Everything posted by TwinsDr2021
-
Andrelton Simmons Isn’t Good Enough to Get Away with This
Sorry truly, some of us are new or newer to the site, I had no idea this was a tongue-in-cheek editorial piece and honestly not sure how I would know it was, it looks like every other article on the site? Honest question, what is the topic of this article, so we can stay on topic? My understanding of it was Simmons tweet and between the tweet and him being an offensive liability it is time to let him go. I guess trying to add some reasons and dare I say logic possibly behind his tweet went too far. I will be done commenting on this thread because I guess it was never meant for comments, it was meant as a funny read?
-
Andrelton Simmons Isn’t Good Enough to Get Away with This
Honestly super confused by your comment. So what is this article doing here? the article is about Simmons anti-vax stance, his tweet, him not being good enough to put up with it and sending him on his way. the 1st amendment is all the comments section, and many things on covid, anti-vax, who has the right to say what has been said. If the mods don't want the stuff that was talked about in the article talked about, move the article, but it sounds more like you are saying if you don't agree find with the premise, find someplace else to disagree? is that what you are saying? You quoted me more than once, and then decided to say find someplace else. So is this a better take? Simmons sucks, the Twins suck (this year) and the rest of the year should be spend auditioning the younger guys out, and his should be back balled from baseball due to his anti-vax stance.
-
Andrelton Simmons Isn’t Good Enough to Get Away with This
So the article was about the tweet from yesterday correct? Not sure what April has to do with it? But if you want to bring up April, there was quite a bit still unknown in prior to April, then he ended up getting Covid, didn't need to be hospitalized, obviously didn't die and from what I read experienced “very mild” symptoms and now has natural immunity. I can understand where he is coming from (even if I disagree with him on his vaccine stance), he basically was saying I don't trust the vaccine, I trust my body and he didn't or doesn't fall into the high risk categories, and in his case he was right, many others say the same thing and have been completely wrong. Until as a country we are willing to see the other side and try to understand (don't have to agree with them) them instead of demonizing them (Both sides) we are never going to come together.
- TD Top Twins Prospect Rankings (Post Draft and Trade Deadline): 6-10
-
Andrelton Simmons Isn’t Good Enough to Get Away with This
For the record I am vaccinated. I went to my doctor and said I don't know if I have ever had covid, never tested positive. He said there have been studies (Cleveland Clinic is one) that if you have natural immunity the vaccination isn't more effective and since I have a family history of autoimmune disease (possibly side effect of the vaccine is triggering these) I should get tested to see if I have had it. He suggestion was if I had Covid not to get vaccinated because the side effects could be worse, I was tested and never had it and got the vaccine. Now onto Simmons, he has had Covid, so him not getting the shot is very understandable, seeing quite a few players, actors, politicians getting covid after getting the shot it is somewhat reasonable for him to say "doesn’t/didn’t really work", him saying "might get some side affects" is an absolute fact, there is no denying that. But when put all together it isn't a good message, the message should always be talk to your doctor and discuss what is best for you and your situation. Is it a reason to cut somebody, absolutely not, but it is 2021 and if people disagree with you, you never know what might happen. Edit: I will add anybody on here telling people to just get the vaccine without regards to their own situation can be just a damning.
-
TD Top Twins Prospect Rankings (Post Draft and Trade Deadline): 6-10
If that is the case and I sure hope it is, the Twins are actually looking like they have an ace type pitcher, because he will be 20 in 23 and 21 in 24. No the odds of him making it to the majors as a 20 year old is very slim, because it will take three years just to get him up to the 100 innings mark
-
Andrelton Simmons Isn’t Good Enough to Get Away with This
Just to so I understand, pro sports players should stay out of the Covid topic completely? Removed this question - So writers on websites without a PhD do the same?
-
Trevor Larnach's struggles
concerned? yes, absolutely, but still very optimistic on his future. Was hoping he would force the Twins hand on starting on the big club next year, so far I am not sure he has done that.
-
TD Top Twins Prospect Rankings (Post Draft and Trade Deadline): 15-11
I like Winder, don't like that he has pitched 72 innings and the talk is he is tired or fatigued. He turns 25 in less than two months. How much do you take age into consideration for the rankings? Sadly if for some reason he would be done pitching for the year, it would be hard for me to consider him a top prospect since it is likely his age 25 season would also be about limiting innings, and wouldn't be until he is 26 that the expectations are he could go a whole season, seems very old for a prospect. Also Strotman turns 25 in less than a month, if he isn't up real soon, he also seems a little old for to be considered a top prospect, doesn't mean he won't be a good major league pitcher, IMO just means he isn't a top prospect. I guess one of the good things having your pitching prospects been on the old side is you probably never really have to pay them a ton of money, they will be 31 or older before they are due for free agency and it is super easy to explain why you aren't going to pay a boatload of money to a guy on the downside of their career.
