Everything posted by Jham
-
Gomez to the Mets for Wheeler
Even when you two agree, you can't agree! There are many ways to improve your team. Is Gomez - Hicks > _________ - Esco/Santana or Santana/Esc for Dave, or ___________ - Suzuki? To me, Gomez is a significant upgrade, probably more so than any catcher or SS we'd be able to snag. The price seems pretty steep however.
-
Joe Mauer has a no-trade clause and will never play catcher again.
"Trevor May is our Ace, and the best pitcher on our staff." (based on peripherals), "But Ricky Nolasco is the worst pitcher and contract and we should pay teams to take him in a trade" (despite similar peripherals to May). The Twins need to clear out [proven player] in order to make room for [prospect(s)] who should just be handed the position regardless of team success, individual success, or entitlement because we "need to see what we have" after all, we're not REALLY going to contend until [current year plus 2-3 years]."
-
Article: They Couldn’t. Could They…?
I think this deal like this should be taken seriously. I wouldn't bet money that May or Berrios will be better than Shields over the next three years. I would bet money that Nolasco would be in the rotation next year regardless of what May and Berrios do in spring training. Look at the rest of the rotation. We had sure better be in win-now mode next season. Hu, Gonsalves, Thorpe, Berrios, Meyer, Jay, Stewart, Rogers, Slegers... We have arms. I'm happy to trade some of them to help the team win now and avoid the inevitable TwinsDaily '17 debate about Hu and Jay being blocked by an aging Hughes and Santana.
-
Is the farm system as deep as we thought?
The royal "we".
-
Waving the white flag on this roster
Ahh, hence the qualifier "probably". It's conceivable he's become one of the great control pitchers in the game. It's also conceivable that he could regress back toward his career marks in walks and HR. His high BABIP could be horrible luck or hard contact. A lot of posters seem to think it's a given that he can continue to post relatively low FIP and xFIP, but looking at his career marks as well as his game footage, I'm skeptical. Doesn't mean he shouldn't be in the rotation or that we shouldn't have ridden his streak of control and limiting HR. I just have some reservation about the expectations that he would be an ace or our best pitcher or even continue with the same level of success he's shown earlier this year.
-
Waving the white flag on this roster
May also has a (probably) unsustainable BB rate and HR run rate bringing down the FIP and XFIP. Not saying he shouldn't be in the rotation or taking away from his first half and improvement in control, just I don't think it's fair to expect improvement on BABIP and not expect some regression in walks and home runs which will inherently raise his FIP and xFIP.
-
Article: Don't Just Do Something, Stand There!
Prospects' value as trade pieces also go up and down. IMO, the Twins front office has been either a) poor at evaluating talent; poor at maximizing and nurturing talent; or c) too stubborn or passive in acting on a or b. If we're evaluating and nurturing talent correctly, we should have a great idea as to who may or may not be expendable. At least I hope we know our own prospects better than other teams. Looking back at our failed prospects. Almost all of them came with sneaking suspicions of over-hype long before their value started to plummet. Prospect rankings are often slow-to-react. We've had lots of coveted players and prospects who we held until their trade value was virtually gone. We've traded virtually no one at the peak of their value. Gordon Gekko would say the Twins do a good job of buying low, but a pretty poor job at selling high. What in-house prospects might people be overvaluing?
-
Tulowitzki Traded To The Blue Jays
Hmmm... Out of the wild-card contenders... who are we better than now? I'd say not the Jays, Tigers when they get Miggy back, Astros.... Orioles maybe? Rays perhaps? Scary prospect up only 3 games.
-
Tyler Clippard traded to the Mets
Even if we eventually "lost" we'd probably have to wait 4-5 years in order to tell unless [insert B- prospect here] was flipped for more assets.
-
Tyler Clippard traded to the Mets
Here's what Met's fans think. http://www.amazinavenue.com/2015/7/27/9051045/new-york-mets-tyler-clippard-trade-casey-meisner#comments I think I'd have trouble giving up Hu or Gonsalves, but the fact that we have both of them plus guys like Lewis Thorpe and Berrios and Stewart who appear to be much closer....
