Everything posted by Jham
-
Game Thread, Twins @ Indians, 8/8 @ 6:10 pm CT
Oh ok. THAT'S why we have 9 relievers. It's like we already knew. ..
-
Game Thread, Twins @ Indians, 8/8 @ 6:10 pm CT
You were half right. Wish it were the other half.
-
Should we be worried about Twins starting pitching ?
Wait, wait, wait. Who exactly should the Twins called up to get experience over the last 2 years? What would your rotation have been last year and this year? May has been up. Gibson. Berrios has been on the fast track, likely to go through 3 levels by the end of the year. Sorry if I don't see Duffey and Rogers, and... and.... as guys I can count on this year, while we're still in a playoff hunt let alone 2 or 3 years out or however long it would take fringe major league starters to accumulate the 50 starts you want them to accumulate to reach their full potential as bottom of the rotation guys. I'm fine with them filling in in a few years if Hughes, Santana, Gibson, May, Nolasco, Berrios or the significant upgrade we should be trying to acquire fall that far. I don't think it will happen in the next couple years such that we should waste time allowing projects to struggle with the big club vs. honing their craft in AAA. Yeah, who doesn't want to see more Duffey... I hope he gets a shot to compete for bull pen spot next spring where he'd have a legit chance of helping the team. If he's truly an MLB ready prospect arm, we should deal him as he'd be unlikely to contribute for several years for us.
-
Sano, Mauer, and Plouffe
0.0% is more likely. San Diego showed their reluctance to deal pieces that could help them last year. They were built to compete this year. If they traded Shields, it would be to either make their team better, or to get a significant prospect in return. I suggested something like Berrios + x for Shields for the same reason I would have been ok with trading for Tulo. Shields provides an immediate upgrade for at least a couple years. Berrios ceiling is probably right around a Shields if he ever gets to that point. I'm not necessarily interested in seeing Berrios struggle through his rookie year and league adjustments while the rest of the rotation will be gone by the time he gets good. Everyone says we have too many 3/4 starters which is pretty much what Berrios figures to be, at least for a couple seasons. If we're going to try to make a run next year, a 1/2 type at the front will probably be necessary once we got into the playoffs.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins @ Indians, 8/7 @ 6:10pm CT
Decent time to get may stretched out. ..
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins @ Indians, 8/7 @ 6:10pm CT
Bunt? Indians love their pitcher, respect pelfrey, or not respect our offense. I'll say the last one.
-
Article: Struggles Have Highlighted Twins Correct Deadline Decisions
Aside from getting one of the very best in the game, if this trade highlighted anything, it's that you can overpay for a player in his prime and then trade him for an even better player if you're willing to take the chances. People forget that quality free agent or trade acquisitions can be traded if necessary, as long as you're willing to eat some celery, er... salary. You know unless they get injured bad or are Joe Mauer. Also, getting the best of the best always requires overpaying. You can go through your whole life drinking Jack Daniels and Kendall Jackson because the difference between a $200 bottle and $25 bottle might not be $175 worth. Or a Perkin's steak vs. a Manny's steak. That's fine, but then you'll die having never had a great wine or a perfect steak.
- Article: The Real Downside Of Buxton's Injury
-
Game Thread, Twins @ Blue Jays, 8/6 @ 6:07pm CT
Frustrating series after an otherwise fun year...
- Twins Should Call Up & Platoon Kepler NOW.
-
Article: Struggles Have Highlighted Twins Correct Deadline Decisions
I'll disagree on the "wait and see" premise with prospects because I believe, right or wrong, that we have an advantage over every other team in baseball when it comes to evaluating our own talent. We see who has the work ethic, attitude, and general health to make it. We know who stays out too late, who won't stop eating, who won't quit drinking, who won't take coaching, and perhaps those who are an injury waiting to happen. If we "wait to see" if they succeed in the big leagues, we lose much of that advantage. Teams and fans alike can see what kind of player you have by watching Sportscenter. There were many Twinsdaily posters who were looking at Meyer the last couple years and hinted that he might be overrated by national prospect lists. I remember being shocked when I actually saw Delmon Young play, because he in no way looked like the number 1 prospect in the game. The Rays had to have seen that. We couldn't look past some sweet stats. Not that the eye test is the best way to access a player, but it's clear all of baseball viewed Delmon in higher regard than he probably deserved. Regarding standing pat, I do not see the team improving a ton internally. Our biggest holes in the bigs are our biggest holes in the minors. We don't have a true ace. We don't have any lights out bull pen guys (Tonkin and Achter are NOT major league difference makers), we have no high-end shortstop, and we have no catcher of the future. We can try to trade for one, but then why not trade now when they can help with a playoff run vs. trading after the season? This leaves free agency, the Twins had better be very active in this regard next year. And be ready to sell high on some guys before the deadline next year.
