Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

bird

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bird

  1. Five games and 5.1 innings for the Nats so far, 3 hits allowed, no runs, and a win under his belt. Thanks for asking.
  2. Credit to the Pro Scouting department for both Wisler and Alcala, who has now out-performed Ryan Pressly of the hated Houston Astros. Hope Pressly recovers from his sore elbow, but I also really hope Houston is so bad they have to use Fernando Rodney, who they just signed.
  3. With Brandon Kintzler as his opener and Lewin Diaz batting cleanup?
  4. Encouraging choice.
  5. Wish you were right in your assessment. However, my sense is that maybe even the most charitable view of them here on TD may be underestimating this club, maybe more than many might be overestimating the Twins, especially when it comes to a raw comparison of talent and a guess about who is ready to produce and who might break out or digress. Pitching appears to be the critical differentiator, as Nick points out. But even here, I wonder why some think the gap is so huge. Aside from Berrios/Giolito, at best an even match, I can buy us having a huge advantage when we compare Keuchel and Gio to Hill, Homer, and Pinedo, and they don't have a Maeda or an Odorizzi. So we have an advantage in both injury insurance and talent. Plus, we match up alright, I think, in a comparison of Lopez, Cease, and Rodon, with Dobnak, Thorpe, and Smeltzer. Next year, things might move in their direction, as I think Kopech is in a different class than Duran or Balasovic. But my point is, given their decent but thin bullpen, they may be capable of hanging in there if they get more than we expect out of the vets, or more importantly out of Cease, Lopez, or even Rodon, all previously well-regarded talents. Unlikely, but over 60 games, a bunch of things could break wrong for our club and break right for theirs. But I think it's the position players that people are sleeping on. Why would one think that Robert won't step in and be more impactful than, say, Larnach or Kirilloff would be, let alone Buxton? Why won't Madrigal step in and be similar in impact to Arraez? Is Mazara that much worse than Rosario? Could Grandal be as important an addition as Donaldson? Are Jiminez and Moncada less likely to break out than Sano and Buxton? We'd rather have 40-year old Cruz, but both Encarnacion and Abreu appear to have something left in the tank. Even Anderson and Polanco can be thought of in the same tier. So, both teams are gonna have fearsome lineups and some questionable defense. While I personally still give the Twins the edge, I just wouldn't be at all shocked if both the Twins and Cleveland are looking up in this sprint season.
  6. Man alive, this organization is in complete shambles. I'll be surprised, even in this sprint season, if they even keep up with Detroit record-wise. The really bad news for them is how utterly hopeless things look, even longer-term. Even their three best starting pitching prospects probably slot in there with Duran and Balazovic, or maybe worse. None are MLB-ready. And half their lineup will be easy outs. Even if, somehow, Merrifield, Soler, Perez, and Mondesi all have an injury-free monster 60 games, this club is in deep doo-doo.
  7. If Gardy had, or has, his way, the Tigers will rush along its group of elite pitching prospects. It would not be at all surprising to see Boyd and Fulmer followed in the rotation by Mize, Manning, and Skubal, all of whom are or might be more highly regarded than, say, Thorpe or Balazovic. They also have Faedo and Burrows close to the majors, and a couple of bullpen arms as well. Although they'll still be pathetic on offense most likely, they could be at least a little better if Daz Cameron and Paredes make the lineup. So I agree with others who think the Tigers might be a tougher opponent than we'd like. That said, I would be disappointed if the Twins lost more than four games to them. Winning the division is not necessarily going be a cakewalk, given that Detroit represents the easiest division challenge.
  8. Clear evidence that there IS a benevolent higher power, no?
  9. Yeah, I wonder if the plans they have on tap down in Ft. Myers won't be more efficacious than we're imagining.
  10. From my perspective, I'd probably regard Cavaco, Thorpe and Sabato as slightly more likely than either Celestino or Jeffers to eventually capture roster spots and have long careers in MLB. Why? Simply because, in the case of Cavaco and Sabato, they were prized prospects by the Twins, and these first round position guys usually make it. Thorpe has shown glimpses already. The fact that Cavaco and Sabato haven't shown ME anything couldn't possibly be more irrelevant. Every one of these prospects naturally has to overcome unanswered questions. Jeffers' defense, Thorpe's command, Cavaco's bat, Sabato's glove, Celestino's next step... Not a bad 6-10.
  11. Certainly the organization would like these prospects to be playing games here in June. However, I'm not sure we have an accurate depiction of what's happening. So much of what takes place is outside of the lines of minor league games. The FanGraphs interview with Matt Canterino, IMO, is highly instructive. https://blogs.fangraphs.com/a-conversation-with-minnesota-twins-2019-second-rounder-matt-canterino/ Whether some of these guys got tons of innings or not, I think it's reasonable for us to assume each of them got plenty of development attention and still are despite the incredible obstacles.
