Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Alex

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Alex

  1. Agreed, so maybe I wasn't clear. I was pointing out what I think is a key flaw in the study in it's conclusion to discount strikeouts as a evaluative tool. In terms of single outcomes, that's a pretty significant correlation.
  2. Let me first say that I appreciate any dive of this depth into statistics. It makes for an interesting read and an interesting discussion. I just read through both. However, there are many flaws in tying the correlations found in this study to value in players. First, it's evaluating multi-outcome measurements against single outcome results. The more outcomes you add to a statistic, the higher your correlation will be by default. OPS, for example, measures six possible outcomes (BB, 1B, 2B, 3B, HR and outs by omission - including strikeouts). Is it any surprise that it correlates better than any other statistic or outcome when it includes all of them? Hits/9 and average includes four-five outcomes (1B, 2B, 3B, HR, and the fifth again being outs) , which is pretty good, but people "savage" it (from your other response) because it does not include a key element that players can do to help their team win and add value. It's why WHIP works so well here because it essentially is a catch-all for everything -- of course would correlate. If you're giving up a ton of hits and walks per 3 outs, you're going to be in trouble. Contrast that with K, HR, and BB, which measure a single outcome each. Assigning value as you do here to a single outcome based solely on correlation is dangerous. Your placement of 3Bs proves that. Is a 3B really that worthless? Sure it doesn't correlate to a win, but to argue that it is less valuable an event than a 2B would be preposterous, right? (This is why Tom Tango's work is so valuable) So, in looking at evaluating a pitcher, we should be asking what tools we have, and which are predictive. Can we predict H/9 for pitchers? K's? Do K's correlate with H/9? If you're looking to criticize people for valuing strikeouts in pitchers because they don't correlate as well as you'd like to runs p/game, what other stats, along with HR and BB should we be using?
  3. Your quote and response to my post is confusing. I was saying that Gardy may have been upset about more than just the flip for those that are saying he overreacted to that. -- What I find frustrating about all of this (his defense as a whole) as a fan of the Twins is that we were assured that Hick's was ready defensively even if he struggled at the plate. So far, that hasn't been the case via statistics or eye test.
  4. C'mon, the guy is a pro athlete. He can at least jog back to his position, even Randy Moss does that on occasion. All I can tell you is that Gladden was pretty upset about that aspect of it, so there might have been something to it. I don't know for sure, I'm just pointing out that everyone is focusing on what they saw on TV when there might have been more to it.
  5. As I said in the game thread, on the radio, Gladden added that even after the catch, Hicks stalled the game by walking out to CF and that everything was waiting on him. So, there might have been more to it than just the flip.
  6. Gladden said that Hicks was also slow back to CF, walking back, and that everything had to wait for him. Gladden seemed pretty hot, too, more because of that than the catch.
  7. I'm starting to wonder if he made a deal at the crossroads... Even if he ranks the rest of the season, I never thought we'd get five good games from him like this.
  8. Yeah, I get that. You can have the computer manage a lot of things for you to start and then add in things you'd like to do slowly. If you get back into it, I can certainly give you some ideas if you need them. As far as making it more challenging, I've found that the more realistic you make the game the more challenging it becomes. For example, make scouts less reliable and/or do a "stats" only type of league.
  9. Online play offers the same kinds of experiences, too, but if you like Mogul, there's nothing wrong with that either.
  10. Great game. As Snepp hints, there is probably a lot more flexibility, depth, and customization than in Mogul.
  11. Sorta like the Rangers are doing. Seriously looking like a Redbox movie may have been the way to go tonight.
  12. Are these statements speculation or do you have some sort of expertise and facts here? I'd think a guy like Mastro, who can play 3 OF positions actually isn't terrible at the plate and can steal bases in the majors like it's little league can have a decently career (especially if he approaches league average for OBP) . Even is Buxton, Hicks, and Arcia are all playing in the Twins OF 2-3 years from now Mastro will be a nice, affordable backup under team control.
  13. Wasn't ripping you, just adding on. Absolutely it must be odd for Plouffe.
  14. Honestly it was a great breakdown with how he ranks among other hitters as well as catchers. The argument against his greatness that people have about him not playing enough catcher and having to switch positions eventually have been put to rest.
  15. Grandpa is compact, in great shape, and runs like Sonic the Hedgehog.
  16. Well done. I've had the same impression as you, watching a player that deserves to be immortalized, but love the numbers perspective.
  17. No, there was another one a couple games back.
  18. Worley looks frustrated with himself out there. Nice play to end the inning, though.
  19. Teams did for decades. Why is it surprising that extremely scout-heavy organization (with a rep for doing it well) that rarely hires people from the outside would be one of the last teams adopt or consider these ideas?
  20. I'd argue that the Twins could help themselves in this regard. Until we see new evidence, the current evidence is all we have and most of it points in one direction. There's certainly been some encouraging steps this season.
  21. Thanks. You stated this far more clearly than I did.
  22. Listen, I'm not "picking" on him. I find it surprising he hadn't heard of it and it tells me that coaches (at least the Twins) live in much more of a bubble than I thought they did. I mean, he hadn't even heard of it, even when you consider last year's MVP discussion? I just find that fascinating that someone so close to baseball wouldn't have heard of it and it gives me a new perspective on what kinds of things they (or at least Rick Anderson) pays attention to.
  23. Should have clarified. I meant if you think he has no need to even "clutter" his mind with the idea of what has become a ubiquitous baseball concept even if I can see there is little value in him using it. I was, of course, referring to that article (thanks for linking it) when I referred to being unaware of WAR. That article is as encouraging as it is discouraging with regard to statistics. I was glad to see the use of Pitch FX (and that was actually document awhile ago) but disappointed to see the response to the WAR question and the high value of WHIP (as pointed out above, doesn't always correlate with a successful staff).
  24. If this is your belief, then you have a lower opinion of him than I do for my surprise at the fact that he called it "a new one" when asked about it.
  25. I wasn't arguing that, but to not know the term even? It would indicate living in a pretty closed bubble to me.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.