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
You are not wrong, but a bunch of the pitchers (2017) selected (in the first) have or are pitching in the majors from that draft, most just have been terrible or not good. Would people feel better if they would have drafted one of them and are seeing them in the majors now, or still on the hope for Lewis in late 2022 or 2023. I don't know that answer. 2013-2015 - just me looking at the first rounds looks like they were kind of terrible years for pitching it would have been nice if they would have stayed away from it, But hey at least we have Burrows from 2015 draft. In total hindsight I wish they would have take Walker Buehler in 2015 (24th pick) Stewart if making the majors is a plus for him, since high school pitchers seem to flame out, Gordon hurts since it has taken so long and really doesn't project to be a starter, and Jay was a terrible pick and I believe that was widely considered a terrible pick.
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
Yes, sorry, I fixed the previous message and explained I quoted the wrong person.
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
Sorry my rant started with "Danchat" said "was more due to the complete and utter failures of Gonsalves, Jay, Stewart, Romero, and others" and I responded - "So no blame goes to the FO, that can't see their highly rated prospects are garbage and it might be a good idea to trade them for some value, either other prospects or a pitcher at the deadline. So yes I guess I can see how it turned into me saying they were garbage prospects and then a bunch of hypothetical's started., when in reality that wasn't my opinion, seeing the previous posts in this thread I was saying how highly rated the prospects were. and also I agree 17 probably was not the year to trade away prospects they hadn't seen as they had said the plan was to be sustain winning. I quoted the wrong person, and I apologize to Dman
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
My actual complaint is they didn't do crap at the deadlines when they had assets and when they were in the process of winning the divisions, and those assets just went away and they got nothing. So the basically pissed them away, I am a realist, I understand most prospects don't pan out and I also understand a team like MN might not get a bunch of chances to win in the playoffs, so I say trade (when you have assets) to at least try to get more of an advantage in the playoffs. But again I am a person that would have traded Lewis, Rooker, Enlow and just about any other prospect rated lower than them for Greinke, Gallen, Bauer (that would have been hard to do in division) or Stroman,
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
I don't believe that, I also don't believe they thought they were garbage. IMO they thought they would be decent starting pitchers and maybe better, and they were the bridge to the new pitchers they had just drafted and would be drafting. I believe they think they are so smart (and you have to think that to be in that job, so I don't mean that as a negative) that with Berrios, Gibson a few smart trades and get free agents picks they could piece meal it together or even better end come up with the next Kluber, Bieber, Bauer, Clevinger. It pretty much worked to win the division titles, and fell apart year, but next year will be the real question, if they can turn the ship back around, they deserve to keep their jobs, if not, so long. I don't think you can be allowed to mismanage assets for that long and keep your job. and two terrible years in a row, does just that. I mean do you think they signed Donaldson for 1 year of contending and 3 years of rebuilding? I don't but one down year out of 4, now that isn't wasting that asset which in this case is money.
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
So no blame goes to the FO, that can't see their highly rated prospects are garbage and it might be a good idea to trade them for some value, either other prospects or a pitcher at the deadline.
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
thanks, I understand that both were on lists prior to them joining the organization. My point on Jay and Stewart were just that they were former 1st round picks, Jay was still considered a top relief pitcher prospect and other team fans love to see a former 1st round pick thrown into a deal. Also Duran has only really been a top 100 prospect once and only by baseball america and that was pre-2000, so does he fall into the Stewart, Jay, Gonzo, Romero Pot? Because some still think he will be a top starting pitcher (Not me, but some)
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
The problem isn't that they have gone on to do something, the problem was this front office didn't do a damn thing with these assets. And beside Kohl (but still young and former first round pick) they all had a bright shine on them while this FO was in charge, Jay had wore off a bit, but was still considered a sure fire relief pitcher. People keep talking about the Tampa way, the Tampa way is more than just trading stars when they get to expensive it is evaluating players and trading them away if they are going to clog up their 40 man roster. Prime example - They just traded two of them to the Twins, getting a short term boast on offense, and freeing up 2 40 man spots at the same time. The Twins don't trade prospects (except in the Odo and Maeda case which both worked) because gosh forbid some day they turn out.
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
Yes, Stewart was on in pre 15/16, does that not count that he was a one time top 100 prospect same with Jay? Jay was also on the pre 16, How is saying Gonsalves is a stretch, per https://www.baseball-reference.com/register/player.fcgi?id=gonsal001ste Baseball America had him Pre2017 at 97, and pre2018 at 99, Major League Baseball had him Pre-2017 at 92, Pre-2018 at 78. So we ignore Romero was a top 100 prospect pre-2018 because a few years later he couldn't get into the country? The reason I listed Gibson and Berrios was mostly because they were the top starters on the 2 for Gibson, 3 for Berrios division championship teams. I also find it convenient that you the current top pitchers and prospect all but Duran go back to the guys I listed. Again my point is, when Gonzo and Romero were at their highest they didn't trade them for help at the deadline, they held on to them and got nothing, same with Jay, Stewart. Maybe none of them would have been headlines like Graterol was but, a Romero, Jay, Wade, Baddoo, and about 9 relief pitchers could have been traded for one decent starter at the deadline, and they would be no worse then they are today.
