Everything posted by Taildragger8791
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/17): All is Wells
-
Take a deep breath
I could kind of see that. And not as much pressure to go deep in the games in that case, since he'll be yanked for a PH by the time he'd usually be knocked out of an AL game anyways.
-
Take a deep breath
I'm not even sure Gibby is a 4-5 starter at this point. At least not on a competitive team. He consistently can't even go 6 innings, which is generally all you ask of back-end guy. Just be an innings eater and don't dig too big of a hole. Then he goes and puts the team in a hole and burns 3-4 relievers almost every time he's out there.
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
-
Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
This is the frustrating thing about Gibson that gives his supporters an opening to defend him. He manages to put up sloppy demoralizing games like this but doesn't typically get completely shelled. By the time he leaves you feel like he gave up 10 runs but really it was only 3-4 and left with runners on base in an early inning. Leaving just enough of an opening for those reviewing his stats to claim he's actually not that bad. And it looks like that first QS will have to wait for another day.
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
-
Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
As much fun as it's been to watch the Twins this year compared to last, and as much as I really want to watch a game even when I know it's going the wrong way, Gibson has an amazingly strong ability to make me want to tune out and go do anything else. I don't even get mad about it anymore, just disengaged and disinterested out of hopelessness.
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Indians 4-17 @ 7:10 PM CT
- Mitch Garver - 2017
-
Hicks for Murphy trade: 14 months later
I don't think the two situations really compare. There's a little less (although definitely still some) heartburn involved when a promising mid-1st round pick peters out at the level of a part-time player. Jay was the 6th overall pick and 2nd overall pitcher, and from day 1 had the likely ceiling of being a reliever. While both are useful players, the latter situation is (for good reason) seen as having left a lot more upside on the table by never even giving yourself a real chance at an impact player.
-
Hicks for Murphy trade: 14 months later
The implosion is certainly bizarre and the magnitude of the drop-off couldn't have been expected. But the severity of the drop-off also makes me believe there were some sort of critical flaws or warning signs that went overlooked in the Twins' evaluation of him. There's a reason the Yankees were giving him away. You'd hope that good scouting could reveal some of those reasons. I also accept that it's an inexact science and there's an information imbalance with the team that has the player and the team that is getting him. And sometimes sh*t just happens. I just wish it didn't seem like we were piling up more than our fair share of sh*t lately.
-
Hicks for Murphy trade: 14 months later
I can't get too worked up over the Hicks trade since neither he nor JRM are ever going to be quality players and the front office that executed the trade is gone. The only gripes I have are that it signaled a poor evaluation of talent in even bothering to acquire JRM considering how epically he failed, and it also perpetuated this routine of dumping the starting center-fielder just to prematurely promote the next unfinished CF prospect. And all that with no backup plan to maintain competence if the prospect needs more development. Hopefully the new front office pumps the brakes on that kind of impatience.
-
Hicks for Murphy trade: 14 months later
Sounds to me like Plouffe was the one actually blocking the prospects there. Also, Kepler had an option last year because they used it to start the season.