Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Taildragger8791

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Taildragger8791

  1. I agree on Dozier, if there's good young pitching or catching talent to be had in a return. I guess I agree on Santana too but I don't see the market for him. Age/contract are going to work against him. Rather than get a mediocre player that's going to clog up a spot I'd rather let him continue to lead by example for the young pitchers, and provide a little stability so the bullpen can maybe get a break every 5 days.
  2. That sounds like a big assumption you made there. Just to provide some context, even if that did shave off half a run it would only take our starting rotation from the worst ERA in baseball (5.48) to the second worst in baseball. They would need to shave off another half a run to get just outside of the bottom third in baseball, and then almost another half a run to get well into the top ten. That's how far we have to go. And with all the work there is to do breaking in young pitchers and fixing our veteran ones there's little chance they will be significantly better than Nolasco, Milone, Duffey, or Dean were this year.
  3. Realistically, there aren't any options to turn over this rotation in one year other than getting Sandy Alderson liquored up at winter meetings and tricking him into trading Syndergaard and deGrom for Plouffe and Duffey. So we're going to just have to suck it up and relive this season again next year while we wait on options to develop, and yes it's going to be a bunch of try-outs and burnouts and 95+ losses. I doubt you'd get more back from trading Santana than you'll get from playing him. He provides some stability and mentorship to the other pitchers. I don't want to sell the farm for veterans. Dozier is the only chance to get some talent back but the 2B trade market may be weak with how strong that position has been this year, and it's rare for the Twins to sell high on a player, so I don't expect anything to happen. The only chance to improve this junk rotation is to swap out the coaching, because that's the biggest common thread between so many sub-par performances. You can't fire every pitcher on the team, especially when there is clearly some talent there. With that, then the hope is that next season provides clarity on these things going into 2018 on how to build a better rotation: Which Gibson is real, 2015 or 2016? I have my doubts but there isn't anyone pushing him out at this point so you have to let him keep trying, even if it hurts to watch.I'm not crazy about Santiago but he'll eat innings...maybe. If the money could be reallocated more effectively I'd be for cutting him though. I worry he's going to underperform and eat the money instead of innings like almost every other pitcher we've run through here. Whether that's due to coaching, defense, or a warlock's curse I don't know yet.Can Berrios make the leap?Can May start and hold up?Give Mejia a long tryout to see what we have thereAt mid-season, audition Gonsalves and later on Stewart to see what they look likeIf Jay has a big year at AA I'd be okay with giving him a little time later in the year, maybe out of the bullpen to startAlso: Put Duffey in the pen and let his two good pitches play upHughes also stays in the pen all year unless he suddenly goes "Rookie of the Year" and starts throwing fire. He's likely done as a starter.
  4. I noticed that as well. The wrist is bent more and the hand cups around the ball more. It adds up to a noticeable difference rather than just looking for the extended pinky.
  5. I didn't intent to be pedantic, but the way you phrased this heavily implied that you thought our prospects would shake out that way: "That six good prospects to go along with May.Granted, none of them look like an ace at this point but I will take two 2s a 2 ½, and two 3s and day over 5 guys that that represent the statistical average for 1-5 starters." Seemed pretty clear cut the way I read it, but my bad if that wasn't your intent. Anyways, I agree that's probably better than a prototypical 1-5 rotation but we're a long ways off from that scenario without some big luck. It would take most of our prospects hitting their ceiling, a great fast-moving college pitcher in the upcoming draft, and probably one more pitcher that currently isn't in the organization.
  6. That's extremely optimistic to think you'll get "two 2s a 2 ½, and two 3s" out of that group, and likely a #1 with the pick next year. The percentages just don't play out that way. Guys flame out or get hurt or just don't make the jump way too often. We haven't developed even a 3 in a long time. Realistically, you'll be doing great if you got a true 2, 3, and a 4 out of that mix. Also, the #1 pick in the draft may not even be a pitcher, and there isn't necessarily going to be an obvious ace available. Even if they get one it'll be a 3-4 years before they'd contribute. I'm not advocating for any action, I think the Twins have to hold steady, see who develops, and maybe make a couple smart trades if a great opportunity is presented. Finding an appropriate trade return for Dozier is the only big one I'd push for. I just can't get on board when people look at the farm system and assume quantity will settle out to a starting roster of studs. Especially with the way things have gone lately. The failure rate is way too high.
  7. It was enough sample size for the Twins to decide they couldn't make use of him and trade him off for petty cash.
  8. That's a lot of hair splitting to try and differentiate between grades of luck. I don't even have to see Dozier's scouting report to know that the scout didn't project him to have an all-time great power-hitting season for a middle infielder. He was 165lbs when drafted, at shortstop mind you, and he hit 14 HRs in his entire minor league career. He was likely projected to have gap power with enough pop to sneak a few out. Anyone who sniffed hope for 20+ HR power this would have drafted him far sooner due to the positional bonus.
  9. I'm still bothered by the fact that we apparently couldn't get any use out of Worley, who's been a pretty effective pitcher everywhere except his stint in Minnesota. Hell, his ERA was 3 runs higher here than at any other point in his career. What the hell are the Twins doing to ruin pitchers?
  10. I'm not sure what your point is. The Twins certainly deserve credit for drafting Dozier, but even after a few years in the majors, and even up until 3 months ago, nobody thought he was a 40+ HR hitter. That aspect was blind luck.
  11. I don't think that the list of players you gave is comparable other than Dozier who is a blind luck steal if the power keeps up. The rest of those players, and their 1st rounder Gibson, could easily be on their way out of baseball in 2 years. They'll get a bunch of opportunities since they have some talent and this team is non-competitive, but that doesn't put the class at the same level as Rosenthal, Carpenter, Miller, & Adams. I don't care about cup of coffee guys or non-impact players when evaluating the draft/development results. Those guys don't build playoff teams and that should be the standard we're looking to achieve.
