Everything posted by Jham
-
Buxton's done. Stick a fork in him.
I strongly disagree. You're proposing a race to the bottom. You can't just keep reaching at unproven and hope to have 9 guys reach their potential simultaneously. Some of your prospects will bust, others will level out. You might not have anyone better than the guy you just let go. Give yourself the best chance of winning, and most often the rebuild will take care of itself. Imagine how much different this season would be if we DFA'd Pelfrey, traded Milone, and put Meyer in the rotation this spring. I categorically disagree with any organizational move that is predicated upon a belief that we have the power to tell the future. Furthermore, I don't think it's productive to assume that the team will lose either way. Either of these fallacies in logic will tend to lean toward an over-valuation of young talent instead of a realistic evaluation of how to make the team better. Boredom in the known and infatuation in the unknown is what landed us Gomez and Humber instead of Lester and Crisp or Melky and Hughes. As it turned out, it's also what lost us Gomez, lost us Hardy, and got us that flame thrower we got for Hardy. Almost every average and even below average MLB player was once a touted if not highly touted prospect. We may lose, but we should try to win.
-
Pelfrey's Trade Value
Seriously, if we would have DFA'd Pelfrey after spring training, I would not have been mad at all. I'm certainly not going to be mad if he goes back to the old Pelf after giving us a stellar first half. He's already provided more than I ever expected anyway. Regarding luck: I think this term gets thrown around too much by sabermatricians who can't explain why their predictive stat isn't correctly predicting. No metric can correctly account for every variable in the game of baseball. Calling the variables we can't quantify "luck" is not only an incorrect description, it's willfully ignorant. If we bet on Pelfrey's ERA for each start this year and you based your guess on his FIP and mine on his current ERA, I'd have most of your money. Which has been the better predictor? No stat is perfect. Maybe it will even out. Maybe his FIP is inflated and will drop. Maybe he's doing something FIP doesn't even account for. I remember reading Bill James' Moneyball and his statement that "clutch" doesn't exist, and thinking, "Really? He's trying to bring science to baseball, and his way of trying to explain something he doesn't understand isn't to study it, it's to deny that it exists?" :Let's say perhaps Pelfrey is striking out fewer and getting "lucky" double plays is because he's trying to replicate his success and get double plays instead of strike outs. At what point are all the double plays not "luck"? I'm not going to look up the stats, so perhaps I'm wrong. It seems like Pelfrey has much better command, equal or better velocity, and vastly improved split-finger change. His stuff is better. His results are better. I would guess the K's will come and the FIP will start to edge down.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (6/19): Wimmers Continues To Dominate
Seriously? He was with the big league team almost the whole year last year. He got sent down this year because of his bat. He looked hopeless and confused at the plate. The fact that he was also less than stellar on the field just made the call easier. He's been given his shot. It's up to him to earn another shot. You don't just give away big league at-bats as part of a roster experiment without a pretty strong hunch? Otherwise you're just hoping and guessing. Look at Hicks. Three years later and people still don't know what to think of him. Good players will dominate lower levels. Santana needs to rake and get his confidence back. His defense won't win gold gloves, but he's good enough to play short in the big leagues. He really really really needs to take some walks though. No one was throwing him a strike when he was up.
-
Pelfrey's Trade Value
If you consider having "too many pitchers" an actual problem instead of a leverage point or strategic advantage, fine. But I don't think the correct solution is to trade away one of our better pitchers only to replace him with someone worse. Pelfrey has not only been better, but significantly better than the rest of the staff who have also thrown well. In a previous Pelfrey thread, I said keep throwing him til his arm fall off or the wheels fall off. Why not extend him at an affordable K? If his trade value is low, how would his free agent value be any higher? Last year, we had a couple injuries/underperformances and had to wade through like 7 failed below-fringe starters. Let one of those teams to come to us with an offer. Don't trade away depth just for the sake of clearing space for a) Santana who may or may not come back and pitch well, or Berrios who was shelled in his one start above AA, and frankly projects as a middle rotation type in his prime.
-
Rotation
And maybe another one when his replacement shut down the best team in baseball tonight?
-
Arcia
Yikes. At this point, if that's your plan A) you better have a super strong plan B. I'd probably take another year of Hunter, moving Mauer to right, or moving Plouffe or Sano to right over a Hicks/Arcia platoon at this point. We're supposed to contend next year.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins@Cardinals 6/15 7:15PM
Hey, the old Duensing is back!
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins@Cardinals 6/15 7:15PM
Plouffe would have have been out by a mile if Jay throws home, but discretion is the better part of valor I suppose.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins@Cardinals 6/15 7:15PM
Why didn't he do that in the fourth inning?
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins@Cardinals 6/15 7:15PM
Hey, Tonkin IS younger than Stauffer...
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins@Cardinals 6/15 7:15PM
Probably wouldn't have made a difference, but it looked like Mauer only half stretched there.... I'ma stop piling on now. Come on bats! We need a slump buster. Arcia was usually good for that last year... Buxton can get this team fired up in a hurry if he can start hitting.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins@Cardinals 6/15 7:15PM
I saw something like that in Mexico once... Seriously, Guy Fierri ordered a 15 inch hotdog with habenara peppers and onions out of a school bus.... uh oh, crushed... anyway, it was called a "homewrecker" and probably belongs at a ball park. May needs to get the ball down. Seriously? Again?
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins@Cardinals 6/15 7:15PM
May battled out of that, but he's having a lil trouble locating and lots of balls between the belt and letters...
