Everything posted by Alex
-
What should Jamey Carroll's role be?
The answer to #1 is Carroll. I think the answer to #2 is none of the above. The MI needs to be the next issue they address, imo, while continuing to improve starting rotation, but at least there's something in the minors with regard to starters.
-
What should Jamey Carroll's role be?
My hunch is that none of the Twin's current MI will be starting anywhere in two years, and if one of them is still consistently in the majors four years from now, they should out themselves fortunate. I hope I'm wrong about Dozier, or heck, all of them, but these guys have a body of work that is just not impressive and not one of them has a sure starting spot in what is one of the worst MI in the league. It's really amazing when you think about it. I think Carroll is the best and could start this year, but for reasons other posters mentioned, he should probably be playing as a utility player.
-
Murphy: On Kevin Correia
Fangraphs has him as 6th highest (not good) of 128 pitchers (qualified) in ERA- at 127 for 2010-12. At #1 and #2, Nick Blackburn and Jason Marquis....
-
Article: Gleeman and the Geek Episode 81: Spring Training Questions
Wimmers threw one game at AA.... Thoughts on Anthony Slama? Any chance he ends up in this bullpen or is he doomed to AAA Purgatory?
-
Miller: Morneau's Forecast with Twins: Cloudy
If he has an MVP type season, the Twins won't be able to offer him the money to stay and would probably be wise not to. Frankly, I don't see a scenario where Morneau stays with the Twins, even though I'd love it if he did. If he hits well, he'll be too expensive. If he doesn't hit well, there'd be no reason to sign him.
-
Neal: Who Pitchers On Opening Day?
I think it's a relatively telling state that the worst pitching staff in the league has one pitcher go down and has no clear answer to this question despite having a full offseason I've predicted Worley, but I could see the Twins giving it to someone like Correia.
-
Re: Mauer's Contract
The flaw in this argument is that the Twins actually have the money to pay two hypothetical starters $10M this year AND had it last year but chose not to. They will also have that money over the next five years and more. So, Mauer's contract hasn't kept them from your hypothetical at all. They could, in fact, have had their cake and eat it, too with Ramos, Mauer, and two $10M dollar pitchers. Mauer's salary isn't what's keeping them from being competitive.
-
Murphy: Inteview with Terry Ryan
Sure but you've narrowed your field considerably, 43 pitchers wouldn't give every team in the league two starters. Additionally, it completely ignores young pitchers who are better than those. So again, it really tells us nothing about most pitchers in the league.
-
Murphy: Inteview with Terry Ryan
Right, I'm picking pitchers that all pitched a qualified number of innings. There are 88 of them. Their range of value and amount success is widely varying and does not really correlate to IP (except at the fringes, and there are even exceptions at the top end: Clayton Richards). Thus, how could it be the most important statistic when it doesn't even relate to how successful a pitcher was in THAT season? Cherry picking Diamond was an interesting choice. Diamond ranked 80th in IP, or the bottom 10%. Would you say 90% of the pitchers on the list were better than he was? Picking any other stat gives us a much better picture of his actual value and success. In WAR he ranked 45th. In ERA, he ranked 31st, xFIP: 42nd, K/9 86th, BB/9 4th, HR/9: 31st. So, his IP was only close in ranking him as a pitcher to his K/9, but everything else he was in the top half. So, if IP is actually the worst at showing you what kind of year he had, how can IP be the most important stat? I'd never advocate picking one stat, and you obviously have to consider IP when looking at stats to make sure they aren't flukes or small sample sizes, the same way you would with PA for hitters, as it gives context, but that is all. Again, except for the edges (Verlander, etc..), but it's a ridiculous stat to call the most important.
-
Murphy: Inteview with Terry Ryan
I'd encourage you to go to Fangraphs here: Major League Leaderboards » 2012 » Pitchers » Dashboard | FanGraphs Baseball You can play around with what stat you'd like to rank pitchers by, WAR, ERA, IP, xFIP, whatever. It's interesting to note, and not surprising that IP will correlate with what most of us consider good pitchers and bad pitchers at the extreme ends of the spectrum. However, for a massive number of pitchers, it doesn't correlate at all. Jarrod Hudson had a 3.47 ERA but only threw 187 IP, putting him in the bottom 3rd of the majors of qualified pitchers in IP. There are a ton of pitchers like this: Samardzjja, Lynn, Hellickson, Moore, Hudson... How can IP be the most important stat if there are pitchers like this in the bottom of the league in IP? Meanwhile Clayton Richard and Justin Masterson threw over 200 IP. I'd take any of the pitchers I named above over them for last season's performance. How can that be considered if IP is the most important stat?
