Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

TwinsDr2021

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by TwinsDr2021

  1. 100% agree it can't be all years. sometimes the stars don't align, injuries and prospect or two don't work out. But when you are a core of Buxton, Sano, Rosario, Kepler, Cruz, Berrios, Garver, Arraez, Berrios, Gibson, Duffey, Rogers and May. All home grown talent except Cruz, you have to supplement that core with some other top end talent. The Twins didn't and instead Cruz, Berrios, Gibson, Rosario, May are gone, and they now the hope is they will supplement that with prospects. And if those prospects turn out to be good in a year, two or three, the whole original core will be gone minus Buxton, and they will be back trying to supplemented the prospects that worked out. and the Cycle will continue ( and quite of bit of MN Twins fans will rejoice because of the hope and promise of the next group of prospects), because always relying on prospects to continue success will never work long term. And I would ask for examples where that has worked long term. 2020 was the season for the Twins to go all in, they just had come off a 100 win 2019 season. So what did this front office do? They resigned Pineda to a cheap 2 year contract, singed Homer Bailey to an even cheaper 1 year contract, signed Rich Hill to an even cheaper contract and wowed the fans with a Tyler Clippard signing. Swapped out Castro for Avilia for a 2.5 million dollar savings, and let Gibson, Cron, Schoop and Perez go (probably all smart). At this point they made a 100 win team worse, then because they failed at everything else and there was no way the fans would accept making the team worse and not spending money; in late January they signed Donaldson to a huge contract. But knowing the team was still worse and lacked pitching they traded for Maeda (the one thing that really worked out) in early February. And because of that crappy arse offseason the Twins put themselves in the position for what happened in 2021 and where they are today. (if they couldn't have signed top talent they had trade capital with prospects, because two years later all of those prospects are you guessed it still just prospects)
  2. I agree I shed no tears for either of these two. But it is things like this that baseball continues to do that drives me further and further away from the game. Lets put David Ortiz in the HOF on the first ballot with suspicion of PEDS (it isn't lost on me he played along one of the biggest PED cheaters in the history of the game) but keep out some of the players that actually brought fans to to the game after what happened in 1994. While also putting players like Pudge, Piazza or Bagwell in and claiming some moral high ground, Now this labor dispute, on top of the stupid shifts.
  3. Congrats to Big Pappi, for being a likeable cheater, that is way better than an un-likeable cheater. (I think that is a great lesson to teach the youth, if you are going to cheat do it while smiling and arse kissing the high and mighty media) The idiots that vote for the hall of fame are an embarrassment to baseball.
  4. Starters on the 40 Man Balazovic, Bundy, Dobnak, Duran, Enlow, Jax, Maeda, Ober, Ryan, Sands, Strotman, Thorpe, Vallimont, and Winder. That is 14, We can remove Enlow and Maeda, making it 12. So I am going to go out on a limb and say just about every prospect is going to pitch out of the pen at least to start, unless they start out in the minors so red hot and actually pitching a decent amount of innings each start. Duran is 24, and never really had great results in the minors and has pitched 16 innings the last two years, he is destined for the bullpen, unless you want to stretch him out in the minors (and on the 40 man) for the next two years. Sands is 24 going on 25 (July 17th) has never pitched 100 inning but did pitch 80 last year and if he starts out hot in AAA he could come up as a starter. SWR will be 21 all of next year and isn't on the 40 so there is no real chance for him being in the majors next year, so he should be starter in the minors all year.
  5. Kind of makes you think, how did this FO let this team get into this position. Oh I know not trading some assets when they were competing to go deep into the playoffs and having a bunch of vets pitch last year in a completely lost season. The deeper you dig the more questions come up about what this FO has really been planning or lack of planning. There really shouldn't be a question why Tampa traded Ryan Stroman last year, they were sitting in a similiar position and they passed their question marks off for a veteran hitter to try and make a deep run.
  6. If the Twins think Martin will be up quick, they are going to have to figure out how they are going to work the 40 man since he isn't on it. Of all the players listed only Miranda, Celestino and Lewis are on the 40 man so besides Martin, I believe none of the others will be up in 2022. And to be honest most of this list does nothing for me, I hope Miranda and Martin turn out, I think Lewis will probably have a long career similiar to Cuddy, and I have no idea on the rest, but trading offense at the major league level for pitching doesn't look like the wise thing to do.
  7. For those wanting to trade Donaldson, what are you expecting as a return? (a couple of flyers that are 4-5 years away or another teams prospect that they probably don't want to put on their 40 man anyway?) Also I read his money could be spent better in other places, but there is already more then enough money to be spent but wasn't. Sure he is probably overpaid but the over pay amount is probably the amount the Twins will have to eat anyway. IMO if the twins feel the need to trade Donaldson because of salary, all fans should be done with them. If they are willing to trade Donaldson and eat money to open up 3rd for Miranda, I could understand that logic, but their back up plan better not involve Arraez at 3B and Gordon at SS, because they leaves them with NO plan C. My final thoughts are trading him would be a HUGE negative on this Front Office, How could they sign him to a 4 year contract and be in a rebuilding mode in year 3 and have to eat a bunch of that contract and lets be honest the year 2 was already a huge negative on this FO. Now if a couple of this pitching prospects are the real deal and our offense isn't good because we traded away a possible 4 WAR player for a rookie that ends up struggling, again how much worse does this FO want to look.
