Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Deduno Abides

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Deduno Abides

  1. Colabello's 2013 with the Twins wasn't that different that Kubel's 2013 with the Snakes and Cleveland. In Colabello's favor are (1) can play in the field; (2) less injury history; and (3) recent minor league performance projects very well. Kubel's first half of 2012 (new league, homer-friendly stadium) is likely to be a mirage. Is anyone else curious about whether another team would sign Kubel if the Twins cut him? Which ML team would be a fit for him?
  2. A metric that can be used to forecast which players make the 25 man, when choosing between a veteran and a newcomer, is the number of times Twins management uses the word "proven." Use of that magical word seems to tremendously increase the value of the player being referred to and minimize the value of any player being sacrificed so that the team can retain someone who is "proven." The funny thing is that, if management were measured by what has been "proven" by performance over the past few years, it would not be retained. Instead, management is measured by qualitative factors, such as skills assessment and predictions of future performance. Nonetheless, it seems that players for the Twins are measured more by past performance. A corollary to using past performance to measure players is a hesitation to sell at the top of a player's performance and a tendency to bail on a player right before an upturn, but those are discussions for another thread.
  3. Old Nurse, you are of course correct that any injury that causes an athlete to miss 4-6 months of his or her career is serious. I'm certain that everyone wishes Iglesias a good recovery and a good career, as long as he goes 0-4 with a dropped double play ball every game against the Twins. News reports make it sound like Iglesias' stress fractures have been around for a while, dating back to his Boston days. News reports do not, however, seem to refer to "leg weakness." That's a TD inside joke based on the use of the words "bilateral" and "legs," which dredge up bad memories, to which we all now try to laugh about. We're all glad that reports of "bilateral leg weakness" in Joe Mauer a few years ago have not appeared to be permanent. Regarding Iglesias' injury, I'm not a doctor, nor do I play one on TV, but I'll stick my "leg" out and say that there may be many causes for stress fractures, but the most likely causes are overuse, insufficient rest and muscle imbalances. Playing baseball could actually be the final straw, even if played on a soft surface, if he had been doing a lot of straight-ahead fitness training during the offseason, such as running and weightlifting, which caused his body to be under general stress, and then the repetitive lateral and twisting motions involved in playing shortstop during spring training proved to be too much for the stressed muscles and tendons to handle. I would also opine - without research - that stress fractures may be more common in younger athletes, because they may have less awareness of their physical limits, causing them to push on when a more experienced athlete might back off, and because sometimes their musculoskeletal systems may not be completely developed, making them more susceptible.
  4. Causes of bilateral leg stress fractures: (1) Hustling to cover grounders that Miguel Cabrera should have fielded. (2) Watching too much cable TV news. (3) Scott Boras offered 10% of whatever Drew signs for. (4) Falling from a really high fence while longingly watching the Red Sox World Series parade. (5) Heels were too high on rookie dress-up day.
  5. This is good news. Assuming Gibson sticks in the rotation, it starts a march of major league quality pitchers from the minors to the rotation. Next is Meyer, and there are some very promising arms in the lower levels. (I predict May can be a major league quality reliever, but not a starter. Think Latroy Hawkins.) It has been a few years since home grown pitchers with more than a hope of sticking started appearing in the rotation. Also, the fact that there is debate about a pitcher people think is deserving but who didn't make the rotation (Deduno) is great circumstantial evidence of progress. By the way, long relief is a good role for Sam at the start of the season, based on his injury last year and possible changes to the rotation as the year goes on. This could be the Twins' strongest rotation in several years.