-
Can we discuss Molitor and his bizarre obession with bunting?
I like our chances with Hunter, Hicks, and Dozier with 2 on and no outs better than Robinson, Hicks, and Dozier with Robinson being counted on to get a bunt down (which he did), but that was far from a guarantee. Hunter probably should have pinch hit for lefty Hicks as well. Hicks has been better of late from the left side, but I like Hunter's experience in that spot.
-
(almost) time to trade Plouffe for a catcher
We've got good veteran pitching for once. I think we need to take advantage of this window. Trading a top 12 3rd baseman for probably a bottom 1/3rd catcher seems like a surefire way to make the team worse in my opinion. Getting a veteran catcher makes more sense, but we already have one, and more can be signed in FA. McCann is going to catch in Detroit. Avila will want Avila to test free agency and make the most money he can. Unless we get a catcher who should at least be in the top half of the league next season, I think we need to roll with Suzuki, Pinto, and take a run at a FA.
-
(almost) time to trade Plouffe for a catcher
Well, I did state that Zuke is already under contract. Not ideal. But if no one on that list of free agents excites you, then I ask, how good are catchers around the league if none of the options are better than Zuke? Seems to me that having a great hitting catcher is a luxury, not a necessity. I'm just not cool with trading Plouffe (or anyone for that matter) for a worse overall player simply because we don't like the performance of our current catcher who must not be that terrible if you don't see any improvement through FA outside of Avila or Wieters.
-
(almost) time to trade Plouffe for a catcher
Trading Plouffe would make us worse defensively by a large margin, worse offensively by a large margin, and probably net a player who requires some grooming. Take Plouffe out of the line up to replace him with a catcher? No thanks. Oh, unless we have another DH who can step in and hit like Plouffe or Sano. Here's a list of catchers who will be FA after the season: Alex Avila (29) Chris Iannetta (33) John Jaso (32) George Kottaras (32) Jose Molina (41) Dioner Navarro (32) Brayan Pena (34) A.J. Pierzynski (39) Matt Wieters (30) I'd actually be ok with almost any of them. Zuke is still also under contract, has done well with this staff. If the rest of the line up improves, he can be fine at catcher. Unless we can move Plouffe for a top 10 catcher in the league, I'm just not seeing it.
-
Season is not over
Maybe. Berrios won't have Hughes, Santana, Gibson, May, Milone and Perkins saving games for him for 10 years though... I'm a big fan of Berrios. I think he should be in our pen right now and for the last month. Our first window to win is probably this year, next year, and 2017. If you want to bank on having things go according to plan 4, 5+ years down the line, great. If Berrios is as good as we hope, he'll want a long-term deal... and is that really better, and assuming global warming continues to have an effect on the concrete, and if the Republicans take back the White House next year.... Lots of ifs either way! At least now we have some options. That's a plus.
-
Season is not over
Would you bet on that rotation over Shields, Hughes, and Santana? (I'm assuming a berrios for shields trade). I guess it depends on whether you believe Shields is clearly better than the rest of our staff, and whether you think Berrios will be better than everyone we currently have. I'll admit that he could be, if you'll admit James Shields is currently.
-
Season is not over
Whoa, nice pieces with a couple potential stars... who's your starting rotation? Who's going to beat Kershaw or Gonzalez or Matt Harvey next year in the World Series? Even with Sano and Buxton and Arcia. Who is going to be a Cabrera or a Harper? Now the Royals got there last year by catching fire. And we could do that... but really, we could probably do that THIS year... (a couple additions needed). I mean, we could upgrade the back end of the rotation. But your 5 starter doesn't even start playoff games. I strongly believe we need to make upgrades with impact players next season. We've proven we can compete this year. Next year is time to win. We don't have an in-house ace. We don't have an in-house MVP candidate yet. Our pen is in shambles. Berrios isn't ready to be an ace. Sano isn't ready to be an MVP. You can win that way, but it's tough. The difference between us and the best team in baseball isn't Tonkin or Hamburger or Berrios or Arcia. I'm not sure any of that (other than swapping Berrios for Boyer) would improve the team let alone make us contenders. (I suspect Arcia is an upgrade over Robinson). I hope we didn't trade for anyone because we plan on buying hard in FA this year and making trades during the off season.
