Everything posted by 2wins87
- Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 1 Thread
-
2019 draft
This feels like a bit of an ownership lie. According to Forbes they have a 9% debt to value ratio, which is perfectly manageable (less than the Twins). It's hard to believe that they couldn't afford to spend $140 million on payroll again this year and for the forseeable future if they had the will to do so. They actually reduced their debt from 10% to 9% in 2018 (again according to Forbes) with a payroll of $140 million, which given their valuations means that their debt level at the very most was constant in nominal terms, if it didn't drop by a little. I just don't buy it. Most of that money is just becoming profit.
-
Article: Finer Points: Draft Bonus Pools
I'm confused by this hypothetical, were they planning on signing that guy for like $10,000? Presumably they budgeted close to his slot value for him, so when they lose his slot money they also aren't using the money that they would have to sign him. They should still be spending more or less all of their remaining pool money on the remaining players. There is a little bit of overslot wiggle room before the penalties kick in, so unless he was their first pick and they thought they had a big underslot deal on him then they would be very unlikely to be affected by penalties. If a team does go overslot on everyone expecting to be able to negotiate a guy into signing a $10,000 contract which he's unwilling to do then that seems like their own fault and they should be penalized.
-
Article: When the Twins Go Buying ... Who Are They Selling?
I keep coming back to Toronto when looking at trades. Stroman has already been mentioned, but I'd also be pretty interested in Ken Giles. He's in the same place as Pressly was last year in terms of service time, but will be a little more costly in arbitration so likely would command a slightly lesser prospect package. We know that Toronto is looking to build around Vladito with guys in a similar service class, so basically guys that will be ready by next year. The AA/AAA depth right now looks better than last year, and there are a bunch of guys that could easily be considered redundant while still being interesting in a trade. From a quick perusal of my list: Arraez, Gordon, Alcala, Raley, Smeltzer, Wade, Rooker, Blankenhorn (and maybe Cave too). They could easily take a couple of those guys off the table if they want to work them into their 2020 plans and still be able to present an excellent prospect package to Toronto.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/22): Barnes Baffles in Daytona
If you look past ERAs to some more peripheral stats Jax and Enlow look to have about equally good numbers. I've never been particularly high on Enlow, but he's doing fine and is still young. Jax has been good but his top-line ERA number definitely overstates how good he's been. I'd have a hard time putting any of the minor league relievers in a top 20 list, even top 30 given the solid depth of the system right now. Smeltzer, Balazovic, and Sands have been the biggest risers on the pitching side for me this year. All of them have some good reports on their stuff to back up their numbers. Ober would be in that group if it weren't for his continued struggles staying healthy. I'm just cautious about getting too excited if he can't stay on the mound. On the hitting side it's obviously Blankenhorn, Diaz, and Cabbage. We shouldn't be too surprised to see any of them breaking out but they've all been very much more impressive than I expected this year.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/16): Diaz Powers Miracle Win
Also one of the dumbest comments ever by the announcer (ok, announcers say a lot of dumb stuff): "He didn't throw it at Lewis he threw it behind him." No, he threw it at him and missed. Idiots all the way down. Glad it didn't get any more out of hand and the Miracle players just got their revenge at the plate.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/4) Down But Never Out
Minor league catchers do not and should not catch every day. That's a recipe for retiring due to injuries or just general wear and tear before the age of 30. I do think we will see him moved up to AA sometime around mid-season. I was still somewhat skeptical of him due to his questionable bat before the season, but I am a believer now. He just keeps improving. I wouldn't worry too much about playing time as long as he's making the most of it.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/3): Tanner English Grand Slam Sets Tone in Wild Blue Wahoos Win
I think Raley ought to be by now (especially considering the slow starts by so many other guys). I shifted him up to 19th on my own personal ranks after his good spring training, and he's been moving up after he initially had a bit of a slow start too. He's looking like a solid hitter again, hopefully he cuts his K rate down closer to where it was last year. Wiel's still more of a sleeper in my opinion, but he certainly has a shot at the majors. His K rate is still worrying and he's pretty much 1B only, so that makes it pretty tough for him to break through.
-
Article: Minnesota's Rotation: Better than Advertised?
I'm not too surprised at how good the rotations was. I sort of bought the company line that they were going to coach Perez and others into big improvements. Maybe I'm a sucker. The biggest surprise for me has been Odorizzi, since I never felt he was all that great. An under-appreciated story line is that Odorizzi's velocity has actually been up a bit, and I wonder if Wes Johnson is behind it at all. It's only about 1 MPH difference, but if you look at his average velocity at this time in the season from other years he's clearly above the last couple, and possibly throwing as hard as ever in his career. It's something I'm keeping an eye on.
-
Meanwhile down on the farm-Bailey Ober
The injury last year was also elbow related, but evidently it was not serious and he was able to rest his arm a bit and come back strong this year.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/27) April Showers Bring … Postponed Games
I believe a pickoff gets counted as a CS, so that's the same play. Still, he started out the season 5 for 6 or something like that and has been caught a couple times in a row now. I wondering if his struggles at the plate are causing him to press a little bit too much. I'm not too worried about it too much at lower levels now. It's good for prospects to be aggressive as long as they are learning about reading pitchers and getting jumps. He never had Buxton level speed (who does?), but he should be a pretty good basestealer if he doesn't bulk up too much and lose speed or something
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/22): Dobnak Dazzles... Again!
