Everything posted by 2wins87
-
Article: Catching Up With RHP Tom Hackimer
8.9% walk rate isn't great but it's not all that bad either. I think deceptive arm slots can easily be underrated in prospects. It definitely upgrades the raw stuff at any level but it's hard to say how much. I like that Hackimer had success against lefties this year, it's the same thing Hildenberger did in 2015. I wouldn't be at all surprised to see Hackimer follow the same trajectory as him. I don't know if two right-handed side-armers would be too many for one bullpen, but I think Hackimer has a good chance of being there in another year or so.
-
Twins Daily Midseason Top Twins Prospect Vote
I'd like to see JT Chargois and Lamonte Wade in the next couple rounds of voting.
-
Article: Draft Blog, Entry 2 (4/14/16)
I'd be interested to hear Jeremy's take, but from what I've read there's not much top end catching talent in this draft, so it's hard to see any of them being a good pick at #15 right now. We'll see what happens, but my guess is the Twins won't take any catchers in the first couple of rounds. Obviously the catching position is the thinnest in the Twins pipeline, but I don't see this draft being a good way to remedy that.
- Article: TD Top Prospects: #5 Tyler Jay
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #6 Stephen Gonsalves
Part of his high ranking probably has to do with his frame (he's got 5 or 6 inches on Duensing). With youth, a good makeup, and athletic body it's not unreasonable to expect improvement. We don't know if that'll happen but I think that's why he still gets high ratings among prospect rankers who look beyond numbers. A fastball-changeup combo is a little bit rare mix for a reliever, so it makes sense to keep grooming him as a starter, especially with his body. If he can't put together a breaking ball he might not make the majors but if he does he looks like a pretty solid starter.
-
MiLB.com's Twins Organizational All Stars
Almost every position on this team is filled by a prospect who is pretty exciting for one reason or another. Good reason for optimism
-
MiLB.com's Twins Organizational All Stars
I've been putting together a ranking and have him in the low 30s right now. He seems to have really good plate discipline and contact ability. I wouldn't expect him to have much power at this point, so we'll see what happens there. His K rate was a bit more than half of the next qualified batter in the GCL. That's pretty impressive.
-
Is Adam Walker UNDERrated, or OVERrated?
He may get overrated by some, but at the same time, it's easier to dismiss him in a system with a lot of other strong prospects. Steven Moya is a guy with a similar profile in a weak system, and he gets a lot more attention due to the lack of other prospects around him, so I'm not so sure Walker doesn't get a little underrated nationally. Moya isn't in the top 100 at mlb.com and I don't think Walker should be either, but Moya was rated at #100 before the season. Moya doesn't seem any more likely to succeed than Walker and he was only a few months younger in AA, so this seems like a pretty big overrating to me.
-
Is Adam Walker UNDERrated, or OVERrated?
I think there are two comparable players that are a little ahead of him development-wise. These are Joey Gallo of the Rangers and Steven Moya of the Tigers. They have different minor league track records, but all have somewhat similar size, power, and hitting profiles. They're in a little bit different places on the spectrum of plate discipline and contact issues; this site (which unfortunately seems to have broken in June) has data on things like whiff%, in-zone and out-of-zone swing%, etc., which is interesting to compare. Gallo seems to have better plate discipline but worse contact issues than Walker, and Moya seems to be the other way around. For comparison, Sano seems to have both better plate discipline and better contact rates, which makes sense. Gallo was much younger than the other two in AA so is maybe a less fair comparison. Neither of them have very good numbers in the majors so far, but both are good enough that they'll get plenty of chances to improve. Walker should too, but may have a harder time breaking in due to stiffer competition on the Twins roster. I would also say that the improvement in his walk rate has been under-appreciated. I personally don't give him a great shot at being much more than replacement level in the majors, but he's working hard on his approach at the plate and it seems to be showing. We ought to give him credit for that. I think he's appropriately rated on average, but has been one of the most divisive prospects in the forum. People who just look at the strikeouts and say he has no shot against major league pitchers are underrating him. People who just look at the home-runs and expect him to continue to do that in the majors are probably overrating him. The majors are definitely tougher on guys who rely on one big tool, but he will hit still hit home runs and he will still strike out a lot. I think it's really hard to say whether he'll be able to strike enough of a balance, but right around 8-10 among Twins' prospects is a reasonable rating.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 8: 1-5
A couple guys that I think should be in the top 50: Luis Arraez, Jean Carlos Arias, and Huascar Ynoa. Obviously they are all very young and hard to project, but their upside should get them on the list. I'd also include Eades who was mentioned in a previous thread. He's disappointing for where he was drafted but he had a nice season and still has a good chance of playing in the majors.
- Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 6 (11-15)
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 4 (21-25)
Gibbons is a bit of a surprise to me, he's barely been on my radar until now. Any more information on what got him ranked this high? How are his curve and changeup? 93 mph is nice and all but he better have a nice secondary offering to back it up with.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 4 (21-25)
He's also got a very low K-rate (12% between the GCL and APPY). Guys who make a lot of contact tend to walk less because they often put the ball in play (or over the fence) before the count gets very deep. I'm not saying his BB rate is where it should be, but his combination of power and contact ability is pretty rare and worth getting excited about.
-
Top 20 Florida State League Prospects
I imagine Tyler Jay wasn't there long enough to qualify? It's a little interesting to see Vielma not too far behind Stewart and Gonsalves. I guess you have to respect someone who can play plus defense at SS. His bat has shown a little improvement too.
