Everything posted by Deduno Abides
- Article: Twins To Sign Lance Lynn
- Article: Twins To Sign Lance Lynn
- Article: Twins To Sign Lance Lynn
-
Topkin: Jose De Leon to have Tommy John surgery
Knoblauch 1998-2002: 6.2 fWAR, expensive contract, head case. Milton 1998-2002: 13 fWAR, cheap contract Guzman 1998-2002 includes a year of -3.1 fWAR when he was forced into the SS too young for a base 1999 team, but he must have been better than the available options and he produced positive fWAR on a cheap contract over the full period. Knoblauch wanted and needed to go and the Twins got better value in exchange. Knoblauch did participate on winning Yankees teams, but [OPINION WARNING] the Yankees likely could have won with someone else. Knoblauch’s year in KC was veteran yuck. Haven’t looked into Milton as much, but it seems he became injured the year before he was traded and then fell off a cliff. Each of Punto and Silva had more fWAR than Milton over the next four years (2004-2007), at collectively much lower salaries. Milton was out of baseball in 2008, a year when Punto produced 2.8 fWAR for the Twins and Silva got a $48M contract from the Mariners (which the Twins wisely side stepped). The winner in both deals was the recipient of the prospects.
-
Topkin: Jose De Leon to have Tommy John surgery
Here are some veterans who were traded for prospects, when the team receiving the prospects probably “won” the trade. Note that many good examples of the opposite can also be found. 1. Frank Viola 2. Chuck Knoblauch 3. Eric Milton 4. A.J. Pierzynski
-
Topkin: Jose De Leon to have Tommy John surgery
Assuming front office types are reasonably smart, if it was usually a good deal to trade prospects for veterans, wouldn’t the deals stop, because teams realized that the side of the trade that got the veteran usually won? Once you start excluding certain types of deals from the analysis, you’re usually just cherry picking facts to fit a predetermined conclusion. BTW, the 2016 Cubs would probably happily do again the trade of two veteran pitchers for Addison Russell.
-
Topkin: Jose De Leon to have Tommy John surgery
Not fully understanding your comment about Bagwell and Smoltz being traded mid-season. Even if they were traded on April 1 for the veterans in exchange, getting the prospects would have been better. Trading Ramos for Capps is defensible, but it does not support an argument that it’s better to get veterans and trade prospects. Regarding the Rays, it may be that Dozier > De Leon > Forsythe. It may also be that that they made an error in judgment. It may also be that the Rays have a unique situation that causes them to weigh non-talent factors more heavily than other teams do.
-
Topkin: Jose De Leon to have Tommy John surgery
I would bet it’s close to 50-50. It is a mistake to think there’s a clear rule or pattern, instead of having to measure each potential deal individually. Of course, that may not be as fun for hot takes.
-
Topkin: Jose De Leon to have Tommy John surgery
There are many examples of when this reasoning doesn’t work, such as Smoltz, Bagwell and Wilson Ramos. Even Archer, for whom many people would like to trade a boatload of prospects, was twice traded with other prospects in exchange for established players - Mark DeRosa and Matt Garza. The current management of Cleveland and the Cubs probably wishes those teams hadn’t made those trades, but also realizes the trades are part of the reason why the previous management is previous. Judgment is required. You’ve got to know when to hold ‘em and know when to fold ‘em.
-
T-Wolves Regular Season Thread
One possible positive about Rose: Thibodeau runs his bench like he’s coaching Game 7 every night, which wears out his players and wastes people who don’t play. At least he will play Rose, which hopefully means more rest for the starters. Of course, having seen Thibodeau for a while now, Rose’s minutes will probably come at the expense of another bench player and the starters will continue to average 35-40 mg until such time as they are ruined.
-
Article: Twins Considered Favorites To Sign Lance Lynn
In another few days, the available free agents might not be signed in time to be ready before Santana. Of course, if Santana has any problems. . .
-
Article: Twins Considered Favorites To Sign Lance Lynn
That may be, but at least one of Mejia, Slegers, Hughes and Longibal Sanchez need to be at least adequate, or a fourth starter is needed.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Joe Mauer Will Give Up Hitting When You Pry The Bat From His Cold Dead Hand
Taking TR at his word, for sake of discussion, it’s hard to fault Mauer for trying things apart from Twins management and medical team at the time. They were awful at dealing with injuries. Separately, TR was awful at complaining about his players in the papers. There’s old school and then there’s a school marm and a pot bellied stove. On the other hand, although Mauer may not be a rah-rah guy, I can’t think of a single instance when he criticized anyone publicly, whether it was a teammate, coach or member of management, even after years of being the brunt of whispers and veiled shots. That’s an under appreciated good quality of Mauer’s.
-
Article: Twins Considered Favorites To Sign Lance Lynn
Not a fan of Lynn, either, but when you have only three starters you’re sure about at the beginning of the season and one of them has Kyle Gibson’s track record, you may make short term decisions you know you might regret later.
- Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: First Base
-
Kenley Jansen: Only 6 NL Teams are Trying this Season
The CBA should be improved, but I don’t see the evidence for a major problem here. Mike Moustakas, Lance Lynn and Alex Cobb not getting $80M deals? JD Martinez and Yu Darvish not getting $150M? Also, as Thrylos mentions, it seems like Jansen is undercounting. In the NL, four teams are sitting out free agency - Atlanta (waiting for prospects to mature instead of signing more Markakises or Dickeys), Cincinnati (aimless, hopeless), Miami (yeah, they’re tanking) and Pittsburgh (trying to have an upside of being a first round playoff loser while possibly being what is nicely called “cheap”). The other eleven teams are all making investments to win, either now or in the near future.
-
Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: First Base
Rooker could affect Dozier’s 2019 status, if it looks like he could replace Dozier’s offense at less than 5% of the cost, particularly if the Twins think Gordon could approximate much of Mauer’s offense (again, at less than 5% of the cost) and play competent MI defense. All of a sudden, $31M is available Alternatively, if Rooker can play decent OF, he could have at least as much trade value as Steven Souza, who brought back an apparently interesting lefty starter.
-
When do the Twins cut bait with Phil Hughes?
Newsfeeds tell me tonight is the finale of The Bachelor, so, tomorrow?
-
The 25th man
Can you believe that Chris Herrmann, JR Murphy and Anthony Recker are all battling for Arizona’s third catcher slot? At least one of them may be available at the end of spring training, if another head is wanted for Rochester.
- Romero Ready and Waiting for Twins
- Article: Uncertainty Continues To Follow Sano
- Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: Catcher
-
When do the Twins cut bait with Phil Hughes?
ftfy
-
MLB.COM Comes out with new top 30 prospect list
It’s probably a talent and age thing.
-
Article: Twins Fans Should Be Excited About Jorge Polanco
A lot of teams, with statistical models, are batting players like Dozier first or second. Perhaps the most similar hitter on the Astros is George Springer, who hits first. For the Twins, the expectation is that Sano will be a good clean-up hitter, batting behind Polanco and Mauer.