Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

TwinsDr2021

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by TwinsDr2021

  1. I agree the only pitchers I would rate above him are Ryan, Balazovic, and maybe SWR. And only below Miranda, Lewis, Martin, so he should be IMO 6 or 7. Unless the belief is that Canterino could make his way though AA and AA and to the majors this year, but if he does I don't see that happening as a starter (just based on the expected innings this year), his stuff seems better than Winder, but with the amount of innings he has pitched the last 2 years, I don't know if I expect to see him in the majors until late 2023.
  2. It only matters when it comes to fans perception of trades I guess. Trading a prospect ranked 25 for a relief pitcher for example, is perceived way different that a prospect ranked in the top 5. IMO I think of prospects as possible difference makers in the MLB. a 24 year old prospect in A/AA is less likely to be a difference maker than a 21/22 year old at the same level. With the covid year I think prospects that missed the year in the minors will tend to be a bit older for a few years, but in reality the cream always rises to the top and biggest difference makers will almost always come from the guys that make the majors at a younger age.
  3. If he comes close to Greg Gagne he would have exceeded all expectations IMO. Gagne has a career WAR of 26.3 and 10 years of a WAR above 1 and 8 above 2.2. Also to stay on the age theme, he debuted at age 21 but to be fair didn't really play until age 23.
  4. Calling BS on this one Seth, if Varland and Wallner did what they just did at A+ at age 21, they would be WAY higher up in the rankings, also if Celestino was already 24 and hadn't turned 23 yesterday he wouldn't barely be in the top 25 prospects. I don't really care if they get called up at 21 or 26 either if they turn out to be really good, but there has been talk on this board for two years about Kepler (trading him, not good enough, 4th outfielder, etc..) and he will be playing this year at 29. But if a 26 year old gets called up and plays like Larnach or gets hurt like AK, nobody has time to deal with that the other younger prospects that will be the guys getting the hype and playing time.
  5. I think the big difference between Lewis and Torkelson, is that Torkelson has played one year in them minors at three levels, hit 30 homers and had a .935 OPS. Lewis hasn't been played in two years, and the expectation of the two are way different going into this year. I would expect Torkelson should contribute in the majors, and IMO Lewis shouldn't be expected to even play in the majors this year. (hopefully he can exceed those expectations and prove people wrong) But that is the reason Torkelson is a top 10 prospects and Lewis is barely in the top 100. IMO age is a huge difference, but Lewis isn't a good example, because he is still young, He can still make the majors by 23, even if it is the start of 2023. have a good weekend.
  6. Not disagreeing with you but Torkelson might not be the best example, he was drafted in 2020, played basically all of 21 as a 21 year old and played at A+, AA, and AAA, and won't turn 23 until August, so unless Detroit is playing a service game he should see the majors at age 22. Rutschman I believe was affected by Covid and if not for that would more than likely have been in the majors last year as a 23 year old (since his birthday was a week ago). Matt Wallner was drafted in the same draft and hasn't played above A+.
  7. I would tend to agree with Covid the ages might creep up, but in most cases guys that are future All Star types will still see the majors at a fairly young age at least on the offense side of things. I think where we will really see the difference is in the pitchers based on how careful teams are with them. And the idea there is no need to bring a 22 year old up when you can stretch him out in the minors a year or two and control that pitcher though his late 20's.I can see lower Revenue teams to doing that so they never really have to pay the big dollars for pitchers. Cleveland for example has kind of been doing that, it might not be intentional but Clevinger, Plesac, Civale, Morgan, Plutko, and Kluber are examples.
  8. I would agree that I think of prospects as kind of the game changing players, not just guys that will make it. For example and forgive me if I missed somebody, but looking at last years all stars and when they first played in the majors it seems pretty consistent that the best ball players start their MLB career early. There are rare cases like De Grom. Which means most of the Twins prospects need to step it up this year if they hope to be future All Stars. Age Players 19 2 20 10 21 10 22 18 23 14 24 14 25 6 26 4 27 2 28 1
  9. Completely off topic, the topic is Are the Twins an unattractive destination for FAs?.
  10. Have I been unclear that it is about money and length, until things are even, then other things come into play? Since a peak in 2007, Minnesota has seen its rate of natural population growth — births minus deaths — steadily decline even before COVID-19 hit. And it's had a net population loss due to domestic migration in all but three of the past 21 years.Dec 21, 2021
  11. Are they trying? Comparing teams that aren't trying to sign guys to "larger" contracts to teams that supposedly are trying, isn't much argument. IMO if Miami decides they want to get involved in signing players to "large" contracts they won't have a problem getting them to sign there. Mauer established residency in Florida just to sign his first bonus, and if I am remembering correctly quite a few players do that. In the last 4 years I know about dozen families that have moved out of MN for Florida, Texas and Tennessee and not all of them are conservatives.
  12. Difference might be Bonds was 43 and Bauer is 31 and is owed 64 million. It is my understanding that the dodgers paid him 40 million last year, so unless MLB suspends him for close to 2 years I see him playing again. I can't see a suspension of that long holding up on appeal, with the precedent that has been set.
  13. It will make MLB look really bad if being a Jerk is worse than steriods or Domestic Violence.
  14. No it would have been terrible for the Twins to sign him to that or really any contract. The "but" was now the players aren't getting as much of the overall Revenue because guys like that aren't getting the money and teams are smart enough not to pay somebody like or Rosario/Dozier for example and give those jobs to younger cheaper guys. For example take Ricky Nolasco for example and what he got, Pineda has been similiar and can't get that. Good for teams bad for players.
  15. Because of the first line I wrote - The number 1 factor is money and years. Tampa isn't going to compete against other teams for big name free agents, because they can't or won't spend that kind of money, so weather and taxes rarely if ever play a part, The Twins on the other hand were supposedly trying for guys like Wheeler and Darvish so to get them they probably are going to have to offer more than some other teams. Charlie Morton signed a two year 30 million contract and Franco signed for 200 mililon, because of money and years.