  6. In an article entitled, "Phillies Ruben Amaro Might Not Be Terrible Anymore," Grantland says one his best trades was Worley for Revere. http://grantland.com/the-triangle/mlb-warning-philadelphia-phillies-ruben-amaro/
  7. Agreed that the Twins value defense at SS, until such time they try to put someone like Michael Cuddyer at the position in order to squeeze in an extra bat. To my memory, (thankfully?) that happened at 2B, not SS. However, the issue isn't whether the Twins value defense at SS, but how well they assess defense. In the not distant past, J.J. Hardy was considered insufficient at the position, but since being traded away he has won the past two Golden Glove awards. To add self-inflicted damage to self-inflicted damage, we all remember and don't miss the defensive quality of Hardy's chosen replacement. Regarding Florimon, sometimes he "looks" like he could hit better. Good athlete, good speed, calm demeanor. Not sure exactly why he can't get two or three better at-bats each week. Also, regarding his defense, although we can argue whether or not the word "elite" is the appropriate semantics, there is not a reasonable argument against the assertion that he is one of the best in the league. I agree with other comments that he and Dozier had a good year last year. Also, if a team gets better offensive performance out of its corner infielders and outfielders, it actually can be a playoff team with a SS of Florimon's defensive caliber. Look at the Orioles when Mark Belanger was their SS. Sure, it would be great to have Troy Tulowitzki, but playing Florimon is not what holds back this team. Regarding Escobar, it appears he has potential to be better than Denny Hocking, Matt Tolbert and other scrappers that have received hundreds of ABs per year for the Twins. He can be a good UT and spot starter, and he, Florimon and Dozier may allow the Twins to focus their attention on other positions for improvement. If Santana gets it together, all the better.
  8. Some random thoughts: Catcher: Suzuki is signed to a one-year deal, which means that the intention is that he is here only to help with the transition to Pinto for 2015. However, it would be great to see Pinto on the team right out of the gate. This is based not on his strong September in the majors, but instead on his strong year throughout 2013 in AA and AAA. I'd like to see him start the year in the majors, with Suzuki playing the role of Henry Blanco or Junior Ortiz. The biggest issue I see with Pinto is health. He was injured last year, last fall and now, again, during spring training. I guess there could be a need to make sure he can stay off the DL for an extended duration before declaring him the full-time major league starter. Either way, Herrmann is not a bad back-up. If he can catch decently and manage to obtain at least a .650 OPS, he'd be middle-of-the-pack in league context and WAY OVER the Butera line. Infield: makes sense. Good to see Colabello's continued efforts to improve possibly bear fruit. Outfield: right now, only two players are likely for 2015, and two are possible. For Arcia, the upside goal has to be that he turns into a 30 HR masher, hopefully by 2015. 2014 should be all about whatever is best to position him for that future. For Hicks, with apologies to Satchel Paige, he better not look (go) back, because someone's (Buxton) gaining on him. If Hicks doesn't make it in 2014, he'll probably have at most until the end of May 2015 to be the Twins' centerfielder. He needs to show what he's got. If he plays OK, he can either move to left next year or be traded to another team in need of a good centerfielder. If he shows a good glove but only an adequate bat, a trade may be more likely, because left field may be saved for a run producer, either by free agency, or someone else coming up from the minors - Rosario? Vargas? Walker?? If Colabello and/or Parmalee show a healthy bat this year, they may also be candidates to be at least left field placeholders in 2015. The two question marks are Presley - will he be a good fourth outfielder in 2015? - and Parmalee - will he hit enough for the Twins to establish himself as a major leaguer or will he need to go somewhere else for free in hopes of becoming the next Garrett Jones? Not relevant to the 2015 plans are Willingham, unless he can be traded this summer for a prospect (thanks for a great 2013 and for being a likable player); and Kubel, who I would argue will likely not be relevant to 2014 plans, either. Look, we all liked Jason Kubel when he played here, but he's been injured repeatedly in his career, he's in the rapid decline phase of his career, and he really had only a good first half his first year in Arizona, when he was new to the league and playing in a hitter's park. If his .216/.293/.317 in 2013 was due to injury, what accounts for his 2012 second-half split of .201/.275/.470? Convert that performance from Chase Field (where his 2012 OPS was one hundred fifty points higher than his away OPS) to Target Field and . . . (shudder). Starters: do you remember that last year Vance Worley was the opening day starter? Do you remember that one of the biggest worries last spring training was Cole Devries' injury? Do you realize that 60 starts last year were by