  12. I get your concerns, but have a couple of thoughts. First, Falvey has already departed from Ryan's past history of over-valuing and hoarding prospects. He parted with high draft picks and a Top 5 prospect in the Donaldson/Maeda transactions for example, and they've articulated clearly that trading prospects is something they're going to do. They've traded several other highly-regarded prospects, too. Second, my guess is that they don't believe they need a half dozen positionally unlimited players on the roster. Maybe they'd prefer that a couple of these top guys were more skilled defensively, that's valid, but i question how much of a concern that is at this point. Larnach, Kirilloff, and Jeffers may not be great defenders, and aren't veratile, but they aren't slouches either. Rooker? Yeah... It would be fun to run an exercise based on an assumption we're all still TD pals in 2025. Pick your favorite available pitching prospect, and then your next two fallback pitching prospects. You'll have a huge advantage of ignoring all the price tag stuff. For example, you might pick Cole Wilcox, who fell due to bonus demands, demands which would have prevented the Twins from considering over-slot prospects Raya and Rosario most likely. Let's see how Sabata stacks up in five years against those three choices. My guess is that one out of the three fares better. And maybe we don't care about that too much because Rosario or Raya are the real deal. So, like you, I would like another Berrios signing every year. It will be interesting to see if Falvey is as adept at developing elite pitching as some think he will be. Deliberations continue.
  13. As a point of reference, like 2020, the 2015 draft class was supposed to be exceptionally strong pitching-wise (Brady Aiken, Dillon Tate, many others). Of the first 42 picks, 18 were pitchers. So far, 2 of 18 have produced 1 WAR or better, and very few still are thought to be likely to come through. (Although the 2 that did, #24 Buehler and #28 Soroka, have come through big time.) Bottom line is the failure rate on pitchers is so vastly higher than with position players that there is logic to taking your chances with later round pitching prospects. I mean, Cody Stashak #380, round 13 from 2015, is probably going to produce more than all but a half dozen pitchers from that entire 40 round draft. Andrew Vasquez, #950, round 32, got 9 games with the team in 2018 before injuries derailed him. So I think the Sabato selection is partly a function of a conviction that Falvey has that the talent differential diminishes quickly after a handful of guys and development capability is the secret sauce. That, and they must be in love with Sabato's potential.
  14. And it's always been a reasonable question, Mike. The answer is complicated, IMO. Because we have to reconcile that there were about 6 available pitching prospects in the first round of this 2020 draft who have similar talent, and 2 of the 6 will likely end up having equal or better MLB careers than Sabato. But 4 of them will likely peter out. The answer to your question involves the question of "which 2" will it be. And in this area of the draft, even the successful ones are mostly mid rotation guys, at best Kyle Gibson types, and my theory is Falvey believes the chances of finding and developing that kind of pitcher doesn't diminish that much in rounds 6-10. In this draft, there won't be 10 first round pitchers worth much, and 10 pitchers had already been selected prior to pick #27. Evidence of that belief comes from the fact that they loaded up on college pitchers in recent drafts, tons of them, playing the numbers game you've alluded to be a necessary tactic. The other things that come into play are that the organization can certainly horse-swap or sign FA pitching talent, Odorizzi and Maeda being recent examples. Plus we need to look no further than Randy Dobnak or Devin Smeltzer to catch on to the reality that Falvey is banking on development prowess. Will that work? FanGraph's interview with Matt Canterino is enlightening and encouraging. So it's not as if failing to draft pitching "early" in Rule 4 is some sort of death knell.
  15. Not sure how you drew this conclusion, but it seems premature and overly bleak. One could as readily adopt the opposite stance and conclude we just drafted the next Marwin Gonzales.
  16. I'm not sure the author mentioning Willie Calhoun means he thinks Alerick's ceiling is similar. Calhoun plays the field like he's wearing Grandma's oven mitts. Alerick may be no better than mediocre defensively at a handful of positions, but he played CF and wasn't dreadful. Alerick was picked #59, Calhoun was a #132 pick. In that 2015 draft in the 2nd round ( picks #43-75 ) only 2 of the 13 position players in that range have produced WAR in MLB, so it's advisable to temper both expectations AND CRITICISM regarding the specific selection. Draft strategy is open game though. Maybe our #80 pick from that draft, Travis Blankenhorn, would be a fairly good weather vane for what to expect. But OTOH, we can dream a little, right? Who knows?
  17. The remarkable thing about this is that the Yankees broke the cap and spent north of $30M (!!) on IFA prospects during their 2014-15 spree, 8 of them to 7-figure bonuses. These prospects should have emerged by now. They have exactly one of those prospects among their Top 30, and that guy was signed for less than Polanco got. That's 20+ signings to get a guy who ranks right up there with Luis Gil in their system. Sweet justice.
  18. If that was the comment, a concern that a medical condition MIGHT, repeat MIGHT derail Gordon's career, fine. The commenter, and all the rest of us, have no idea at all about the cause of his medical condition. It's just plain wrong to speculate that Gordon is irresponsible about his "lifestyle" and diet. It brings us full circle to those who concluded he lacked dedication because he's a wannabe rap star. While it's not beyond the realm of possibility that he can control his own fate better, it's uncharitable to conclude that. Let's let the beat writers tell us what's going on. They're all over it as usual.
  19. Yeah, I think the Law ranking reflects this. My guess is he'll be the low person as far as ranking the overall system, but only by a few slots. We should remember that he's not as excited about a number of our top guys compared to others: Lewis, Larnach, Balazovic, Duran, and Jeffers for sure. We could really use some exciting breakout seasons, maybe especially from some IFA prospects like Urbina, Severino, Javier, Celestino, Rijo, Alcala, Rodriguez...much more hope than expectation however. But yeah, there are so many hope and prayer guys in the system, so we're bound to have a few guys drawing the attention of the pundits.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.