Everything posted by bird
-
State of the Twins Farm System - 6 Years Into Falvey's Reign.
The last few comments have been insightful, and seem to share a view that perhaps things are better if we take a harder and more nuanced look at things. My belief is that one cannot make a proper assessment of the quality of the draft and development process without taking a combined look at the MLB and MiLB talent. Three primary reasons: 1) recent graduations making contributions to the big club; 2) Acquisitions to the club using the MilB talent; and 3) paying consideration to the injury situation. I'm a huge believer in maintaining some "talent balance" between one's MLB and MiLB talent pools. Why? Because I believe the ONLY way, these days, to outflank the competiton on a sustainable basis is to trade a lot, to trade surpluses to solve shortfalls, and to "win" those trades fairly consistently. Personally, I like to look at "rankings", for example ESPN's Power Rankings for MLB, or systems rankings from Fangraphs and Keith Law (not MLB please). My conviction is that if either ranking falls below the median on a consistent (3 years?) basis, you're gonna be in deep doo doo. Things need to have some cyclicality, in that sometimes, you're trading surplus capital from MiLB to augment MLB, and sometimes the opposite, and if you have good quality in both, you can do some of each. An example from this trade deadline is that Fangraphs viewed the Twins as having the second best results in terms of "improving their postseason chances, and they did that without losing a singlr prospect with a FV of more than 40+. CWS, by contrast, did nothing. Why? Because they HAVE nothing to trade in their MiLB system. They have a total of seven (7!) prospects with a 40+ FV or better, and none above 45+. Two last points. To make a fair assessment, we need to look at things relative to other organizations (I use the AL Central because , well...) And we have to account for advantages in the draft order over whatever period we're studying. The pundits are biased in favor of future all-star types when they grade farm systems. They greatly underrate depth. So far in 2022, other contending teams in the AL Central have had three or four members of their rotations give them 19 starts or more. The Twins have zero, and the Twins starters with the most starts are Bundy and Archer. So why are they still leading the division? Greater depth. In every day players (Cave, Contreras, Palacios, Beckham), in Injury replacement starters (Smeltzer, Winder, Sands, Sanchez), and even RP's (Megill, Cotton, Cano, Moran)< to name just a few examples. Detroit, Chicago, and even Cleveland cannot match this. Sorry for the length. In summary, I think the system is in better shape than most people think.
-
Once a Glaring Weakness, Twins' Bullpen Is Now a Clear Strength
And now add Alcala. Invincible.
- Prospect Retrospective: Caleb Hamilton
-
Twins Thrilled with Draft's First Night
Mack and Bechtold, to name a couple of catcher conversions still playing. Others will know for sure, but was Caleb Hamilton a conversion to catcher too. He just debuted with the big club as an injury replacement.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Chicago White Sox 7/14 6:4O PM
Oh, and Les Straker cuz dumb luck.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Chicago White Sox 7/14 6:4O PM
Joe Mauer will try.
-
Is Reusse still relevant?
Concur. He has more humanity in his crabby fingers than the rest of the town's sports writing crowd would be able to muster up collectively. He cares about a lot of things, but he doesn't much care what you or I think of him.
-
Decision Looms on First Round Pick
I strongly disagree with an assertion that Gordon is either so invaluable that the FO would entertain a DFA of him, or that his trade value has "bottomed out". I think the opposite is closer to the truth. I mean, think about this: Cave was a slightly below league-average 4th OF last year (yes, I realize he's a favorite whipping boy). This year, we've had THREE 4th OF's emerge who are all at least arguably above league average in Celestino, Gordon, and Garlick. Let's assume for a moment these things: 1) the FO has confidence that Buxton, Kepler, Larnach, and Kiriloff will all be 100+ OPS guys and adequate OF starters; 2) the FO thinks Lewis can become a high-octane version of Whit Merrifield, and become that player immediately. If that's the case, then one, or even two, of Garlick, Gordon, and Celestino is immediately a surplus asset, eligible to be dangled at the deadline, hopefully IMO for low minors talent. If I'm calling the shots, I'm seeking a stupid overpay for one of these players. And if I'm wildly enthusiastic about Austin Martin or Will Holland emerging in a hurry as the next Nick Gordon? I take my chances and fetch a tasty return for two of these guys IF the opportunity arises. Because you'd still have one of them, plus Lewis, and if the injury bug hits, a short period with Cave or Contreras is tolerable. Afterthought: Arraez can fumble around in LF for a game or two as well, and maybe Miranda if a slew of injuries happens.
