Everything posted by TwinsDr2021
-
Trade Target: Frankie Montas
I am not trading Larnach and Jeffers for one year of Montas, because if they weren't willing to give Berrios a good contract, why would they give a big one to him, because he is going to get paid if he has another year like last year. Then they end up trading him for less than they gave away. I would include either Larnach or Jeffers, plus a decent pitching prospect and a flier on a young athlete. This trade as no chance of happening, if you were the Twins and somebody offered you Arraez, Rooker and Varland what would you be willing to give up? IMO it wouldn't be anything close to a major league pitcher. Rooker is going to be a throw in on any trade not a guy that has any actual value, again IMO A's Get: Arraez 33.3 Rooker 1.7 L. varland .50 = 35.5 Twins Get: Bassitt 17.0 Manaea 18.5 = 35.5
-
Bye bye Buxton?
The pirates won, 94,88,98, 78,75,82 games from 2013 though 2018, and won three playoff games in that time. They attempted to 2018 with the archer trade, it back fired badly.
-
Bye bye Buxton?
I guess I was trying to say if they had made those in-season trades in the great years, it would be way easier to accept them trading Berrios and possibly Buxton away now. Would it suck, sure, but it would be understandable. But if this team won't sign its stars OR make trades when they are good, well why stick and have loyalty when they obvious don't care. My point was you can't separate the two with the fans, Brook tried that in a thread about being Mediocre, and the comments trended towards how they did in the postseason and regular season.
-
Bye bye Buxton?
Has Tampa really been consistently good? They basically have great the last 4 years, then not so good for 4 years, then good to really good for 6, and before that terrible. One of the things that Tampa seems to do, is wheel and deal with their minor league players
-
Bye bye Buxton?
You are missing, that as Twins fans we can agree we have to trade away players at times to reload, but when things are going well or unexpected we also expect the Twin to do something to get them over the top (doesn't have to be a championship, has to be an attempt to win the championship). In your examples, you left out that the A's, White Sox and Royals all did this, made in-season trades or signed players to supplement their core players brought along though the minor leagues. You are only telling half the story of those teams.
-
Bye bye Buxton?
To be honest I think most twins fans understand this, there are times the Twins are going to have to trade away players to reload, most of us understand we are not the Yanks, Red Sox, Dodgers, etc... The frustration comes from when they are doing really well, they didn't make the in-season trades that the Royals, White Sox and yes the A's have. And the Twins fans were told they didn't make those trades because they were focusing on sustained success.
-
What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
If they trade Buxton, they should trade Sano, Kepler, Polanco, and Garver, that way they will have gotten rid of everybody from the old front office, and basically everybody from the last 3 playoff runs, and try to win with their guys. Give them next year and 2023 to prove their worth. The great thing (for them) is there will be no expectations on them and very few fans watching the games. On a different note, would you trade the Blue Jays Martin and SWR for Berrios and his contract? I would
-
Bye bye Buxton?
I like Glasnow, but trading a 28 year old Buxton for a 28 year old Glasnow , a 29 year old Houser, and a 32 year old Bradley. Doesn't seem like the kind of trade that replenishes the pipeline. IMO if the trade Buxton there better be a possible superstar in the making (even if it doesn't work out.) Trading for guys like Glasnow and Houser, again IMO should be for prospects. I do like that Houser has 3 years of control, not a fan that Glasnow has only 2.
-
Bye bye Buxton?
If they trade Buxton, I also believe they should trade Donaldson, but why sign anybody, it isn't like there will be much of anybody watching or caring about if they lose 90,100,110 or 120 games. I mean if you don't actually care about winning at the major league level, why pretend? Wouldn't it best to try the 3 inning pitcher or some other option, when there are no fans to complain about it? My 13 year old son said if they trade Buxton, lets get the MLB network and find another team to cheer for. He said "today him and a few of his baseball friends were talking at school and they were discussing which team was going to be their new favorite" In the past I would have tried to convince him not to, and I just said I kind of like the Padres and Blue Jays, who you thinking?
-
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
You keep changing what I said. first you clam I said 3 straight titles, now you claim I said they having done anything. Neither of which I said. Also - The Twins signed Cruz to a one-year, $14.3 million contract that comes with a $12 million club option for 2020. Which is exactly what I said basically a 1 year contract.
-
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
I was wrong when I said 3 titles, I should have said two and a wild card (2017,2019,2020). That is the playoffs 3 of 4 years and went into the 5th year highly regarded. (In 2018 they went 78-84 and took 2nd in a bad division) Their big moves were trading for Odo, signing an aging Cruz to basically a one year contract (in February), signed Donaldson (which was big), and traded a highly regarded minor league relief pitcher for Maeda. I would say all of them worked out pretty well, but that is all they did, Wait, sorry that is not all, they traded their best pitcher and are having problems signing their position player. So yes my opinion is they barely did a darn thing, if people want to believe that wasn't a window or they did do a lot that is their opinion.
