Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

2wins87

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by 2wins87

  1. The K rate by itself was pretty good though, especially if you view him as a slugger. I think prospect guys like Callis, Mayo, and Sickels (who also had him pretty high) will generally tend to look at a low walk rate as a more fixable issue than a pure inability to make contact consistently. You still have to do some projection and say that the game power will develop as he matures, but I get why national evaluators still like him. I'd still have him lower also due to his lack of positional value, but I think that explains some of the scouting vs performance gap in his case.
  2. The new MLB top 30 for the Twins is out: http://m.mlb.com/prospects/2018?list=min No real outlier opinions on anyone, but good little tidbits on everyone as usual.
  3. I think Lewis might get some time in CF as they try to work everyone into the lineup, but I hope they keep developing him at short. I do think he ends up in Ft Meyers by midseason at latest. Baddoo is probably a corner OF long-term.
  4. If Lewis moves off of short he's better in the outfield with his speed. A lot of scouts see him as a CF, though that position may be occupied at the MLB level for a while. I could see switching Lewis and Javier around too.
  5. I guess you're right. I just remembered his projected batting line being lower than those for Garver and Wade. But Steamer actually doesn't project his defense or baserunning to be all that great, which seems wrong, probably just because it's conservative on those for guys without much MLB data. If you adjust them upward a bit, which seems reasonable, his projection actually looks pretty good.
  6. There's an argument to be made that sticking with position players with the #1 pick is almost always a better strategy overall. Kiley McDaniel and Eric Longenhagen this up in their chat yesterday, pitching prospects that are ranked similarly in national rankings bring back less future value (in terms of WAR) on average. This is basically just because of the high rate of injury for pitchers. They got a guy with a lot of potential value in Lewis, and with probably a lower level of risk than Greene, Gore, and Wright. And they were able to get some high upside guys with their next few picks. If there were a Strasburg in the draft and they picked Lewis over him it would have been a mistake. But given that none of those guys was a Strasburg type, I doubt that this draft will look like that much of a mistake in the future, regardless of how much the other guys succeed.
  7. Continuing Fangraphs prospect week they are out with their top 100 KATOH projection list. All the caveats of scouting the stat line apply (though their system is much more sophisticated than the average internet commenter). If you aren't familiar with the system just think of it as comparing current prospects to former prospects at similar levels, ages, and approximate statistical profile, and then looking at the range of outcomes and coming out with an average expected WAR over their first 6 years in the majors. Twins rankings: Granite - 6 (10.4 WAR) Lewis - 23 (7.6 WAR) Garver - 32 (6.7 WAR) Wade - 40 (5.7 WAR) Gonsalves 66 (4.7 WAR) Littell 96 (4.1 WAR) It's interesting how bullish it is on Granite still, especially since he's accrued enough time in the upper minors and MLB level to be projected by other MLB systems, and none of them are particularly bullish on him for next year. I was also surprised to see Lewis so high, since there is a huge range of outcomes for guys at the lower levels. Clearly his strong performance along with aggressive promotions puts him in the company of some very good former prospects.
  8. The ranking of Garver has actually been the most baffling thing to me this year. He was old for his level last year, and every other year. Now he destroyed AAA - where I would say age to league no longer means much of anything - but the argument is now that he's too old. I used to think he was ranked too high, mostly because of his age and questions about defense. I've been encouraged by reports of his defense solidifying, but now he's kind of an afterthought. I get why national rankers more or less ignore guys that are 26 or 27. But it's not that strange for a catcher to be fairly old before making an impact at the MLB level. About a quarter of the dozenish catchers to put up 2+ WAR last season didn't get a regular job until they were at least 27 (Austin Barnes, Robinson Chirinos, and Manny Piña specifically). There's no reason to think that Garver's not still a prospect and doesn't have time to make an impact.
  9. Gonsalves and Romero both in the HM section, which are prospects which also received 50 FV grades but didn't make the list
  10. Maybe he means defensively? IDK The best part of having prospects on these lists is that we get an early look at their new write-ups. Their take on Gordon's defense is probably among the most bullish I've seen, pegging him as a slightly above average defender overall, which would actually be pretty valuable at short. They do say that his range is the limiting factor, but it kind of sounds like they still view him as a shortstop.
