 years of up & down play while learning. It seems premature to bury him. Hell, your own analysis showed he only saw 20 pitches all year at 95+ mph. He probably saw that many in all his time in Korea. I also have to add that I'm not surprised by a chart showing decreased performance with increased velocity. I'd guess that pattern exists for almost ever hitter. Unfortunately his baseline was already pretty low so the overall numbers look pretty poor. If this were a long-time minor league player I'd be more concerned, but let's give him a year with health to see if he can get used to velocity. I'm far from a rosy-glasses optimist but I do see potential with Park for one reason, which is that we typically see new hitters in the Show struggle with big league breaking pitches more than anything else. Park seems to already be tuned in on those. Give him a year to time up that bigger velocity and we could be handsomely rewarded.
  3. People and sportswriters do get carried away with hyperbole and the over-simplified idea of "winners" teaching "how to win". But I do think there is something to be said for getting productive guys who are known to have good work habits and professionalism and know how to sacrifice personal achievement for the betterment of the team. It's no surprise that often those guys come from a winning background, since winning teams by nature have more of those guys than bad teams. Bonus points if that player has a reputation for actively reaching out to other guys instead of just quietly going about his business.
  4. To be fair, nobody in this thread is questioning his effort or want-to. What I've read is pretty much everyone recognizing and lamenting over how serious the injury appears to be and expecting the worst. It might sound harsh, but if it turns out that his arm is toast it would be better for the Twins to know sooner than later so they can plan appropriately. I'd also hate for him to suffer a more permanent injury trying to come back for...what? A couple of seasons at 70% of what he was? If the injury really is that serious then I hope he's proud of what he accomplished and enjoys a long healthy life, and maybe comes back as a coach or FO contributor when he's ready.
  5. It's the same compilation of guys either way so I don't think it matters in this case who's bat plays better where. Just find the best defensive combination and go from there. I'm not sure if Polanco can man 3rd with his arm but I see it brought up a lot and he did start there a handful of times last year. He has the range and the arm is less of an issue when charging in on the ball. You'd probably get more no-throws or late throws, but that might be countered by getting to more balls consistently. I see no reason Sano couldn't learn to play 1B adequately if he's athletic enough for 3B. If Mauer went down for the year I could see this being a pretty efficient way to fill the lineup. If we could get the 2014/2015 version of Escobar he'd slot in great at SS too. Of course I hope Mauer can be more effective with a reduced role, but it is interesting to see the creative combinations that open up when you remove his name from the equation.
  6. I think he started all around the outfield and as time went on he split time between both corner OF and 1B to develop positional flexibility. They knew he was at least athletic enough for corner outfield, but I think I read somewhere that's a common development strategy for guys like that who can handle it.
  7. Wouldn't it make more sense to move Sano across the diamond and shift Polanco to 3rd, then slot in your shiny new SS? That improves the defense at both positions on the left side while massively improving the 1B production. The only tradeoff is a hit to SS offense, which few teams are great at anyways.
  8. I think if you had a spectrum connecting Chris Davis and Giancarlo Stanton Sano would currently sit somewhere in the middle. I'd place him to be a hair better than Davis due to the walks/pitch recognition and a little more power, but a fair bit behind Stanton due to the strikeouts and contact issues. I seem to recall a lot of swinging strikes from Sano on balls in or near the zone last year, and his strikeout rate needs to come way down for him to be more than a "3 true outcomes" guy, which is his floor right now. It would be great if he can shrink those holes and leap from that spectrum and onto whatever one Miggy Cabrera has been owning for over a decade. I know that's where we had our hopes set, even though a Stanton-type would still be a really darn good player.
  9. I can't imagine these transactions impacted the assessment that much considering Light was expected to have a minimal role this year, and Park's production can't be that much worse than his main replacement in Vargas. Adrianze isn't going to supplant anyone without some serious injuries or total non-performance by Polanco & Escobar. There has to be something else driving these seemingly random predictions.
  10. When do we find out if Park made it through waivers? I thought the window to claim a guy was only a few days?
  11. Teams monitor strenuous innings as much as total pitches, especially with young pitchers. If a guy is throwing 30+ pitches per inning they're going to yank him sooner than later to protect him from himself. On top of it being more stressful on the arm, the guy may start overthrowing or losing his mechanics out of mental frustration, thus injuring himself in a game that was already out of hand.
  12. It isn't "fine" just yet but there is a lot of talent in the lineup presenting a realistic potential for improvement. There are no guarantees, but there is a clear path to success there. That's miles ahead of the rotation which doesn't have anywhere near that level of upside in the system, nor is there even a clear path towards respectability.
  13. Totally agree. The problem is he doesn't throw it over the plate. His last extended stint at AA (2015) he had 32 walks in 43.2 innings. There's no amount of strikeout ability in existence that can counterbalance walking a guy almost every outing.
  14. Not to mention Burdi hasn't even dominated at AA yet. That would be quite a leap to go straight to the MLB roster.
  15. I know you have to take best player available, but man I really can't stomach another toolsy high school outfielder this year. Get an impact pitcher already.
