May should start in the rotation next season, but he's certainly shown his value in the pen. If need be, plug him back in the pen next year. They tried this with Alex Meyer but the pen hasn't seemed to get him going either. It doesn't work with everyone, obviously. Nolasco shouldn't be around next year and I'll bet Gibson is on the block this off season. Malone probably will be here, and possibly Pelfrey. So that makes the rotation Hughes, Santana, Malone, Pelfrey and May, with Duffey and Berrios as possibilities. That all changes if we're stuck with Nolasco, and either or both of Malone and Pelfrey go. TR has some pondering to do this off season.