Everything posted by Mark G
-
Xander Bogaerts Represents a Happy Medium for the Twins
I wouldn't mind Bogaerts at all. It might come down to who he is pared with at 3rd base as to how much of a defensive asset or liability he would be, but the bat would make up for it over a 162 game season. I am a little confused in the article, though. On one hand it says he would be a good segue to our SS of the future, moving to 2nd or 3rd base over time. On the other hand it talks about a 5 year deal he might be willing to take, meaning he would displace at 2nd or 3rd.........who? Like in musical chairs, what happens to the rest of the infield when the music stops? Who goes where? And who doesn't have a seat left? I would want to think about that before I give a long term deal to a short term SS who we will want to move around fairly soon. Maybe sign him to that type of deal and trade both Polanco and Urshella, making room for the kids we have who appear ready? The money just might work that way.
-
Edouard Julien Can Take the Next Step in 2023
"One suggests him not getting serious consideration until spring training 2024 after all of 2023 at AAA." That, I believe, would have been me. I still believe it. This extremely humble observer does not believe a professional athlete in any sport, much less baseball, is old at 24 which is what he turns next April. And with all the people ahead of him, why rush anything? When did a year at AAA become so absurd? He needs to improve his defense, and still needs to prove he can hit advanced pitching. If he is as good as we would like to think he is, he will prove it and be part of the future. In the meantime, we maintain the years of control we currently have. I have seen way too many players get called up only to be sent back down again because they were over matched at that moment. Give him the time he needs. With all the guys on the roster ahead of him now, what's the rush?
-
Edouard Julien Can Take the Next Step in 2023
Love the potential, and his stats rising as he gets older and moves up the minor league ladder gives one a lot of hope. But with the log jam at 2nd we currently have, and the fact he is only 23 and has only gone as far as AA, I would like to see him for an entire season at AAA, somewhat similar to what Miranda did, before bringing him to spring training and giving serious consideration. If he continues to excel at that level we may have to start considering 2nd base a position of strength and possibly move some folks around or have some trade chips. But I would like to give it a year to see.
- Reviewing 2022 Performances by Twins Shortstop Prospects
-
Reviewing 2022 Performances by Twins Shortstop Prospects
I wish I could share your enthusiasm, but the primary reason Lewis has only played a part of 1 season in the last 4 years is two major surgeries. I do not doubt his ability to swing a bat; what I do doubt is his ability to play the field long term without major injuries. I wonder if both Lewis and Kirilloff are of the Buxton mold; very talented and very fragile. Until both can prove over a period of time that they can stay on the field, the only place I would pencil in either one of them is the trainer's room. My point was that we keep on bringing up Lewis as though he would be plan A, when he hasn't proven he can stay on the field at any position, much less SS. And if we could somehow muster up the fortitude to keep the best SS in our system - heck, most systems - this whole conversation would be moot and we could get on to the task of putting together a potent outfield, and hopefully Lewis would be a good candidate there. As an aside, you are right, this isn't 1992, but it isn't 2052 yet either or we would be able to put all the Humpty Dumpty's back together again. ACL surgeries may be run of the mill at times, and with some athletes, but 2 in such a short time is still more than a slight concern. Let's hope you are right all the way down the line. If so, I will take my crow medium rare.
-
Reviewing 2022 Performances by Twins Shortstop Prospects
My only response would be that it is not Falvey's decision, it is Jim Pohlad's decision. If he wants Correa we stand a chance, but he knows the commitment it would take. Falvey only does the paperwork, JP signs the checks. If we do not sign him, it will not be on Falvey, it will be on JP.
-
Reviewing 2022 Performances by Twins Shortstop Prospects
"there is no guarantee Kiriloff will come back stronger and better after this highly invasive surgery". It always amazes me how many people are so skeptical about Kirilloff ever being able to be the player he once was and we hope he can be, but are convinced that Lewis will come back after not one, but two major knee surgeries. Knees that will always be questionable for years to come. Not putting down your optimism, just trying to be realistic about how much of a plan A Lewis can be. And below him, who is a legitimate plan A anytime soon? SS is a tough position to fill long term. A contending organization who has had the answer in their clubhouse all year would be trying to keep him instead of guessing which minor leaguer is going to be his replacement.