-
3 Options for Royce Lewis When Carlos Correa Returns
I get all that, and have no argument about that at all. But I DO challenge the idea that others have made that Lewis is incapable of getting his previous skills up to snuff in a matter of a month or so, and even improving from there, and that therefore he needs more AAA development time. Even though he missed a ton of time, we have to remember that he's been taking his glove out to the SS position almost every day since he was, like, three. Plus, his athleticism is exceptional. Very very exceptional. Add to that what we hear about his considerable brainpower and "character".
-
Twins Minor League Report (5/10): Mighty Mussels No-Hitter!
Fangraphs describes the Twins as having "loads of catching depth" and lists six prospects among the honorable mentions, meaning not regarded highly enough to be among what they consider to be our top 40 prospects. That feels like good news to me. Three of those six prospects are mentioned in today's report: Alex Isola, Jeferson Morales, and Jair Camargo. Ironically perhaps, AAA C/1B and Hitter of the Day Caleb Hamilton didn't make FG's list. Loads of catching depth indeed.
-
Is the Twins Rotation for Real?
I've been guilty of being overly optimistic about pitching prospects in the past. I've come to realize that it's so much more a numbers game with pitchers because of the injury risks and the unpredictability regarding development. It's the sheer numbers of real prospects in the system, many on the cusp, that I find encouraging. I tend to look at things relative to other things, in this case, the other teams in the AL Central. Here's what I found: 2022 Fangraphs says the Twins have 7 pitching prospects with a fair value (FV) of at least 45 (plus non-pitchers Miranda, Martin, and Lewis). Three of those are on the big club now (Winder, Ryan, Duran). Additionally, lower value guys Sands and Moran are up. The other four are in AAA or AA (Canterino, SWR, Henriquez, Balazovic). Overall, there are a total of 16 pitching prospects on the list with FV's under 45, so there's impressive depth. That's 23 names. So keep that 7 number in your head. Here are the number of pitching prospects at 45 or better FV in the other systems: CLE 3 DET 4 (all AA and lower) CWS 0 (actually, CWS only has one prospect ranked as high as 45+, a 3B) KCR The 2022 summary isn't published yet, but based on 2021, it will come in at 3-4. Conclusion: Having 7 really promising prospects, three of which are already huge contributors on the big club, is a potentially significant advantage over the division rivals, especially in light of and every day lineup as strong as ours.
-
Is the Twins Rotation for Real?
This I'm sure sounds like heresy to some, but I for one would say both Rodon and Gausman were solid passes, as was Stroman. From a business standpoint AND even from a baseball standpoint, one who accepts the concept that there is an acceptable value/$ quotient that exempts a front office for passing on a player is likely to agree that passing on Gausman at $110M/$21M each and every year for 5 years, and passing on Rodon at $44M/$22M each of two years may have been prudent, especially Gausman. Why? Mainly because they most likely would have delayed any contributions from Ryan, Ober, Winder, Sands, and perhaps a couple others later in the season (Henriquez, Canterino, Balazovic?) with not as many extra wins as people might think. So, $43M in 2022 for Rodon and Gausman, perhaps resulting in an extra win or two in 2022 over, say, Ryan and Ober, who cost less than $2M, and perhaps most significantly, made making an aggressive play for Correa viable from a business AND baseball baseball standpoint. I expect one of Bundy or Archer to implode, BTW. But, like last year with Ryan and Ober, I also expect one or two starters from the minors to step up like they did.
-
Joe Ryan and Nick Gordon
Yeah, my guess is that Falvey is thinking, hey, this Gordon is an asset that is significantly more valuable now than he was a year ago. Whereas Baldelli is thinking, hey, Gordon may be able to help us eke out a win or two that we otherwise wouldn't get this season.
-
Joe Ryan and Nick Gordon
You might be right. But I must have flunked the eye test, because to me, he handled 1B rather admirably considering he probably hasn't even practiced over there fore more that a few sessions, and never had that magical coaching experience there with Tom Kelly. I was mostly impressed with his instincts.
-
Buxton Injury Update - "No Structural Damage", may need a week off, says Ken Rosenthal
Everything Is Broken by Bob Dylan
-
GAME THREAD: Twins vs Mariners, 4/11/22, 6:40pm CT
Concur, but understand the alternative logic. In this case, Correa hasn't exactly been a no-brainer in this situation at the moment. Personally, I think it was very slightly more likely to see a bad throw to the plate than to see a Correa clutch hit.
- 3 Things to Look for in Dylan Bundy's Twins' Debut
- 3 Things to Look for in Dylan Bundy's Twins' Debut
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Seattle, 4/9/22 @ 1:10pm CT
-
Twins sign Chris Archer, outright Lewis Thorpe
You're expressing a widely-held sentiment, and you may be right. However, there's a pretty good chance that you're pleasantly surprised, at least to a moderate extent. I say that based on the sheer number of MLB-ready (or very close) options for both the rotation and the pen. I mean, just two days ago, we saw three flamethrowers come in and strike out the last nine batters in a row with mid-nineties and better heat and some pretty decent secondary pitches, and these were not the front-runners for BP spots (yet). I say wait and see.