  11. Would I rather have Darvish or two inferior pitchers while losing an additional asset off of waivers for no return and delaying the development of several younger, cheaper pitchers likely to be better than Lynn and Cobb in a couple years while they continue to take up roster and payroll space? Why is this a question?
  12. Interesting list, looks like it might be the outlier this year. After Lewis, I don't think there's any clear order, but I do think Gordon, Gonsalves, and Romero are in their own tier based on proximity, floor, etc, so it's a little surprising to see them so mixed up. I like lists with diverging opinions on certain guys, but there's a lot of volatility in this one. If I'm judging list accuracy, I like to use WAR total over a player's arbitration and pre-arbitration years. It takes a long time to be able to judge, and there are always misses on guys where there is a consensus as a prospect, but I feel like this one will probably be significantly wrong just based on the volatility of the guys near the top of the list. As a side note, I have a feeling that everyone is missing on Garver, who could probably rack up 10+ WAR at catcher over the next 6 years just by being decent. Developing major league catchers is hard, I'm not sure why Garver hasn't gotten more attention given how close he is, I have a feeling he'll end up being more valuable than at least 3 or 4 of the consensus top 10 guys.
  13. Severino was a C+ guy when he rated the Braves organization. I guess he just missed him in the update.
  14. Rowson appears to be a very good hire based on the overall performance of the offense last year. Adrianza was very good for being picked off waivers. It's early to grade the draft last year but I liked the way they used their big pool to get a number of impact players. And actually their best move was probably driving a hard bargain on Dozier and ultimately retaining him rather than trading him below value just because he looked like their best trade chip. They haven't been perfect, but they seem competent, and I'm still withholding most of my judgement until we see how they build the team for this year and beyond.
  15. I can't really defend the pick but saying "live fastball" is understating it a bit. He's hit 100 MPH, which, while getting more common, is still rare. I think Burdi may have hit 100 too, though I'm not positive about that, he's close at any rate. I'm guessing that they gambled that no one would take him right after his Tommy John. As for Bard, Kinley's definitely got more velocity but he's been wild as hell. I like the overall package of Bard better, but the front office apparently thinks they can refine his control or something. Like everyone else, I'm not a fan of the move. I would have preferred that they fill another 40-man spot with one of their own rather than picking up a guy who's extremely unlikely to stick around for the season.
  16. I always think of Chris Young as a comp for Aaron Slegers, both being 6'10" and throwing in the low 90's. (Young has been in the mid to high 80's for most of his career, but did throw in the low 90's his first few years.) I looked up Young's chart from this year and he's much more over the top, coming in from almost straight on but from an even higher point than Slegers and the others. Chart Young is interesting because he had a knack for exceeding his fielding independent metrics year-in and year-out, which mostly seems to be due to his ability to generate tons of pop-ups. He induced tons of flyballs in general but had a low HR/FB ratio since most of those flyballs weren't squared up. Slegers doesn't have the same crazy FB/GB split. His minor league track record does indicate that he can generate an above average pop-up rate though. His higher groundball rate likely comes from the fact that he throws a sinker about as often as his 4-seamer. Anyway, that's my base case for how a guy with back of the rotation stuff can be a bit more than a back of the rotation starter. Young has had a long and reasonably successful career. As a side note, if Slegers doesn't pan out it could be interesting to see if the 6'8" Tyler Wells follows a similar but more successful path. Right now he's just about all whiffs and pop-ups in single A, though his stuff doesn't get rave reviews either.
  17. I think people might be reading too much into Garver's usage in September. If the Twins weren't in the playoff hunt, he might have gotten more time behind the plate. The front office did essentially clear the way for him by declining Giminez's arbitration. Obviously they still like Castro's defense and pitch calling better, but I'm not sure their tentative usage of Garver this year necessarily means they don't believe in his capability behind the plate. We'll see how things go next year I guess.
  18. In principle I would prefer them to Darvish since they are younger and would be cheaper. Of course, that's what gives the Pirates and Rays tons of leverage, so in reality it's probably pretty unlikely that the Twins could land them without giving up a lot from their farm system. I'm not sure exactly what it would take to get them, so I'd prefer their contracts to Darvish's, but yeah, most realistic trades might be too much in terms of prospects.
