Everything posted by howeda7
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
I wasn't big on them getting Kimbrel, I would have preferred Keuchel. But I still think the point stands that if you want a guy that bad, walking away over an extra year is odd and something they have to get over.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
He's not going to take a discount. You over-pay him for his arbitration years (since we have $40 million we're apparently not going to spend) to get him to give you a year or two of FA for a discount. You could probably get him for 5/$60 million right now which would buy out 3 years of arbitration. He gets ~$8 million more this year and takes less in 2024 which is apparently the year we care most about.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
Exactly. This FO always seems to draw the line on the extra year. They want MadBaum and have been talking about him for months but that 5th year is just an absolute deal breaker. They were so IN on Craig Kimbrel, but that extra year was a deal breaker. Why must we forever hamstring the current team worrying about 2024?
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
To the people saying "why would we want to be like the White Sox or Tigers?" they've both been to a World Series this century. The Tigers are in the mess their in because they went for it hard 2011-2013. But if I were a Tigers fan, I'd still be glad they did. They've managed the after-math poorly though.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
No one can truly "know" anything in this regard, but I'd be very surprised if he turned down an extra $15 million. We'll never know because we wouldn't even match the Arizona offer much less beat it.
-
Front Page: Winter Meetings Bring a Dose of Cold Reality for Twins
I'm tired of the "no one will come to MN" excuse. You could have had Keuchel with a competitive offer in June. You could probably have him now. You could have traded for Stroman or Minor at the deadline. All of these will probably require you to over-pay. Tough. Do it. Or admit that we can't ever compete and trade everyone within 2 years of FA.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
The tax thing is over-blown. It's never stopped the Cubs, White Sox or any CA team and they have higher taxes. 50% of your income is earned on the road. It's hurt the Blue Jays at times, but that's a combination of VERY high taxes and exchange rates at times. He wouldn't come here if our offer was equal to Arizona's. But if we'd offered 5/$100, he's probably a Twin.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
Only ~60% of his income would be earned in California and 15% still will be playing for the D-Backs.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
According Doogie (consider source I know) they didn't. They wouldn't go 5 years at all.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
Signing one starter does not "blow up future budgets". Yes you do have to pick your windows and go for it. The Rays are a fun franchise. So are the A's. They've also won zero World Series in the last 25 years.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
If it's true he absolutely wouldn't play here, then Falvey shouldn't have diddled around until he was about the only option left. I guess we'll go big at Ryu and Kuechel. But, I bet they don't want to play here either. No one will take the Twins $$. It's no good. But they tried and tried.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
I'm not sure how you're defining revenue level, but the idea that we can't compete with the White Sox and Tigers in FA is ridiculous. If what you're saying is true, why did we offer $100 to Darvish? Why did we offer $100 million to Wheeler? Can we play in FA or can't we? The fact that Ervin Santana is still the biggest FA contract we've ever given is pretty pathetic.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
This isn't the same as Joe Blow. His family doesn't have to move. He would be in Minneapolis 3 months per year and on the road 3 months per year. His family can live wherever they want.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
There is no indication that MadBaum said he wouldn't play here. Does he get us passed the Yankees alone? No. Let's say Berrios steps up into an ace. He wins game 1. Now we roll out MadBaum, Odo and Pineda in games 2-4. Does that give us a better shot to win 2 more than Odo, Pineda and Smeltzer? Yes.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
The only thing lamer than the "he wouldn't play here" excuse is the "Yeah well every other team passed on him too" excuse. That can literally apply to every FA ever. Give me a break.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
Why would you give Garret Cole 9 years. FA starters almost always require you to risk bad years at the end of them. That's just the way it is. If you have a window to win, you have to be willing to risk a bad contract or two 5-6 years from now. Otherwise you will never, ever play in FA and you will forever be the Little Team that could who gets steamrolled by the Yankees in the 1st round.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
Exactly. If the Twins offered him 5/$100, he'd be a Twin. No he probably wouldn't come here for equal offers. So you pony up a little more. He could fly his family in every week-end.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
Because they didn't think he was worth 5 years.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
In any one case that could be true. But the "no one wants to play here" blanket excuse is tired. The Brewers, White Sox and Co. all sign FA's to bigger contracts that we ever do. In this case, his agent said it wasn't the case, and Doogie says the Twins wouldn't go to 5 years. So we're flushing 2020 to worry about 2024. Again.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
I can't put this on the Pohlads. I guarantee they didn't tell Falvey to cut $20 million in payroll after a 100 win season with massive attendance increases.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
Doogie says they didn't even attempt to top the 5/$85 he got from the D-Backs.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
For those would rather "spend that money elsewhere" where are you going to spend it? We have a current payroll of $100 million and can allegedly spend $130-140 million. There aren't many places left to spend it.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
***regrets Googling Cleveland Steamer**
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
He would be our game 1 or game 2 starter.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
And I'm sure somewhere there was a metric that said Verlander was a shell of himself and only a fool would acquire that contract.