-
Why Would the Twins Pay Anyone but Carlos Correa?
All I know is that JP and Falvine know the numbers they need to begin with, and very likely know the numbers they need to end with to get it done. I will withhold judgment for now, but I can't help but think they will come in, as Ted pointed out, something short of that, knowing the result, and then claim they tried their best, but the man just wanted too much money. In an auction, you don't get brownie points by putting in a bid and then hoping no one goes higher; you get the points for winning the bid even if someone does. Time will tell.............stay tuned.
-
The Single Biggest Flaw with This Minnesota Twins Front Office
"The Derek Falvey-led front office of the Minnesota Twins" That is the premise the article started with, and while I agree with the vast majority of the article, I still maintain it is the Jim Pohlad led front office. Nothing goes on there without his knowledge, and even if the decision he makes is to delegate the decisions to others, the decisions are his responsibility and the buck stops with him. This is his team, not Falvine's or Rocco's; begin with Big Jim and work your way down.
-
Twins Front Office Doubles Down On Process for 2023
Funny, but the one name I thought would be here throughout, I haven't seen at all (or did I miss it). Ultimately, this all begins and ends with Jim Pohlad. This is his team, not Falvine's or Rocco's. If he wanted changes, there would be changes. As I have said elsewhere, even if the decision is to delegate decision making to someone else, the decisions are his, and the buck stops with him. It doesn't do much good to complain about the branches if we don't care about the tree.
-
Twins Daily 2022 Awards: Most Valuable Player
Feel free to correct me if you think I am off base, but I would submit that analytics are far more than just stats, or we would use just stats. Analytics are a way of assigning weight to stats that give some more importance than others when evaluating players. Buxton has a BA 90 points lower than Arraez, for example, and his OBP is 70 points lower. His SLG is 100+ higher, which makes his OPS and OPS+ higher overall, thereby raising his "value". As an aside, how you had Buxton 3rd on your ballot is something I am unable to understand, but I digress. And, as has been said elsewhere, value is in the eye of the beholder (which, I guess, is why we had to bring analytics to the game to eliminate subjectivity). Correa, for example, made a huge difference in the life and play of Miranda by bringing him under his wing, so to speak. He is even planning on bringing him to his home over the winter and spending a week with him working on all sorts of things to make him a better player. What is the value in that? Arraez is a spark plug, and from what I can tell, a pretty popular guy in the dugout. Is there a value in that? Now I like Buxton as much as the next guy - well, maybe not the next guy, but a lot of guys - but someone who played the field 58 games out of 162 isn't my most valuable no matter how high his SLG is in his limited PA's, especially with a low BA and OBP, as well as a 33% strike out rate. Most valuable player is still somewhat subjective, because there has been a debate for a century or more over what player even means. The reason pitchers have their own awards is they don't play the field more than the innings they are on the mound, and they no longer hit (with one notable exception today). Yet you have two pitchers on your ballot. Not that I think that is wrong, as I consider a player a member of your roster, not just a person in the batting order, so I would consider pitchers as well; others may not. Anyway, the long winded point of this extremely humble observer is that out of all the considerations that one would take into account, analytics should be low on the list, and they are more than just stats. Thanks for the give and take, I appreciate your info.
-
Twins Daily 2022 Awards: Most Valuable Player
I know I am showing how new I am here, but just who is the we in we selected Louis the MVP? I totally concur, but I am curious as to the group. Maybe I should know and just missed it somewhere along the line. I do think whoever the group is, y'all got it right. My only non concurrence would be that if y'all are letting the analytics decide for y'all who the MVP of a team is, I find myself tuning out. Just the extremely humble opinion of one of the newer ones, even though I know the minority I am in.
