Everything posted by Taildragger8791
-
Article: Twins Blunder Polanco's Development
Gotcha. I just don't see 2B or 3B having any opportunities for him this year. Maybe 20-30 starts filling in for injuries and rest days. They're kind of stuck riding him out at SS to see if he can do it. It would be a waste to leave his stick and legs on the bench unless he's a total butcher at SS.
-
Article: Twins Blunder Polanco's Development
The thing I thought was odd about Polanco's handling is how he was used as an extra depth piece for the MLB roster whenever they needed another infielder. He was called up and down several times between 2014 and mid-2016 for stints of only a day to a week, sometimes not even to play but just to be there as bench depth. It's a highly unusual way to handle a really young and promising prospect. I'm not arguing that it messed him up (definitely not his bat), but it speaks to how little planning and forethought went into his development and the overall roster management.
-
Article: Twins Blunder Polanco's Development
And how was he going to contribute anywhere else as a Twin when Sano and Dozier are locked into their respective positions? If they weren't going to play him at SS then he's only going to start about 10 games a year, when Dozier needs a rest. Or he'll have to play out of position at 3B/OF and get maybe 40-50 games, which is pretty wasteful. At that point you may as well trade him for a bag of balls or something, at least then you're putting some value to work.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #4: Nick Gordon
I think the argument, at least for me, is that his OBP won't translate to the MLB level because he's going to get challenged in the zone to prove he can hit effectively and do a little damage. That could quickly become a sub-.300 OBP because nobody is going to walk him when the absolute worst thing he can do is flip a single over/through the infield. EDIT: If he hits for .300+ with pitchers challenging him then maybe he gets a little respect and keeps his OBP up, but he hasn't shown the ability to hit like that (like Revere did).
-
Article: Twins Blunder Polanco's Development
I'm curious where you think Polanco will be if Escobar is holding down SS. Barring a trade the only other place for him is on the bench or AAA (can't remember if he was granted a 4th option?).
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #4: Nick Gordon
I think that's an oversimplified view of his hitting. It's not so much that he can't hit at all, it's that he hits with the power of Ben Revere but without the elite base-stretching speed or contact ability. Even that meager career slash line of .264/.327/.309 will be difficult to maintain as he moves up and better pitchers challenge him knowing that he can't possibly do any damage. You're basically staring down a Pedro Florimon rerun. Gordon has considerably more contact ability and way power (only 11 XBH for Vielma in all of 2016), and he's even showing some potential as a run producer. They're about the same on base-stealing, maybe a slight edge to Vielma as of today. I just don't see how the two even begin to compare with the stick.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #4: Nick Gordon
I'm good with Nick Gordon at #4 due to his higher-than-usual floor. Not every position on the diamond has to be a player with an elite skill. Sometimes you just need a steady & reliable guy at a key spot. I think of him as ending up like a Denard Span at SS (good at everything but not elite or terrible at anything) and I think we'd be pretty darn happy about that.
-
Article: Twins Blunder Polanco's Development
Skills fade when you don't practice them, and you don't make a seamless transition from playing SS at AA two years ago to playing MLB SS today. It's supposed to be a steady progression of development so players get used to the speed and other differences, ingraining the routine plays into muscle memory. Polanco has been jerked around over the last few years and collectively he has barely a season's worth of games at SS above A+ ball since 2014. The vast majority of those starts coming in 2014 & early 2015 at AA. Since then he's been yanked around the diamond and between levels and never got to settle into a position or role. He went from playing SS at AA to benchwarmer in MLB to 2B at AAA, then yanked back and forth between the last two until late last year when he finally got some regular time at SS. There was no progression/development towards MLB SS. They basically cut him off after AA. Maybe they had the right idea and he can't play the position, but I don't think even they know that for sure and it seems silly that they abandoned his development before they really knew. Particularly when his bat has been MLB-ready for over a year and every other position is blocked.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #5 Tyler Jay
...implying that Gonsalves isn't a little bit of a roll of the dice as well. He's really promising but he's getting by despite pretty notable control issues and a mediocre breaking ball. Likely due to having an advanced changeup that minor leaguers typically struggle with. Improving those two things will be keys to watch for in his development this year, because he has all the other qualities he needs to be successful in the big leagues.
-
Fantasy baseball article that is bullish as to Sano and Berrios
Not much analysis unfortunately. Just an observation about his control issues. But from what I recall it wasn't so much his control as it was major league hitters reading him like a book, thus ignoring pitches they didn't want and feasting on ones they did. Hitters didn't have to chase him out of the zone. There's definitely something else there that needs fixing before he'll be effective.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #6 Wander Javier
From everything I've read the DSL is below even GCL in competition level. I don't think you can draw any conclusions one way or the other from stats on 30 plate appearances there, that's such an insanely short sample size with no context for who he was doing it against. It suggests he was talented relative to the competition, which is good, but that's about it. We'll just have to wait for him to get into the GCL this year to see where his swing development is at.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
The walks weren't too bad (although I see 8th in AL for BB/9 and 13th for K/9), the problem last year is that we gave up a lot of good contact in addition to the poor strikeout ability. Getting in more favorable counts should help, but framing won't stop guys from barreling up fat pitches or get your sub-par defense to convert outs. We had far and away the most hits and highest BABIP and HR/9 in the AL. We were teed off on.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #6 Wander Javier
I considered that. The way I saw it is that both Buxton and Kirilloff played 48 and 55 games in the rookie leagues, respectively, with Buxton advancing to the Appy league after a couple dozen games and Kirilloff starting there. Both showed well enough as 18 year olds in advanced rookie leagues to go straight to low A in their first full season. So those rankings had more to go on in both cases. It's probably true too that, fair or not, top 10-15 picks get a little more pedigree credit than international players due to how much more we know about them at the time of acquisition (older in age, more game tape, typically played against better competition, more scouting history, etc).
