Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Alex

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Alex

  1. Not really, considering that sounds like he's referring to the eye test and not, you know, numbers. EDIT: He's pretty much been his numbers this season again. Moreover, what is baffling to me is that there is some kind of narrative that the Twins are using advanced metrics but are benefiting (to the tune of 3 consecutive 90+ loss seasons) by keeping it secret. Does their pattern of moves really suggest they do a good job analyzing/valuing numbers? Consider their use of spring training as a key evaluative tool in choosing players to make the roster (Hicks/Ramirez, among others), keeping players who seem to deserve a chance based on their numbers down in the minors (Slama, Colabello, Richardson etc..). Illogically keeping players up while sending others down (Hicks and Dozier both received longer looks than Parmelee, Colabello, and Arcia before getting sent back) From my observations, they are far more into scouting and what they see in a player than what that player has actually done.
  2. Even if you don't trust in the concept of WAR or it's accuracy, its existence has nothing to do with the added value a hitter like Mauer brings when he is able to play catcher. Just look at next year IF Mauer does move to first base and it means we don't sign another first baseman. Let's use current stats. It means that his .880 OPS (this season) goes to first base. This nets us about +.130 OPS at 1st base, which is a gain. However, Doumit or Hermann start to play more catcher, which means that spot on the field is then filled by a player with a sub .700 OPS (-.180). Net loss is about -.50 OPS.
  3. If the Twins are using advanced metrics more than other organizations there's little evidence of it or their ability to keep a lid on it is impressive because I've heard other teams refer to them and even admit they know what they are. In Spring Training when we played the Rays, I remember listening to Joe Maddon's interview and comparing it to Gardy's and the difference in analysis was astounding. Maddon talk about why they were batting Longoria 4th instead of 3rd (where teams traditionally place their best hitter) due to their research regarding the fact that they found the batting him in the #4 spot might net the team more runs due to in-house research. In an interview on MLB radio with the Pirates GM just before the trade deadline, he referred to their own metrics in evaluating players for trades and talked a lot about their defensive shifts, which have been highly successful and are based off of their own research. I don't hear the Twins talking much about their own research and evaluation other than "scouts say..." Meanwhile, we have Rick Anderson, after last season saying that "WAR" was a new one to him. This, after it would have been difficult for anyone to read an article about last year's MVP battle without running across the term. I also remember Parker's article that he wrote about Jack Goin and left with the impression that again, it was less than other teams were doing. In John Bonnes's interview with Terry Ryan a season or two back, Terry Ryan was either playing coy or was ignorant regarding some of the advanced statistics John asked him about. These are just some examples off the top of my head but there is little that leads me to to think the Twins are not using all the tools at their disposal to be effective in evaluation. I obviously can't say for certain that they aren't using it, but the OPs question was what evidence there was that they weren't using them. My answer is that I regularly see evidence that other teams (though certainly not all) ARE using them than the Twins.
  4. What? He's brilliant. He's just setting himself up for the win!
  5. You've probably summed up the issue here indirectly. If you think Morneau will be reasonably capable of those numbers -- you think he's more likely to reach them than not -- then it's not crazy to re-sign him. I think those numbers are a reach for him as he ages another year. Complete side note: Ran into this as I was looking at his stats. There's been some talk about Morneau going to a hitter friendly park because it will help him. Ironically, Morneau is hitting far better in target field than on the road: Target Field: .305/.351/.500 8 HR in 242 PA Away: .231/.293/.366 7 HR in 266 PA I'm actually shocked.
  6. Maybe, but it would be impossible to tell without giving them a chance, no? I'll also go ahead and predict the same of people thinking that Morneau needs to be re-signed. I really don't get it, other than the sentimental value, but I imagine if people take an objective look (IE not a Twins fan), there's no way they'd be happy if their team brought in Morneau for a significant deal, especially if they were a rebuilding team. Are there really fans on other boards in other MLB cities arguing their team should go out and get Morneau?
  7. I think "core" refers to players coming out of team control and entering FA. A player like Santana, who was lost to them because they couldn't afford him, and in the nearer future, players like Arcia, Sano, Meyer and Buxton. It did not, and should not imply they are going to overpay players who are past their prime. No offense, but I'd argue the "glass half-empty" crowd in this case are the ones saying the cupboard is empty or that better players couldn't be found in FA. They're arguing it's doom and gloom if we don't sign him.
  8. Because anyone can play it. Players with better bats who can no longer play other positions because they aren't athletic enough stay anywhere but 1B.
  9. Doubtful that they fall off a cliff, but I read an essay by Gabe Kapler that cites research that indicates the average peak age for MLB players is 28, especially in terms of power. So, it wouldn't be surprising if Fielder's (not unlike Pujols) best years are behind them. Even more reason to take a pass on Morneau, btw.
