Everything posted by Taildragger8791
-
Article: Dozier Trade Talk Heating Up?
Agreed. I just want to make sure that we don't trade the potential to be significantly better in 3 years for the potential to win a few more games next year. We still have a couple more years of growth and prospect graduations to go through before this team is likely to really take off and be pennant-quality.
-
Article: Dozier Trade Talk Heating Up?
Setting the bar for "middle of the pack" in the division is pretty weak though. Sacrificing future potential for a pennant-winning team in order to push for being the division pain-in-the-ass isn't enough for me or most people. And nobody outside the home market cares about teams that finish 3rd+ place and 10+ games back in the division. Sure, it was fun at first when the Twins were winning a weak AL Central in the mid-00's. But if you just wind up getting embarrassed and out-classed in the playoffs every time it really takes the shine off those division crowns and seasons. Why not learn from that and push to be better?
-
Heads up: AFL championship game is on MLB Network
Gordon, Garver, and English are all in the lineup. English already with a great diving catch to stem some bleeding.
-
Heads up: AFL championship game is on MLB Network
The Twins' team is in the championship and it's on boob tube today.
-
Kate Upton, Justin Verlander, RIck Porcello and the Cy Young Award
Nobody ran away with it by being utterly dominant this year (ERAs all over 3.00) so it's hard to accept any griping over the winner between the 3-4 candidates who are deserving. Verlander probably earned it in my mind, and losing with 14 first place votes is annoying, but you don't automatically win if you can't separate from the pack. But Kate Upton, that was great.
-
Sickels: Byron Buxton Crystal Ball
I don't know that the SB numbers are all that low. Even if Buxton brought his average and on-base numbers up to say .270/.340 levels and continued to attempt (~20%) and succeed (~80%) to steal at his career rate he'd still only fall in around 25 steals a year. He'd have to see big uptick in attempt rate or OBP while keeping his success rate near 80%, which seems tough to do. It'll depend on how much better he gets at reading pitchers and situations, which is learnable to a point, but in my opinion the great base-stealers just seem to have that instinct innately on when and how to run.
-
Article: Top Five Twins Bounce Back Candidates
I don't know if Park qualifies as a "bounce back" candidate since he hasn't really set a baseline to bounce back to yet. He hit some long homeruns and had a couple short stretches that looked competent, but otherwise flailed a lot and was demoted as a result. I'd put him in the same category as the young guys that are still developing and establishing who they're going to be (Sano, Kepler, Vargas, Buxton, Rosario, Berrios, Duffey). Most of them will be ok and find a role on the team, a couple will fizzle out. That's just the nature of the game. When it comes to guys I think of as actual bounce back candidates (Hughes, Gibson, Perkins, Plouffe, Mauer), I don't have faith that any of them will get back to even their median performance levels. Plouffe likely needs to be moved to clear roster space and save Molitor from himself. The rest of them will get their opportunities but I certainly don't want to depend on them. There needs to be a Plan A that doesn't require gambling on these guys to be key contributors. That kind of "planning" is how we ended up with a persistent tire fire on the pitching mound all year instead of actual big league pitchers.
