Everything posted by Taildragger8791
-
Rotation "Set"
I agree that Vargas isn't an established major leaguer, I just meant that he kind of is what he is and we have a good idea of what we're going to get with him. He's 26 years old and has been up and down for a few years and is basically at sink-or-swim time in the major leagues. As for Berrios, if he is making serious adjustments to his delivery then no, I don't think he'll get to work on that as well because his primary focus will be winning games. Not to mention that he won't get as many innings/appearances in WBC as he would in ST. I also don't think we want random coaches on his WBC team screwing with his delivery and mechanics (remember complaints about last year when every Joe Blow had access to him to give advice?). The Twins' coaches are in the best position to monitor him and provide feedback on his progress, and he can throw whatever pitch as much as he needs to instead of worrying about game results and situations dictating his pitching. What if he reverts to his old form he's comfortable with and gets blown up all spring? Even if he reverts and succeeds, then he comes back to us a mess and will have to go to AAA to start over again so he can learn to reliably get actual MLB hitters out.
-
Rotation "Set"
Berrios is in a critical phase of development trying to transition from AAA wonderboy to MLB regular. This is an important time for him to be working on his adjustments he needs to make to be effective in the big leagues. Taking off to go pitch in the WBC, where he isn't getting critical instruction and feedback from his coaches and may not be building up the requisite arm strength he needs will naturally set him back. Berrios is also on the roster bubble, mostly because of those struggles, and by not competing or showing the coaches he made the necessary adjustment he's naturally put himself at a disadvantage in that 5th starter competition. That's his choice to make, and he made it. Santiago is a vet and is what he is. Vargas and Rosario are more established and known quantities and don't have any serious competition for their roster spots (whether or not they should is another issue). So these guys going off to the WBC for a while isn't much of an impact as long as they are professional enough to get themselves ready.
-
Don't Fret About Twins Prospect Rankings
If it was truly intended to be a strict rule then the punishment should have reflected that. Instead it was implemented as more like a soft cap and a luxury tax, something that's existed in sports for a while and a handful of teams exceed when it's deemed to be worth it. Personally, I think it's a dumb system and I'm glad they changed it. But I'd be lying if I didn't admit that one reason I dislike it is because the Twins would never have the gumption to exploit it like other teams did. And let's not pretend like the Pohlads aren't adroit businessmen who are used to exploiting byzantine rules/laws/systems for their benefit. Heck, you don't have to look any further than Target Field to see one prime example.
-
Don't Fret About Twins Prospect Rankings
I don't think it's fair to call it cheating. The system was created and agreed to by all teams. And the smart teams realized that it was more beneficial to accept the costs of exceeding their allotment than it was to stay within it every year. It's not "cheating" because anyone else was free to do so too. They didn't break a firm rule and try to get away with it, like paying players under the table. They played within the definitions of the system. It's no different than going over the luxury cap and paying a tax to do so.
-
Rotation "Set"
I kind of wish that system were changed a little. Make it so vested veterans can refuse assignment and walk away with 20% or 30% of their remaining contract and still get to be free agents. If they want their full remaining contract they can be sent down to clear 25-man roster space. They can always try to earn their way back, but this gives the team and the player some flexibility to move on from bad situations or at least make them better. I doubt many players want to be the albatross on a team who gets playing time or roster space based on his contract instead of his performance. Let him accrue MLB service time too if you want, I don't care. Just don't clog my roster. I'm sure this would open up avenues for abuse that need to be considered, but it's silly that teams are stuck reserving a roster spot for non-performing veterans just because their contracts by nature are expensive and guaranteed.