Poppen is not on the 40-man and he pitched on Saturday, so he's not an option on 3 days rest. He's got pretty good velocity (above average but not plus), his secondary stuff is more average-ish I think.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/22): Dobnak Dazzles... Again!
Stewart would be scheduled to go for Rochester tomorrow I think. I might prefer him over Littell since he has a propensity for ground balls and fly balls have a propensity to leave Minute Maid Park. I'd have to think that the Twins infield would back him up way better than the Red Wings' has. Littell would be scheduled to go Thursday but will have 4 days of rest tomorrow so he's certainly an option too.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/17): Thorpe Finds His Groove
Scouts never thought he had particularly good stuff and said he thrived on polish vs inexperienced hitters. So that's probably caught up to him a bit at higher levels. Then again the Yankees are unfairly good at developing prospects, so maybe there is something to that too.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/17): Thorpe Finds His Groove
He has a walk rate over 20%. I wonder how many pitches to hit he is getting. He definitely isn't locked in yet but if he's getting pitched around a lot it could make it look worse.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/16): Graterol Shines, Cabbage Shreds
The first 7 batters to face him all struck out swinging, which is quite impressive. He did get hit hard a few times after that. The same thing happened to him at the start of last year. He had good peripherals in terms of Ks and BBs but got hammered with a bunch of HRs and other extra base hits in his first few starts. I'm not entirely sure what to make of that. It's strange to see a guy have both swing and miss stuff and stuff that gets clobbered at the same time. I guess it could be a result of fringe-average stuff with good pitch-ability, and he just doesn't have as much margin for error as other guys with better stuff. Last year he managed to improve on the hard contact while keeping his K and BB rates about the same and ending with pretty solid numbers. We'll have to see if he can do the same this year.
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/16): Graterol Shines, Cabbage Shreds
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/13): We Are Talking About the Same Sport, Correct?
When most of the hitters are struggling and most of the pitchers are dominating it's probably a good idea to look at the overall run scoring environments of the leagues that they are playing in. So far, for whatever reason, offense is down in both the Southern League and the Florida State league from last year. It's pretty close to the same in the Midwest league and way up in the International League (further evidence that, yes, the MLB ball was juiced a couple years ago, and at the very least it is a lot better for offense than the minor league ball).
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/9): Fort Myers Walks-Off, Pensacola PR
If the first batter was out, then the third out would have come on the sac fly which scored the first run... so yeah. I do sort of feel that if a batter reaches base after the third out would have been recorded, and then still comes around to score that those should start to count again, and there were a couple of those. Bottom line is that there are 3 or 4 stats to look at before ERA. It also doesn't seem like Stewart pitched terribly overall. It was pretty much one ground ball through the infield after the next, but it does seem like he came a bit unglued after the damage started.
-
Article: Seth's Preseason Top 20 Minnesota Twins Position Player Prospects
Blankenhorn's overall minor league production is very Plouffe-esque. So it's certainly possible that he turns into a good major leaguer, but I'm not sure we want to see the scenario where he gets a long enough leash in the majors to do so...
-
Article: Seth's Preseason Top 20 Minnesota Twins Position Player Prospects
I'm not someone who feels strongly on Rortvedt one way or another, but this does bring up an interesting question. How much of a consideration should minor league framing be? And when should it start to be important? I'm pretty curious to see how Garver's numbers look this year after a month or two. He was worth -10 runs last year according to Fangraphs' new numbers, but we've heard several times that framing was a specific offseason focus for him. If he's average or better this year then I think we'd have to give pretty heavy consideration to the hypothesis that all it really takes to be a good framer is the willingness to work on it and amount of effort put into it (there already is evidence that as teams have become more aware of framing everyone has clustered closer to the average). Basically it seems like the approach is mostly just to lower the stance and get a bunch of better calls on low strikes. Maybe it won't be that simple, but we'll have to see. It seems possible that it might be the kind of thing that players don't really need to focus on until AA or AAA once they have all the fundamentals down, then they put in a some time with their catching coaches and voila, average mlb framer.
-
Article: 2019 Rochester Red Wings Preliminary Roster
Looks like a better team this year. Looking for bounce-backs from Gordon and Wade. Decent mix of young guys with potential (more than last year) and some older AAAA types. The roster should also probably be less affected by guys being shuttled back and forth between the majors this year.
-
Who is Donny Breek?
He was signed from the Netherlands in 2017. Played youth baseball there at a high level for quite a while so he was scouted from a pretty young age. He pitched quite well in the GCL last year though stats there are pretty variable. I think he's low 90's fastball, good changeup, maybe with some room for projection. He's in the book, and I'm sure Seth and the other writers could tell you more.
