Everything posted by Jham
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Indians, 8/14 @ 7:10pm CT
Wow, I think gardy wrote "never change" in Tonkin's 2014 September call up year book last year, and Mike took it to heart...
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Indians, 8/14 @ 7:10pm CT
Straight and true compared to hicks in the 2nd.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Indians, 8/14 @ 7:10pm CT
Will the Indians be better than us next year?
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Indians, 8/14 @ 7:10pm CT
That ball is seriously carrying in this humidity, or so say rosario and hicks' agents...
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Indians, 8/14 @ 7:10pm CT
I said FRONT leg...
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Indians, 8/14 @ 7:10pm CT
Must have read the "mauer retirement/bench thread". Nice to see.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Indians, 8/14 @ 7:10pm CT
Maybe the first time I've seen Mauer hit with a stiff front leg.
-
Article: Switching Gears
I think Terry Ryan really deserves some blame for the initial collapse, but he also deserves credit for the relative rebound. I think he took it pretty hard when we traded away Castillo and it deflated the team. This was back when they had the old graded FA system. We would have received a compensatory draft pick probably better than the prospects we received in the deal. He also knew that he'd left us in impossible positions with Hunter, Nathan, and especially Santana. He pawned off the fall-out of the mismanagement on Smith. Smith made things worse. Ryan has since gone back to what initially made him successful: shrewd management of young talent and low-level FA signings. He also seems to be embracing the things that led to his team's collapse, ie not taking every opportunity to add talent to the roster. When our draft picks are in the 20's instead of 1-5, it is less likely we'll be able to consistently replace the talent that leaves with in-house options.
-
Pour one out for Boyer
Personally, I thought Boyer looked tired the second half of the season. His stuff was still ok, but the control left him and every ball was up in the zone. Opposite of when he was pounding low and away with the slider earlier in the year. Not surprising given his physique, how much work he put in just to make the team, the fact he was out of baseball last year, and his insane usage by management. I'd be willing to see what he's like after a significant rest, if he gets that. Duensing and Fien were both rushed back from injuries, and it showed in their productivity. Duensing particularly turned a corner more recently. Having JR Graham and May in the pen has really hurt the rest of the pen since those two arms are hardly ever used. The old rubber-armed relievers have value if only to save the rest of your go-to options. Unfortunately, it looks like all our relievers break down with high-usage.
-
Mauer, what to do?
Negotiate retirement? What's to negotiate? His contract is guaranteed. Why on earth would he agree to give money back? He'd be the first player to do so, it would only highlight his decline, and further humiliate him. The chances of him retiring are a fraction of a fraction of the options we're not allowed to propose on this thread. However, you did hit on a couple points: pride and below-avg at the position. Would he accept either of those roles? Would other more forbidden options start to look more appealing?
-
Trade Buxton?
Of course you'd trade him for a sure fire star. Trout, Harvey, Fernandez, etc. However, few teams if any would be willing to trade a proven superstar for a potential future super star. Therefore, you probably keep the potential super star unless you absolutely need to deal one in order to get that final piece. Like any trade, you're balancing now vs. then, and potential vs. proven ability. Sometimes a star now is worth a potential superstar later or a potential star might be worth 1 season or even half a season of a super star. No one should be off limits, but it would take quite the stretch to imagine a scenario where it would make sense to trade Buxton for what his market value would likely be.
-
Beltre' HOF?
My first thought was still the steroid rumors. Here's a fantastic article debunking much of that speculation. http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/adrian-beltres-fluke-2004-happens-again/ I think his ability to stay at third and play at a high level in comparison to some others who dabbled and then went to first should get him in. Who's been a better 3rd baseman over that time period without switching to first? Cabrera sort of, but way worse defensively?
- Article: Twins Transactions: Buxton Activated, Optioned to AAA
-
Article: Twins Transactions: Buxton Activated, Optioned to AAA
On your first point, I was going from memory. I'm sure you'll forgive me if the last few seasons, especially Hicks last few seasons, blended together. On your second point, I guess we just disagree on how much of a difference on development a couple extra weeks in the bigs would have for Arcia and Buxton. Buxton is still facing a new level. Both will probably be up in September if not sooner. I'm annoyed that Arcia hasn't been recalled since he can help the team, but perhaps the organization sees his personal development as more important right now. Buxton, I'm not concerned about at all. I'm disappointed he got hurt again, but other guys have stepped up, so his absence has not really been felt. As a final point, I would say there may be some organizational value in treating players like people instead of property or commodities. It's not unreasonable to think that an organization might get more out of their players by demonstrating some loyalty and accountability instead of cutting or scapegoating guys. I think we've failed in that regard in the past. It's a delicate balance.
- Article: Twins Transactions: Buxton Activated, Optioned to AAA
- Article: Twins Transactions: Buxton Activated, Optioned to AAA
- Article: Twins Transactions: Buxton Activated, Optioned to AAA
-
Article: Twins Transactions: Buxton Activated, Optioned to AAA
I don't think Bonnes ever asserted that reducing Hunter's playing time is "bordering on unhinged". Waiving Hunter or benching him for a rookie at this stage maybe, but he stated that a slight reduction in playing time for a number of players, Hunter included, was totally reasonable. Don't invent arguments because you want to see your favorite prospects. Not all fans are you. If this is Hunter's last year with the Twins, I'd like to see him go out the right way. And no, I don't think that even playing out the AAA season would hurt either Arcia or Buxton. In fact, many were shocked that Hicks didn't get the call last September. I think Hicks might have gotten the message finally. Arcia needs maturity and dedication, not more reps.