-
Rotation "Set"
I think that 2 WAR is basically Gibson's ceiling and his floor is obviously quite a bit lower, as evidenced by last year. 2 WAR shouldn't be the expectation, but the hope. My issue with him is he's so inconsistent. He seems to either give you a great game or sometimes short stretches of good games, or (more commonly) he's completely ineffective and gets lit up like a Christmas tree. When you average it all out it doesn't seem so bad but it hides how he taxed the bullpen and gave the team no chance to win in at least half of his starts. That wonderful 2015 that people like to point to as evidence that he's a good pitcher has some devils in the details. That season was anchored by a crazy strong month of May where he had a 1.36 ERA, something he has never come close to repeating (never within 2.40 of that in a single month again). He also had a couple of decent months at 3.73 and 3.93. Unfortunately he added three other months with ERAs of 4.84, 4.70, and 5.29. That speaks to what I was saying about how he can put together short competitive stretches (usually in the 3.70-4.00 range) but he'll also put up god awful stretches where he buries his team right off the bat. That's not a #3 pitcher and it's not a #4 pitcher on a good team. I'm not even sure anyone would accept that out of a #5 if they had playoff aspirations. Yes, I realize a month is a short sample size but it's the quickest and easiest way to illustrate how volatile of a pitcher he is, and how his overall numbers hide how ineffective he is in a significant proportion of appearances. If he put up a 4.40 ERA every month he'd be a much easier pitcher to live with as your #4 or #5, but the fact that he will single-handedly bury your team in half his starts is difficult to swallow. Edit: Disclaimer: No, I'm not advocating for cutting Gibson at this time. They're basically committed to trying him out this year to see if he can make an adjustment and recover his career. But he shouldn't be a lock to keep his position if he's sitting on a 5.00+ ERA mid-season and there are other young pitchers available to try out. He's not as proven or established and people like to believe and we need to keep looking to improve on his roster spot.
-
Article: Phil Hughes Shows Improvement In Second Spring Start
Hughes' salary shouldn't matter to anything at this point. That's a sunk cost. Put him in the position where he brings the most value to the team from a performance standpoint. Don't care if that's in the rotation, bullpen, or off the roster, but I hope that is the only aspect the team is considering.
-
Article: Phil Hughes Shows Improvement In Second Spring Start
I don't know why these names come up every time a pitcher lacks velocity. There's a reason Moyer and Radke were so exceptional. That's because it's really rare and difficult to be consistently successful without a good fastball. Hughes doesn't have a bag of tricks to throw at hitters, he has a fastball/cut fastball/curve and sometimes a change. The change is mid-80s, almost as fast as his new fastball, which doesn't work and is probably why he's all but scrapped it. And his delivery doesn't have much deception to it. So...long story short he needs a real fastball.
-
Article: Phil Hughes Shows Improvement In Second Spring Start
Not necessarily. Pitchers can be behind their regular season form while hitters can be even further behind, thus still putting pitchers ahead of hitters. That makes sense when you think about what all goes into hitting vs. pitching. Hitters have to knock of rust on their swing mechanics and timing, pitch recognition, picking up spin and movement, reaction time, etc. Pitchers are mostly building up arm strength and regaining feel for their motion and pitches. Hitters have to react and be near perfect to have success, meaning often times the pitcher just needs to get the ball to the plate to have a good chance.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Twins Win in Clearwater
I don't think Sano's strikeouts stem from a lack of work ethic, but they do concern me since I was hoping for improvement on that front. I'd expect that if his K's were going to get better then he wouldn't be already striking out constantly against rusty pitchers and minor leaguers throwing with restricted repertoires. Maybe he's just gotten by with his plate approach for so long that it hasn't been proven to him yet that it's an issue. And it's possible he's right, but this year will be a good litmus test on where he's at and how effective that approach can be. He's coming into his 3rd year, healthy and in shape, and at his preferred defensive position. There isn't much of an excuse to underperform.
-
Vikings will not pick up AP option
I think Latavius Murray would be a perfect fit. All around back and a great pass blocker. That would be a sight for sore eyes around here.
-
Game Thread: ST game #6 - Twins v Pirates, 3/1 @ 12:05pm CT
I think I've at least heard of this Gonsalves guy.