  19. Archer or Cole--absolutely. We have to be realistic about what kind of pitchers Gonsalves and Romero are. Both Archer and Cole have already reached a higher level than Gonsalves has a ceiling. He has #3 starter stuff, and I'd believe he has the makeup and intelligence to possibly pitch at a #2 level at times, but but Archer is a fringe #1 guy and Cole is a solid #2 with potential to pitch at a #1 level when he's on. As for Romero, he's got #2 stuff with a lot of risk. There's still a good chance he ends up a bullpen arm. I think it's a no brainer if the rest of the asking price isn't too high. I would probably keep Lewis off limits, but anyone else is shippable at the right price. There's just little probability that any of them will have the kind of impact that a front-line starter would. My preference for the starting pitchers that have been talked about would be: Archer, Cole, Odorizzi, Darvish, Cobb, Arrieta, Lynn. Obviously the first three are contingent on what they have to give up to get them, but if they are building for sustained success having a younger cheaper guy is better than signing a big contract for an older free agent. Arrieta and Lynn feel like free agent traps waiting too happen, so I'm not sure I'd really want them at all unless the deals are very team friendly.
  20. I try not to get too exercised over the ordering on these rankings, but like others, I'm trying to get a feeling for the recent pickups, and I just don't see them being as good as indicated by these rankings. I'm not putting any weight on a short season performance, we see a lot of guys look completely different in their second year vs their debut. But from what I've gathered about Pearson and Banuelos they just don't seem like top 20 prospects in this system even though they were much more highly rated in other shallower systems. My baseline for Pearson is Leach. Pearson was rated slightly above Leach on most pre-draft boards, but he ended up slipping to 85 (right around where Leach was rated). He signed overslot for around 63rd pick value. But Leach was picked at 37th and signed for about 49th value. I don't pretend to have special knowledge about either of these guys, but at the very least this tells me that they are in similar tiers, and that the Twins FO actually likes Leach a significant amount more. And I don't see anything in their debuts to indicate that they've significantly diverged yet. I'm sure you could find scouts that like Pearson better but I'm having trouble believing that you could find one who would say he's clearly a better prospect. I'm legitimately curious if there is any sort of scouting information on Pearson (or Banuelos) that suggests that this take is significantly mistaken. It takes me a while to get to know knew additions and I probably often underrate them. But I feel like we got two guys who rank in the late 20's to mid 30's range in our system, not two top 20 guys.
  21. Burdi will still be building up strength from his TJ next year, I don't see any real possibility that he'll make the 25 man roster until 2019.
  22. Yeah, I'm starting to feel like there is getting to be a little fastball saturation. Hitters are seeing more and more high velocity guys, even in the low minors. I sometimes wonder if it actually opens up avenues for guys in different niches to be more successful than they might otherwise be, provided they are really good at their style of pitching of course.
  23. Rortvedt definitely improved in the second half, but even his second half split would be indicative of a marginal MLB bat. That said he is young and evaluators still seem to like his tools a decent amount. I think there are a few examples of catchers that didn't hit great in the minors, but had good defensive tools and managed to steadily improve their bats over time. I have tempered expectations at this point, but I'm definitely not writing him off. I have him around 30, but it's a deep and intriguing system.
  24. Whitefield and Rodriguez seem really high to me based on some of the names behind them. I know Whitefield is still more raw than the typical prospect his age but striking out in over 25% of his at bats in A ball while only drawing walks in 6% would be a red flag for any prospect. I don't think the tools justify a ranking this high. I'd have him closer in ranking to someone like Jaylin Davis. On Rodriguez, I buy giving a guy a little bit of a boost for bloodlines in the lower levels, but he's been at least a year old for his level the last 2 years and he's not blowing away the competition. His stuff projects as back of the rotation starter but he doesn't really have the track record to indicate he's very close to reaching that. I'd easily put Slegers ahead of him for proximity and Tyler Wells and Watson ahead for potential. I'd also have Jax lower but that's more on uncertainty about how much time for development he'll get and if that'll make him fall too far behind.
  25. Agree on Rosario, presumably his defense won't look as bad next year if he just throws to the cutoff more often. He does things that cost money in arbitration (hitting quite a few home runs). Kepler hasn't posted an above average OPS to date. If he improves his on-base average with a bit more power, then yes, he'll cost quite a bit more, but if he has a similar season to the last two he's not really gonna be that much more expensive. I think your contract projection already includes some projected improvement. If he doesn't improve in his third full season expectations will be shifted down somewhat.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.