-
As the Twins Fell Apart, Jake Cave Earned My Respect
The Cave man has always been a good 4th or 5th outfielder to have around. He can play all 3 positions, is a decent defensive player at all 3, and has a little bit of a pop now and then.........mostly then, but what do we truly expect from a utility outfielder? If you are looking for 4 or 5 starting caliber outfielders, then all you are going to get is a rotation. Is that what we want? This extremely humble observer would rather have 3 guys you want to play every day and a guy or two that will sub for any one of them when the time is right. The Cave man fits that bill, and is priced right for a team that needs a lot of guys priced right. Give the man his due, gray beard or not. Another contract like he had in '22 would be perfect.
-
Ranking the 2023 Free Agent Shortstop Class
Jeez, we had the guy we want. He has said he would like to stay, if it could be worked out. Why can't we find a way to keep him?
-
How Can Rocco Baldelli Regain Twins Fans Favor?
A couple of questions as I fade away to sleep (I work overnights)......... Is admitting mistakes in private really admitting mistakes? Admitting to whom? Themselves? If a tree falls in the forest and no one is there to hear........... And if the mistakes are made by "their people", how is protecting them (and keeping them) solving the problem of the mistakes? No matter how good or bad a hand you are dealt, it is still up to you to play the hand. How long can you blame the dealer for your losses? Just one extremely humble observer's thoughts as he drifts off to sleep.......zzzzzzzzzzz
-
How Can Rocco Baldelli Regain Twins Fans Favor?
I love the analogy, and in its own way it is perfect. Can I give you another one, fictitious as it is? I manage a Holiday Station Store (I actually did a long time ago), and the company gives me, as manager, a great amount of leeway in how I stock my store, as I know my neighborhood and my customer base. So, I stock a lot of produce, put out certain hot foods throughout the day, and put hard goods on my shelves that I think will sell. I price them according to what my customer base will be willing to pay before going somewhere else. For 2 years, I don't have issues with spoiled product, I produce a pretty good gross product, and the company and the customers are pleased. But in those 2 years the makeup of the neighborhood has been changing. A lot of the apartment buildings have had considerable turnover, and the economy is a little different. In other words, my customer base has changed. But I don't. I continue to stock fresh produce, which I end up throwing out because no one is buying it. My milk spoils because it is not a popular staple anymore. And the hot foods I continue to put out are thrown away because my new customer base doesn't like them. In those 2 years I have considerable waste, a low gross profit, and a total net loss. My customer base is not pleased with my store, and my company is losing its patience. What are the odds I keep my job unless I adapt, like yesterday? What worked for 2 years hasn't worked for the last 2. No one is going to please everyone, and in reality shouldn't try to. But when your customer base, the ones you live or die off of, tell you you are doing something wrong, you have to adapt, adjust, or you lose them. And in the real world, it doesn't matter what or who you manage, you have to succeed to keep your job. To succeed, you adapt, adjust, to the ever changing circumstances. Does anyone truly see that here? Again, as I have said before, I don't pretend to speak for anyone else, but this extremely humble observer does not. Your analogy really was great, and I agree with it in principle. But even if you produced the greatest radio station ever your listener's tastes would change over time, and you would have to make changes to your format along the way or you would die. I just want our favorite team to do the same.
- How Can Rocco Baldelli Regain Twins Fans Favor?
-
Review the Debuts: Twins Rookie Pitchers
No question; Jhoan Duran. A potential top flight closer comes along how often? Leave him in the pen and let him close until he proves us wrong. This extremely humble observer doesn't think he will.
- How Can Rocco Baldelli Regain Twins Fans Favor?
-
How Can Rocco Baldelli Regain Twins Fans Favor?
And they move runners up, putting them in scoring position or even better scoring position, they eliminate the force play and reduce the odds of a double play considerably. They put more pressure on the pitcher and the defense. The out becomes worth it, especially when the person you are asking to bunt is your low average hitter and is likely to make an out anyway.
- How Can Rocco Baldelli Regain Twins Fans Favor?
-
How Can Rocco Baldelli Regain Twins Fans Favor?
