Everything posted by bird
-
Take Two: Pending Physicals, Twins and Dodgers Agree to Trade
This Columbian kid might be a very interesting prospect to follow, in part because he's a catcher. FG has him at 35+FV already, a half grade better than Raley. The Twins have two other catching prospects valued by FG at 35+FV, Caleb Hamilton and Charles Mack, a converted MI. Rortvedt is a 40FV, and Jeffers is a 45+FV.
-
Take Two: Pending Physicals, Twins and Dodgers Agree to Trade
Yeah, and aside from Cave, Wade, Kirilloff, and Larnach, they also have all of these outfield prospects valued above the 35FV Raley: Rooker, Celestino, Urbina, Baddoo, Wallner, Emmanuel Rodriguez, Edouard Julien, and Willie Joe Garry, all at 40FV or better. That's a dozen more promising outfield prospects, and they might have to move Royce Lewis and/or Blankenhorn there too.
- Take Two: Pending Physicals, Twins and Dodgers Agree to Trade
-
Take Two: Pending Physicals, Twins and Dodgers Agree to Trade
Is it possible you are underestimating what the Twins (and others) know about these guys? Is it possible you are overestimating the significance of what very very very little you (and others here) know? They DO have a ton of information. We DON'T. The Twins just concluded their pitching minicamp, where invited pitching prospects came in to work exclusively on improving or maybe developing a single pitch. You and I have zero idea about the outcome of all this. We don't even know which prospects participated. So, for any of us to rattle off a bunch of plus plus stuff from an old scouting report written by an outsider seems a bit silly and maybe a bit arrogant to me. FanGraphs, who I think most of us here find more credible than MLB, gives a 50FV grade to Balazovic, Graterol, Duran, and Jeter Downs. I think, without knowing more, us outsiders would have to say they are comparable talents. The reason MOST of us view the other three to have more value than Graterol? 1. More pronounced injury risk. 2. Starters versus bullpen, at least temporarily 3. More past and projected performance volatility Still, you might be right. Most of us aren't confident enough with what we know or what we can predict to have your level of conviction. Labelling it a stupid decision doesn't sound smart to me.
-
Graterol Trade On Hold? Valuing Starters and Relievers
Again, could be, but I'd still be inclined to think the medical review starts earlier with the sharing of existing medicals, and then the trade only becomes official once the acquiring team's own medical staff has a chance to complete a scheduled physical of the player. Personally, I find it utterly unfathomable that the Dodgers would take on half of Price's contract without first seeing what the existing medicals tell them. But hey, what do I know? No more than your average beat writer on the subject i'm guessing.
-
Graterol Trade On Hold? Valuing Starters and Relievers
That could be, but i very much doubt that teams are in the habit of negotiating and agreeing to trades like this without receiving the medicals. Skipping that kind of due diligence, even when the decision can be reversed at the mere cost of a monstrous hit to a firm's reputation, would be an act of negligence in any industry that I've ever covered. I agree that the Twins were under no obligation to share their own conclusions, even those based on medicals.
-
Graterol Trade On Hold? Valuing Starters and Relievers
I can only imagine their reaction is related to one of three things: 1) a failure to do a thorough review of the medicals; 2) criticism beyond what they expected; or 3) actual new medical information previously unshared. The first two indicate being "pretty naive". I pick Door # 2, but it's just a guess.
-
What others are saying about the trade
How foolish of you. And them. I'm going with jud6312.
-
Graterol Trade On Hold? Valuing Starters and Relievers
Like others, I'm guessing Chaim Bloom has some buyers remorse and feels the sting of the critics, and that the hesitancy is unrelated to new medical information. However, I'd also guess that Boston can figure out a way to look at those MRI's and find language that describes what's in those images in new and creative ways to make their case if they so choose. I certainly have no reason to expect, you know, some form of honesty somewhere in the mix. Not in this industry.
-
Twins Trade Graterol to Dodgers for Kenta Maeda in Blockbuster Deal
Sure. I just happen to remember Pierzynski, Mauer, Garver, and a number of other hoarded catching prospects much more fondly. I believe it's a false celebration and a false description, this whole "end to hoarding prospects" thing. I believe what we're seeing is further evidence that Falvey has a BALANCED and strategic approach. He's trying to win now and simultaneously accomplish three things: 1) have a deep and talent-rich MLB club, capable of being good enough to get to the postseason, good enough to overcome injuries, strong enough to have tradeable redundancy there, and lucky enough to make a run in the postseason; 2) keep enough powder dry in case an opportunity presents itself (by avoiding financial inflexibility); and 3) maintain a pipeline that continuously, without interruption, feeds the major league club. He's almost there already. It's an elite group of about a half-dozen organizations.
- Twins Trade Graterol to Dodgers for Kenta Maeda in Blockbuster Deal
-
Is Marwin Gonzalez a lock to make the roster?
