Everything posted by Taildragger8791
- Article: Deadline Primer: Shake-Up At Short?
-
Article: Deadline Primer: Shake-Up At Short?
I believe the quote also said something like "our phones are open, call if you have any ideas", which is a pants-on-head crazy statement from your GM. You'd like to see a little more direction and pro-activeness projected from your front office. Hopefully it was a poor choice of words and they have a better plan than letting other teams frame the trade proposals. Appearances matter when you're putting on such a display of suckitude for several years now. I'd also be pretty frustrated if they dumped Polanco for anything less than a sure-fire starting-caliber player. He's a young MLB-ready middle infielder who can legit hit and we're going to burn him because we can't stomach losing one of Escobar/Nunez/Dozier? Pretty short-sighted unless they have good reason to believe he can't establish himself at SS/2B.
-
Article: Commitment Issues
NOBODY could have seen it coming? That's a pretty bold statement. Maybe not to this severity but it shouldn't have been a total shock that he'd regress considerably and be thoroughly mediocre. His career ERA is 3.83 which is high for a supposed back-end reliever, and 2014/15 were clearly much better than his established baseline. Even his minor league performance was pretty rough until his call-up year. Sustained excellence shouldn't have been the expectation. I also found it interesting that he was 10 for 26 in save opportunities in his career at the time we acquired him. That may not be the best statistic but it speaks a little to his performance in high leverage situations.
-
Worst ejection ever
I'm still not sure what he got ejected for but it looked like it was due to his reaction to the bad check swing call, possibly quipping something at the 3B umpire. I'm surprised by the quick hook but arguing balls/strikes is always a risk to end badly. I wish the umps had thicker skin than that.
-
I Like Kepler
For some reason he looks more like Morneau to me than Mauer. He has the sweet swing of Mauer but is more willing to muscle up with that power swing when he sees his pitch. He doesn't have 30+ HR power like Morneau did but I still like that well-rounded approach more than Mauer's when it comes to a middle-order hitter like we hope he'll be.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (7/7): Moving Day And Two Palka Dingers
Way to jinx it. Now we won't see him til September.
-
Travis Harrison - 2016
That doesn't follow. Kepler started out extremely raw and broke out at AA as a 22 year old after showing flashes of talent throughout previous years, thus earning the opportunity at AAA and then MLB. Harrison is more or less stagnant while repeating AA at 23 and hasn't really flashed the same talent or shown steady growth. I doubt pushing him up a level is going to magically spark him.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins @ Rangers, 7/7 @ 7:05pm CT
I know the Twins have been pretty bad, but they're not an MILB team yet.
-
Tracking Arcia
I'm not sure what the point of this thread is other than to be a sacrificial anode for the rest of the forum. Thankfully. But I don't see the point in comparing Arcia to Kepler. Arcia wasn't cut (if the return is petty cash he was effectively cut) because of Kepler. He was cut because the Twins managed the roster to a point that they felt they couldn't keep him around anymore. The story on Arcia won't be told for years so this is a silly effort. Btw, I love the way Kepler looks so far. Looks like another Morneau with a hair less power. Dude is gonna be a stud.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (7/6): Arraez Leads Kernels To Win
Speaking of Burdis, has there been any further updates on our own Burdi? It's been dead quiet on him and he's been out a suspiciously long time for a bone bruise. Reportedly he had a setback, but I'm not sure how you have a setback from a bone bruise. Surely there is more going on?
-
Santana trade rumors
Honestly, I don't think it is. If we want to punt next year for development and get something for the vets then by all means, go for it. I don't think we'll compete anyways. I'm just pushing back on the statement that the group was intriguing, and setting the expectation that if you enter the year with those names you're looking at another 60 win season. If Stewart and Gonsalves prove themselves they won't have any trouble breaking into this rotation even with Santana and Nolasco still around by mid-year. Most of those names are going to pitch themselves out of a rotation spot. I think that's a big if on Gonsalves until he finds better control, by the way. If you miraculously got 5 good starters and Stewart has to wait for a trade or injury then so be it, that's a good problem to have for a change.