-
Tyler Clippard traded to the Mets
I guarantee the Twins were involved and got outbid on this one. How could we not have been? I wonder what the A's wouldn't take... Casey Meisner was the Mets' ninth-best prospect in Amazin' Avenue's midseason rankings. Meisner has split time this year between the Savannah Sand Gnats and the St. Lucie Mets. He has a 2.35 ERA in 111 innings across the two levels with 7.2 strikeouts per nine innings and just 2.2 walks per nine. http://www.amazinavenue.com/2015/7/27/9051045/new-york-mets-tyler-clippard-trade-casey-meisner
-
You're the GM: deadline moves
I'd have traded cash and say... Felix Jorge to the A's for Clippard who instead went to the Mets for Casey Meisner. http://www.baseball-reference.com/minors/player.cgi?id=meisne000cas
-
Berardino article: Twins embrace geek squad
The whole theory behind money ball is keying in on traits and trends that other teams (large market teams) miss. New stats keep being created and old stats tweaked in order to find more accurate or more consistent performance evaluators/predictors. If a team has more accurate metrics that give them an advantage in player evaluation, they would be fools to share it with their competition. I would think then, that the best organizations measured by new metrics might not be ranked the same under future metrics, just as traditional stats and current metrics aren't always the same. But then we'd need a sabremetric to evaluate the sabremetricians... "GM-WAR"? I'll see if the trademark's available..
-
Article: Twins Kick Baltimore Tires
Oh I agree on not giving up on him, since we already have him. I'm saying if I was another team, I wouldn't bet on it in terms of trading for him. If I'm the Twins I don't bet on it by counting on him. Personally, I think he's taken a big step forward. However, his defense is a bit shaky at times and unless he starts hitting for a ton of power, his bat is sub-par. Will his power improve? Coin flip?
-
Article: Twins Kick Baltimore Tires
If we're dealing Rosario, it may behoove us to get him a few games at 2nd or 3rd to increase his value to teams needing a 2B or super-utility Zobrist kind of player. His bat profiles more of 2B than a corner. I can't imagine Hicks having much value on the trade market. He's having a career year right now, which is essentially Dozier with 1/4 the power. On the other hand, if the rest of baseball still sees him as an elite defender (certainly not) and 5-tool prospect (neither the tools nor "prospect" really fit) then we should deal him before they really look at it.
-
Royals Acquire Johnny Cueto
Can we see what KC gave up before we give up on winning the division? Cueto would not be the first ace to change NL to AL and struggle.
-
Game Thread: Twins v Yankees, 7/25 @ 6:10pm CT
Ok, but if he gives up another one, I'm blaming you for doubting the power of the baseball gods.
-
Game Thread: Twins v Yankees, 7/25 @ 6:10pm CT
Hmmm... feel like that hr was my fault...
-
Game Thread: Twins v Yankees, 7/25 @ 6:10pm CT
Nice to see milone bounce back if only for a few innings.
-
Article: The Duffey Dilemma
Berrios and Rogers are the only ones I see as potential upgrades from even Fien and Boyer. My thought is that Duensing AND Fien both rushed back from their injuries. Fien needs to go back to the DL. Boyer is simply overworked. He wasn't even in baseball last year, no? Duensing is fine with the exception that Rogers might be slightly better... maybe. Big risk to take when Duensing is pitching well and has experience, including playoff experience. Berrios has taken time to adjust every time he's jumped a level. Presumably he'll be a better pitcher than Fien and Boyer. But I wouldn't bet that he is right now. I haven't watched Duffy pitch enough to say whether he's an upgrade, but based on his initial struggles with AAA, I would guess probably not. Dominating guys who aren't good enough to bat 7, 8, 9 in a major league line-up doesn't do a ton for me. Now Clippard on the other hand... I'm not against going to an 8 man pen at this point to try to keep arms fresh and give new guys a shot.
-
Stick a fork in Hunter, he is done.
I bet my buddy that the Twins would have 2 or more 20 HR plus guys at the beginning of the year. Dozier's there. Arcia and Vargas flopped. Sano was called up too late. Basically Plouffe and Hunter need to start mashing!
-
Stick a fork in Hunter, he is done.
Which means we should move up__________ because he's been absolutely stinging the ball? I am fine with Hunter getting some days off because it's the middle of summer, it's hot, and he's 40. He's not been super productive of late. But much like SS, C, Pen, 1B, DH, now 3B and starting staff... basically everyone who wasn't an All-Star, I'm not sure we have much better options compared to trying to rest him when we can and hoping he gets hot again. Hunter has always been a streaky hitter. I'm not for replacing one of our best hitters with another streaky hitter just because of a slump/ assumptions due to his age. Now getting him some rest while getting Arcia some AB's makes more sense to me. For that matter... Rosario looks a little run down of late as well. A lot of guys need to play better right now. Winning cures all. The team looks a bit tight. Arcia was a spark last season.
-
1,000 baseball player thread
From my hometown of Faribault, Minnesota. Current White Sox reliever, Jake Patricka.
- Article: Three Trades The Twins Must Make Now, Part I
- Article: Twins, Rockies Talk Tulowitzki