-
Twins sign Chris Archer, outright Lewis Thorpe
Yep. Whereas Door Dash might be a bit extreme, that young man might benefit from a little counseling.
-
Twins Bullpen Boost: Let Jhoan Duran Eat
Let's assume (I know, it's a weak assumption) that they start the year with a rotation of Gray, Bundy, Ryan, Ober, and an acquisition, and that Rogers, Duffy, Alcala, Thielbar, Cotton, and Smith are 6 of perhaps 8 BP guys. On paper, we all know that this group isn't going to inspire a lot of confidence among us rubes. I think we tend to remember the guys who disappoint (Thorpe, Smeltzer types) and we tend to forget the guys who surprise us (the Duffy, Ober, Rogers, and Ryan types). I'm not going to guess which prospects will be viewed as better-equipped to build up innings as starters and which prospects might benefit the team and themselves by getting mostly low-leverage experience as #7-8 guys in the pen. The idea of inserting Duran into the mix like Alcala was has appeal. It'll be fun to see what the field people do, given the reality that almost all of the starting prospects are likely to be subjected to innings limits. What gives me the most hope are the sheer numbers of both injury-replacement starting options and bullpen candidates. I think of Chi Chi, Winder, Balazovic, Duran,Strotman, Sands, and possibly before season end, SWR and Vallimont as possibilities. And if middling prospects like Ober and Ryan are successful, we should have hope that a couple more from this group could come in and have similar immediate success. The number of BP candidates, guys who are likely ready to roll if they're good enough, is impressive. Moran, Cano, Jax, Thorpe, Dobnak, Henriquez, and even Stashak and Smeltzer. We really only need a couple-three of these guys to step up. So personally, I'm not in agreement with the argument that we absolutely HAVE to add from the outside to have a very good year, but yes, I see the point that better, proven options is desirable. I'm just not going to panic if it doesn't happen. I believe this FO and its baseball people know what they're doing.
-
Is it too early to call Cavaco a bust?
Like you, Mike, I tend to think the takes from MLR and Dman and others reflect what many of us felt at the time. Frankly, any one of the next half-dozen selections would have given me more comfort. MLR described it as possibly the FO getting "cute". I describe my own nagging suspicion this way: I wonder if they're prone to occasional bouts of hubris that encourages them to get cute, like at the trade deadline a couple years back. I'm willing to withhold judgment on their drafts and on a few other questionable things, on the basis of some of the really positive moves they've made. As for Cavaco, I don't have an opinion, just a general observation about what I see as a deficiency in talk about prospects. I think there's a giant chasm between an athlete's theoretical or assumed tools and and a player's skills. To me, the bet with Cavaco, like it was with Buxton for example, is that his inferior skills eventually catch up to his presumably superior tools. But roight now, it's sure hard to see how his tools are superior to Stott or Corbin, or how Priester's or Zack Thompsons vastly superior skills won't compensate for any what they might lack in tools. I always feel a higher comfort level with prospects whose tools and skills aren't miles apart.
-
Did the Twins Miss Something With Jake Reed?
Last year, I spent 15 minutes and scanned the 40-man rosters of every team to count the number of former Twins out there on other teams. The number? 36. That's not a typo. And what struck me was that about 20 MLB teams had at least one former Twin. I don't think there were a half dozen of those players that you would have added to the Twin's 26-man at the expense of removing the player we had at the same position, pitchers included. And there probably were not more than 10 guys that you would have jettisoned someone on the 40-man to make room for them. What did I conclude from that? Well, almost nothing, other than that there sure are a lot of Harpers, Magills, and Granites floating around out there.
-
TD Top Twins Prospect Rankings (Post Draft and Trade Deadline): 1-5
Position players are a safer bet than pitchers given similar perceived ceilings. This is due to the increased injury risk, of course, but also because the performance volatility, year to year, is higher for pitchers. Don't ignore the reality that frontline starters can be acquired via trade, and they can be developed. I don't know the statistics, but my specualation is we could look at two groups: the first being a random sample of 1st round pitchers, and second, a group of the top current pitchers of the same quantity. I'd bet that the number of failures among the draftees would be about the same as the number of successful pitchers in the second group selected in the 3rd round or later. So, once again, we have a bunch of pitchers among our top ten prospects about which we're excited. (Note that none of them are 1st round draft choices). And once again, we'll probably see a higher failure or "disappointment" rate among the pitchers than the position players. So yeah, Mike, I think there's merit in selecting the position player. You once suggested Gausman might be a better bet than Buxton, and despite the incredibly bad misfortune endured by Buxton, no one would make that trade, right?