  8. I am going to go with the guys on the 40 man as first up. Ryan is a no-brainer, the only way he isn't on the opening roster is if he is hurt. As for the order I guess it will depend on what they need Drew Strotman IMO he is only on the 40 because he came over in a trade, I would think he is the first up and possibly the down and off the 40. Then Cole Sands because he pitched 80 innings this year and should be go for 110 or so. The Vallimont and Duran because I think they will come up for the Pen. Then Josh and Jordan. Then I believe Canterino will force the Twins hand to be added the 40. I don't think we see any of the others, because I believe there will be other minor league pitchers that will need to be added to the 40 to cover bullpen spots though the year. I don't think Twins can afford to put any more prospects on the 40 man this year then they already have. Just my 2 cents.
  9. "But if the "solution" to their problem is signing someone like Iglesias or Simmons as a stopgap, and then struggling to find at-bats for better players buried on the 2B depth chart behind Polanco" When is the last time the Twins struggled to find at-bats for better players buried on any depth chart?
  10. So if Pressly pitches close to the way he does in Houston, The Twins win 100 hundred plus games and offer him 20.4 million over 3 years (contract the Astros gave him) he says no? (because Houston or Texas might come calling?) , or are you saying the Twins wouldn't have offered him that? Both say more about the Twins and their organization than it does about Pressly.
  11. So you are saying the Astros got just over a year an half of an allstar for 3 years of two minor league performances? That is makes the Twins look worse as of today.
  12. I like to think of it as, what would you give up for Royce Lewis if he was on a different team. I know what I would have given for him as dropped quite a bit the last few years. Would you give up Garver for him now if say Lewis was a Marlin? Would you give up Ryan or any of the other top prospects? I don't if I know if I would consider him a headliner anymore in a deal? He has a lot prove this year IMO if he doesn't want to go the way Gordon went.
  13. hmm, Ok, we are going to pretend the Twins didn't trade a future two time all star pitcher (so far). and we are going to pretend Alcala in 2020 was so good the Twins put him position exactly once to save or hold a game and he blew it? or in 2021 he failed to hold or save 25% of his opportunities. But he was in the pen for two years. don't mind that he was replacement level at best, the Twins picked up Juan Minaya (just one example) off the scrap heap and he out performed Alcala last year as just one example. (On top of the 40 man rosters spots these two players have taken up) You can make all the assumptions you want, I will take what has actually happened and compare at this moment. If you want to argue that Twins couldn't have afforded the extension he signed or that he hasn't lived up to the extension, feel free, I mean it would be foolish but at least it would be an discussion on something that has actually happened. If you want to argue there is no way the Twins would have gotten Pressly to pitch as well as he has, well than that might explain Alcala issues so far. Trading veterans for prospects is always based on hope and promise, and almost always it takes a few years for the trade to pan out (unless you are trading a terrible player for prospects then the trade can work out well right away and even better in the future) and as of 1/21/22 the Twins have gotten little to nothing out of the trade, doesn't mean that this was a bad trade yet or the wrong move at the time, it just means if the Twins want to have it turn out for them they are going to have to start seeing some good results at the major league level.
  14. Well either I don't write well or you just refuse to understand. Where have I said it was a bad trade? I have said repeatedly at this point they have lost the trade, and I believe at some point the trade will look good, but it hasn't yet. And to continue down the investment path is pointless. Your comparison with Shields and Tatis makes less sense than anything else you have said. The Padres traded away an overpaid and not all that good starter, who went on to produces .1 WAR for the Sox over three years (-.1.9, .3, 1.7) so basically getting any return for a negative WAR pitcher that was paid over 30 million by the Sox is a win for the Padres. At the same time Shields was terrible Tatis moved up into the top 10 overall prospect rankings, but even if Tatis never turned out to be anything the Padres won this trade. But the Twins didn't trade away a terrible overpaid starting pitcher, they traded away a really good cheap relief pitcher that would go onto two all star games (at least) and help his team to two of the last three world series and signed a pretty good extension for both the player and team. In year 4 the Padres got 4.2 WAR from Tatis and like I said the Sox ended up with .1 WAR, so maybe you are making the Twins even look worse by such a comparison.
  15. This makes no sense, if Alcala was actually good in 2020 and really good in 2021, with the expectation of being at the top of the rotation in 2202, or Celestino came up last year and played above replacement level, you couldn't take what has actually happened into account? and you could only use forecasting on the next 4 years of the trade? That is complete BS, you and everybody else (including me) would be saying how great of trade this was Twins, and what a great job this FO did with that asset, but instead you and others want to run cover for the poor lowly twins because they haven't gotten a darn thing out of the asset yet. And your stock analogy also makes no sense, if you sold Microsoft stock while is was going up to buy a start up, and it took 5 years to return, yes year 4 would be bad. You could have held onto Microsoft longer and waited to sell and invest in the future amazon at a later date, you OC would be high doing it your way and your ROI would be lower.