  16. The number 1 factor is money and years. But for the twins to offer 10 million a year to somebody and Tampa offers 10 million. The player is taking about 487500 less. (I know it is a hair less than that) (Salary/2 * 9.75%) So for the twins to compete with no tax states evenly their offer has to be higher. Now if the players family isn't really interested in relocating to MN, because of weather, family, or whatever reason. The Twins also have to up their offer because it is going to cost the player more to have two places and be flying family back and forth. Now if there aren't other teams also interested in that player, the Twins don't have to take that into consideration, they can offer a take it or leave it type contract. But if you have a few teams interested in that player and one team happens to be close to where that player grew up (of wife grew up) and another is a no tax state, the twins have to take that into consideration when offering a contract. They can't just match the other teams contract and believe they offered the same (I mean they can but they would be wrong).
  17. I would add another thing that got MLB to this point is analytics. Take Brian Dozier for example, here is a guy that hit 42 homers at age 29 and 34 at age 30, and has only made 30 million in his career. In the past at 32 he probably would have gotten better than 9 million 1 year contract. Stuff like this is good for mid to low revenue teams but....
  18. Agree with you on all of this, except I think Minnesota fans are much more forgiving on what their athletes do then what they get paid. AP, Cruz, Pineda all of done something recently or in the past that most would think is wrong at best, horrible at worst and the fans forgave them. But Mauer, Cousins, and Donaldson for example get raked though the coals for seemingly being good people but getting paid way too much. (IMO) So if Bauer came here on the cheap he would be loved, but if the Twins have to pay him a big contract he would be hated. (again IMO)
  19. ? agree with this statement. The season is over we have what players actually did, not what they should have done. But we can look at those numbers and use them as prediction going forward.
  20. That is the great thing about thinking the plan solely relies on promoting from within for long-term success (which most won't provide what that actually means), as long as their are prospects in the wings the plan is working or just about ready to work.
  21. Agreed on the biggest issue is money, but I will say I think taxes might play a part in some cases. Joe Mauer moved to Florida to save a few hundred thousand. So guys pick the place they want to play regardless of the tax implications, but I believe others do look at that when it comes down to a couple of cities they have no real ties with. If the Twins offer you 10 million and year and the Rangers offer you 10 million a year. That is someplace north of 400K a year. (Assumption is that only 5 million is made in MN at 9.85%) Now for us that grew up or live in MN that probably isn't a huge deal since dumb enough to live here already ? and we are still going to make a boat load of money. but for somebody that grew up in the south or maybe a country south of the US that could be a big factor.
  22. We including me keep saying that but it would be interesting to see if it is actually True, Miranda for one came back better. Maybe the guys that are going to be good did fine or improved and maybe the guys that take way longer or never were going to make it suffered. It will be interesting to see what happens going forward. On another note if Lewis wasn't already trending down on the national lists, I don't think the injury would have affected his status as much as it has. Starting high on the top prospects lists, there are really only two paths, one is quick to the majors and the other is down the prospects lists and hope to prove them wrong. Lewis has always seemed the guy that was going to follow the second path. Enlow on the other had has probably never been on the national prospects radar, but since we are super fans we see a guy that was a 3rd round pick that was supposed to go to LSU and see a future ace. He hasn't done anything in the minors that screams that, but we hope and hope and then he gets injured and we get to use that as an excuse to hope and hope and dream so more. Enlow has probably always been over hyped by us, he turns 23 and never has pitched above high A, if not for the Covid missed year, he would have to come back from injury lights out to even be considered a prospect anymore.
  23. With the 40 man current construction, for every none pitcher that gets put on somebody must go on the 60 day or be cut, so to see Palacios, my guess is Gordon will be gone or more pitching injuries. Also IMO, I don't think a team is going to take a 25 SS that has a lifetime .715 OPS in the minors (He has been playing AA since 2018) so for him to do what he did at Wichita last year shouldn't be surprising, it should have been expected. Nick Gordon put up better numbers in AA at age 21 and 22. And for a guy like Palacios, the Covid missed year shouldn't be an excuse, he has been in the minors since he was 17 in (2014), lots of people get hurt and miss a year. He has had a couple of good years in the minors after basically repeating a level. It is almost sad that as Twins fans we are talking about guys like Palacios being a help or possible solution to a problem. Do other "real" teams talk about losing a guy to rule 5 that was a FA minor league signing?
  24. They added a plan C for SS, hopefully it is plan C.
  25. what I said was and you quoted it - "If teams are willing to keep an older prospect in the minors (Winder for example age 25) because they feel the need to make sure that they have him at age 32 instead of just age 31, that seems weird to me' And that is my opinion, others can certainly have their own opinion. We can debate all day how valuable having control over them the last year is, I just think it might be more important to hold back a guy to get that last year when they are 27, 28, 29, then it is when they are 31, 32, 33. In your scenario, it would seem smart to not waste active roster spot on somebody that is going to pitch twice, which is also a different argument than keeping him down for they get an extra year at the end of his rookie deal. We could create hypothetical all day, for example if the go to a hybrid or stacked strategy, he could pitch 5 times and have between 10- 15 innings in and the manager and FO could have a real good feel for him, but those are just hypothetical and mean nothing until the FO decides what is going to happen.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.