-
Fangraphs adds catcher framing data
In a move that that was inevitable but a long time coming, Fangraphs has now added catcher framing. They have multiple articles discussing the methodolgy and impact: https://blogs.fangraphs.com/war-update-catcher-framing/ https://blogs.fangraphs.com/fangraphs-pitch-framing/ Similar data was already available elsewhere, but if you like data it is nice to have it at Fangraphs where it is rolled into valuation metrics, and easily sortable and whatnot. The data does only start in 2008 with the advent of PITCHf/x, so it adds another big difference to pre and post 2008 data, but Fangraphs has always been about quantifying the best available current data, not necessarily being a long historical repository of data. Anyway, I have a few thoughts after digging around a little bit: 1a. Garver was quite poor at framing last year and it really cuts into his fangraphs WAR, making him only slightly above replacement. It'll be interesting to watch if the work he put in this offseason turns things around this year. 1b. In a smaller sample, Astudillo's framing was about average, which might help the case that he can at least be a part-time catcher. 2. Ryan Doumit was even worse than we probably remember 3a. There was a debate about Mauer and Yadier Molina and the HOF a little wile ago, both are positive pitch framers over the portions of their careers for which there is data. Mauer is only slightly positive, getting 13.6 framing runs (about 1-1.5 WAR) from 2008-2013. Just extrapolating backwards you could probably add another 1 WAR for the seasons for which there is no data. So it probably doesn't much help his case but it doesn't hurt. Molina on the other hand, is helped immensely (by around 20 framing runs per year in the first year in which data is available), which puts his career fWAR at 53, actually slightly ahead of Mauer, and you could pretty reasonably extrapolate 5 or 6 more WAR for the seasons without data. 3b. Some of the early framing numbers seem really extreme. The methodology didn't change, and the idea of a catcher framing a pitch is much older than the data itself, but it still seems to have taken a little while for teams and coaches to realize that framing was something to focus on to really gain a significant edge. Anecdotally, there seems to be a change around 2013. Guys like Molina and McCann who put up huge early framing numbers drop down to just solidly above average. How much of the early numbers are just going to guys who happen to have benefitted from their size, stances, or whatnot without any conscious effort? If we care about things like this for the hall of fame do we want to discount the early years somewhat? Jeff Sulivan also had a piece about the decrease in the variance and year-to-year correlation of framing stats as working on framing becomes more mainstream around baseball. Is the outsized value of pitch framing going to just be a blip? 4. Mauer's 2009 MVP season now looks even better at 8.2 fWAR (to Jeter's 6.7 fWAR), though I doubt this would change any Yankees' fans minds that Jeter was somehow robbed. This is now the 3rd best catcher season by fWAR since 2008, beat by McCann's 2008 and Posey's 2012. Both of these are aided much more by framing value, though Posey's and Mauer's seasons are very close without framing value and McCann's would be pedestrian without it. 5. Good catcher framing is also taken out of pitcher value while poor framing is added to pitcher value. Is it right to put framing entirely on catchers? Do pitchers have some control due to where they are throwing their pitches in which counts? I already have some philosophical issues with fWAR for pitchers which are a topic for a different discussion, but I wonder if the perceived effect on pitchers is correct. They do acknowledge that deciding how to treat framing for pitchers was the main reason it took as long as it did for pitch framing to come to Fangraphs, but there are probably still a lot of debates to come.
-
Joe Mauer and/or Yadier Molina belong in the HOF?
HOF debates get tiresome pretty fast but I'll make a couple of points. First, the idea that the Hall has gotten easier to get into is nonsense. Harold Baines was a bad inductee, but there have been inductees like him for the Hall's entire existence. Name any positiion and it's probably pretty easy to find a Hall of Famer that makes no sense, and most of them were voted in long ago. Jesse Haines? Lloyd Waner? Bill Mazeroski? Not to mention the fact that for the first half of baseball history black players weren't even allowed in the MLB and the overall level of play wasn't very impressive. I think for the most part the standards have gotten higher, though the Veteran's committee is still odd and the writers are super inconsistent and petty. Second, I don't think the voters have ever really appreciated how difficult being a high level catcher is. We've only recently started measuring pitch framing and finding that it can actually provide a lot of value to a team, and I'm not aware of much work on the effects of catcher game calling/working with pitchers. I imagine you can probably point to some evidence that Molina has been valuable to his team in ways that haven't always been measured, though this kind of evidence is obviously hard to quantify. But most basically, there aren't a lot of catchers that have made it to the Hall, most catchers don't have particularly long and productive careers, so we should probably grade on a curve for all catchers. I think Mauer should really be a no doubt case (you can leave him off the first ballot if that kind of thing matters to you). I actually think he'll do pretty well in the voting also, uniting some of the younger and older voters. The new school guys can point to his very impressive peak at catcher and the amount of WAR he managed to rack up. He's the only catcher to win 3 batting titles, which is kind of meaningless but is the kind of thing that traditionalists like. He was the face of the Twins franchise for many years and one of the best pure hitters of his era. He was actually pretty "clutch" at the plate. The arguments for Molina have to be a little more squishy. He was never the face of his franchise, but he does have a stellar defensive reputation, and he's had a long and pretty good career at catcher which is a feat in of itself. I wouldn't really argue against him if you can make the case that he was one of the most important players for the Cardinals over his career.