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #6 Wander Javier
I agree he's exciting and he might be one of my new favorite young prospects to follow this year. I just don't know how you rank someone so high with nothing to go on except unrealized potential. He hasn't demonstrated anything remarkable in game action yet so it's pure projection based on above-average raw talent and limited DSL time. I understand getting enamored with the upside, but the floor/ceiling spread is enormous at this point and should be considered.
-
2016-2017 Wolves season
Wiggins is a 2 masquerading as a 3 right now and I don't know if he'll ever put on the 20-30 lbs he needs to muscle up against the league's best small forwards. That means he and LaVine can't be on the floor together for extended stretches of time, and I don't know if a max contract LaVine coming off the bench can work financially or chemistry-wise.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
Apparently KLAW really wants that credit for predicting Berrios' eventual failure.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #6 Wander Javier
Mike (edit: and markos) covered it pretty well. Javier and Gordon are 3-4 years apart developmentally and who knows what the MLB roster will look like in 4-5 years. You can't project baseball rosters that far ahead. That's why getting prospects is all about best player available, and let the chips fall where they may. If it causes a logjam then you have some good trade bait to rebalance things later.
-
What to do at Left Tackle?
I'd do everything possible to upgrade from Kalil, but I think we saw this year how much lower the floor is when you swap him out for just any guy. Bringing him back on a 1-year deal at least assures a minimum level of competence on the QB's blindside.
-
What to do at Left Tackle?
Do you even have to franchise Kalil? He might do a one year prove-it deal so he can cash in on a better multiyear deal next season. And where else would he have a better opportunity to showcase himself? If we can't sign someone else I'd certainly entertain that idea. You know you'll get the most motivated version of Kalil possible.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects: #7 Adalberto Mejia
That might be a more popular opinion than you think. I sense there's a little more positivity around Mejia since he's basically found money, being acquired in the Nunez trade instead of coming up as a top prospect that we invested heavily in (resource-wise by the team, and emotionally by the fans). I personally wouldn't mind seeing him in the rotation out of spring training if he shows well. I think the guy could be a decent back-end starter and if we don't audition him soon he's going to get passed up for opportunities by the crew at AA. But with the long list of guys ahead of him I'm assuming he'll be in AAA for a while, barring injuries. At least that'll create some drama so we get to have an interesting debate later this year on who the next call-ups should be.
-
Bark's 2017 MN Twins OF Insanity
Love the optimism and I think it'll be a fun group to watch this year. I think the AVG/OBP are a little high for Buxton and Rosario, particularly Buxton's OBP unless he greatly improves at drawing draw walks. The SB are a little high too. Buxton will need to become an on-base machine and increase his aggressiveness to steal over 30 bases, and I don't think Rosario gets enough opportunities between the low OBP and only averaging a 65%-70% success rate. I would think he'll need to get that up to 75% to get the automatic green light. Everything else I think represents the realistic upside of this group, and they'll be one of the best things to follow in 2017.
-
Article: 2017 Minnesota Twins Roster Projections - The Starting Pitchers
I don't know if I'd call the pipeline "poor" but it's certainly not above average either, yet. The fact that we have some names to talk about seriously is a big upgrade from where we were the last several years, but I think we also forgot that's how it's supposed to be. Teams are supposed to have a steady trickle of MLB-quality talent. Otherwise you end up with 90+ loss seasons on the regular. But to get even a top-10 rotation out of this system it'll take a couple of lottery hits, big trades, or top free agent signings (if there's even any available). I like that we at least have a couple of lotto tickets for a change, which provides some optimism. This pipeline could look a lot better at the end of the season if they start to pan out. I just hope the front office has contingency plans for the next couple of years if they don't.
-
A Different Dozier Topic...and something new for us to talk about
I don't think the team is going to have as much financial flexibility as you think if things pan out. The team will want to get Buxton and Sano under contract in the next couple years to control their arbitration costs and hopefully buy out some free agent time. That might be true of Polanco, Kepler, or Berrios as well. They'll need to acquire a top-end pitcher at some point unless we hit the lottery in a trade or the draft this year. And Dozier himself would be a $20 million per year player in 2 years if he continues to perform. He certainly wouldn't take a discount on the only big contract of his career. He's playing it smart and betting on himself to cash in on his production.
-
A Different Dozier Topic...and something new for us to talk about
Well we always heard from Terry Ryan that the Pohlads willing to spend more money and weren't restricting him. I guess this next 2-3 years will put that to the test.
-
Hammond Happenin
When does Punto slide (head first) into town?