-
Article: Cody's 2016 Twins Offseason Blueprint
I'm struggling to get a feel on what Sano is going ultimately to be as a hitter. His basic slash line looks alright at a glance for a run-producing power hitter, but I came away from last season with the feeling that while he had some big hits he also had way too many at-bats where he came up short or was non-competitive. Particularly in key situations. That's just going off my general impression I remember from the season, however. Looking at his splits might explain where that feeling came from: after the all-star break he only hit .228/.286/.452/.738, while before the all-star break he hit .243/.350/.472/.823. The weak finish to the year is probably weighing down the impression I took away. The other thing that sticks out is that when he's behind in the count he's struggled mightily. I'm sure most people on here remember later in the season when the analysis came out that he does most of his damage after working his way ahead in the count or to a full count. What I see is that his damage came on the first pitch or when he gets to start out ahead in the count. If he starts out behind or gets 2 strikes his numbers fall way off, particularly in the power department. In 2016 he hit .172/.235/.323/.558 after 0-1, hit .185/.185/.296/.481 when behind in general, hit .219/.223/.439/.662 when even, and with two strikes he hit .123/.210/.230/.440. One more thing I thought was interesting. I seem to remember Sano having trouble with high heat last year, and swinging through those pitches often. BBREF has a split for power pitchers and finesse pitchers, and here were his stats with regards to that: Power: .168/.248/.267/.515 Avg: .232/.325/.465/.790 Finesse: .285/.359/.589/.948 Perhaps the heat is what he's struggling with after all? If he can learn to recognize pitches faster or catch up to the faster pitches he could break out in a big way. But until he closes that hole in his swing good pitchers with high heat will continue to minimize him.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
I know they aren't hired right of college to assistant GM. My point was they go from college to low-level front office, probably getting paid well below what they could get in the general job market with their background. That weeds out anyone who doesn't have the passion for baseball and doesn't have the economic freedom to be underpaid for many years. This is where your pool of eventual GM candidates is coming from right now. I assume at some point somebody will break the mold and change their hiring profile, and as soon as they prove successful everyone will copy that and maybe we'll see more diversity that way. But as long as the profile is what it is, it won't change without going out and recruiting for those low level positions and probably offering better pay in the process. The problem with that is you might wind up getting less passionate baseball people, which could wind up with less effective front offices.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
Alright, I'll bite. So the current hot trend is to target candidates with premier academic backgrounds? What is the demographic of those who graduate from the most prestigious universities with excellent performance, that then choose to go into baseball scouting and front offices instead of taking a high-paying job elsewhere? My out-of-thin-air guess is it's going to be almost entirely male and overwhelmingly white. Not many people, particularly ethnic minorities, have the luxury combined with the financial freedom & passion to turn down great job offers elsewhere while they go spend 10 to 30 years trying to climb the baseball front office ladder. The only way you're going to turn it around is to proactively reach out and foster interest within those underrepresented groups. Go recruit women & minorities from those schools to get them into your organization early on so down the road there will be a more diverse pool to select from. Maybe I'm being naïve or giving too much benefit of the doubt. I just have a hard time assuming that this is a case of overt racism and intentionally denying opportunities to equally qualified women/minority employees.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
I would imagine it's the result of having an organization that's so insular and inbred. They rarely made any significant changes to personnel and when they did it was usually from within the Twins family. They stuck with people and personalities that they knew. This limited the influx of new ideas and experiences and placated the change-averse nature of the leadership and ownership.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
I mean...I want to be surprised but I can't say that I am. I half-expect to hear a few more surprising statements like this come out over the off-season revealing how behind the Twins organization was on various things.
-
Article: Ninth Wonder: What To Do At Closer?
Acquiring a closer in mid-season is way more difficult and expensive, and leaves winnable games on the table that can make or break your season. Similar to what happened in 2015 when we went into the year with a shoddy bullpen, tried to patch it up mid-year, and missed a playoff spot by a few games as a result. I don't expect that to happen next year considering how abominable and unsalvageable our rotation is, but the scenario you described is a too-little too-late approach. It's not prohibitively expensive to get a one or two year deal on a bounce-back candidate free agent, and there's room in the bullpen to add a piece. Why not cover your bases and give yourself a chance? There will still be plenty of opportunities to break in young pitchers without over-relying on them to be ready. Then, if we have another 102-loss team on our hands you can hopefully trade that veteran for something if they managed to establish some value.
-
Article: Ninth Wonder: What To Do At Closer?
I'd agree with that, but I don't think hardly anyone is seriously advocating for a long-term big money FA for the bullpen. Nick's suggestions, and most of those I've seen in this thread, were talking about buy-low 1- or 2-year deals on bounce-back veterans. With the additional consideration that said veteran could be flipped for trade value if they reestablish themselves. Any thoughts of getting a Jansen/Chapman type sounded pretty tongue-in-cheek to me.