  16. I am confused on how at this point and time you can say it is a no brainer good trade? The Twins have literally gotten next to nothing in the majors and the Houston got a two time all star. It sure looks like the Twins will start getting some real contribution from the trade this year and hopefully years beyond, but that hasn't happened. Can you believe it was a good trade and still say at this point the Twins lost the trade, absolutely. I thought at the time it was a the right move, I still think it was probably the right move but at this point I can also say the Twins have absolutely lost this trade. Until hope and promise turn out, that is all it is hope and promise.
  17. So are you saying they would or wouldn't have signed Pressly? I am confused, sorry.
  18. How is that a safer assumption? the Twins would have been coming off a 100 win season and he would have been the stud relief pitcher. and I assume you meant stats in your last sentence, and that makes zero sense, You don't win trades with hope and promise, you win them with results, and as of now the Twins have gotten little to none in the return of results, now I have said it over and over, the Twins still have a good chance of winning this trade, but as of today they haven't.
  19. If Alcala becomes the guy you hope he becomes and the Twins are winning at a high level, then the Twins overwhelming win this trade and the FO looks like geniuses. Now I believe there is zero chance he becomes a 100-120 inning pitcher, there is probably a decent chance he becomes a 50 - 80 inning solid or better relief pitcher. (I also don't believe the players union is going to allow pitchers in their prime to be long relief pitchers and giving up millions of dollars until they fail as starters)
  20. isn't it an assumption they wouldn't have signed him? Maybe they trade him at the deadline for even better prospects the next year, Isn't everything an assumption at this point, other than what has happened? What we know is that the Houston has been in 2 of the last three world series and they resigned Pressly (see stats in my previous post) and the two prospects they Twins got haven't done anything (minus 20 good innings in a lost season with zero pressure). At this point the Twins lost this trade and it isn't even close, but the Twins have control over the prospects for a few more years and there is time for the Twins not to look horrible and even look great on this trade. But for the first three plus years the have came out on the losing end.
  21. It is crazy to think how many players that are good enough to be major league players, but are stuck in High A or AA because of the philosophy that is how it has to go? The Tigers got 2.1 WAR from Baddoo, and the Twins would have gotten a high A player maybe a AA player, not because they are so loaded in the outfield but just because.
  22. What would TB do, they would trade him, so I am against extending him. ?
  23. History says Alcala likely won't be dominant, doesn't mean it won't happen. Also the last 20 innings or so he pitched when he was pretty much lights out more than half of those innings were against terrible, terrible teams, Det, KC, Cubs, Actually if you only look at his stats all year against terrible teams, he was pretty dominant the whole season, it was really how terrible he pitched against the CHW that end up making his numbers not look really good for the whole year. You are correct nobody knows that happens with the twins in 2019 with Pressly, maybe with him they win two more games and start at home, maybe without Pressley the Astros don't win 107 and the twins end up with home field though out. At this point IMO it isn't even close how the Twins did with this trade, they have gotten destroyed, that doesn't mean at the end of this the Twins can't or won't win this trade, but as of today it is not even close. The Twins have gotten 85.1 innings, 1 save, 11 holds, and 5 blow saves, and an embarrassing 23 games by Celestino. Houston has been in 2 of the last 3 world series, Pressly has been an all start twice. pitched 162 inning with 43 saves, 45 holds and 13 blown saves. To good thing for the Twins is they traded away a relief pitcher, so if Celestino ends up being a starting MLB outfielder for a few years, the Twins will more than likely win this trade based on WAR no problem.
  24. Having basically unknowns in LF, RF, SS and 1B if considered pretty competitive? It could be, it could be great, it also could be a disaster if Martin/Miranda aren't ready, or AK/Buxton get hurt, and Gordon is the SS everybody said isn't a SS. With that opening day lineup the back ups are Larnach, Celestino, Rooker, and Arraez. Thanks but no thanks, if that is how the season ends and all or most of those guys are good, then it was probably a decent season. But if even a couple of those guys end up like Larnach, Celestino or AK. It will likely mean 2023 will probably be similiar to 21 and 22.
  25. 100% agree, without Arraez I don't see depth anywhere except maybe catcher. Since 2016 AK has played 340 games, At this point Laranch and Celestino shouldn't be counted on (Rooker?), and Miranda has never played a major league game. Lewis hasn't played in 2 years and had a .649 OPS in AA the last time he played, and Martin while having a decent enough first year certainly didn't scream skip AAA and start in the majors. To me the Twins offense depth is very similiar to their pitching depth, damn you hope most hold their own and succeed, but things could get real ugly real fast, because there really isn't anything in the pipeline after these prospects (close to being ready)

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.