-
Should/Will Twins re-sign Torii Hunter?
I've seen the Twins go into season after season with no Plan B. I've seen Terry Ryan's inability to make deals to help the team and fill holes in the roster. I'm satisfied with the production we've seen from Hunter. I'm satisfied with the level of mentorship cited by the players themselves (especially Hicks) we've received. I'm satisfied that he's not a long-term fixture who will take up money and significant playing time from younger players. I don't have a problem with Hunter being retained next season so long as a) he's not plan A (think Konerko in his final year); or we use our glut of knocking on the door types to improve the rotation, or catching situation. I'd be far more upset if we don't re-sign him, Rosario and Hicks regress, Arcia still can't figure it out, Buxton gets hurt again or isn't productive, and we end up having to trade prospects for an outfielder who might well be worse than Hunter.
-
Article: Switching Gears
We've gotten into this position by wasting the years prior. We're obsessed with catching lightening in a bottle (Perkins, Dozier) and hoping that our talent will mesh into something serviceable. Adding veterans during a rebuild should have provided opportunities to trade guys away, and groom younger guys. But we've refused to add notable FA, and failed to trade players at their peaks. Rather than continually trying to get more talent, we've contently waited around for talent to bloom. This "immense young talent" we speak of doesn't include a catcher, an ace, or possibly even a lock-down reliever or shortstop. Who are we waiting for who figures to be a huge upgrade over what we have on the field now? Polanco maybe? Pinto doubtfully? We have a bunch of average players and no stars. Will May and Berrios have better years next year than Pelf and Milone had this year? Mauer can't be moved. Once Bux and Kepler are up, how do the cupboards look?
-
Article: Twins Transactions: Buxton Activated, Optioned to AAA
Well there seems to be 2 different arguments that people are blending into one. 1) Should the Twins Bench/Waive Hunter in order to get Buxton at bats. 2) Should Buxton have been optioned to AAA or immediately called up or briefly rehabbed and called up in order to get experience wherever he could? I think only 1 poster has suggested benching or waiving Hunter, yet the Hunter v. Buxton debate rages on. Regarding Question 2: I wouldn't have been mad either way. I can't believe people are freaking out like this over a few weeks in AAA coming back from a thumb injury. This seems to be a perfectly reasonable course of action for a young player who wasn't met with immediate success in his first stint. Calling him up immediately in order to try to spark the team/gain experience in the league and with his team would have also been reasonable. Neither move is likely to change EITHER the Twins fortunes or Mr. Buxton's, IMO. I think people would say that AA is prospects league, more high end talent, while AAA is an extended bench with plenty of veteran minor leaguers with MLB experience ready to be recalled at a moment's notice. Perhaps fewer high-end talents, but with far more experienced and consistent performers providing a higher level of play day to day, week to week.
-
Article: Twins Transactions: Buxton Activated, Optioned to AAA
He's a back up. He's played decently if unspectacularly in sporadic playing time. I understand your roster frustrations. I too think we have better options. But I don't get knocking a guy who hasn't really been part of the problem If anything, he maybe overachieved, especially the month where we won games. I think you and I just evaluate players differently. I loved the tools I saw when Bux was up. But was not overly impressed with his routes and body control in the field or on the base paths. His plate discipline was seriously lacking. His reckless style of play lead to strike outs, dropped balls, and outs on the bases (and triples, outfield assists, and catches) and of course another injury. Has he dominated for a month? He's played well. Has he dominated like the best player not in the Major Leagues? Not for a couple years. Torii Hunter is not a red herring. Posters are hard-core bashing the guy who has as much responsibility for the teams relative success as anyone. IF you think that the season is over and it's time to focus on player development, fine. But you don't have to slam Hunter in order to do so. Some have taken this tact, others have chosen to take cheap shots at guys like Hunter, Nunez, and Robinson who have actually played up to expectations unlike many other guys on the team, some of which the same posters (myself included re: Arcia) are asking to be called up.
-
Article: Twins Transactions: Buxton Activated, Optioned to AAA
Seriously, what has Shane Robinson done wrong this year? I can see the frustration with Suzuki and before him Santana, but Robinson has gone about his business and performed admirably as a utility outfielder, IMO. What indication has Buxton shown that he's ready for the Major Leagues? When was the last time he dominated at the minor league level to the extent a top prospect should dominate? Others say Kepler's bat is already more advanced than Buxton. To expect him to come up and be better than Hunter right off an injury is unlikely at best. Let's see how his recovery goes. I personally don't have a problem with the pay. Perhaps this is a little organizational message to him about being smart and taking care of his money makers. He can really go get it, but if his hands and wrists go, he's useless.
-
Game Thread, Twins @ Indians, 8/8 @ 6:10 pm CT
That doesn't help the run differential. ..
-
Game Thread, Twins @ Indians, 8/8 @ 6:10 pm CT
Oh, so THATS why Shane Robinson is on the team... awesome.