Worley, Diamond, Albers, Walter, Devries, Pedro Hernandez, and Liam Hendriks, all of whom would, at best, be the 13th pitcher on this year's staff? This year's staff is way better. Of course, TR didn't exactly go out and get in-their-prime versions of Roy Halladay and Cliff Lee, but we might now at least have . . . what? . . . a decent starting rotation? A shot at competence? This is the biggest source of hope that 2014 will be better than 2013. Also, if any of the five listed by Seth - I would hope for the same five - falters, then we will have pitchers in AAA, who, while perhaps unproven, have a good chance to perform at least as well as the starters of the sundry sixty from 2013. This includes Meyer, Gibson, May, and possibly Darnell. Relievers: not a bad list. A few trade candidates, including Burton, Fien and Duensing, but trades would be more likely in June or July than during spring training, when teams may think a middle reliever is what they need for the playoff chase. There is depth behind this list, including Guerrier, Pressly, May (I think he's better fixed long-term for relieving - Latroy Hawkins, anybody?), Tonkin, Ibarra (they must see something in this guy), Hoffman, and the several lefties that the team has collected. Even Gibson should be considered a relief candidate, if the starting rotation performs adequately; there should be no reason for him to spend the year in Rochester, unless there's an injury or trade by mid-June, he should be in the majors in some role, unless he proves not worthy. Many of these pitchers could plug in after a trade of the veterans with little loss of performance. In fact, some of these pitchers may actually have more upside than Burton, Fien or Duensing, at lower cost. By they way, when do we start counting the salary that will come off the books before 2015 so we can start guessing which free agents could be good fits?
  9. A lot of executive decision-making is based on "how will I look if the decision is wrong," which is often given more weight than "what gives us a better chance for success." In sports, a common manifestation is to play veterans instead of rookies. An earlier comment to this thread was to the effect that wanting Pinto to start ahead of Suzuki could show a short memory as to Hicks' performance last year, as if one rookie failing to jump from AA to the majors suggests that all rookies should get more seasoning at AAA before going to the majors. Besides the fact that Pinto performed successfully last year in AAA, major league (and Twins) history is full of players that successfully started on opening day in their rookie years, many of whom with little or no AAA experience. However, if that rookie bombs, then fingers get pointed at management, for wrongly placing the young player in harms' way, whereas if a veteran doesn't perform well, then the player seems to bear the brunt of the blame, under the theory that he failed to live up to past performance. The decision-maker is the same person, but starting the veteran seems to pose less risk to the decision-maker, because there is a greater acceptance that starting unseasoned players, while possibly being higher reward, is also higher risk. This decision-making bias will be even stronger when a recent event shows the risk of of starting the unseasoned player, even if it could be proven statistically that choosing a rookie would lead to a better result the majority of the time.
  10. At least five players are likely to have their statistical rookie seasons in 2015 - Buxton, Sano, Meyer, Rosario and Santana. At least three of these will be among the most heralded Twins rookies since Mauer and Mourneau, and, collectively, it will be the strongest rookie class since 1982 with Hrbek, Bruno, Viola, etc. This matters to decisions about the 2014 roster because it could cause acceleration of other players onto the team, so that not too many players are having statistical rookie years at the same time. Players such as Arcia, Pinto, Hicks and Gibson should be given every chance to establish themselves as major leaguers in 2014, so that not too many players in 2015 are going through rookie-related issues, such as figuring out how to handle themselves in the major leagues, being calm in the locker room and simply getting special attention from coaches. Also, players who may still have some upside in their careers and possibly contribute in 2015, such as Parmalee, Escobar and Herrmann, should also get a more-extended opportunity to prove whether or not they can contribute. Veterans clearly on the downside, such as Kubel and Bartlett, or those on the sorry-but-it-never-really-happened side, such as Ramirez and Fryer, should get less of a chance than was given to previous fill-ins such as Tony Batista and Juan Castro. If they can't prove during spring training that they are clearly superior options to players who have possible growth, they should not be given a tenured position (like a scholarship) based on career accomplishment. If a veteran shows good talent during spring, great. Otherwise, all else being equal, someone scrapping to establish himself as a major leaguer will be a better fit for the 2014 Twins - and probably result in a better w/l - than someone trying to extend his career for one or two more years.