- Article: Ninth Wonder: What To Do At Closer?
-
Can the Twins Afford to Release Mauer?
That's reasonable and could work if the manager adhered to it. My other thought was if he plays 120-130 games it probably means someone else got their playing time cut. Someone that needs that time for development and evaluation, such as Park/Vargas and potentially Palka/Walker later in the year. I'd like to emphasize development next year so we can have a clearer picture going into 2018 on where everybody stands.
-
Can the Twins Afford to Release Mauer?
I'd probably lower the bar to 100 games, unless his performance and health dictate more. He only played 134 this year and looked like his legs were a wreck. His should be a backup & bench bat, playing mostly on the advantageous side of platoon splits when possible. I don't want to see Vargas & Park get shoved to the side for Mauer next year. He still has value in those roles with what skills he has left. Then revisit after next season to see if he his final year should be cut based on how things went in 2017.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 7 (6-10)
The like didn't show up until after I got the reply, my bad. It's entirely possible, he's just got a big uphill battle starting this next year to make it work. He's going to get plenty of opportunity to try. The difference is he's gone from someone we hoped to be comfortable slotting into future rotations to someone that we need to ready a backup plan for, which certainly complicates things for the 2018+ teams.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 7 (6-10)
I was being cheeky, and I assumed you were too. I just don't see the value in comparing to all-time greats who were extremely exceptional at how they succeeded. Tons of pitchers have better raw stuff and strikeout rates than Maddux that wash out of baseball every year because they don't figure out the finer points required to have actual success. Nobody ever advocated to cut him so I don't get point of that snark either. It's entirely reasonable to have doubts about a prospect while supporting him.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 7 (6-10)
And worse BB/9, H/9, BB/K, and way less innings per start.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 7 (6-10)
Berrios and Gonsalves are the only pitchers in that list that are intriguing to me for next year. May, Duffey, Gibson, Stewart, and Mejia are lottery tickets to even be serviceable. We're going to go through a lot of pain next year while we figure out who can play but hopefully it'll set up a somewhat established rotation and bullpen for 2018. Jay needs another full year of development and building innings, but he has real promise with his stuff. Looking forward to seeing how him and Thorpe recover from their injuries and develop next year.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 7 (6-10)
I don't know if being 21 is an excuse for having a track record of low strikeout rates. Strikeouts at those lower levels are achievable largely on stuff alone. By far his best K rate above rookie ball was 7.6/9 when he repeated high-A this year, and otherwise has rates of 4.6/9 (AA), 5.0 (High A last year), and 6.4 (Low A last year). Those are remarkably low for someone who scouts think has such good stuff, so I don't know what to make of him. Is it sustainable to rely on inducing poor contact against major league hitters? The Gibson/Pelfrey comps make sense but those guys still had managed decent strikeout rates in the minors. How many MLB pitchers thrive with a K/9 below 6.0?
-
Alex Meyer called up to LAA
That Nolasco guy has looked pretty good since he started there. We should try to get him.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs. Tigers, 9/21/16 @ 7:10pm CST
After Parker's article about Berrios tipping his pitches, I've been watching his wrist angle as he brings the ball behind him and have been able to call every fastball or changeup he's thrown before he starts forward. It's plain as day. No way the hitters don't see that too.
-
Article: Penciling A 2017 Starting Rotation
Again, I basically agree. I'd rather dump Santiago and his salary to open up a spot. If some team offers up a promising young starter then of course I trade Santana. But I don't think there's a logjam preventing those guys from coming up next year. Gonsalves won't be up until mid-season most likely, by which point there will be a spot for him. Jay and Stewart might be looking for room in the second half and by then another 1 or 2 guys will have pitched themselves out of a job or be hurt. If not, then that means the rotation is doing pretty well and don't need to be replaced anyways. But most likely two out of Mejia/Gibson/May will be replaceable before the end of the year.