-
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
So in 5 years, they traded for Odo and Maeda, signed Cruz and Donaldson, I stick with my point .
-
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
Wasn't the window clearly open when they won 3 division titles? They barely did a darn thing. But hey maybe in 2024 or beyond they will do something. This isn't meant for you, but it is kind of sad that even the fans have gotten into the "wo is me" we are just the Twins and are a mid market team that can't have nice things and are happy with the hope of the next group of prospects.
- Tempering Expectations for Bailey Ober and Joe Ryan
- Are the Twins About to Build a Radically Unconventional Pitching Staff?
-
Possible trade candidates from Oakland to acquire.
are you saying for the Twins to get to the playoffs, we need better pitchers than those 3? What are the odds of 3 of the Twins pitching prospects end up as good as them let alone better? Combined all three will make less than 24 million next year, with signing Buxton that would still leave plenty of money to fill out the team. Sure maybe the end up with 85 wins next year, but with the two that could still be here, and the prospects living up to expectations they are set up for 2023, and that is when they could sign #1.
-
Are the Twins About to Build a Radically Unconventional Pitching Staff?
If you are a first or second round talent , maybe 3rd(or the parent or the agent) do you really want to sign with a team that basically says for the next 10 years you are going to be a 3 inning pitcher? And what team is going to draft a pitcher in one of those rounds and pay them the slot money to be a part-time pitcher? So basically the team will have said we won't ever go after healthy top end talent, we are going to settle for lesser? (Remember I replied to the comment about 3 sets of 3 inning pitchers) And yes it is bad for baseball to try and remove the star starting pitchers, quite a few of the games I have attended with my son revolve around who the Twins are playing and who is pitching that day. Multiple times we have decided not to go to a game on a bullpen day, because they tend to get long and boring and have went when Berrios or Odo, or a stud on the other team was pitching. I am not saying this year it would be a bad idea I am saying the philosophy is a bad idea, and I can't believe the players union would accept it. I actually think pairing Winder with a Ryan and Ober with Balazovic, would be a great way to build them up. Sign a couple of pitchers, trade for a pitcher, then let the rookies thrive but not asking too much of them for too long.
-
Are the Twins About to Build a Radically Unconventional Pitching Staff?
Are we sure that is what the Rays do? I was looking at the games logs for them the last 3 three years, and their good pitchers, pitch on average more than 5 innings. Now they don't have the finances for a bunch of those good pitchers, but I don't really seem them limiting their good pitchers on some philosophy of more times pitching and less innings per time?
-
Possible trade candidates from Oakland to acquire.
Agreed Arraez isn't helping get anybody from the A's, I am thinking they are going to want something like Larnach, SWR, and lottery ticket young guy.
-
Are the Twins About to Build a Radically Unconventional Pitching Staff?
One of the problems I see with this is drafting pitchers, which agent would ever let their client sign with a team that does this? College Seniors with no other options? This would have been a great thing to do last year towards the end, and maybe this year to get the prospects up and given a chance without putting the pressure on them to go deep into a game. But as a long term strategy is bad for the players, fans and the game of baseball.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
Not sure what the number should be, but probably higher than 250 innings (ober, ryan and Dobnak) Maybe Cruz was real money it was 14 with an option for 12, so if he wouldn't have worked out it would have been much, a one year contract is never bad right? (the Twins paid him just over 26 million in his time here.) IMO the Twins FO have straddled the fence since they got here, and that is why they are in the position they are in. I have no interest in giving this FO another rebuild, if they were to clean house an bring another FO in, I could back another rebuild.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
Is this what the FO has been doing since it got here? The only real money the FO has really spent is on Donaldson, and now the fans or the owners should be happy with another two years? The real problem has been Falvey was hired at the end of 2016 and they haven't built a pitching staff from within, they currently have a fairly deep of pitching prospects but....
-
Possible trade candidates from Oakland to acquire.
It certainly seems like the time for the Twins FO, to call up OAK, and try to pry a few of those starting pitchers away. Montas FA in 2024, Bassitt and Manaea in 2023, so it seems like it shouldn't cost a ton for Bassitt and Manaea, Montas maybe a bit more. I would be willing to give up bunch of the prospects and/or maybe Laranch for Montas and one of the others.
-
A case against signing the top free agents
Hasn't this been the plan for about 40 years, since that 82 team?
-
Should the Twins Gamble on a Veteran Ace?
I would for Kershaw, something like 3/48, but that probably won't get him. I also would go for Verlander 3/54 but a buyout after two. I want neither for 1 year, and neither for more than 3 years. But maybe I should go with the, we are the Twins we don't deserve good things, we only deserve middle tier players because of money, and that 2022 is just another wasted year in MN for baseball, and maybe if they show something we can go and sign a pitcher the following year, unless that year is another building year then the year after that would be a great time. (Unless there are injuries and the Twins are in selling mode for the next group of promising prospects)