-
Season is not over
Who do we have in the minors who figures to be more than a bit piece on a contending team next year? Hoping a bunch of middle of the road prospects suddenly bloom into stars at the same time isn't going to work. Allowing guys like sano, buxton, and perhaps Arcia work through their youth makes sense if you think they're sure major league difference makers. Hoping for guys like Tonkin and achter to turn into playoff quality players. ..
-
May vs. Pelfrey The Actual Data and The Law of Unintended Consequences
I like the notion of trying to factor for more variables. SIERA is still based on general premises that may or may not be true in a pitcher's specific case (Fly ball pitchers limit HR, strike out pitchers have a higher GB/DP percentage). I also REALLY don't understand the idea that ERA is a flawed statistic, but SIERA and FIP are both attempting to predict future ERA... I'd rather see FIP predict future FIP and SIERA future SIERA. Why try to predict something we don't feel like using anyway? I also don't understand why taking defense out of the equation is so important when comparing teammates who play in front of the same 8 defenders... (Pace of play, ability to pound the strike zone, and your own ability to field the 1 spot may account for some variance, but those are pitcher controlled anyway)
-
So what's next?
Ummm... Jack Morris talked about how Tom Kelly said you needed to see a player for 3 years before you could really know what type of player you had. Danny Santana, Arcia, and Vargas all had big years/ half years last year. Look at what they did this year. Hicks, Sano, and Rosario all basically had lost seasons last year. So the premise of bringing up Parmalee and Hermann.... I mean Polanco and Swim or whoever... just to "see what we've got" doesn't do much for me unless you're hoping to build a contender in 3 years, or trade guys off if they come up and succeed in the short term. A good September against expanded rosters offers very little in the way of evaluation IMO. Given the steps we've taken this year along with the current construction of our pitching staff, we had better be looking to compete next year! People complained about our FA signings the last few years. IF we had played ourselves out of contention, there certainly would have been a market for Hunter, Hughes, Pelfrey, and Santana if we decided we wanted to sell. IF we had played ourselves into contention, guys unlikely to help for the next few years should have been somewhat expendable. As it were, we are sort of kind of contending for the fringe wild card spot a little bit. Veteran/prospect limbo. But organizational depth is great right now BECAUSE of the free agent signings. Veterans have value. Re: Veteran pitchers making way for "possible contributors", why sit proven guys to experiment with guys who might only be "possible contributors"? If we had a legit possible ace, that's one thing. The guys you're suggesting we replace them with have projected ceilings about where our current staff is currently performing. I was hammered in another thread for suggesting we use one of these projected starters to get Shields who would almost certainly be the best pitcher on our already decent staff. Re: giving guys a look now instead of "wasting next spring", we pay our scouts for a reason. They've been decent about telling us who is ready, and who isn't. The guys they've been reluctant to suggest have typically struggled in the bigs despite great MiLB numbers. The guys they've fast-tracked have generally done well, at least until the league adjusted. So if your question is would I rather "waste" this year's August/September trying for a Wild Card spot we're currently tied for, vs. using 2 months to plan my roster for next season and possibly wasting next year because of a rash decision to go young, I'd much rather continue our current course.
-
Blaine Boyer hot takes
We've tried cutting him, but every time we do, he stands outside Target Field and goes all....http://s3-ak.buzzfeed.com/static/campaign_images/terminal05/2012/4/19/11/john-cusack-is-down-for-a-say-anything-sequel-1-5166-1334850413-6_big.jpg on us, and our heart melts a little, and we take him back. Damn Peter Gabrielle...
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins @ Blue Jays, 8/3 @ 12:07pm CT
Bone... Donaldson... Robinson has been serviceable this year. I'm not going to knock his contributions. Arcia should probably be up to start for Hunter though.
-
May vs. Pelfrey The Actual Data and The Law of Unintended Consequences
If you want to total the innings and average them, great. I guess it depends on whether you like shorter possibly better starts, or longer possibly less effective starts. Pelfrey and May play in front of the same defense. Why are the results so different? Defense? I'll take Pelfrey's stretch over May's. This may change. Pelfrey seems to have lost the splitter which was a difference maker. All I'm saying is that Pelfrey's value is his ability to limit HR (shows up in FIP) generate double plays (doesn't show up in FIP) and go 9/20 starts 7 innings or more. May's biggest knock, like it or not, is that he hasn't gone deep in games, and that his walk rate and HR rate are far FAR below anything he's done in his career.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins @ Blue Jays, 8/3 @ 12:07pm CT
82 pitches through 4 innings? Plus fifteen pick-off attempts with Revere at the plate... Why do we start Robinson against Iwakuma, and Rosario against Price again?