Everything posted by Alex
-
Berardino profiles Twins' mysterious stat guy
Gotta say the PP Twins articles have been excellent lately, and this was another one. I think that the Twins apparent ignorance is actually that. I do think they are keeping some things back as well. The small statistical department and some statements just seem too impossible to be made up and match what they do on the field. Rick Anderson did seem to be clueless about WAR in another article. Is that really possible?
-
Berardino: Mastroianni Out Awhile + My Twins Med Staff Rant
Probably a good point. I'd add, though that the Twins were very well aware that he would have only very limited use in at least the first week of the season, basically as a pinch runner and late game defensive sub. IMO, you just can't have a guy like that on the bench when you don't have another CF. A lot of people were asking why he wasn't DLed at that point. In fact, playing him actually continued to setback a possible return from the DL (though that proved moot). The roster management issue here isn't a phantom one, but you're right that Mastro shares some of the blame.
-
Article: Hicks Shaping Up As Bruno Success Story?
I was saying it after they traded Revere and Span, so it's not really hindsight. To the idea of people going insane if he weren't up, I'd say "So what?" If people are going to go nuts about a player not being in the starting lineup from AA based on spring training numbers, that's really their problem isn't it? The Twins didn't put them in a position where they could do it anyway, and he'd be up now anyway the way injuries played out.
-
Article: Hicks Shaping Up As Bruno Success Story?
I would have liked to see a better backup plan (and I was thinking of stashing someone in AAA), but you are right that they can probably sign one on the fly if needed. I don't disagree about the MI, but it's certainly looked far better so far and they have 4 players that can hold down those positions defensively adequately.
-
Article: Hicks Shaping Up As Bruno Success Story?
Hick's had a good year in AA. He wasn't "tearing it up." And, why are people still using spring training numbers? I wasn't against either trade, and you might be right that we might be able to find someone of the caliber I was talking about relatively easily (AAAA), but we are an injury away from that, or we'll probably be looking into it if Hicks's doesn't continue to improve.
-
Article: Hicks Shaping Up As Bruno Success Story?
Ludicrous? How about exaggerating the number that I actually suggested? I wasn't suggesting four or five. I suggested one, and when I said similar to Mastro, I was implying a CF on the bubble, but one who could at least play a suitable backup, especially with the range we are lacking out there.
-
Article: Hicks Shaping Up As Bruno Success Story?
I agree that I like almost everything Nick writes, even though I don't always agree with him. But I think to say the criticism is unfair is a bit harsh. I mean, if someone wrote the opposite about Hicks after three games we'd be crying small sample size, too. (In fact, Nick is in the opposite side of the Correia thread). Throw in the inherent bias (we know Nick was pulling pretty hard for them to start Hicks) and I think the pushback isn't surprising. On the other hand, Nick's been honest of his criticism of Hicks (last night's called third strike), too, and some here are just focused being overly and continuously critical. I do hope he's right about Hicks, though.
-
Article: Hicks Shaping Up As Bruno Success Story?
An unknown from AA is not depth. Predicting that Hicks would succeed and that both would be healthy was a very high risk proposition and certainly far less likely than the reverse, that both would be relatively healthy and Hicks would perform as an adequate ML CF. Arcia can't play CF regularly.
-
Justin Morneau
Can't tell if this is serious, Badsmerf.... When Morneau was struggling, he was opening up early (credit: Parker's video analysis), making it nearly impossible to hit the outside pitch. I feel like I've seen him doing the same thing recently on the ABs I've seen, though I haven't broken it down in slow motion or seen every AB he's taken.
-
Blylevenisms
I think that Twins fans are ready and deserving of a more intellectually stimulating broadcast. *They are not the broadcasters we need, nor the broadcasters we deserve right now.
-
Article: Hicks Shaping Up As Bruno Success Story?
Right -- having people who play CF is not the same thing as having a CF. I think the Twins should have been looking for a second option like Mastro, mostly because if Hicks didn't/doesn't work out, you really don't have anyone behind him and you don't want Hicks or Benson getting ABs everyday without hurting the team as much as possible. Who is our current backup CF even?
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Marlins, 4/23 - 7:10pm
Major league level veteran hitter!
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Marlins, 4/23 - 7:10pm
At some point, teams will need to see if Hicks can actually hit like Bonds before they keep pitching around him like Bonds, right?
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Marlins, 4/23 - 7:10pm
Yeah, I didn't catch it on at-bat, but the side angle looked like it came right at the knees at the front of the zone and then dropped.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Marlins, 4/23 - 7:10pm
Hicks is looking better, but that pitch was too close to let go.
-
Blylevenisms
Had both these in the Arcia HR.
-
Fun With Numbers
Just an update on Hicks vs. The Weather. Hicks tied this one up, but the weather answered back within just 24 hours to regain a 4-3 lead. Hicks might get two games tomorrow to make up the difference. This is edge of the seat kind of stuff.
-
Article: Hicks Shaping Up As Bruno Success Story?
While I think this article is a bit premature and never thought we should have moved Hicks up, for him to be hitting close to .200 by the end of two weeks, he would need to hit around .500. I'd settle for him putting up decent numbers (like he put up in AA) to keep the experiment going.
-
Mackey: Sano Could Hold His Own in the Majors Right Now
Absolutely agree, and that was my point -- Plouffe will never be a Hardy type.
-
Mackey: Sano Could Hold His Own in the Majors Right Now
Most teams in the league would be happy with a Hardy-type. He's a far better SS than people give him credit for and he can hit.
-
Fun With Numbers
The Twins have more postponed games than Hicks has hits.
-
Wolfson: DFA'd Borbon a possibility
You mean like say, a struggling CF who you just called up from AA and looks overmatched, a 4th OF type CF who just went on the DL, and nothing else in the cupboard?
-
An amazingly parallel story....
Found this via Twitter and Hardball Talk's Craig Calceterra. The Embarrassing History of Pete Abraham & JBJ | Fire Brand of the American League While it centers around one writer's coverage of a player it actually is an amazing mirror to the story of a player here in Minnesota. You could almost interchange the Twins' player and it would read the same.
-
Article: Twins Being Crushed by Constant Contact
If Batman were into baseball he'd be....Bill James...
-
Article: Twins Being Crushed by Constant Contact
Okay, but I think the rest of the post still stands and it is why you are getting a lot of blowback on this thread. It would literally take less than a minute to look up the stats that have been discussed here (as others have pointed out).