  11. Even if the surgery had been in November, this is more unfortunate for Miguel Sano in 2014, but of limited importance to the Twins in 2014. However, it could turn out to be good news for both Sano and the Twins in 2015. You'd think it would go without saying, but some comments seem annoyed that he did not have surgery earlier. Surgery is painful and all surgeries have risks of being effective or worse, even if done by the best surgeon, and recovery is lonely and a lot less fun than playing a game like baseball. There is also continued doubt about whether you will lose your fitness or technique. His schedule makes complete sense - he should, as he is doing, take a few weeks to relax and see his family, because once he has the surgery, he is going to commence a well-established, but arduous path of recovery. All of us need to wish him well as he goes through this process. Second-guessing the timing doesn't help anyone and is also based only on the weak circumstantial evidence of "they seem to have been wrong before; therefore, I think they were wrong this time, also." However, even if the timing was wrong, it is of little impact on the Twins. If Sano had had surgery in November, as some comments suggest, AND, if he had recovered sufficiently to play for the Twins after 8-10 months AND play well, his impact on the Twins in 2014 would have been small. Last year, Trevor Plouffe was a 1.9 WAR (BRef). Miguel Cabrera, in his rookie year (which could be one of the best comps for Miguel Sano), was less than a 1.0 WAR (BRef). At best, if he had surgery, Sano would have played half a season. Even if - in that half-year - he produced better than Cabrera did in his rookie season and Plouffe has a bad year (my guess is that Plouffe has an OK year this year), the difference between them would have been small, so the impact of Sano on the team in 2014 would have been small. Frankly, the best chance for Sano to meaningfully impact the Twins in 2014 would have been for rest and recovery to have succeeded, so that he could play the full year. Now, he is going to spend a year getting in shape. He's going to work on strengthening exercises that he may not have been able to do this past year, out of worry that they would have hurt him. He's also going to feel like he has something to prove, likely even more than he does regularly. When he comes to 2015 spring training, he'll likely have a chip on his shoulder that meets Gardy's newly stated preference for players with attitude. Unless there is a setback in his surgery or recovery, he will make it clear that he belongs in the majors in 2015. There is precedent. In 1994, Chipper Jones was about to start his rookie year as the Braves' third baseman when he tore up his knee. He missed the whole year, but came back the next year and was a major contributor to the Braves' winning the World Series. For a non-pitcher, a knee is worse than an elbow. Although it is tough to predict a World Series for a team that doesn't have a pitching staff equivalent to Maddux, Glavine, Smoltz, etc., it seems realistic that Sano could have an impact on the 2015 Twins equivalent to the impact Chipper Jones had on the 1995 Braves.
  12. Trevor May should be considered to go North with the team in a long relief role. Predicting pitcher success and health is difficult, but, as of today, the Twins' 2015 rotation will likely be composed of Nolasco, Hughes, Pelfrey, Gibson and Meyer. At least one of Deduno, Worley and Diamond likely will also be around. That slots May in, at best, the seventh starting position for 2015, while there are also other starters that are rising through the organization and could be ready to pitch in the majors in 2015. Therefore, keeping May as a starter may not be in his or the team's best interest. Reports are that May has a talent that would be unique on the 2014 Twins - a heavy fastball. The AFL provides a small sample, of course, but he had great stats as a reliever last fall. Promising pitchers on Earl Weaver's Orioles used to begin their major league careers in long relief. May's fastball is going to slow down as he ages, so this may be an opportune time to take advantage of his talent by initially using him in appropriate situations. If he succeeds, he can move either into the rotation or into a higher-leverage relief role. If he doesn't succeed initially, he could still go down to Rochester and work on the lessons he learned in the majors.
  13. Bad trades? What about Tom Brunansky for Tommy Herr? For the current regime, it wasn't technically a trade, but everyone would probably like to go back in time and retract David Ortiz in exchange for spending reduction.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.