Everything posted by drjim
-
Article: Twins With Options On The Trade Front
That would be a cyanide pill to swallow after this past year.
-
Re-opening the WAR debate
Reading that makes me think Nate Silver might be on to something (or on something).
-
Article: Twins With Options On The Trade Front
Kiriloff and the unprotected bullpen arms don't add anything. High volumes of medicore or injured prospects are not that attractive. Though I have some hope for a rebound for Kiriloff. Kepler and Gordon is probably close for Cole, I think adding Gonsalves easily does it, but not enough for either of the other pieces. I'm personally really high on Kepler, but I'm not sure that's the position of the industry, and while Gordon and Gonsalves are nice pieces, they aren't the difference makers someone would want for a really solid 2 like Cole.
-
Re-opening the WAR debate
Seems to me he addresses this in the article. Seems the revisions of statistical analysis is moving (rightly) towards less certainly. I basically agree with your other two points, but I suspect this is the opening salvo of what will be a more public and sustained entrance into the debates.
-
Re-opening the WAR debate
My complaints about WAR were always based on 1. converting defense anf baserunning to runs, and 2. the flaws in the idea of the replacement player. But tying actual team wins to the sum of individual players WAR would seem to be an obvious desire, at least as measuring actual production is concerned.
-
Re-opening the WAR debate
Some good thoughts from Nate Silver:
-
Re-opening the WAR debate
Shots fired from Bill James: https://www.billjamesonline.com/judge_and_altuve/
-
Pat Reusse's Turkey of the Year 2017
Counterpoint: Lots of people prefer to be lied to and/or have their beliefs validated and their media consumption proves it.
-
Pat Reusse's Turkey of the Year 2017
I don't know if that's necessarily true. The market seems big enough for all types.
-
Gophers Football
The schedule was not that much harder this year. The nonconference schedule was a joke, the Big Ten West is pretty terrible and the Big Ten as a whole is mediocre. I haven't followed super closely, but I really think they could have been more of a pound and d team and had more success, but changing systems with mismatched (and limited) talent is probably the main culprit. The next two years are probably going to be worse on the field, and Fleck is not exactly killing it in recruiting (though it is ok).
-
Pat Reusse's Turkey of the Year 2017
Homers, especially Gopher football fans, have never liked him. Mid-90s struck me as a fertile time for ripping local local sports teams, depending on your opinion of Denny Green. He always struck me as the most savage of critics, because he is not a cartoon about it, but also a great read when there is success, especially unexpected success. Recently I have appreciated his focus on local sports, especially Gopher women's sports, (He has a little bit of a history with women's sports, to put it mildly). And at his heart he's a baseball and Gopher guy, which are my favorite sports to follow too.
-
International signing scandal force Brave FO resignations
From reading the report, it seems mlb was appropriately surgical in stripping prospects. They declared free agents the prospects they acquired through manipulating the spending caps (and the one draft pick extra benefits) and handcuffed the org for a couple years going forward. Don't know how they could justify stripping away other legitimately acquired prospects.
-
Turkey-Day game
It was an annoying sequence, but all those calls struck me as correct.
-
International signing scandal force Brave FO resignations
Paying the players too much money wasn't the problem.
- Article: Part 6: Seth's Updated Top 50 Twins Prospects (11-15)
-
Pat Reusse's Turkey of the Year 2017
The series is by far the best thing I have read. And I completely agree with Chief, easily the best local writer of my lifetime and I don't expect him to be passed.
-
Pat Reusse's Turkey of the Year 2017
I think this might represent his swan song from the column.
-
International signing scandal force Brave FO resignations
Agree with this. The systematic skirting of spending caps does not seem like it was a common activity of other teams.
-
International signing scandal force Brave FO resignations
I don't think the bundle was for giggles or as a favor to the trainers, it was to blatantly skirt the yearly spending caps. That is why they got so hammered, it was a clear, obvious and egregious violation of the collective bargaining agreement. I don't agree that many other teams did this. The early deals were not the problem.
-
Gophers Football
I think Kill resigned himself under pressure from his family. The U would have kept him if he would have stayed. The dorm scandal is not the reason that Claeys was let go, it just happened to be a very convenient and well-timed scapegoat for the Administration.
-
What can Minnesota offer Shohei Otani?
I will say that this movement in the narrative towards making a trade does make me a little nervous. That's usually the chatter before they aren't willing to spend. And I'll repeat Doogie's nugget from his podcast a couple of days ago that his conversation with a scout led him to believe that the front office truly thinks it is still a season away. Probably means they won't overspend all that much for a starter.
-
What can Minnesota offer Shohei Otani?
While this is a possible outcome, nothing of consequence has happened for any team this offseason in all of mlb. Taking one offseason of data when they were coming off 103 losses strikes me as likely an unrepresentative sample of the way they will generally operate.
-
Gophers Football
It was pretty much expected. There was graduations, transfers, players who quit, and lost recruits. Either way, kind of bad to follow up the best season in decades with this gong show. But switching coaches at a program like Minnesota is going to result in at least 3 years of rebuilding. I hope I never have to hear Fleck speak again, but he does have a track record of success at smaller schools.
-
Gophers Football
Correct. Took him two years to get his health right before he could coach again. It would be awesome if he could keep it going, but he couldn't keep his regimen as the Gopher coach.
-
Article: What's Next For Kohl Stewart?
I would say the one exception I would make would be a clearly ready college arm - Price and Strasburg were about as surefire as you can get, Verlander quite close too. Kershaw, like he is in many ways, is an exception to a rule. And even he was a #7 pick. What's interesting too, is that 5 college arms were selected before him that year and none stuck as a starter (though a couple became good relievers). The college bat taken ahead was Longoria.