  10. So, the TLDR version of this thread is, "No."
  11. The problem is signing Morneau doesn't give him or Colabello the chance (someone else used an excellent descriptor: stagnation). The OF will hopefully be more crowded next season with Arcia out there permanently, hopefully. The more I think about it another issue with re-signing Morneau at any price means he becomes the defacto starter. He'll be a year older and likely producing less and no ones going to sit him if he does in favor of a younger player because of his pedigree here. Another team could probably take that risk and then benching him if he's not performing, but that's a big part of the problem with signing him for "intangible" reasons. Heck I wasn't big on re-signing him in the first place, but I'm getting to the point where I think it's almost crazy.
  12. Please feel free to share whatever evidence you have. I don't watch every 1B in the league play as I don't have the time, so I rely on people who are paid to analyze it and put it into a measurable form. EDIT: I'll also point out that the post I was responding to used ZR (and the last time he ranked highly was 2010). Morneau still looks very good in RF, but the problem there is that the Twins strike out fewer batters than anyone else in the league. This means he's getting more chances which is what range factor measures -- it doesn't actually measure range.
  13. Here's an interesting comparison: Morneau the last two seasons (age 31-32): .267/.333/.440 19 HR (570 PA) .267/.321/.431 15 HR (508 PA) Josh Willingham - (age 31-32, prior to getting 3 years at $21M) .268/.389/.459 16 HR (451 PA) .246/.332/.477 29 HR (563 PA) While these numbers don't look all that different, Willingham put up a better SLG both of those seasons (thanks to more HR power) and a significantly better OBP. So, is it realistic (or wise) with any objective reasoning to bring Morneau back on a deal that is more than a couple of million a year at best? Also, think about it from the angle of if Morneau weren't a Twin. Would we be happy seeing the signing of a .750ish OPS 1B on the FA market for a decent contract? Dare I say we'd treat it like a certain pitcher signing...Further, I'd argue that people would be rooting for more chances for CC and CP.
  14. No one else? As G+G pointed out in their podcast, fill in first baseman are available on the FA market and a Parmelee/Collobello platoon would be fine for next season to fill in and give them a chance to get some at bats.
  15. It's true that Mauer is most valuable catching. However there's no value in putting wear and tear on him behind the plate in non-competitive seasons.
  16. Agreed Seth. And even one of the things I thought that would have been another good reason for trading Morneau is the ability to save his health for future seasons by allowing him to play a bit more 1B.
  17. But he's giving fascinating insights on the value of the RBI as within a player's ability, maligning Plouffe's lack of RBIs in Rochester and Mauer's lack this year.
  18. The better question might be, who should the Twins move this offseason if at all possible. i'd like to see Doumit, Hammer, and Correia all moved to make room on the roster for other younger players, either those in the Twins system or younger FA. I realize these guys have little value, but it would be nice to open up some space.
  19. I think it's partially this, but I think it's also that teams realize that the value of a guy they'll only have for a couple of months at most is less valuable than the chance of decent prospect succeeding. I think that's a recent paradigm shift (last few years) one the Twins used to be good at exploiting but other teams have gotten smarter, and I think the Twins are struggling to adjust.
  20. Hendricks? I don't see them adding anything in FA unless they trade someone away.
  21. Love the Florimon bunt. The Twins way of manufacturing runs is really working out for us....
  22. Alex replied to DaveW's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
    It's a tough situation the Twins are in. They have essentially three aging corner/DH players who are aging and not hitting all that well (Willingham, Doumit, and Morneau). This logjam has occasionally blocked some young (Arcia) and/or interesting players (Colabello) from moving up and getting regular time or at least decent looks. Unfortunately, Doumit and Willingham are back next year for sure. Signing Morneau again puts us right back in the same spot the team was in this year, with no flexibility at any of those spots and Arcia up full time. Personally, I'd like to see Parmelee get one more shot (he's only had a season's worth of MLB PAs) and would like to see a bit more of Colabello (not saying full time but he's been adjusting well to big league pitching) and that's pretty much impossible with Morneau. The other thing that isn't being discussed here is that while we all like Morneau, there are likely to be cheaper options at his position that can be signed and fill in and aren't the risk that he is. A multi-year deal would be a mistake. You just can't have a player that has been this inconsistent locking up a spot on your roster multi-years. It's a problem that's shown itself with the Doumit extension (signed while playing really well), not trading Willingham (at peak value), and giving two years to Correia.
  23. Turns out it was a brilliant move...set up the grand slam perfectly...
  24. Sorry to bring us back to the game, but I hate the bunt in that situation. In a tie game, fine, but no outs two on...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.