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
My biggest issue with the FO (continuing to employ Rocco), they were given Gonsalves (2 time top 100 prospect), Jay (1 time top 100 prospect), Stewart (2 time top 100 prospect), Romero (1 time top 100 prospect), Berrios (3 time top 100 prospect), Kyle Gibson (2/3 time top 100 prospect), Graterol (2 time top 100 prospect) ,Balazovic (1 time top 100 prospect) and currently out of that group they have Maeda, Duran (1 time top 100 prospect), Balazovic (1 time top 100 prospect), Simeon Woods-Richardson (2 time top 100 prospect)
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
I don't like being that guy, but have those 3 really emerged? IMO the only one of them that might be considered a lock to start next season is Kirilloff and that is only if he is 100% healthy and hitting in spring training. If Larnach doesn't improve the rest of the year, I am not sure how you can justify him being a opening day starter next year.
-
Four Players the Twins Could Trade This Winter
I completely agree, but if this FO decide they can't compete in 2022, I am out, done with the Twins. They told us they would bring sustained winning and starting over 6 or however long they have been here is not that, I can't stand Rocco as a manager but have put up with him since they have been pretty decent and winning divisions, I am willing to say 2021 is fluke and not the norm and sometimes seasons like this need to happen to refresh, replenish the old and/or stale. They have already lost my son, he has two Twins jerseys, Buxton and Berrios, he knows my favorite player of of the 90's and 2000's was Vlad, So he has kind of been paying attention to the Jays, and when Berrios got traded there. He said my new team in the Blue Jays, I want a Vlad, Berrios and Bichette Jersey, that was a sad day in our house.
-
How confident are you in the FO to turn this around?
Correct me if I am wrong but didn't they inherit some top pitching in 16? Jay, Gonsalves, Stewart, Romero, Mejia, Thorpe, Jorge, Wells Jax, Graterol. The problem I have with the players you mentioned is age, injuries and/or command. Winder - 25 when next season starts, has an ERA of 4.67 in St. Paul averaging just over 4 innings a start. Duran - Injuries will be 24 when next season starts and has a 5.06 ERA in St. Paul, with 13 walks in 16 innings. Balazovic - will be 24 when the season starts, nothing really to complain about other than he has never pitched more than 93.2 innings in the minors so there should be no real expectation that he is going to pitch 150 innings in the majors for a few years. Canteriono - will be 24 when the season starts, is injured and the highest he has pitched is high A. Sands - will be 25 next July in AA, like Balazovic has never pitched more than 97.1 innings (College) and he is back down to averaging less than 5 innings per start. Vallimont - Will be 25 in March, has walked 36 guys in 59.1 innings in AA. Strotman - Turns 25 in less than a month, 33 walks in 58.1 innings (AAA TB), seems like a guy they Twins should have up since he is on the 40 and might be somebody they have to let go over the winter. Ryan- 25, projects as a relief pitcher from what I have heard. Woods-Richardson - love him is a real prospect being that he turns 21 shortly and in AA, big K's low walks IMO most of these guys are too old to be considered real prospects (that doesn't mean that can't and won't be good to great) and in another post a few weeks ago, I pointed out that most top of the rotation guys have already been in the majors and performing by this age. For example Berrios was an All Star in his age 24 season and had been in the majors for parts of three years.
-
Four Players the Twins Could Trade This Winter
Most of this makes no sense IMO, unless they don't plan to ever really compete again. (because thinking 24/25 is the next window is too far away for fans and in baseball) So they trade Rogers and spend the money they save on lesser pitchers? Trade Donaldson with the only back up plan at third is a prospect with a career .771 OPS (he has been hot this year and I HOPE that continues) or Arraez who would be out of position, and opening up another hole that Arraez filled. Trade Buxton at lowest of low values, with no back up plan for a replacement. Kepler -"Trevor Larnach and Alex Kirilloff’s emergence in the outfield make Kepler more expendable. " Is this really true have Larnach and Kirilloff did so much this year that they make Kepler expendable? The idea of going into next year with a lineup of Sano, Polanco, Arraez, Miranda, Jeffers, Larnach, Kirilloff, and Gordon/Celestino and 10 rookies pitchers does nothing for me. Plus if you are going to do this why would you go out and sign top end starters or why would they sign here?
-
Is Jorge Polanco the current face of the Twins?
IMO, Hunter might have been the face, but the nickname soul patrol, might have helped, and it also helped that he starting hitting home runs in 2001 to go along with his gold gloves. also IMO option, Morneau wasn't really the face Joe was but they also had a cool nickname M & M boys. I mean no offense to Polanco, he is a solid to very good major league player, and when he is on he is great. But I think it is hard to envision the face of the team being a good they team didn't think was good enough at SS to move to 2b.
-
Is Jorge Polanco the current face of the Twins?
Having Polanco as the face of the Twins says more about the current state of the Twins then it does about Polanco.