-
Game Thread: ST game #6 - Twins v Pirates, 3/1 @ 12:05pm CT
Yeah in the end it balanced out, but as a broke college kid and broke new grad it still felt less painful (especially considering gas prices at the time). Premium isn't so much a rip-off as people just misunderstand what it's for. It's for high compression engines, common on sports cars, German cars, motorcycles, etc. Putting it in the family car or SUV is quite literally burning money, however. And I'm not aware of any vehicles that need the mid-level octane, typically everything is fine at 87 or is optimized to run on 91+.
-
Game Thread: ST game #6 - Twins v Pirates, 3/1 @ 12:05pm CT
When I lived in Iowa and South Dakota I almost always got the middle one, because that's the one with the 10% ethanol blend and it was cheaper than regular gas (I assume due to tax subsidies as well as proximity to the ethanol plants and corn production).
-
Berardino: Napoli was almost tempted to join Twins
The Twins having 5 legit DHs would be very surprising and welcome news to the Twins management and fans.
-
Article: Minnesota Baseball Goes Back Inside
Interesting that they show dirt around the bases in that graphic but didn't do it for real. I wonder if it's too difficult to clean it out of the fancy pants field-turf without damaging it?
- Article: TD Top Prospects: #1 Fernando Romero
- Article: TD Top Prospects: #2 Stephen Gonsalves
-
Dozier to the Cubs make some sense for both teams?
I understand all that. But it's one thing to project a breakout year for a guy and a whole other thing to project becoming an all-time great 2B, which is the territory you'd be dipping into. It's an extremely high expectation that isn't even fair to the player.
-
Dozier to the Cubs make some sense for both teams?
Improves...in what way? Improving on last year's numbers would be near record-setting and MVP frontrunner territory. That's difficult to project for anyone without an extensive track record of performances like that. I could maybe see improved consistency & peripherals, but not necessarily his season-ending stats. Personally, I don't see Dozier getting traded at all this year barring a league-wide injury epidemic at the position. We simply won't get the premium return we want. There are too many options that teams can go get and plug in due to the glut of 2nd basemen across the league right now. It's a luxury for most non-competitive teams to carry a great second basemen and someone would happily flip a guy to a contender for less than the Twins would need.
- Article: TD Top Prospects: #2 Stephen Gonsalves
-
Hammond Happenin
If we hear about a flu bug taking out the whole team this weekend I think we know who to point the finger at...
-
Berardino: Sano working to take on 3B
286 is awfully high for any athlete under 7'0" that doesn't have a position listed as OL or DL. Even if that were pure muscle (unlikely) it would be unnecessary for a baseball player. At some point more muscle is just getting in the way. Miguel Cabrera was reportedly up to 285 and got down to 255-260 when he had to switch back to 3rd. He managed to do okay. If Sano at his age and athleticism can get down to 260 and stay there then he shouldn't be too physically limited. It'll come down to technique and skill more than anything.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #3: Alex Kirilloff
I feel like this is a poor trolling attempt or something. The article was written by Seth, not Jeremy. Your post strongly implied that Alex Gordon had the same walk rate of 4.7% and then tried to bait everyone into discussing it. But that assertion was patently false because Alex Gordon has always had strong walk rates even with his extremely aggressive promotion schedule after being drafted. Edit: After evaluating a little further I realize you made an error when you said "Alex" Gordon, when you apparently meant Nick Gordon. I'm still not sure what discussion you were trying to prompt, but that at least clears up the mistake.
-
Article: TD Top Prospects #4: Nick Gordon
Coming from a family of professional athletes lends credence to a player's athletic pedigree. Lots of professional athletes come from families full of other athletes. Whether or not the mental part of the game comes along with it is a crapshoot, but it certainly doesn't hurt that someone grew up around the game. Watching how professionals conduct themselves and train, absorbing information and the environment, etc. Again, it doesn't mean a guy can hit a curveball, but it takes some doubt out of the overall equation and builds confidence with respect to other important qualities of a player.