"He who accepts evil without protesting against it is really cooperating with it." ---- MLK I'm going to have a hard time excusing guys who are virtually irreplaceable. Guys who would have every team in baseball clamoring for their services if they protested. Bregman, Springer, Altuve, Correa, Cole, Verlander. No one protested in a way that shows a sinew of real moral courage. Not one. It won't happen, but I'd like just one reporter-just one- to corner Marwin Gonzales and ask the questions. "Marwin, by all the evidence, you took part in sign-stealing in 2017 and benefitted from your cheating to the serious detriment of your fellow major league ballplayers. Did you in fact cheat and harm other players in 2017?"
-
Twins Announce Non-Roster Spring Training Invites
Sawyer is a non-roster invitee to the NYY camp, along with Zack Granite.
-
Is Marwin Gonzalez a lock to make the roster?
Frankly, I don't think most of these professional athletes are even capable of some type of moral outrage, even when a fellow player's cheating has directly harmed them, like Pineda's cheating most certainly did. It speaks volumes that a team could implement a systematic scheme known to each and every player to cheat their fellow players in as direct a manner as the Asterisks did in 2017, and yet, the needle on not one single player's moral compass spun out of control? Pathetic. As I recall, there were photos leading up to the postseason game last year where Marwin Gonzales held up a sign intended to let Pineda know that he was with the team in spirit. Such a caring and terrific team player, right? I mean, how ironic is THAT? A coincidence? Or was it a form of empathy?
-
Is Marwin Gonzalez a lock to make the roster?
I don't know what Falvey is contemplating, but if I were him, I'd be looking at both Cave and Gonzales as players who could possibly fetch a worthwhile return and who both are surplus/redundant. I'd at least be thinking about adding low minors talent and letting Wade, Rooker, Gordon, Raley, Blankenhorn, and Astudillo fight for the spots. I can't help thinking about the fact that Luis Gil, the price we paid for Cave, became NYY's 4th-ranked prospect eventually. That's smart, aggressive asset management.
- Report: Twins to Sign RHP Jhoulys Chacin to Minor League Contract
-
12 years ago today
Wait a second, back up. You guys are looking at this all wrong. Jared Camp for Johan Santana. Jared Camp gave us Johan, and Gomez, and Guerra, and Humber, and Mulvey, and Hardy, and Jacobson, and Hoey, and Rauch. I rest my case, your honor.
-
ESPN Insider - Lineup Rankings
If I was to read this article, I'd send ESPN a bill.
-
ESPN Insider - Lineup Rankings
That and the loss of Jason Castro.
-
Marwin Gonzalez, the Twins, and How the Astros Cheated Minnesota
My personal wish is that every time the Astros go on the road, the home team situates the team mascot on top of the home dugout during the top of the order, and when the home team pitcher goes into the windup, the mascot gives the signal for the fans to yell "BANG BANG" in unison. Until the league makes them stop, because, you know, that's cheating.
-
Twins Trade Ryne Harper to Nationals for minor league pitcher
True, and yet people might be shocked to learn that 36 former Twins pitchers made at least one appearance on the mound in the majors for another team in 2019. Most of these guys (not all) were pushed aside because we had better options here, and most of the pitchers we let go performed at below replacement levels for their new club. I mean, Oliver Drake stands out in this group. I just want this FO to do a better job than the last of squeezing something out of the tube more often. The old regime let Swarzak walk in FA, got nothing for Neshek and Rosario, etc. The new guys have screwed up too (Nick Anderson), but at least they're occasionally getting a long shot prospect (Harper) or a hundred dollar bill (Magill) more often than before.
-
Twins Trade Ryne Harper to Nationals for minor league pitcher
Towards the end of FG's ZIPs projections, they mentioned Harper among a handful of pitchers who might possibly help the team in 2020. From that, I concluded that maybe we were being a tad unkind towards Harper and that his value might be higher than we think. But I think an "interesting" 9th rounder for a guy we DFA'd is a really good result, something I'm happy to see from this FO after years of frustration with the old FO letting the fringe guys go for nothing over and over. Who knows, but my guess is that this guy's upside is Sean Poppen and his downside is Tyler Beardsley, who quickly enough changed professions.
-
What Can The Twins Do With Marwin Gonzalez?
I wouldn't be at all opposed to seeing him moved at the deadline for a low minors prospect if they have a versatile replacement (Blankenhorn?) to take his place.
-
2020 Baseball America Top 100 Prospects
While MLB may be underrating one or more of Balazovic, Duran, and Graterol compared to a couple other publications (FanGraphs has all three at a lofty 50 FV), I think it's also important to realize that there are a ton of really good pitching prospects out there at this time. I'm far from an expert observer, but my sense is that the Twins have a decent but not great comparative advantage when it comes to premium pitching talent, maybe a bit above average. In the AL Central alone, there may be as many as 10 pitching prospects in the other systems who are as good or better than any of these three. CWS and DET probably have superior pipelines nowadays, and KCR isn't that far behind, and all of those clubs will pick before we do in the 2020 draft, which is supposed to be exceptional in terms of both first half of the first round talent and overall depth.
-
Ex-Twins in 2020
I miss Tim Melville.