-
Murphy: Inteview with Terry Ryan
Heh, I suppose that's true, that not pitching a lot of innings probably means that, for whatever reason (injury or performance) a pitcher won't likely pitch "a lot" in the future (whatever that number means), but it does seem like a guy is durable until he isn't as you point out.
-
Murphy: Inteview with Terry Ryan
Ok, serious question. Is pitching a lot of innings is a predictor of being durable and pitching a lot of innings in the future?
-
Murphy: Inteview with Terry Ryan
I actually think it's the opposite. If he hits better in general, the driving in runs thing will happen more often. Or, if he were to come up more often with runners on base, that would help, too.
-
Murphy: Inteview with Terry Ryan
I think that's a fair point and probably is what he meant (and why I asked), it's just that references to that I hear from the front office are almost always behind what a lot of other teams are doing in terms of statistics. I'd like to find something that's heading that direction in their comments, I guess.
-
Murphy: Inteview with Terry Ryan
I probably read too much into things, but Ryan's focus on Morneau driving in runs does not do much to persuade me they've moved beyond antiquated stats.
-
Murphy: Inteview with Terry Ryan
Do you mean the fact that they value durability over talent is a huge problem?
-
Neal: Diamond Unlikely to be Ready for Opening Day
Not Worley?
-
FSN: Worley Looking Forward To Target Field
All good points (and why I agreed with the post that single season doesn't tell you much and cited Willingham and Plouffe); however, to be fair, I read your initial posts the same way as ashburyjohn.
-
FSN: Worley Looking Forward To Target Field
Thank you. It doesn't mean it's perfect, but people did seem to have a big misunderstanding of how it is calculated. One season isn't a great sample size for a few reasons (Josh Willingham and Trevor Plouffe, for example, are much better at Target Field) but it's more well thought out than simply comparing pitching staffs.
-
Sinker: Why The Twins Will Stink
You reminded me of how I felt this time last season. And while I was still frustrated they cut payroll, I was far more hopeful than I am this season. The Twins had signed a two excellent hitters, a middle infielder who at least be solid, and Morneau and Mauer likely had to be more productive than they were the previous year. The pitching staff wasn't a big change, but Baker would be back in the rotation and hopefully Liriano could figure things out. Their back end of the rotation signing wasn't all that exciting but it was just the 5th starter. Capps was a frustration on many levels, but there was a back-up plan. Of course, we all know how the starting pitching went, but I had far more hope prior to last season than I do this, even though the team is bound to improve; it's sort of by default.
-
Mason: Correia expects to eat up innings for the Twins
Other than in recent interviews where Dave St. Peter pretty clearly stated that Ryan has plenty more freedom to spend money than he has this offseason.
-
Mason: Correia expects to eat up innings for the Twins
When he was signed I noted that he has a tendency to avoid the balk.
-
Article: Terry Ryan Thinks Brian Dozier Was Rushed In '12
To be clear, I wasn't referring to this year but last year, clearly a wasted year of both development and evaluation for Dozier because he was way above his skill level for developmental purpose. In fact, you could see by the end of the season it had clearly messed with his confidence and he mentioned recently it also hurt his mechanics. So, just brining someone up doesn't tell you what kind of player he is going to be or could, especially if the timing is wrong. I'd agree, though, that he probably needs to be back in the majors this year, but I think it's too late. Had he played in the minors last year, I think you'd see a better Dozier this spring.
-
Terry Ryan said this ballpark [Target Field] has not settled in...
Can someone explain what effect this would have or why there's even a theory that it would? I'm being serious here. Also, does it somehow negatively affect our pitching as well and what is Josh Willingham's super power to negate the effect?
-
2015=Bright
You didn't, though. Also, your opener was that winning teams are sometimes about chemistry and saberstats, though. The 1991 crushed the stats, and especially excelled in "saberstats." As to your last point, if the team is competitive (near .500) I think most of us will be happy to say we were wrong about the staff itself, but yes, we'll probably point out that we were right in that we should have gone after better pitchers, middle infield, or whatever with the available cash, especially if a guy like Marcum is healthy and has a great year. If we're competitive but Correia is the weak link, Ryan will definitely have painted himself into a corner. I guess my return question is what if the staff, besides Worley is worse than expected (like if Diamond regresses)? What if the lineup is worse (as unlikely as I think that is)? What then? Will those of you who championed/put faith in Ryan's moves say he made some mistakes or will you, like Phil Mackey, fall back on "The Twins were never going to win a division title anyway" as an excuse for a pathetic offseason (edit: as far as improving the major league club is concerned)?