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins@Cardinals 6/15 7:15PM
What are you guys watching during commercials? Anything better than DDD on Food?
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins@Cardinals 6/15 7:15PM
Can anyone remember Mauer EVER going for the lead in sac situation?
-
Arcia
Needless shot at Shane Robinson who has hit pretty darn well and definitely contributed so far this year. We're not where we are without Robinson and Nunez proving how vital depth and versatility is in back up position players. Arcia was my favorite player last year, but he has to be better than Robinson before I want to see him play more than Robinson.
-
Joe Mauer - Final Line
The problem is we didn't sign Joe Mauer to be "the old Joe Mauer". We signed him to be the 2009 MVP Joe Mauer. He's given us no seasons like that since. Some thought he could maintain his 2009 MVP level of success for at least a few years. Others thought he took a month off and juiced up for a contract. Midway into his contract, we've given up on getting the 2009 Joe mauer, we would be more than satisfied with the old Joe Mauer, but instead we're just getting Old Joe Mauer. The main thing is his bat speed has slowed down, not strike zones or shifts. It's obvious because he can't hit the ball as far anymore. His advantage of being able to watch the ball longer and let it get deep is gone. He has trouble catching up to heat. He has to start his swing earlier leaving him vulnerable to off speed. And compounding that problem is the fact that he's trying to pull the ball more which is taking its toll on his swing and requires that he get the bat through even earlier which means even more guessing. He should go back to driving the ball to left. Barry Bonds never worried about the shift. Ortiz never worried about it. Ted Williams hit .400 against shifts. He should then think about a lighter bat.
-
Joe Mauer - Final Line
.262, 5 HR, 707 OPS Excuses will start to pile up. People will surmise he's not healthy. Pretty soon the doctors will in fact diagnose an injury that had been bothering him since, oh we'll say spring training. He'll have some minor arthroscopic wrist surgery or something, and he'll be out for the season in mid-August but could possibly be ready for the playoffs if we're still in the hunt.
-
Article: Stauffer DFA'd. Tonkin Recalled. We Don't Know What We Don't Know
I'll state again that I think the team's rebuild has been hurt more by relying too heavily on young players than too heavily on declining vets. Our inability to bring in talent in free agency left us with nothing to trade during lost seasons. It allowed developing players to quit working on their games, and left us without serviceable options all over the field. You can't always predict which vets will pan out, just like you can't predict which prospects will make it. This is why you bring in as much talent as you possibly can. in whatever capacity you can. I thought it was crazy that the team brought back Pelfrey. I thought they were crazy to go north with Boyer. I'm willing to forgive them on Stauffer and give them credit for cutting their losses. I actually hope he accepts his assignment and stays with the organization. His velocity was way down. I wouldn't mind seeing if he can provide something when healthy. Re: Tonkin, Oliveros, and Slama, look at our AAA line up. Our best hitters in Rochester are... Pinto? Santana? Arcia occasionally? I don't think dominating a bunch of Eric Fryers and Doug Bernier's means we should trust these guys to get Moustakis or Miggy in a big spot.
-
Article: Stauffer DFA'd. Tonkin Recalled. We Don't Know What We Don't Know
To me, Stauffer was a necessary risk that didn't work out. Everyone saw how our bull pen collapsed last year. Everyone pointed to the pen as a weakness going into the year. We had to do something, and Stauffer was coming off an ok year. Similar to the Jered Burton signing in my eyes. Just didn't work out. I do not perceive lack of trust in young players to be a huge problem. We relied on Hicks for like 3 years now, and each year he's screwed us to some extent. This year was less because Robinson put together a decent first month. Danny Santana screwed us. Vargas and Arcia have screwed us. Imagine if we hadn't signed Torii Hunter. I think it's a bigger mistake to trust AAA success over a Major League track record. But here's the thing, you can have both IF you take the risk and bring in some vets. You can always replace them with young guys if they warrant the call or the veteran falters. Out of our FA signings, Hunter has worked out, Nunez has contributed, and Robinson has contributed. Stauffer did not. Santana hasn't played. Meanwhile, Pinto has flopped, Santana has flopped, Buxton and Sano aren't ready. Burdi has imploded. Reed hasn't been much better. Arcia, Vargas, Walker and Hicks seems stuck in a state of arrested development. It's as Ann as the nose on Plain's face, organizational depth requires some Stauffers.
- Alex Meyer Bullpen Success
-
Article: Twins Lack Punch From Middle Of The Order
I mean, the real real problem is that Mauer has lost bat speed. It's made worse for Joe because he was a hitter who depended on letting the ball get deep. He now has to guess, start his swing earlier, watch it less, and square it up more exactly. Mauer's inability to lift the ball has lead to a ridiculous amount of double plays without offsetting 3 run shots. I suggested this in an earlier Mauer thread, while others stated the stats weren't there. Well, they're there now. Most of Mauer's HR in prior years came to straight away center or left. His first home run in Target Field was a bomb into the trees in center. He's lost the power to go center or oppo. He's in trouble.
- Game Thread: Twins vs Brewers 6/06 @11:10 am Pacific Time (1:10pm CT) Sophomore slump edition
- Game Thread: Twins vs Brewers 6/06 @11:10 am Pacific Time (1:10pm CT) Sophomore slump edition
- Game Thread: Twins vs Brewers 6/06 @11:10 am Pacific Time (1:10pm CT) Sophomore slump edition