  12. So...pretty much the same thing as Blackburn and Slowey then. Partial rookie season with not much to show, followed by a couple of 2-3 WAR seasons, then falling off a cliff and never really recovering. Fangraphs WARs: Slowey: 2008: 2.7 2009: 1.4 (short season) 2010: 2.3 [insert cliff] Remainder of career: 1.2 Blackburn: 2008: 2.0 2009: 2.4 [insert cliff] Remainder of career: -0.4 Gibson: 2014: 2.3 2015: 2.5 2016: 0.6 [nervously putting on parachute while looking out for cliff] I think you can see why pointing to Gibson's first few years isn't all that inspiring.
  13. I'm curious why people hold Gibson up as a draft success, unless they're just talking about guys who reached the majors and aren't considering their impacts. We're looking at a career 4.63 ERA & 1.40 WHIP with one good season. He's going to be 29 next year and is trending the wrong way. If we've seen the best he'll ever be then he'll be just another fizzled-out short-lived starter like the Blackburns and Sloweys that we've gone through over the years.
  14. I guess that's part of why we're on different pages. I'm hoping this team can build for a run of dominance instead of holding on for hopes of sneaking into a 2nd wildcard spot and then getting smashed in the playoffs like we did through the mid 2000's. Those division wins feel tarnished when you look at how weak the division was and how thoroughly outclassed they were in the posteason.
  15. This is where I agree, if Dozier can't get the return we think he's worth then we have to keep him. And I also agree that this staff doesn't have many people's trust to develop the young pitchers we may get in return. But if they can get the right players then they should still pull the trigger and try. This team has a decent offense but their ceiling is severely limited by the rotation. I don't think expecting the existing guys to "just do better" is realistic. They've mostly proven who they are at this point and they're all mediocre MLB starters except for Santana and maybe Berrios (hopefully). If we go into next year with the same staff it's likely going to be another miserable season of up and down stretches, where the 'up' is limited to competent-but-not-great and the down is as low as blown-up-by-5th-inning. Few offenses can out-hit slumps that deep.
  16. That's another mischaracterization of the situation. The implication wasn't that Dozier led to the 100+ loss season, it's that even as good as he is this is still a 100-loss team. That's how far from contention they are. They need multiple players who can contribute within a couple years and into the future. They ideally could trade Dozier to get those players, while freeing up that $15-$20 million to go out and reinforce an underperforming position where we don't have in-house solutions (SP, C, maybe SS/3B down the road).
  17. I'm not sure why you phrased it that way, because that's not at all representative of the Twins situation. They didn't just "fall out of contention", they were never in the picture for contention (102-103 loss pace at the moment), they haven't been close to in the picture for 5 out of 6 seasons, and they won't be in the picture again next year if they don't get some serious improvement on the mound. Dozier is the best asset we have, and is a bit of a luxury as a slugging 2nd basemen who's going to be a free agent before this team turns around. We have other sluggers in the system, but we don't have a sure #1-#2 pitcher. How else do you propose to fill that gaping hole?
  18. It seems tough to believe that you don't have to catch much to learn how to play catcher. You can practice and chat with coaches all you like but there's little replacement for live reps, and experiencing the game situations and pressures. Garver is going to finish the year with maybe 60 games above A ball at one of the toughest defensive positions, where he was already raw at to begin with. How is it that he's supposedly ready to handle the big league staff with so little advanced-level experience? Unless he made huge progress he's going to need another year just to accrue maybe a typical full season's worth of starts above A ball. I don't know what the reasons are for not getting him more starts, but it's hard to buy that he's going to be ready for the majors until he gets more game time behind the dish.
  19. My bad. Misread your post. Was thrown off because you wrote Gonzalez instead of Gonsalves and got focused on the second part of your post. I don't have a problem with throwing out of the zone, but you have to have the right pitches to do it at a 35%-40% rate. Gibson can't fool hitters into chasing with his pitches so he has to live in the zone or walk guys, which is why he struggles sometimes. Hopefully Gonsalves has better stuff to keep getting swings and misses.
  20. If undisciplined AA guys are swinging at junk out of the zone that shows up as a strike, not a ball, so it's possible he's closer to 55%-60% of pitches in the zone and is getting bailed out with hacks. The high walk rate suggests that as well, but it looks to be improving. As Berrios is finding out you won't survive trying to get MLB hitters to chase fringy stuff out of the zone, so it's better to work on that now. Thankfully he seems to be improving at a good pace. Edit: I just looked at last night's box score and I see 66 strikes out of 105 pitches, not 73/42. That's definitely on the low side of where you want him to be. 2nd Edit: Disregard first edit. Tired eyes, my bad.
  21. I'm glad to see Gibson bounced back to have an efficient second half of the game, even if his WHIP is still up there. Now he just needs to finish strong and get that full 7 or 8 instead of petering out and making a sh-- show of it. Maybe he'll go Randy Johnson and take out the bird that jimbo was talking about!
  22. Gah. Even a #5 pitcher needs to be able to control a game like this against the worst offense in baseball. Especially when you're handed an early lead and your offense is threatening to pile on for you. Just put up a relatively clean 7 innings and your bullpen and rest of the team relax for once.
  23. I bet you didn't think it would be so soon.
  24. Braves are the worst offense in baseball for a reason. They've still got Gibson already up to 33 pitches and 3 baserunners, right on pace with his usual 6 inning 1.50 WHIP type of start. Hopefully he settles in now.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.