I can't argue with a whole lot of the above, but what happens when their numbers 1, 2 and maybe even 3 pitch 6 or 7 innings (or more?) and ours pitch 5, or 5 1/3, or 5 2/3? Then it comes down to bullpen depth. Can we match that as well? Will we continue to stick with the 3rd and 4th times through the lineup plan, or will we let our best pitchers stay on the mound? Would the plan change just because it is a playoff game? My gut tells me that if you won't let a guy try for his no hitter because of a pitch count, you won't change for anything. So we need to get a BP of studs or what we see is what we get.
-
How Can Rocco Baldelli Regain Twins Fans Favor?
I am not sure if this will be considered going off topic or not, because it is more general, but I couldn't disagree with you more about one point. The manager of a baseball team has as much or more control over games than most football coaches. He makes decisions on virtually every pitch, much less who plays, who plays where, where they hit in the lineup, when changes are made, shifts.......I could go on for a while. Even if the decision is to let someone else make the decision (allowing a catcher to call pitches, giving the green light to runners and letting them decide, etc.) the decisions are his. He will tell a coach how aggressive to be or how careful. He sends the signs to the field through his coaches, and again, I could go on. How you can believe that the manager, of any team, doesn't have the most impact is beyond this extremely humble observer's mind set, but you are certainly entitled to believe it. And it is not just the one run games folks are concerned about. The team scored 3 runs or less in approx 47% of the games this year. That is where small ball comes in; manufacturing a run now and then or, in our case, not manufacturing one, has made a difference in way too many games. And I know I am older and think more old school, but fundamentals are knowing how to bunt, run the bases, throw to the right base under each circumstance, hit and run, steal..........some people refer to it as small ball. How would I know if a team has good fundamentals if they don't do so much of the above because the analytics say not to? I can only speak for this extremely humble observer, but I have not seen these fundamentals during this tenure.
-
How Can Rocco Baldelli Regain Twins Fans Favor?
"Stop looking at those Cyber Metric Cards in the dugout and watch the game!!" Agreed!! Some time back I put in a post that said remember the days when the manager would be on the top step of the dugout watching intently each pitch and each play? Me too. Remember the days when the manager would sit behind the protective screen with his coaches and study the stat sheets? Yea, me neither. And I am the one who has to adjust.
-
How Can Rocco Baldelli Regain Twins Fans Favor?
What can be said that hasn't been said already, I guess? As Ted points out, Rocco was picked from Tampa for his knowledge of, and use of all of their analytics that made them successful and somewhat groundbreaking. He brought that here, and has stuck with it through thick and thin. Now it is easy to use any philosophy when your team hits 307 home runs, or plays a 60 game season and barely hangs on to the end of it. But 162 game seasons without the home runs is the challenge all managers will face at one time or another, and we have all seen how those years have gone as well. Ted points out, for example, that all teams have gone to shorter starts to one degree or another, but to do that you need a BP that is somewhat able to handle the load. We didn't have that, and yet we didn't adjust over time. Ryan the 3rd time through the order, or Duffy the first time through the order? Gray or Ober the 3rd time through, or Pagan the first time through? And so on, and so on. It was also confusing as to the "schedule" for scheduled days off for the front line players. Starters pitched less and the pen pitched more. Front line players played less and the utility guys played more. When your pen isn't strong enough to pull that load, and your bench isn't better than what we had for much of the season, due to injuries and other factors, maybe it is time to lean on your starters, both on the mound and on the field. Yet, we never did adjust to the players we had in the clubhouse as the injuries took their toll. We never did perform fundamentals well, and never used small ball to our advantage when it was called for. In other words, we never used the whole tool box that was at our disposal. It was more important to stick to the "plan". The results the first two years were from players who hit a lot of home runs. Take that away, and we are, what, about 20 or so games under .500 the last two years? You have to adjust or die in this game, and I just do not see Rocco adjusting. It is the rest of us who are told we have to adjust to the way the game is played today. This extremely humble observer is saying no thanks. Not if this is going to be the result. I don't want to wait for the 3 run homer every game. Use the whole tool box and lean on your studs. Play a little small ball while your computer spits out more stats. Give us something to watch.