-
Santana trade rumors
Going into next year with those 7 as your SP wouldn't be intriguing, it would be an irresponsible dumpster fire. Milone and Hughes should not be counted on for anything. Duffey and May are reasonable gambles but you can't bank on them holding down 2 spots all year. Alex Meyer is a hot mess who's career may be going off the rails. Pat Dean is a 27-year old non-prospect that doesn't strike anyone out. Berrios is promising but he hasn't established himself in the majors yet. So you're basically looking at 7 lottery tickets and would be lucky if 2-3 paid off. You're certainly guaranteed that 4-5 of those will not.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Oakland, 7/6/16, 12:10 PM CDT
My main gripe with DanSan playing SS is that it pushes Nunez to 3rd, Sano to DH, and Vargas to the bench. After seeing Vargas look great yesterday I don't know why on earth you'd effectively replace him with Santana in the lineup instead of seeing if he can get into a groove.
-
Article: Twins First Half Summary: Murphy's Law
That's fair. I certainly didn't want more vets other than for the bullpen and catcher, and I supported playing the young players who were ready. Yet when you look at this roster it wasn't particularly well built to do that. Plouffe displaced Sano, May displaced to the bullpen, Polanco can't crack the roster, Arcia pushed off the roster completely, no backup for Buxton and Rosario if they need to go down, etc. These are moves of a team thinking it can win and compete now, but then again the lack of offseason moves conflicts with that. The whole division went out and got better and we stood still with an awkward roster overflowing with dead weight vets mixed with really young players. It's tough to buy that Terry had zero opportunities to clean that up a little. And waiting 3-4 years for all the bad contracts to run out isn't realistic. The confusion regarding the plan or expectation for this year is where my frustration is largely stemming from. We went for a middle-of-the-road approach which seems to be taking us nowhere. Thankfully it appears the team is starting to prioritize the youth over vets, so hopefully they stick with that plan for the rest of the year.
-
Article: Twins First Half Summary: Murphy's Law
I was about to say the same thing before I saw your comment, so instead I'll highlight it. If a few veterans underperform or fail then you can reasonably lay most of the blame on those players. If they all struggle or fail then maybe they weren't as good as you thought to begin with. That has to shift some blame to the front office and coaching. Similarly, if a few marginal prospects don't make it then you can blame it on them being marginal prospects. But when nearly all your top prospects keep falling off a cliff then it again points to the front office and the coaching. Either they are picking talent poorly, they are developing it poorly, or the players were pulled out of the oven half-baked to try and cover up other roster mistakes.
-
Article: Twins First Half Summary: Murphy's Law
The obvious implication of calling out Murphy's Law is that "bad luck" and the universe conspired against the Twins to generate all these negative outcomes. It's a flawed analogy which deflects blame though, because in the end real people caused and are perpetuating this train wreck with no end in sight. It's not Murphy's Law when you buy 20 lottery tickets and only get 1 winner for $10. That's the expected result when you gamble, and based on how many times the word "hope" or similar appears in the article I'd say that's exactly what the Twins did.
-
Article: Game Thread, Twins @ Palehose 1:10 CT
Luckily Dick jinxed it by saying the throw-out would surely be overturned on appeal. So naturally it was upheld and Suzuki caught a Panty Hose basestealer for the first time this year.
-
Article: Game Thread, Twins @ Palehose 1:10 CT
About as many times as Bert talked about "that downward plane".
-
Article: Game Thread, Twins @ Palehose 1:10 CT
Danny Santana, for some reason playing left field, fielded a hot grounder and threw home to try and get the runner. Ball sailed to the foul side of the line pulling Suzuki away from the runner who slid on the fair side. Suzuki caught the ball but couldn't dive back fast enough and the missed the tag.