  16. I think Polanco will be fine. And it's not like you're going to bump Buxton. Kepler did well for a young rookie. There's a lot of potential for good performances there. Mauer isn't a black hole, even if he is underwhelming for a first basemen. He should be moved down the lineup though. LF, 1B, and DH are three suspect spots which I wish we'd done more to bolster. Thankfully, they are also the easiest to upgrade in any given offseason so I seriously hope for those to be addressed before 2018. Catcher is a black hole, but that's not a simple fix for any team. There's a good chance this team approaches top 10 in run production. I'm okay with that improvement for 2017. By 2018 they should be well within the top 10. Hopefully it isn't wasted by bottom 3 pitching again.
  17. The lineup will be fine and potentially exciting. We all know this. But if the extent of our rotation's improvement is staked on May, Berrios, and Mejia then that solidifies why some of us don't see big improvement coming this season. We'd be extremely fortunate if more than one of those players held down a 4.50 ERA all year. It's more likely that group will struggle a lot this year with Berrios still figuring out his struggles, Mejia needing to see if he can make the jump, and May needing to re-acclimate to starting while staying healthy. These guys obviously need to pitch a lot and show us what we have in them. But I'm not going to delude myself into believing this pitching staff won't be a dreadfully annoying dead weight around our neck all year. Hopefully they get long auditions to work things out during another rebuilding/development year and we aren't still wondering what we have in 2018 with them. I wasn't super disappointed by the offseason since there weren't many options out there that made sense. I kind of hoped the front office had some creative ideas up their sleeve to surprise us, but I can't fault them for what wasn't there. It is what it is. Nick mostly summed up my thoughts on that a few posts ago.
  18. I keep hearing this statement but I don't really buy it. It's not like we had a disproportionate amount of injuries. Other than Plouffe, Hughes, and Perkins we were overall pretty healthy, and neither Plouffe nor Perkins would have done anything to stem the bleeding last year. Every team loses a few players, but they don't go on to lose 100+ games because of it. And it's not like we got random bad years from a bunch of established good players either. The players that struggled were either super young (expected) or just flat out aren't that good to begin with (also should have been expected). The young ones can improve, but can they improve enough to carry all the dead weight of the has-beens and never-will-bes?
  19. Or it means expectations were too high on some players and they should be adjusted down going forward. Personally, I think 7 players met or exceeded expectations: Dozier, Ervin Santana, Eduardo Nunez, Suzuki, Polanco, Kepler, and Rosario. Sano was a little disappointing but he wasn't that far off the mark offensively, and he was set up to fail defensively by mismanagement. You could probably even throw Kintzler and Pressley in that list. Yes, some of those players had lower expectations, but that's the roster we had and are bringing back (sans Nunez, and I consider Suzuki/Castro almost a wash). Suzuki and Rosario didn't underperform, they mostly played like they should have been expected to (and played a lot). Naturally, I'd anticipate most of the really young players to continue to grow and do better this year. But I also think it's fair to set low expectations on everyone 25 or older except Chargois, Dozier and E. Santana (and even he worries me with his every-other-year pattern). Unfortunately, most of those players are on the mound or occupying key spots in the lineup (1B/DH). So a bottom-3 finish shouldn't be a surprise without changes or drastic improvement from multiple unexpected players.
  20. If Gibson surpasses 200 innings that means he figured out how to stop big innings and giving up base runners in bunches. That would suggest a big bounce back season for him and be a much-needed boost for the team. I really don't expect it though, unless he has some upcoming change to his repertoire or approach that he hasn't talked about. He just doesn't get strike outs or induce playable ground balls reliably enough. Maybe with a stud defense to back him up, but...
  21. It's not about the money or that he isn't a useful player. It's that he occupies a spot on the field that is the easiest to slot in a powerful run-producing hitter, something that we don't have on the team other than Sano and sometimes Dozier. Mauer hits like 10 homers and 65 RBI when we could have someone over there hitting 35 jacks with 110 RBI. Being 4th on the team OPS+ is alright but we had a lot of struggling hitters, so comparing his averages to a bunch of rookies and role players doesn't mean a lot. He just doesn't regularly have a game changing impact anymore.
  22. I was against the idea earlier this offseason, but now I don't think it's out of the question to sign a DH. Mauer is cooked, he shouldn't be sucking up 500 at bats from the two biggest run-producing positions in the lineup. He and Vargas are platoon candidates at best right now. Hopefully Vargas can be more and take over 1B. I'd like to think Park would fill in at first and DH too but he's far from a sure thing and might need time at AAA to start out anyways. There are plenty of at bats for a solid power and run producing bat. And a vocal locker room leader would be a good influence on this team. Outside of Sano and Dozier there isn't a lot of reliable power in this lineup. Everyone else maxes out between 15-20 HRs. I could see the value in some stability and depth off the bench.
  23. Dude, it's cool. We still got Dozier, and I keep hearing we signed some new superstar named "Regression" who's going to pick up all the slack around here. Hold on tight cuz this rocket is about to take off!
  24. At first glance those other pitchers kinda separated themselves with much lower walk rates than Kohl. Kohl usually hovers in the low 3's and ballooned to 4.3 per 9 in AA this year. The guys on that list were was closer to 2 per 9 most of their time and maxed out around 3 per 9 in a couple brief stints. So now we're looking for success cases with low strikeout numbers without impeccable control. The list just shrunk.
  25. I think the fans would come back quickly if this core takes off and they get enough pitching to climb over .500. I only moved to the Cities last year but I'd love to get a 40 game season package if they were competitive. Until then I'll just buy $15 seats on StubHub and sneak down past sleeping ushers when I feel like going.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.