-
Papelbon fights Harper
I haven't really really payed too much attention to the Nationals for the past few year, but reading the comments from Nationals fans about the incident, there does not seem to be any dissatisfaction with Harper's general hustle and work ethic. Maybe Harper is getting a pass for being supremely talented, but with the level of talent in the MLB today, I have a hard time believing that anyone could be talented enough to play better than anyone else without putting in the work. The issue of hustle seems to be a small part of the bad blood between Harper and Paplebon anyway. It seems a lot more likely that Paplebon was upset by Harper's remarks after Paplebon hit Machado with a pitch that was very likely intentional (and only missed hitting Machado's head due to the fact that his shoulder was in the way). Harper called it tired and he's right, throwing baseballs at guys for perceived showboating is tired and it's bad for the game. Certainly Harper's ego didn't help to diffuse the situation, but Paplebon is not being a veteran leader calling out a young player, he's a 34-year-old picking a fight with his new teammate for his own selfish reasons. The best take I've read on the situation is probably from this wapo article which points out how jarring the incident is to young fans. Players jog out pop flies all the time, and I have a hard time believing that it leaves any kind of impression on kids watching the game. What does leave an impression are things like beanballs, which teach that it's ok to retaliate with violence if you feel you've been upstaged. And certainly a superstar being attacked in the dugout leaves an impression and is terrible for the game.
-
Baseball America's Top 20 Appy League Prospects
Yeah, my understanding is that the authors that compile the league and team lists pretty much determine the order themselves, and obviously are talking to different scouts as well. The top 100 list that comes out at the end of the process is more of a group process, so there will be some discrepancies. Good to see Palacios making appearances on both of these tough. I think he's gotta be in the Twins top 20 this year.
-
Who's the man up the middle?
I'm talking full season Dozier, who we should expect to be a 3-4 win player as he's been over the last 2 seasons, which is a tall order for a rookie with inconsistent defense and so-so plate discipline. That's not meant to be a dig on Polanco. He's got a great hit tool and really good defensive tools too, but moving a proven veteran for an unproven prospect is a good way of finding yourself with a near contender with a gaping hole.
-
Who's the man up the middle?
I know the guys who have already moved off short to 2B aren't quite as exciting, but I'll echo Levi Michael as a guy who's finally come around and could end up as a solid depth guy, and also mention Luis Arraez as another exciting long term guy. I don't think moving Dozier this offseason would be wise since I don't think Polanco or anyone else is very likely to match his production next year, and the plan should be to be as competitive as possible next year. After next year, the timing might be more apt, but Dozier looks to be an important part of the 2016 Twins who should be postseason contenders, why break that up?
-
Article: Twins 2015 Minor League Relief Pitcher of the Year - Trevor Hildenberger
The Southern League seemed to eat up a lot of relief pitchers this year. The FSL is always a very pitcher friendly league while the Southern League is probably slightly hitter friendly. The parks in the FSL are usually pointed to as the main culprit, but I wonder if the umps in the Souther League call a tighter strikezone as a lot of relievers (Burdi, Jones, Chargois, Reed) had a drastic difference in walk rates between the two leagues.
-
Baseball America's 2015 Classification All Star Teams
I've never posted about him before now but I've noticed his silly K and BB rates. Sounds like it was put together by BA staff, so it should be based mostly on scouting reports.
-
Article: Twins Minor league Report (8/20): Tyler Jay Pitches Well
"Ok Alex, step one, lose about 10 mph of velocity off your fastball. Upper 80's is all the velocity anyone should need."
-
Ichiro chasing 3000 hits
Everyone loves a good milestone chase, and everyone should love Ichiro Suzuki too. For several years now we've been able to speculate on the rest of Ichiro's career and project him somewhere very close to 3000 hits. It's never seemed clear cut either way which is fun. At the end of July, however, it was not looking good. He was sitting at 2901 hits, but was batting under .250 with only 57 hits on the year. It seemed probable that it would take him another 2 seasons to reach 3000, and his performance didn't make it likely that many teams would be interested in having him on their roster next year. But August has been different. August has been vintage Ichiro. He's already collected 20 hits while hitting at a .351 clip. Right now he stands at 2921 career hits and I'd say it looks pretty probable that he'll get to 3000. Here's my math: I'll assume that Ichiro stays pretty hot for the rest of the season. The Marlins will play him pretty often for the rest of August so he should have no problem getting 25-35 more at bats before rosters expand on September 1st. After that his playing time will probably drop off a bit, but if he's still hitting well he should still get 40-50 more at bats. If he finishes the final month+ hitting .300 and gets 80 more at bats he'll have 2945 hits at the end of the year. If he plays another year hitting around .270, he'll only need to get a bit over 200 ABs to reach 3000 hits. His overall line this year should be good enough that some team is willing to sign him next year and play him enough to get there; maybe the Marlins, maybe the Mariners, maybe someone else. It's still not a sure thing, but I'd put the odds at around 80% now, maybe even a little higher. Do you think he'll get to 3000?
-
MLB.com Twins Prospect Rankings
6 Twins on the top 100 list: Buxton - 1 Sano - 4 Berrios - 26 Jay - 76 Polanco - 89 Gordon - 91 Kepler was also listed as the 8th best 1B prospect
-
MLB.com Twins Prospect Rankings
Yeah I don't know, people stopped paying attention after his slow start in the first two months? In June and July Gordon has hit .301/.358/.386, right in line with a top SS prospect, and scouts really like his defense. He has to add some muscle still (hopefully), but he's still a top prospect.
-
MLB.com Twins Prospect Rankings
Most publications had Cabbage higher than Blankenhorn predraft, so this doesn't really surprise me. Also worth noting, Cabbage was on the young end of the high school class while Blankenhorn was among the oldest, so Cabbage may take a bit longer to develop.