-
Honest qustion: How have the Twins not fired Ryan and/or Molitor at this point?
Did anyone else catch the article on mlb.com where Reggie Jackson gave an impromptu mini-lesson to Kepler during batting practice in New York? http://m.twins.mlb.com/news/article/186729982/max-kepler-gets-bp-advice-from-reggie-Jackson Pretty cool of him to do that, but the thing I found interesting at the end of the article was a quote from Kepler stating that nobody had taught him to hit around the field during BP. He just got up there and swung the bat instead of going through an effective routine. That seems like a pretty fundamental aspect of practice and getting prepped for a game, and I know I've heard other good hitters talk about doing the same thing. Why would this not be getting drilled into young players before or shortly after they get to the majors? I remember hearing similar stuff about Arcia & Vargas having homerun derbies with their BP. Shouldn't coaches assert themselves over BP instead of just letting guys mindlessly yack around? Particularly with top prospects? It sounds like a small thing but casual fans don't get many peeks into the process of developing these players. When everyone is struggling and anecdotes like this come out it doesn't exactly ease concerns for the way this staff is operating. Maybe I read too much into it. Shrug.
-
Article: Brian Dozier Pulls Himself Out Of Slump
I know you jest, but I was trying to be optimistic about the future and the playoffs should be what we're building for, right? It may be 2018 or 2019, but if Dozier is still supposed to be considered part of the future then his performance should be analyzed in that context. I'm glad he's showing some life again and if he somehow sustains it that would be awesome. But, as the article stated, he's probably still going to be prone to long slumps due to matchups and adjustments and that could be a big liability when everything gets tighter in October/September. We should be thinking about what it takes to win championships, not just build a .500 record and be relevant. His past performance may average out over a long season to look palatable, but in a short winner-take-all series it could sink you. A top-half of the order hitter that can be wiped out by careful pitching and shifts is a liability in the playoffs when your opponent fields top of the line pitchers and defense almost every night. Maybe I'm being too idealist, but I'm tired of trying to find reasons to be content with "not that bad" instead of asking for "good" and "great".
-
Article: Brian Dozier Pulls Himself Out Of Slump
I want to be okay with Dozier's approach, but he needs to drastically decrease the length and severity of his slumps to justify it. Hitting below replacement level for 2-4 months at a time seriously hinders the lineup's effectiveness. Consistency counts for something too, not just career averages. Like a "volume scorer" in basketball who's jumpshot goes cold, you have to keep giving them shots until they get going because you're dependent on that production. Meanwhile, you're digging yourself into holes and losing winnable games. What do you do with Dozier if he's mired in an extended slump come playoff time?
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (6/23): Berrios Strikes Out Nine!
And horrible April and spring training. His May stat line is driven by a hot first 8 games of the month where he hit .370 and had an OBP of .452. The next 8 games (taking us to today) were .200 and .285, respectively. So he's shown signs of life but yes, he's still struggling.
-
The Bullpen without Perkins
Not sure why Burdi is on your list. He hasn't proven any success above A+ ball and hasn't been able to stay healthy. The Twins shouldn't be counting on him for anything and should build a bullpen as if he isn't available. If he forces his way onto the roster then wonderful! We could use the surplus for a change.
-
Glen Perkins Out for Season
I'd say go out and get enough solid arms this offseason, including a closer, to fill out the bullpen so we don't have to deal with this crap again next year. Let them all compete, there's no reason to limit the job offer to someone internal. Chargois should of course get an early audition this summer. I'm not making any plans that depend on Burdi or Reed though. They're both starting to look like long shots to contribute in the next year, if ever, and should be made to force their way onto the roster through sustained excellence. If they ever stay healthy and figure things out then we get to have a surplus, which is a good problem to have. I'm not into reserving 25-man roster spots for mercurial reliever prospects. That's what contributed to this bullpen mess in 2016.